Comments on: Twilight & New Moon Scripts Inspired by Brokeback Mountain, Romeo & Juliet and Dexter

By: emily

emily — Thu, 24 Dec 2009 01:03:29 +0000

they both r horrible be cause Chathrine didnt want 2 tell Melissa that thats not right go rewrite that and stuff. Cause new moon was GREAT chris just was actualy in charge.

By: Victoria

Victoria — Tue, 02 Jun 2009 12:09:16 +0000

She did ruin it…. She changed soooooooo many things she even changed some lines!!! It's like she read the book and then just made up crap along the way! Just, horrible……….

By: Victoria

Victoria — Tue, 02 Jun 2009 08:09:16 +0000

She did ruin it…. She changed soooooooo many things she even changed some lines!!! It's like she read the book and then just made up crap along the way! Just, horrible……….

By: Victoria

Victoria — Sat, 30 May 2009 18:41:32 +0000

How do you petition? I'm totally in, that woman ruined it!!!

By: eddy

eddy — Tue, 26 May 2009 17:11:43 +0000

oh please! just give ya all a break.Twilight is one of the best movies not a story book ,thats why it is called Movie and is full of acting,and the comprehension of Acting is a lie thats reveals the truth,watch the movie,don't like it,stop and keep reading the book or the other way round.watch it,is the best,love it .from the angle where i looked at it ,Twilight Movie is a real big deal and New Moon will be more or less than expected! Mellisa her job right,kol tov!all da best!.

By: RavenCullen#1

RavenCullen#1 — Thu, 14 May 2009 17:29:27 +0000

You are right…but if the moive sucks i am going to sue somebody!!

By: RavenCullen#1

RavenCullen#1 — Thu, 14 May 2009 14:29:27 +0000

You are right…but if the moive sucks i am going to sue somebody!!

By: Sam

Sam — Wed, 13 May 2009 17:31:52 +0000

Oh dear. Seriously. I was glad to hear they changed directors and I believe Taylor Lautner was the best cast actor in the first film. (very glad they didnt completely shoot themselves in the head by changing him).
However, I had issues with the script of Twilight in a number of places-where it was like a badly made spoof of an originally wonderful deep love portrayed through a teenager's eyes. Having read this interview I only feel like my previous issues with Ms Rosenberg have grown considerably. As Eclipse is my personal favourite in the Twilight saga, I can only hope that the script is seriously improved by the time they write Eclipse…perhaps it is time for Melissa Rosenberg to follow Catherine Hardwicke off the set…

By: hartsafire

hartsafire — Tue, 14 Apr 2009 12:46:40 +0000

I agree with the majorty here on this Melissa Rosenberg did a awful job with twilights adaptation. Apparently she has never been in love. but more to the point James didn't even speak till the last couple of chapters, same as victoria, she never even said a word she just hissed and growled was all, the bella and edward scenes didn't even make since half the time because they were so out of order. If she can't do better with New Moon then I believe its time Summit finds a new Screenwriter because I don't know if she'll feel like writing anything else if some of these fans gets ahold of her. Humm. wonder if I could do any better lol. Seriously though if it doesn't go over well, then i believe we should petition summit to fire her and tell her to go back to reading her gay books, i can say that because i am same sex oriented

By: Mimi

Mimi — Sat, 11 Apr 2009 22:12:41 +0000

I really hope the next one is better. The first time i saw Twilight it was omg so frickin perfect, but the more i watch it the more I find problems with it. For instance one of my friends saw the movie then read the book and he mentioned that the movie does not really show Bella and Edward's building relationship. He's right, it seems like it goes to fast and is just an action movie. When i brought the dvd, the director was all oh we cut some scenes because it was slowing the movie down. LOVE takes time to build. I feel like the movie Twilight and the book Twilight are the same, but different. They turned a love story into a fast paced action drama. Most people that were so hardcore into the movie were fans and they should have really focused on making a movie for the fans on the Romantic novel Twilight. Like i said i really hope this movie show's more about Bella's pain over edward and they show that they are like closley connected before he goes off and leaves her. but of course they are probably gonna freakin mess that up too by showing edward …not that i dont like edward but edward was gone the cullens were gone. but ok whatever i will watch it anyway and probably still love it no matter how much it's screwed up. sorry for the rant!