Reaction from HisGoldenEyes.com
As fansite moderators, we get to see and interact with hundreds of Twilighters every day. With that comes the chance to see what it is that they truly want. We want someone that will do the book justice, much like Catherine was able to. Chris Weitz seems like the perfect man to, not replace but rather, continue what Catherine started. Besides, if Stephenie Meyer, the queen bee herself, approves of him, who are we to say he isn’t good enough?
Reaction from Twilightlexiconblog.com
New directors are always a crap shoot for franchises. Catherine, on most counts, realistically set up the world of Forks and the Cullens. Chris gets to take over from that foundation. I think Chris is up to the job, if you take About a Boy, a project where he pretty much had total control, it was heartwarming, funny, emotional — all the things New Moon has to be. So I’m for keeping an open mind, especially now that Stephenie Meyer has given her support.
Reaction from BellaAndEdward.com
People have said that men can’t direct romance … but The Notebook is proof enough that they can. I hope Chris pays as much attention to detail as Catherine did, and that being faithful to the book remains his first priority. I personally love About A Boy, and I hope that the fans will support him as much as they supported our brilliant director of Twilight. I can’t wait to see his interpretation of the world of Bella and Edward, and let’s hope that Twilighters have a whirlwind romance with his movie, just as he did with the books.
Reaction from twilight20somethings.com
I appreciate and respect Catherine’s adaptation of Twilight, as well as her love for the fans. She has made quite an impact on the Twilight fandom as a whole. But, with Stephenie’s blessing as the torch is passed to Chris Weitz, I have faith that he will be just as devoted to the books. I only hope he can make a seamless jump into New Moon without changing the Forks we have grown to love already.
Reaction from Newmoonmovie.org
I’m optimistic. Weitz left Golden Compass as director initially because he was worried about disappointing the dedicated His Dark Materials fans. So he’s already dealt with a ravenous, tuned-in fanbase that expected a lot for the book-to-movie translation. Twilight is not an effects-packed action story, it’s a love story. He’ll need to channel his About a Boy sensitive side if he wants to please the fans.