Comments on: Should Breaking Dawn be a Movie?

By: stephanievqz

stephanievqz — Sat, 05 Dec 2009 07:39:36 +0000

even though all that very graphic stuff happens, they cannot stop making breaking dawn. It will make a very large amount of teenage girls angry. and they got their way fighting for taylor lautner to play jacob didn't they? what makes anyone question if they wouldnt do it again? its all about the fans!!!!!!

~*StxPHy*~

By: stephanievqz

stephanievqz — Sat, 05 Dec 2009 01:39:36 +0000

~*StxPHy*~

By: Vampressa

Vampressa — Wed, 19 Aug 2009 06:20:55 +0000

I also agree. This was a awesome ending to the never ending fantasy that SM created. It also sums up everyone's feelings and emotions and reason for them. Bella always felt that Jacob needed to be there, be close to her and in the last book we see why. To imprint on Nessie explains a lot. He was drawn to her even before her birth, I mean how amazing and curious is that? Plus, the whole defeat the all powerful thinking Royal Vampires. I just loved that part. To show that you have have to be the biggest player on the field to win the game. That in itself says a lot about life everywhere. Well, I will be very disappointed if they do not finish out the saga. I beg and plea that they do and give it all the justice that is do deserved.

By: Vampressa

Vampressa — Wed, 19 Aug 2009 05:20:55 +0000

By: Savy

Savy — Tue, 26 May 2009 22:49:28 +0000

i dont care if the edit half. i dont care if its not exactly proportionate. and i dont CARE if they take 4 or even 5 years to make it. but i do care that it HAS TO BE MADE!!!! Breaking Dawn is the final piece of the puzzle to the twilight saga. and to lose the last piece of a puzzle, why we all would just go INSANE!!! IM NOT LYING PEOPLE WILL GO CRAZY!!!! Does anyone want to lose their minds? i dont, BUT I WILL….. I WILL IF I HAVE TO……

By: Ashley

Ashley — Tue, 19 May 2009 14:26:24 +0000

they have to make it into a movie, how can you do the first 3 and than leave it like that. So what if they have to give it a different rating it is a vampire movie after all theres bond to be blood there somewhere. If they dont make it I will be really disappointed

By: Ashley

Ashley — Tue, 19 May 2009 11:26:24 +0000

By: dessa

dessa — Tue, 12 May 2009 07:36:34 +0000

OMG!!! Leanne, I love you!!!
I couldn't say it better…

By: Leanne

Leanne — Tue, 12 May 2009 01:36:47 +0000

I wonder whether Summit Entertainment and Stephanie Meyer have seriously considered the vast genre of readers that her books have appealed too. I understand the books have been directed at the teenage genre, however it is plain to see it has gone much further than that.

I say this, in response to the debate about the making of Breaking Dawn as a movie.
As a person in my 30's and not an avid reader at any stretch I managed to read these books in four days. I absolutely loved them.

I was quite disappointed that BD wasn't as descriptive in the "racier" parts and the birth of Renesmee. (I'm sure readers patiently await these parts) Being the last book of the series (at this stage) I would have thought that they might have been, with all the other climactic action. But I understand.

However, it would be a greater disappointment not to have them included in the movie Breaking Dawn (if and when it is released) and New Moon and Eclipse also. Movies are obviously so much more a visual thing than an imaginative thing.

And to also consider cutting parts of the books out of the movie to make it a shorter movie experience would be disastrous. Readers almost always say the book is better than the movie. And I feel this way about all FOUR books and their transformation to movie...dont tear them to shreds.
Some of the most popular movies in history have been over three hours in length (and you can google that). Surely the producers, writers and Stephanie understand that fans would be prepared to sit for some time to see their favourite book portrayed in full.

Movie creation has come so far and there have been more complicated movies made than BD would be to make. I say put the dollars in and reap the rewards.

More than anything I would like to see them make a theatre version and a Special Extended Uncut version. Make the full movie, make three parts on three discs if you have to, make them racy and a bit gory, make them for what each one is and CAN be, give it an R rating....and then cut them down for theatre purposes to a lower rating. I know I would be prepared to see it in theatre and I would be first to line up to buy the extended uncut as well. I don't know if they will or have considered this but surely its worth while.

Every time I watch Twilight I keeping wishing each scene would go longer than it did the time before.

By: TeamEdward76

TeamEdward76 — Sat, 09 May 2009 19:28:23 +0000

This is the one I most look forward to!! I want them to stay true to the book, as for the rating, hmm, well, parents can brings their kids to a R-rated movies?? I hv no idea …
maybe two versions, one PG and one R …