dakota will be a great jane is a great actress , she can be sweet and i think she can be evil too :p
but for god's sake no high school musical acttors please..
there are great unseen actors outthere find the right one for alec ..

who really cares he fits the part of angelic but deadly

I thnk he is perfect for the part of alec. who cares if he is in HSM, Dakota was in charlottes web

i think it sucks totaaly..



but just saying.. the look the same LOL same nose nd eyes nd hair rofl weirddd


NO HSM PEOPLE!

Alexander Conti is the ultimate choice for Alec, age height experience and looks. Remember, they wear contacts and hair is dark not light blond.

CONTI is the logical choice out of everyone mentioned!!!

imo lucas is a too old to play alec

jane and alec are suppose to be twins.
he's too old. he's 24 for god's sake!

imo lucas is a too old to play alec


jane and alec are suppose to be twins.

he's too old. he's 24 for god's sake!

when i read new moon and the rest of the books with her and her family in them.
i picture dark blacked like pepole not blond and prepey

when i read new moon and the rest of the books with her and her family in them.
i picture dark blacked like pepole not blond and prepey

FREDDIE HAS TOO WEIRD A VOICE

YOU JUST CONTRADICTED YOURSELF, DAKOTA IS WELL KNOWN

YOU HAVE GOT TO BE KIDDING ME!!! FIRST, THEY CAST DAKOTA, ALREADY PUTTING ME IN A TERRIBLE MOOD AND NOW THIS????? IT. IS. NOT. HIGH. SCHOOL. RETARD. MUSICAL.

first i dont think dakota fanning can pull off jane i mean a blonde ... a girly girl sweetie pie ]: lmfao! if you go to janes myspace page shes a evill dark haired smaller girl shes perfect if you go there youcan sign a petittion to see if she wins the role and please no hsm! i mean lucas? wtff his like so gay and ugly and twilight is TWILIGHT and hsm/(gay) IS HSM god disney crap with beautiful twilight summit dose not go!! it should be someone diff or the guy in alecs myspace!

first i dont think dakota fanning can pull off jane i mean a blonde ... a girly girl sweetie pie ]: lmfao! if you go to janes myspace page shes a evill dark haired smaller girl shes perfect if you go there youcan sign a petittion to see if she wins the role and please no hsm! i mean lucas? wtff his like so gay and ugly and twilight is TWILIGHT and hsm/(gay) IS HSM god disney crap with beautiful twilight summit dose not go!! it should be someone diff or the guy in alecs myspace!

Okay. Seriously! There shouldnt be any like well known actors. Because that will just make it soo much worse. SERIOUSLY. Robert Pattinson is soo hott. Hahahha. But AnyHoo. I could see Little Miss Fanning as Jane...but it would be like O.o AND NOO HSM Stars. At all. Geez. I thought Twilight was amaazing. But I absolutly hated seeing My Man ((Robert)) Kissing the evil one, (Kristen) Bahha. But yes. Please no well known actors. Or actressess.

Thankyou:)

Okay. Seriously! There shouldnt be any like well known actors. Because that will just make it soo much worse. SERIOUSLY. Robert Pattinson is soo hott. Hahahha. But AnyHoo. I could see Little Miss Fanning as Jane...but it would be like O.o AND NOO HSM Stars. At all. Geez. I thought Twilight was amaazing. But I absolutly hated seeing My Man ((Robert)) Kissing the evil one, (Kristen) Bahha. But yes. Please no well known actors. Or actressess.


Thankyou:)

I like Lucas but he is no Alec. Why are people trying to put these Disney stars in Twilight? Gaspard Ulliel from Hannibal Rising would make a good Alec.

I like Lucas but he is no Alec. Why are people trying to put these Disney stars in Twilight? Gaspard Ulliel from Hannibal Rising would make a good Alec.

I AGREE WITH ALL 3 OF YOU!!

It looks kind of freaky which is good for Alec

High School Musical??
You have GOT to be kidding me!
Dakota Fanning is a keeper though ; )!

High School Musical??
You have GOT to be kidding me!

Dakota Fanning is a keeper though ; )!

sometimes its the people who you least expect would turn out totally perfect for the character... Dakota has played great characters in the past and she did an awesome job... she is crossing over and taking on new characters so maybe this is a good move for her... and let me remind everyone Robert seemed like a not so good choice at 1st but he turned out to be the best guy for the job... as for Alec's character.... Lucas might pass as Dakota's twin but i dunno... i'll pass on that...

sometimes its the people who you least expect would turn out totally perfect for the character... Dakota has played great characters in the past and she did an awesome job... she is crossing over and taking on new characters so maybe this is a good move for her... and let me remind everyone Robert seemed like a not so good choice at 1st but he turned out to be the best guy for the job... as for Alec's character.... Lucas might pass as Dakota's twin but i dunno... i'll pass on that...

like jodelle ferland for jane volturi google her get past her cute pics then go to the creepy ones

freddie has a weird ass smile

That's what I thought! It's good to know that I'm not the only one who thinks that.

I honestly can't picture Dakota but I think the Lucas would do a really good job. He's an amazing actor and if everyone just doesn't want him to do it because he's a HSM star I don't think thats a good enough reason.

Lucas even though all of he characters for the most part (all basically except the Holloweentown High where he was the bad guy, need I remind anyone) and I think that he would--could truly pull of Alec...not to mention all the other actors that have been listed make me want to gag!! EWW!! They are supposed to be irresistible for crying out loud. True Lucas is not drop dead gorgeous but I'm almost certain that he could pull off a flawless Lucas. If you disagree its your opinion. This is mine so I hope you all will respect that.

then again , maybe not Dakota.

I think that dakota fanning would be a great jane. As for lucas gabreel , i don't think so .

I honestly can't picture Dakota but I think the Lucas would do a really good job. He's an amazing actor and if everyone just doesn't want him to do it because he's a HSM star I don't think thats a good enough reason.


Lucas even though all of he characters for the most part (all basically except the Holloweentown High where he was the bad guy, need I remind anyone) and I think that he would--could truly pull of Alec...not to mention all the other actors that have been listed make me want to gag!! EWW!! They are supposed to be irresistible for crying out loud. True Lucas is not drop dead gorgeous but I'm almost certain that he could pull off a flawless Lucas. If you disagree its your opinion. This is mine so I hope you all will respect that.

then again , maybe not Dakota.

I think that dakota fanning would be a great jane. As for lucas gabreel , i don't think so .

Personally, I think, that the kid from the Unborn would be a good Alec. Ethan Cutkosky. He definately has that creep factor down well, and I think he could pull off a twin of Jodelle well. He might be a bit young based on how old she is now though, that would be my only consern.


The Unborn honestly, was not the greatest movie in the world, I pretty much laughed my way through the whole thing, but the one thing that did make me jump was him. Jodelle and him both know how to pull it off and I think they would do well together.



Though if he doesn't get it, I am open to a brand new person playing him, so long as they are able to pull it off well.

for alec i would go with michael pitt and for jane i would go for the chick from the uninvited lol

That's actually a good suggestion. I think the girl from uninvited could play Jane too.

That's actually a good suggestion. I think the girl from uninvited could play Jane too.

Dakota is a great actress dont get me wrong but i really dont see her playing that role. and having a disney character in Twilight? come on we cant have some character from High School Musical be this Blood sucking Vampire. DUH

for alec i would go with michael pitt and for jane i would go for the chick from the uninvited lol

Dakota is a great actress dont get me wrong but i really dont see her playing that role. and having a disney character in Twilight? come on we cant have some character from High School Musical be this Blood sucking Vampire. DUH

N O O O DISNEY's, E W !!! Dakota is a great actress, but she is W A Y too young and wouldn't fit in this role!

she's not young she's 15.. is the perfect age to do the jane character..

N O O O DISNEY's, E W !!! Dakota is a great actress, but she is W A Y too young and wouldn't fit in this role!

Comparing to the 4 fresh faces recently posted, Grabeel is not that bad of a choice.

SERIOUSLY.


they are both wrong for the roles. they need someone new, and fresh for both. i mean everyone in twilight was not a very well known actoractress. and that helps the movie. because if you did have people to well known, that just wouldn't work in the movie.! TOTALLY wrong!!!!!!!!!!! it's not right. so summit will just have to take the time to go on auditions and find two new actors to be in the movie....

Comparing to the 4 fresh faces recently posted, Grabeel is not that bad of a choice.

I agree with you. But I'm very skeptical about who they shoot as Alec. If they do cast Jodelle, then who would play her twin?
I just hope that the movie isn't screwed up by bad acting.

i feel really funny because almost all of the people here doesn't want to include all disney actors??? haiz.. y is that,u all don't want the ones they post,if people don't choose as early as that then just don't film new moon if all of u are all so freaking choosy.. just be contented to whom ever they put in that role.. its just an opinion of mine.. peace ya'll ^^,

They do look alike, but come on we dont want no disney actor in New Moon i mean hellllooooo!!! =]

omg! you all act like you're sooo indie,and sooo much the outcasts, get over yourselves. Not that I'm in favor of a Disney take over, but a lot of great actors got their start on the Disney channel, and the movies Dakota has been doing lately I think more than qualifies her to be in the movie. And, a few of the stars in Twilight were well known before the movie came out. Actors wanna work, they wanna make movies and do their jobs, they don't care about feeding into your loner indie the kids in high school don't get me crap! GET OVER IT!

Dakota is Great!
but.. Lucas? PLEASE noo! no HSM actors , please try to not screw the movie!

i feel really funny because almost all of the people here doesn't want to include all disney actors??? haiz.. y is that,u all don't want the ones they post,if people don't choose as early as that then just don't film new moon if all of u are all so freaking choosy.. just be contented to whom ever they put in that role.. its just an opinion of mine.. peace ya'll ^^,

They do look alike, but come on we dont want no disney actor in New Moon i mean hellllooooo!!! =]

what are they doing .. to MANy Stars FINd NOt sOOOO faM. actors .......
i think the kids in Race to Witch mountain a new movie coming out they look alike and are good with powers in movies go watch the trailer !!!!! AnnaSophia Robb and Alexander Ludwig

ok no disney people bad idea and i thought we were getting u know unknown actors for twilight i like that alot better

like jodelle ferland for jane volturi google her get past her cute pics then go to the creepy ones

omg! you all act like you're sooo indie,and sooo much the outcasts, get over yourselves. Not that I'm in favor of a Disney take over, but a lot of great actors got their start on the Disney channel, and the movies Dakota has been doing lately I think more than qualifies her to be in the movie. And, a few of the stars in Twilight were well known before the movie came out. Actors wanna work, they wanna make movies and do their jobs, they don't care about feeding into your loner indie the kids in high school don't get me crap! GET OVER IT!

i like dakota but not lucas way tooooooo old sorry please no HSM people gosh seriously there are other amazing actors out there.

I don't reli see dakota as jane but if she was I think the guy who played draco in harry potter should be Alec coz they look a lil bit like each other plus i think he has that whole evil look thing going lol!!

Dakota is Great!
but.. Lucas? PLEASE noo! no HSM actors , please try to not screw the movie!

can i just ask what's up with all suggestions for high school musical actors/actresses?!

I think he would make a great Alec, and i would like to point out to the people that said that Lucas and Dakota don't look twin like, they would be fraternal twins so of course they don't look exactly alike, they would only have similar dominate features which they do

Lucus doesnt really hav experiance in the horror/drama area of movie making. i DONT think he would be a good bit. Hes just to happy! him and dakota both arent good choices. neither has ever had the exprience and are just to known to be good in new moon. they need to keep the actors of new moon within the up and coming group.
also arent alec and jane brunnettes!?

*they're not...*

And stop acting like Twilight is this big indie underground secret. It's not! get over it, either stay on or jump ship, either way a lot of you people are very mean. I could understand if your criticisms were constructive but their not, stop being mean spirited, we should be behind our stars and the movies not working against them.

Stop type casting people. The point of being an actor is the ability to morph into different characters. Vanessa was wrong for Leah for more than on reason, but these two look the parts and they at least have talent. Give them a chance, have some faith in the people who brought us Twilight in the first place. If you were them you would want people to at least give you a chance, right? Be nice!

who are these idiots who keep suggestion High School Musical actors in the Twilight Saga
NO HM keep it Indie Please.

yea pleeeease no high school musical actors!!!
what r they thinking????!!!!

i think your right about jodelle ferland she would make a perfect jane
although im kind of wondering how dekota is going to pull off jane i just dont see it

and the high school musical actor should not be cast i dont think he would fit the role correctly some one who could give off a little creepy vibe would be better hes too cheerful looking

what are they doing .. to MANy Stars FINd NOt sOOOO faM. actors .......
i think the kids in Race to Witch mountain a new movie coming out they look alike and are good with powers in movies go watch the trailer !!!!! AnnaSophia Robb and Alexander Ludwig

*in her acting

I think Dakota will be amazing, and it will really help her grow up more him her acting. I am confident she will pull this off well, if she is jane. However I don't know about Lucas, he was ok in HSM and they are terrible films, who else could play Alec?

i say the olsen twins! hahaha!

by keisha: they should offer jane and alec's role to the olsen twins...LoL. they have the height and are sort of androgynous, so one of them can play alec...just a thought :)

ok no disney people bad idea and i thought we were getting u know unknown actors for twilight i like that alot better

again please no DISNEY members......

I think he'd be great. He's so lovely to look at, also. :D Me likey

i like dakota but not lucas way tooooooo old sorry please no HSM people gosh seriously there are other amazing actors out there.

I think Dakota will do great, but I dont think Lucas can pull Alec off.

i agree...dakota will do just fine because of her acting abilities and because she has the cute face that looks kind of evil, but lucas is not right 4 the part

You're right, Sarah... I didnt know he wasnt acting anymore. I just thougt he was adorable in HP. What about Freddie Highmore?

freddie has a weird ass smile

It looks kind of freaky which is good for Alec

I don't reli see dakota as jane but if she was I think the guy who played draco in harry potter should be Alec coz they look a lil bit like each other plus i think he has that whole evil look thing going lol!!

Hmm.. I dont doubt his acting abilities, he's a pretty good actor but... he is a bit tall, so that kind of shatters that part of Alec's physical description... They should find someone else, imo.
Still Team Dakota though=]

oh my god. they are screwing this movie up! why are they keep trying to get high school musical stars in this movie? thats, like, the worse. they just cannot find anyone, can they?

^^ I agree. I can't see Dakota playing an angel like really blonde vicious girl. I just don't see it. And PLEASE NO HIGH SCHOOL MUSICAL ACTORS!

they should offer jane and alec's role to the olsen twins...LoL. they have the height and are sort of androgynous, so one of them can play alec...just a thought :)

wheheheheheheheh :PP

Just think back to how many people thought that Rob not play the part well...........There are casting people for a reason they know what they are doing......and all of these are just maybes at this point anyway

yea pleeeease no high school musical actors!!!
what r they thinking????!!!!

Alex Linz from One Fine Day or Will Teakston from Harry Potter... maybe?

will theakston will be rubbish he doesn't look like alec at all! besides he's not acting no more!
that alex linz looks more appealing though!
:)

i agree...dakota will do just fine because of her acting abilities and because she has the cute face that looks kind of evil, but lucas is not right 4 the part

Im not comfortable with either of them personally. Again.. on there own they are great, I love Lucas. However, both Jane and Alec are twins... and both are supposedly very dark, Jane scares people easily..

Unfortuantly, I have not seen Dakota in a role that she is really terrifying in. Perhaps if I saw one I might be more inclined to vote yes for her. Though, if they are thinking of using a fifteen year old, why not use a thirteen year old? Jodelle Ferland to me is Jane, she can pull of the evil role well, as well as the looks of an angelic little girl.

Lucas, well hes great and all, and yes im sure he could walk in a ditch or something. But the point remains, he was not only in Highschool musical as a happy go lucky sort, but every other movie that I have watched with him in it, again, happy.

So I am not going to be falsly judgemental, I trust that the people doing casting know what they are looking for. They personally would not be my first choices, and hopefully they will portray the characters well if they are chosen.

The twins are two of my FAVOURITE characters in the series. Please PLEASE do not disapoint with bad casting!!!!

I agree with you. But I'm very skeptical about who they shoot as Alec. If they do cast Jodelle, then who would play her twin?
I just hope that the movie isn't screwed up by bad acting.

Personally, I think, that the kid from the Unborn would be a good Alec. Ethan Cutkosky. He definately has that creep factor down well, and I think he could pull off a twin of Jodelle well. He might be a bit young based on how old she is now though, that would be my only consern.

The Unborn honestly, was not the greatest movie in the world, I pretty much laughed my way through the whole thing, but the one thing that did make me jump was him. Jodelle and him both know how to pull it off and I think they would do well together.

Though if he doesn't get it, I am open to a brand new person playing him, so long as they are able to pull it off well.

i think your right about jodelle ferland she would make a perfect jane
although im kind of wondering how dekota is going to pull off jane i just dont see it
and the high school musical actor should not be cast i dont think he would fit the role correctly some one who could give off a little creepy vibe would be better hes too cheerful looking

nooooooo hed be TERRIBLE

can i just ask what's up with all suggestions for high school musical actors/actresses?!

I think he would make a great Alec, and i would like to point out to the people that said that Lucas and Dakota don't look twin like, they would be fraternal twins so of course they don't look exactly alike, they would only have similar dominate features which they do

Lucus doesnt really hav experiance in the horror/drama area of movie making. i DONT think he would be a good bit. Hes just to happy! him and dakota both arent good choices. neither has ever had the exprience and are just to known to be good in new moon. they need to keep the actors of new moon within the up and coming group.
also arent alec and jane brunnettes!?

*they're not...*

And stop acting like Twilight is this big indie underground secret. It's not! get over it, either stay on or jump ship, either way a lot of you people are very mean. I could understand if your criticisms were constructive but their not, stop being mean spirited, we should be behind our stars and the movies not working against them.

Stop type casting people. The point of being an actor is the ability to morph into different characters. Vanessa was wrong for Leah for more than on reason, but these two look the parts and they at least have talent. Give them a chance, have some faith in the people who brought us Twilight in the first place. If you were them you would want people to at least give you a chance, right? Be nice!

who are these idiots who keep suggestion High School Musical actors in the Twilight Saga
NO HM keep it Indie Please.

HALE NO!!He would be so useless as Alec.They cant do that.

*in her acting

I think Dakota will be amazing, and it will really help her grow up more him her acting. I am confident she will pull this off well, if she is jane. However I don't know about Lucas, he was ok in HSM and they are terrible films, who else could play Alec?

i say the olsen twins! hahaha!


by keisha: they should offer jane and alec's role to the olsen twins...LoL. they have the height and are sort of androgynous, so one of them can play alec...just a thought :)

It's not twin like is it? I thought they were twins!

again please no DISNEY members......

I think he'd be great. He's so lovely to look at, also. :D Me likey

I think Dakota Fanning plays well a Jane but I don't feel it for Lucas either.

I think Dakota will do great, but I dont think Lucas can pull Alec off.

Hmm... I don't know. I honestly don't know who should play Alec. And I'm certainly not sure about Lucas. He was great in High School Musical, but I'm not sure if he can put off Alec in New Moon. It just feels a little weird. But maybe he'll do great. I'm trusting Chris on this. I hope he can make a good choice xD>

You're right, Sarah... I didnt know he wasnt acting anymore. I just thougt he was adorable in HP. What about Freddie Highmore?

I find it hard to see Dakota Fanning as Jane in the new movie to the Twilight Sage Series. Maybe it's just me but I don't know. In the end of it all maybe she will do a great job like she did in all of her other movies. I just hope that Chris Weitz knows what he is doing, to make this movie great. Because I am 100% the biggest Twilight Fan, Go Edward's Team......

SERIOUSLY.

they are both wrong for the roles. they need someone new, and fresh for both. i mean everyone in twilight was not a very well known actor\actress. and that helps the movie. because if you did have people to well known, that just wouldn't work in the movie.! TOTALLY wrong!!!!!!!!!!! it's not right. so summit will just have to take the time to go on auditions and find two new actors to be in the movie....

dakota was a great fan of twilight that why she wanted a roll in the movie and i guess that she's perfect for jane
she 's got the age
the white kind of ill skin and she0s blonde.
and she's a perfect actress

I AGREE WITH ALL 3 OF YOU!!

^^ I agree. I can't see Dakota playing an angel like really blonde vicious girl. I just don't see it. And PLEASE NO HIGH SCHOOL MUSICAL ACTORS!

i agree with the part of no high school musical actors ...

Hmm.. I dont doubt his acting abilities, he's a pretty good actor but... he is a bit tall, so that kind of shatters that part of Alec's physical description... They should find someone else, imo.
Still Team Dakota though=]

oh my god. they are screwing this movie up! why are they keep trying to get high school musical stars in this movie? thats, like, the worse. they just cannot find anyone, can they?

wheheheheheheheh :PP

they should offer jane and alec's role to the olsen twins...LoL. they have the height and are sort of androgynous, so one of them can play alec...just a thought :)

will theakston will be rubbish he doesn't look like alec at all! besides he's not acting no more!
that alex linz looks more appealing though!

:)

Just think back to how many people thought that Rob not play the part well...........There are casting people for a reason they know what they are doing......and all of these are just maybes at this point anyway

Alex Linz from One Fine Day or Will Teakston from Harry Potter... maybe?

Im not comfortable with either of them personally. Again.. on there own they are great, I love Lucas. However, both Jane and Alec are twins... and both are supposedly very dark, Jane scares people easily..


Unfortuantly, I have not seen Dakota in a role that she is really terrifying in. Perhaps if I saw one I might be more inclined to vote yes for her. Though, if they are thinking of using a fifteen year old, why not use a thirteen year old? Jodelle Ferland to me is Jane, she can pull of the evil role well, as well as the looks of an angelic little girl.



Lucas, well hes great and all, and yes im sure he could walk in a ditch or something. But the point remains, he was not only in Highschool musical as a happy go lucky sort, but every other movie that I have watched with him in it, again, happy.



So I am not going to be falsly judgemental, I trust that the people doing casting know what they are looking for. They personally would not be my first choices, and hopefully they will portray the characters well if they are chosen.



The twins are two of my FAVOURITE characters in the series. Please PLEASE do not disapoint with bad casting!!!!

nooooooo hed be TERRIBLE

HALE NO!!He would be so useless as Alec.They cant do that.

It's not twin like is it? I thought they were twins!

I think Dakota Fanning plays well a Jane but I don't feel it for Lucas either.

Hmm... I don't know. I honestly don't know who should play Alec. And I'm certainly not sure about Lucas. He was great in High School Musical, but I'm not sure if he can put off Alec in New Moon. It just feels a little weird. But maybe he'll do great. I'm trusting Chris on this. I hope he can make a good choice xD>

I find it hard to see Dakota Fanning as Jane in the new movie to the Twilight Sage Series. Maybe it's just me but I don't know. In the end of it all maybe she will do a great job like she did in all of her other movies. I just hope that Chris Weitz knows what he is doing, to make this movie great. Because I am 100% the biggest Twilight Fan, Go Edward's Team......