a ttly agree with that she'd b best for the part

Jodelle Ferland in newmoon is a MUST! she could look creppy in newmoon and look like a child 2! PLEASE!!! i should really become a member of this...

Jodelle Ferland in newmoon is a MUST! she could look creppy in newmoon and look like a child 2! PLEASE!!! i should really become a member of this...

i agreeeeeeee!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! jodelle ferland should reallllllllly be her! not dat stupid blonde. no offenese pplz.

I think Hayden Panettiere from Heroes should play Jane. Too bad she's not trying out for it.

If you think Jodelle Ferland should play Jane go to this website!

http://www.thepetitionsite.com/1/jodelle-ferlan...

I think Hayden Panettiere from Heroes should play Jane. Too bad she's not trying out for it.

If you think Jodelle Ferland should play Jane go to this website!


http://www.thepetitionsite.com/1/jodelle-ferlan...

The role of Jane is suppose to look young.... But your right no Dakota! Jodelle Ferland would be the best Jane!

The role of Jane is suppose to look young.... But your right no Dakota! Jodelle Ferland would be the best Jane!

NO NO NO NO NO! dakota CAN NOT play Jane... she is 2 young and is NOT how i pictured her! sorry Dakota but... NO! :)

Lucy Hale looks too old for the part. I think Jodelle would be great! and she is more creepy xD but Dakota is good too

NO NO NO NO NO! dakota CAN NOT play Jane... she is 2 young and is NOT how i pictured her! sorry Dakota but... NO! :)

Lucy Hale looks too old for the part. I think Jodelle would be great! and she is more creepy xD but Dakota is good too

Jodelle. Hands down. I haven't seen Silent Hill, but know of other work she has done before that on the Stargate series. She is an amazing actress, and has been since the age of seven when she played Adria -- ultimate universal evil caught in a little girl's body. And she later played another character at 12 -- a good/bad EVIL girl who liked to play the other characters off of each other. She pulled both roles off amazingly well, and every comment I've ever heard from the cast and crew who worked with her said she was incredibly professional and that they were very impressed with her.

Jodelle. Hands down. I haven't seen Silent Hill, but know of other work she has done before that on the Stargate series. She is an amazing actress, and has been since the age of seven when she played Adria -- ultimate universal evil caught in a little girl's body. And she later played another character at 12 -- a good/bad EVIL girl who liked to play the other characters off of each other. She pulled both roles off amazingly well, and every comment I've ever heard from the cast and crew who worked with her said she was incredibly professional and that they were very impressed with her.

We vote for Jodelle Ferland!

We agree with that! Jodelle Ferland should get the role of Jane!

We vote for Jodelle Ferland!

I agree with that Jodelle Ferland could pull of the role of Jane so much better then Dakota Fanning could!

Doing what's best for the film would be to stop talking about casting Dakota Fanning for the role of Jane and just give it to Jodelle Ferland!

Right and Jodelle Ferland would be perfect for that!

Please read then decide......




Jane is slight with short, pale brown hair. She has a rather slim and androgynous figure. She has an angelic face, which is the only thing that keeps her from being mistaken for a boy. She has wide eyes, full lips, and a childlike voice. Her eyes are red/black. Along with her face being angelic, it is also described as being fiercely childlike.

Don't get me wrong I think amanda seyfried is a good actress but to old to play a role that's described as being fiercely childlike. Jodelle Ferland looks the part the best!

I agree, Jodelle Ferland sould get the part of Jane!

Jodelle Ferland would do a better job then Dakota Fanning. Yes you are right about how Jane has brown hair and it wouldn't be hard to get hair color, but the fact is Dakota can't pull off a scary role like Jodelle Ferland can! Jodelle or Dakota are not young for the role they are both 14 and Jane is also described as being fiercely childlike!

I hope Dakota doesn't take it and then they give it to Jodelle Ferland!

I dont care who plays jane..

I dont care who plays jane..

They will pick whoever they want as Jane. But based on the pics, Jodelle looks the most like how I pictured Jane.

They will pick whoever they want as Jane. But based on the pics, Jodelle looks the most like how I pictured Jane.

Save New Moon! Dakota Fanning is not a perfect Jane. Jodelle should be Jane!

We agree with that! Jodelle Ferland should get the role of Jane!

i don't like Dakota Fanning, specially as Jane. I think Jodelle would be perfect for the role.

Save New Moon! Dakota Fanning is not a perfect Jane. Jodelle should be Jane!

Yes she would!! The little girl that Victoria turned and nobody killed at the battle and Carlisle was trying to save her from the volturi but they ended up killing her anyway... she would be perfect.

i don't like Dakota Fanning, specially as Jane. I think Jodelle would be perfect for the role.

i don't like any of those girls playing jane because they don't go with the description of the character... i think that it should play it amanda seyfried!

Don't get me wrong I think amanda seyfried is a good actress but to old to play a role that's described as being fiercely childlike. Jodelle Ferland looks the part the best!

i don't like any of those girls playing jane because they don't go with the description of the character... i think that it should play it amanda seyfried!

i think jodelle ferland should play it! I think she did a great job in Silent Hill and i think she can defnitely pull off the roll of Jane....

i think jodelle ferland should play it! I think she did a great job in Silent Hill and i think she can defnitely pull off the roll of Jane....

When i was reading New Moon Jodelle was exactly like how i picture Jane. Then when i saw her picture i was like she has to get it. no offense to dakota but i personally just think jodelle will be more believeavble and also she just looks more the part.

I agree, Jodelle Ferland sould get the part of Jane!

what the hell renesmee sucks jodelle wouldnt stoop that low

Jodelle - She can do the whole scary, but child like thing.
I pictured jane like her. Plumb face. Small. Ect..

i totally agree with you about the whole vanessa hudgens thing she will totally ruin the whole movie.

When i was reading New Moon Jodelle was exactly like how i picture Jane. Then when i saw her picture i was like she has to get it. no offense to dakota but i personally just think jodelle will be more believeavble and also she just looks more the part.

jodelle ferland should play jane because she actually looks younger and menacing. like jane does. dakota fanning looks brighter and nice, thats why i think she shouldnt get the part.

Jodelle - She can do the whole scary, but child like thing.
I pictured jane like her. Plumb face. Small. Ect..

I'm 21 and a big twilight fan. I don't think Dakota should be Jane she's already a rising star to go back to square one for a character that mostly stares, glares, & utters simple lines hugh makes no sense to me at all. Jodelle Ferland should be Jane she has that evil mysterious look without even trying.

jodelle ferland should play jane because she actually looks younger and menacing. like jane does. dakota fanning looks brighter and nice, thats why i think she shouldnt get the part.

Jodelle is how i pictured jane. dakota, not at all. i didnt picture jane with blonde hair. pshh, of how things look shes probably gonna take it though.

they're going to shoot the movie NM & Eclipse back to back so the casting directors don't have to worry about an actress aging and looking older cause they are going to shoot all her parts at the same time
Jodelle all the way

I'm 21 and a big twilight fan. I don't think Dakota should be Jane she's already a rising star to go back to square one for a character that mostly stares, glares, & utters simple lines hugh makes no sense to me at all. Jodelle Ferland should be Jane she has that evil mysterious look without even trying.

Jodelle is how i pictured jane. dakota, not at all. i didnt picture jane with blonde hair. pshh, of how things look shes probably gonna take it though.

is a small but not less important role in the twilight series, i bet dakota as jane, but i also bet jodelle for reneesme ! is such a great girl for the role even when noone knows if are going to be a breaking dawn movie.

what the hell renesmee sucks jodelle wouldnt stoop that low

i think jodelle should get it.
she just looks right for the part.

also i agree with someone else
about how more famous people will almost ruin it
when they said vanessa hudgens was auditioning i was like that will no doubt screw up the movie.
to me
they need fresh people
people who haven't really done any projects or maybe a few that they didn't get completely famous for
just because with like hudgens everyone already sees her as gabirella in hsm.
so its hard to picture her in this.
but when its a fresh face we haven't really seen before
its a lot easier and a lot more believable

which is another reason jodelle should get the part
but seriously she just looks the part to me
no doubt about it

i totally agree with you about the whole vanessa hudgens thing she will totally ruin the whole movie.

is a small but not less important role in the twilight series, i bet dakota as jane, but i also bet jodelle for reneesme ! is such a great girl for the role even when noone knows if are going to be a breaking dawn movie.

I don't care who gets it as long as the personify it correctly. Hopefully they give Jane dark hair and eyes though

i think jodelle should get it.
she just looks right for the part.



also i agree with someone else

about how more famous people will almost ruin it

when they said vanessa hudgens was auditioning i was like that will no doubt screw up the movie.

to me

they need fresh people

people who haven't really done any projects or maybe a few that they didn't get completely famous for

just because with like hudgens everyone already sees her as gabirella in hsm.

so its hard to picture her in this.

but when its a fresh face we haven't really seen before

its a lot easier and a lot more believable



which is another reason jodelle should get the part

but seriously she just looks the part to me

no doubt about it

yeah...also, the whole jane character needs to be able to look cute, but she also needs to pull off a really serious side. but she definitely needs darker hair, though

I don't care who gets it as long as the personify it correctly. Hopefully they give Jane dark hair and eyes though

i think that they need to fill the majority of the roles with no name actors/actresses!

I think Jodelle ferland would be perfect she looks so evil and young aswell, jane is meant to be young right? I think she'd be awesome for the part xx

One of those two..just not Dakota

I think Jodelle would be perfect!

Whats with all this Jodelle? dakota is better

I think Dakota is cool. I havent seen her since Charolette's Web... so her new picture kinda shocked me. She will be great for the role, even though it is small.

I think Jodelle ferland would be perfect she looks so evil and young aswell, jane is meant to be young right? I think she'd be awesome for the part xx

young!.. but not kids..
but yeah she's a good actress.

One of those two..just not Dakota

I think Jodelle would be perfect!

Whats with all this Jodelle? dakota is better

I think Dakota is cool. I havent seen her since Charolette's Web... so her new picture kinda shocked me. She will be great for the role, even though it is small.

My intent here was not to offend anyone. And, I believe if you read from the beginning, there was more than 1 low blow delivered here. And I was honestly asking a serious question. Listen I appreciate and respect the opinion and passion of kiristenlSbella and was merely having a discussion. May we all enjoy the future of Twilight and the series, it truly is an exciting adventure to get lost in.

JODELLE!!!!

i think Jodelle Ferland would do a good job she definitely looks ike jane but i am then worried about the cast for alec ... Jodelle has a much younger looking face then dakota so you would have to get a much younger looking alec then the actors you've been considering.....
i still think dakota would do a fantastic job though if she gets picked
definitely NOT lucy hale though

JODELLE!!!!

Jodelle.

She just oozes Jane. Shes played evil great and ALOT of times, so shed be great. shes really talented and sort of unknown.

I was going for Fanning but I think Ferland may make a better Jane and in the polls it looks like that's what most people think too. Still either one will be alright they just really need to do a good job with being Jane.

calm down kids, it's just a comment board. to be fair sorority gal kinda insinuated she did kno her. tho i see both of your points and they are both quite valid, there's really no need to get all angsty. take a breath and be friggin happy that they're making the movie at all! peace!

LUCY HALE ..
to me i just never saw dakota fanning as playing jane iunno maybe she looks a bit TOO young?
if they somehow chose annasophia robb i wouldnt really mind it i agree with rowena, she can look angelic and evil.
how about jessica szhor for leah? (sorry out of the subject)
but i chose LUCY HALE

joelle should totally get this part! shes a great occult actress and can look scary and innocent at the same time.

I agree with anna sophia robb. She can look so evil and so angelic. watch the reaping for referrence.

i think Jodelle Ferland would do a good job she definitely looks ike jane but i am then worried about the cast for alec ... Jodelle has a much younger looking face then dakota so you would have to get a much younger looking alec then the actors you've been considering.....
i still think dakota would do a fantastic job though if she gets picked

definitely NOT lucy hale though

My word isn't Jodelle Ferland a charming little thing. She would be an awesome look for Jane. The whole sweet,innocent charm and then ripes your head off evil. Devious!

Ok, I am going to weigh in with the obvious thing that everyone has ignored....Jane is a vampire...and ever-frozen-in-time vampire. Anyone young enough to play Jane is going to be noticably older in subsequent films, they might even grow taller, which would ruin the effect of all these terrifying vampires being so scared of her. With that said, Dakota Fanning has younger sister that looks A LOT like her. Elle has played Dakota's younger self in more then one film.She is four years younger, and an experienced actress herself. I think it would be awesome for Dakota to start the part, and her sister Elle end up the film. It makes sense if you think about it, it would helpkeep the continuity of the character's appearance. They need to find a similar pair to play Alec, especially since boys hit puberty at around that age and that could really screw things up. Think about how most of the fans reacted to possibility of Talyor Lautner being replaced, it could ruin the series. It just makes sense to plan for the sequels. That's my vote!

they're going to shoot the movie NM & Eclipse back to back so the casting directors don't have to worry about an actress aging and looking older cause they are going to shoot all her parts at the same time
Jodelle all the way

Between the three, Dakota....Jodelle looks way too young. Jane is supposed to be child like not a child. Dakota looks older.

Jodelle!!!

Jodelle.


She just oozes Jane. Shes played evil great and ALOT of times, so shed be great. shes really talented and sort of unknown.

I was going for Fanning but I think Ferland may make a better Jane and in the polls it looks like that's what most people think too. Still either one will be alright they just really need to do a good job with being Jane.

dakota or ferland

LUCY HALE ..
to me i just never saw dakota fanning as playing jane iunno maybe she looks a bit TOO young?

if they somehow chose annasophia robb i wouldnt really mind it i agree with rowena, she can look angelic and evil.

how about jessica szhor for leah? (sorry out of the subject)

but i chose LUCY HALE

i think they r all good choices besides that lucy hale girl she would suck for the part but i like dakota and jodelle they look good for the part especially jodelle

joelle should totally get this part! shes a great occult actress and can look scary and innocent at the same time.

and who would that be??? (Don't leave everyone hanging!!)

Totally not a good enough reason to miss out on New Moon. No matter how it turns out if you love the story you should enjoy the movie

Jodelle Dakota mother trucking sucks

I agree with anna sophia robb. She can look so evil and so angelic. watch the reaping for referrence.

jodelle...enough said.

i agree with you i feel dakota would be a good choice cause she has the acting skills and jodelle would be good to i just want a good actress to play the part but i agree with you on the dakota thing

not here sorry i meant at "do you know her just curious"

whoa kinda a low blow here...

My word isn't Jodelle Ferland a charming little thing. She would be an awesome look for Jane. The whole sweet,innocent charm and then ripes your head off evil. Devious!

i think jodelle is the perfect girl with the whole i just a little girl kind of look

Between the three, Dakota....Jodelle looks way too young. Jane is supposed to be child like not a child. Dakota looks older.

no

Jodelle!!!

I pick Dakota for Jane. I think Jodelle would be good, but I have another character in mind that she would fit better. ; )

and who would that be??? (Don't leave everyone hanging!!)

Jodelle for Jane Volturi 2009 copy and paste if you agree

I dont care bout dakota she dont even use her real name cuz her real names not dakota its hannah...Jodelle

Jodelle

Jodelle all the way...she really could be great and she is an amazing actress even though i agree Dakota is also but please pick jodelle

I wanna really see jodelle do her stuff PICK HER

Please if you have any taste Jodelle

dakota or ferland

Ima twilight guy..my GF got me into it so if i would choose anybody it would be Jodelle she just seems kinda cool and fit for the part

IM gonna be the one in a while to say Dakota

My friend showed me this and i think Jodelle should get the part she really deserves it as much as dakota does please pick JODELLE

OMNW (oh my new moon) Jodelle is wonderful actress...she has expirence jodelle is amazing while dakota is playing sweet cuddly parts such as the girl in the pig movie

Jodelle would be awesome i never knew of her but i looked her up and she seems like a good person to be Jane..

JODELLE

omg i hope jodelle gets it she deserves it

Yea Mariah your right jodelle is so perfect for the part

OMG please please if you have any sence please pick Jodelle shes best for the part pleaseeeeeeee

im not gonna see new moon if dakotas jane...but i think jodelle is perfect

Totally not a good enough reason to miss out on New Moon. No matter how it turns out if you love the story you should enjoy the movie

jodelle ferland PLEASE

Jodelle would be awesome

JODELLE FRICKING FERLAND

i always imagined jodelle as being jane....i saw her in silent hill and she was awesome

i was in target last night and saw the silent hill dvd cover...hehe. i can totally picture her as jane! but dakota's a great actress and i bet she can pull off the role as well...so to me its a tie.

ANNASOPHIA ROBB!

no doubt about it! shes the absolute best, just watch this vid!!!!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EVcQFKJCCLs

shes amazinggg and perfect!!!!

It might be a small role in New Moon, but it gets bigger, especially in Breaking Dawn. I think she might take it just to be part of the whole Twilight phenomenon. Look how Cam Gigandet's star rose due to his role of James, even though James dies in Twilight and won't be back in any of the other movies (unfortunately!)

i think they r all good choices besides that lucy hale girl she would suck for the part but i like dakota and jodelle they look good for the part especially jodelle

yes alessa

Jodelle Dakota mother trucking sucks

Do you know her? Just curious.

jodelle...enough said.

i agree this role is too small for Dakota but she could probably do a great job

Please don't talk down to me, I'm not a child. My point is simply this, they are stars because we make them stars. I think it is unfair for us to make them so, and then turn around and not want them bc they have become what we made them. Her name and resume aside, she is a great actress and should be given a chance. And, to say that she wouldn't take a part because she is "too big" is an unfair judgment. You don't know her or the type of role that she would take, or the motivation behind offering her the role in the first place.

Clearly you are upset. I am many years removed from high school and sorority life, with children of my own now, i.e. the name TwilightMom. I don't mind outstanding actors and am a huge fan of Dakota, I just happen to think the movie already has the best of what it needs and there are many excellent actors out there that are not name pieces. No one has a monopoly on the movie or the books for goodness sakes. It's nice to finally see a movie with such unknown talent instead of being overpowered is my only point.

Jodelle Ferland - Shes how i pictured Jane.
She can do a evil look, i think.

Mwha-Emma Xx

have you seen any Silent Hill movies she fricking killed the whole church cult omg look up her scarier pictures

AnnaSophia Robb should play Jane!!

AnnaSophia Robb should play Jane!!

What's in a name? A good actor is good actor no matter what their name is, should the film be deprived of the best just because the 'hot topic wearing, my life sucks and I hate high school' crowd think that they have a monopoly on Twilight. Because I don't fit into that category. I'm in a sorority I was involved in high school, I have many friends and I love Twilight just as much as everyone else on here. It's not about star power or attracting a new audience, It's about doing what's best for the film.

i think jodelle is the perfect girl with the whole i just a little girl kind of look

You are correct, it is a great project, but my concern is that by the time they get to Eclipse the star power will overshadow the story. The story is a very riveting love story about "normal" people (or as normal as vampires are I guess). Which is why I think it attracks the people it does. It would be very sad if it was ruined just to make a buck, the movies will make plenty of money without the big stars. Take Bella's mom in Twilight for instance, a very small part by a good actress although not STAR power, still a great actress and she got the job done. NO need for someone with a bigger name to be in that part. Just let the movie be what it is.

i think jodelle ferand is a better looking jane than dakota. and yea she the girl from silent hill

i think olive from pushing daisies is perfect. i don't know her real name

hm, i think dakota will be great for the part, but its such a small part in this movie i dont see why she would take it. I mean she is an a list actress, she needs bigger rolls. But i think sh ewill probably get the role no matter what people say anyways haha.

there is no such thing as a small part, and sometimes actors want to be apart of a great project that they believe in even if it is only a small part. The role might be small but it still needs to be acted well.

I pick Dakota for Jane. I think Jodelle would be good, but I have another character in mind that she would fit better. ; )

Jodelle for Jane Volturi 2009 copy and paste if you agree

I dont care bout dakota she dont even use her real name cuz her real names not dakota its hannah...Jodelle

have you seen any Silent Hill movies she fricking killed the whole church cult omg look up her scarier pictures

Jodelle all the way...she really could be great and she is an amazing actress even though i agree Dakota is also but please pick jodelle

Please if you have any taste Jodelle

Everyone who said jodelle be sure to vote for her I DID LIKE 5000 times lolz yea so um i totally back up Jodelle 50000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000% all the way through

Ima twilight guy..my GF got me into it so if i would choose anybody it would be Jodelle she just seems kinda cool and fit for the part

IM gonna be the one in a while to say Dakota

My friend showed me this and i think Jodelle should get the part she really deserves it as much as dakota does please pick JODELLE

isn't Jodelle the girl from Silent Hill?

yes alessa

i was in target last night and saw the silent hill dvd cover...hehe. i can totally picture her as jane! but dakota's a great actress and i bet she can pull off the role as well...so to me its a tie.

OMNW (oh my new moon) Jodelle is wonderful actress...she has expirence jodelle is amazing while dakota is playing sweet cuddly parts such as the girl in the pig movie

Jodelle would be awesome i never knew of her but i looked her up and she seems like a good person to be Jane..

JODELLE

Yea Mariah your right jodelle is so perfect for the part

OMG please please if you have any sence please pick Jodelle shes best for the part pleaseeeeeeee

jodelle ferland PLEASE

JODELLE FRICKING FERLAND

ANNASOPHIA ROBB!


no doubt about it! shes the absolute best, just watch this vid!!!!



http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EVcQFKJCCLs



shes amazinggg and perfect!!!!

It might be a small role in New Moon, but it gets bigger, especially in Breaking Dawn. I think she might take it just to be part of the whole Twilight phenomenon. Look how Cam Gigandet's star rose due to his role of James, even though James dies in Twilight and won't be back in any of the other movies (unfortunately!)

I think Jodelle Ferland would be good for the part.....although Dakota will get the part.

I voted "someone else" and my choices are AnnaSophia Robb and Dakota Blue Richards. Anyone but Fanning.

yea i agree about annasophia robb she has a more menacing persona about her.

i agree this role is too small for Dakota but she could probably do a great job

i'm going to vote for Lucy Hale. I really like Dakota, but she's too young for the role. And I always picture Jane with dark brown hair.

jane IS supposed to be YOUNG or young looking at least. and dakota is perfect.
plp tend to forget that there is such a thing as hair tint aaaaand jane is not a character that can be easily pulled of. it needs acting skillz and dakota has them. we dont need another disney or nickelodeon star in here plzz!!
team dakota!!!

Jodelle Ferland would do a better job then Dakota Fanning. Yes you are right about how Jane has brown hair and it wouldn't be hard to get hair color, but the fact is Dakota can't pull off a scary role like Jodelle Ferland can! Jodelle or Dakota are not young for the role they are both 14 and Jane is also described as being fiercely childlike!

i agree with you i feel dakota would be a good choice cause she has the acting skills and jodelle would be good to i just want a good actress to play the part but i agree with you on the dakota thing

young!.. but not kids..
but yeah she's a good actress.

yeah...also, the whole jane character needs to be able to look cute, but she also needs to pull off a really serious side. but she definitely needs darker hair, though

Jodelle Ferland - Shes how i pictured Jane.
She can do a evil look, i think.



Mwha-Emma Xx

Dakota willbe fine because she will have Eclispe and Breaking Dawn to think about. She would be getting her feet wet for much bigger role in the end. I think she is the best to choose from. Now Jodelle Ferland would be great for the Breaking Dawn for those of you who have read the book already.

Yes she would!! The little girl that Victoria turned and nobody killed at the battle and Carlisle was trying to save her from the volturi but they ended up killing her anyway... she would be perfect.

So difficult >.<! I think I'm still going to vote for Dakota, because I really love her (I love the other actresses too, but I really think Dakota can do this well). Still.. It's not mine, nor our, decision. And I'm glad I don't have to make it XD.

i think jodelle ferand is a better looking jane than dakota. and yea she the girl from silent hill

yea i agree about annasophia robb she has a more menacing persona about her.

i think olive from pushing daisies is perfect. i don't know her real name

Her name is Kristen Chenoweth. She was the original Galinda/Glinda in the musical Wicked.

Everyone needs to calm down. Dakota Fanning has already been chosen, and I think she'll do a great job. Jane isn't supposed to look evil, she is supposed to be childlike. She is supposed to give the impression that she is evil but not necessarily look the part. It will be interesting to see her in the role.

hm, i think dakota will be great for the part, but its such a small part in this movie i dont see why she would take it. I mean she is an a list actress, she needs bigger rolls. But i think sh ewill probably get the role no matter what people say anyways haha.

jane IS supposed to be YOUNG or young looking at least. and dakota is perfect.
plp tend to forget that there is such a thing as hair tint aaaaand jane is not a character that can be easily pulled of. it needs acting skillz and dakota has them. we dont need another disney or nickelodeon star in here plzz!!

team dakota!!!

oooo :o i luv Lucy Hale!!

It's just such a small role, I don't see Dakota taking it.

i agreeeeeeee!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! jodelle ferland should reallllllllly be her! not dat stupid blonde. no offenese pplz.

Please read then decide......


Jane is slight with short, pale brown hair. She has a rather slim and androgynous figure. She has an angelic face, which is the only thing that keeps her from being mistaken for a boy. She has wide eyes, full lips, and a childlike voice. Her eyes are red/black. Along with her face being angelic, it is also described as being fiercely childlike.

I hope Dakota doesn't take it and then they give it to Jodelle Ferland!

I agree with that Jodelle Ferland could pull of the role of Jane so much better then Dakota Fanning could!

there is no such thing as a small part, and sometimes actors want to be apart of a great project that they believe in even if it is only a small part. The role might be small but it still needs to be acted well.

Right and Jodelle Ferland would be perfect for that!

You are correct, it is a great project, but my concern is that by the time they get to Eclipse the star power will overshadow the story. The story is a very riveting love story about "normal" people (or as normal as vampires are I guess). Which is why I think it attracks the people it does. It would be very sad if it was ruined just to make a buck, the movies will make plenty of money without the big stars. Take Bella's mom in Twilight for instance, a very small part by a good actress although not STAR power, still a great actress and she got the job done. NO need for someone with a bigger name to be in that part. Just let the movie be what it is.

What's in a name? A good actor is good actor no matter what their name is, should the film be deprived of the best just because the 'hot topic wearing, my life sucks and I hate high school' crowd think that they have a monopoly on Twilight. Because I don't fit into that category. I'm in a sorority I was involved in high school, I have many friends and I love Twilight just as much as everyone else on here. It's not about star power or attracting a new audience, It's about doing what's best for the film.

Doing what's best for the film would be to stop talking about casting Dakota Fanning for the role of Jane and just give it to Jodelle Ferland!

Clearly you are upset. I am many years removed from high school and sorority life, with children of my own now, i.e. the name TwilightMom. I don't mind outstanding actors and am a huge fan of Dakota, I just happen to think the movie already has the best of what it needs and there are many excellent actors out there that are not name pieces. No one has a monopoly on the movie or the books for goodness sakes. It's nice to finally see a movie with such unknown talent instead of being overpowered is my only point.

Please don't talk down to me, I'm not a child. My point is simply this, they are stars because we make them stars. I think it is unfair for us to make them so, and then turn around and not want them bc they have become what we made them. Her name and resume aside, she is a great actress and should be given a chance. And, to say that she wouldn't take a part because she is "too big" is an unfair judgment. You don't know her or the type of role that she would take, or the motivation behind offering her the role in the first place.

Do you know her? Just curious.

whoa kinda a low blow here...

not here sorry i meant at "do you know her just curious"

My intent here was not to offend anyone. And, I believe if you read from the beginning, there was more than 1 low blow delivered here. And I was honestly asking a serious question. Listen I appreciate and respect the opinion and passion of kiristenlSbella and was merely having a discussion. May we all enjoy the future of Twilight and the series, it truly is an exciting adventure to get lost in.

i think that they need to fill the majority of the roles with no name actors/actresses!

calm down kids, it's just a comment board. to be fair sorority gal kinda insinuated she did kno her. tho i see both of your points and they are both quite valid, there's really no need to get all angsty. take a breath and be friggin happy that they're making the movie at all! peace!

I don't know her, but I know other .I'm an actor and I have friends that are
actors and children of actors. Out side people don't know what they go
through. Fans or non fans think that they know them and they don't, you have
no idea what blogs they read and tabloids their forced to see. It comes with
the territory, but it makes it no less hurtful. It's not my job to stick up
for the world, but as an actor and friend of other actors I feel protective
of people in the business.

I definitely agree with you. That was my first thought when I heard she was even talking about getting the role.

AnnaSophia Robb should play Jane!!

a ttly agree with that she'd b best for the part

no

isn't Jodelle the girl from Silent Hill?

I definitely agree with you. That was my first thought when I heard she was even talking about getting the role.

I think Jodelle Ferland would be good for the part.....although Dakota will get the part.

I voted "someone else" and my choices are AnnaSophia Robb and Dakota Blue Richards. Anyone but Fanning.

i'm going to vote for Lucy Hale. I really like Dakota, but she's too young for the role. And I always picture Jane with dark brown hair.

Dakota willbe fine because she will have Eclispe and Breaking Dawn to think about. She would be getting her feet wet for much bigger role in the end. I think she is the best to choose from. Now Jodelle Ferland would be great for the Breaking Dawn for those of you who have read the book already.

So difficult >.<! I think I'm still going to vote for Dakota, because I really love her (I love the other actresses too, but I really think Dakota can do this well). Still.. It's not mine, nor our, decision. And I'm glad I don't have to make it XD.

oooo :o i luv Lucy Hale!!

It's just such a small role, I don't see Dakota taking it.