i have to disagree with the thing that the outtake of rosalie calling edward and telling him about "bella's death" should be part of the new moon movie.. i have to admit, when i finished reading that outtake, i said to my self that it should be shown, but then i realized that where will be that "twist" in the story?.. those who haven't read the new moon yet should see how the trick goes, when jacob and bella thought that it was just carlisle who called and how jacob's words "he's at the funeral" would change the course of the story, not knowing the impact it brought to edward..

anyway, this is just my opinion..though i agree with most of what you've said.. me, too cant wait for the new moon to be out in theaters..

i have to disagree with the thing that the outtake of rosalie calling edward and telling him about "bella's death" should be part of the new moon movie.. i have to admit, when i finished reading that outtake, i said to my self that it should be shown, but then i realized that where will be that "twist" in the story?.. those who haven't read the new moon yet should see how the trick goes, when jacob and bella thought that it was just carlisle who called and how jacob's words "he's at the funeral" would change the course of the story..

anyway, this is just my opinion..though i agree with most of what you've said.. me, too cant wait for the new moon to be out in theaters..

i totally agree with most of u..they did not do a good job at all of portraying the love bella and edward had for each other in twilight which throws off the whole basis point for new moon, the entire point of NM is that edward left and that bella became weak and fell to peices and jacob was there to pick up the pieces, they will have a hard time fitting all that raw passion bella and edward have for each other into the first 15 to 20 minutes of NM to have bellas depression make sence..

I just re read New Moon last night, and for one, it is better second time around...but When Bella is runny through Volterra running towards Edward, that definately needs to be in slow motion. And the fountain she has to run through needs to be there to show jus how desperate she is in that moment. THE KISS HAS TO be in the movie, the kiss when she wakes up in her bed with Edward after being in Italy.
TEXT:"His mouth was on mine then, and I couldn’t fight him. Not because he was so many thousand times stronger than me, but because my will crumbled into dust the second our lips met."

And then I believe it was as soon as she ran into Edward under the clock tower she said: I knew we were both in mortal danger. Still, in that instant, I felt well. Whole. I could feel my heart racing in my chest, the blood pulsing hot and fast through my veins again. My lungs filled deep with the sweet scent that came off his skin. It was like there had never been any hole in my chest. I was perfect—not healed, but as if there had never been a wound in the first place.
--That needs to be in the movie. like have Bella look like a zombie through the entire movie after Edward leaves and then have her look like he never left in the first place when she is in his arms again.

Also one more thing and I'm done, after the Voltri let them leave, when Bella freaks out and Edward is trying to calm her down..definately needs to be there.

I'm all about emotion :) gotta have the parts that made me cry or wanna cry be in da movie.

I just re read New Moon last night, and for one, it is better second time around...but When Bella is runny through Volterra running towards Edward, that definately needs to be in slow motion. And the fountain she has to run through needs to be there to show jus how desperate she is in that moment. THE KISS HAS TO be in the movie, the kiss when she wakes up in her bed with Edward after being in Italy.
TEXT:"His mouth was on mine then, and I couldn’t fight him. Not because he was so many thousand times stronger than me, but because my will crumbled into dust the second our lips met."



And then I believe it was as soon as she ran into Edward under the clock tower she said: I knew we were both in mortal danger. Still, in that instant, I felt well. Whole. I could feel my heart racing in my chest, the blood pulsing hot and fast through my veins again. My lungs filled deep with the sweet scent that came off his skin. It was like there had never been any hole in my chest. I was perfect—not healed, but as if there had never been a wound in the first place.

--That needs to be in the movie. like have Bella look like a zombie through the entire movie after Edward leaves and then have her look like he never left in the first place when she is in his arms again.



Also one more thing and I'm done, after the Voltri let them leave, when Bella freaks out and Edward is trying to calm her down..definately needs to be there.



I'm all about emotion :) gotta have the parts that made me cry or wanna cry be in da movie.

I hope they dont show edward in the movie only the first and last part ........it will be better just to here his voice in her head on the phone......and mabe show the convo wit rosile .......thats it i want to be able to miss him if he keep popping up wat the point of the movie

I hope they dont show edward in the movie only the first and last part ........it will be better just to here his voice in her head on the phone......and mabe show the convo wit rosile .......thats it i want to be able to miss him if he keep popping up wat the point of the movie

You stated it so perfectly here....Everything was spot on!

I agree with all- my concern is that while I loved the first movie- it didn't even get close to showing how completely and irreversibly connected they are. They will need to touch on this somehow in NM in order for people to get how broken Bella is. I can't wait for NM but I must say that it was painful to read- and I am being generous using that word.

New Moon will be perfect...
obviously...
i dont doubt the capabilities of the twilight saga cast and production team...
perfect...it will be! :)

don't forget the part at the very end of the book when Bella is having a vote on her mortality!! and Edward becomes furious when the vote is she should be a vampire!! (New Moon, yes?)

I agree with all- my concern is that while I loved the first movie- it didn't even get close to showing how completely and irreversibly connected they are. They will need to touch on this somehow in NM in order for people to get how broken Bella is. I can't wait for NM but I must say that it was painful to read- and I am being generous using that word.

No, but I am flattered you think it could be real! :D I made it!

New Moon will be perfect...
obviously...

i dont doubt the capabilities of the twilight saga cast and production team...

perfect...it will be! :)

is the poster reaaaaaaaaaaal? :)
im waiting for the real one and i never know!!! haha

No, but I am flattered you think it could be real! :D I made it!

Totally agree with you i d like surely see Edward's emotions when Rosalie tells him for Bella's death.About jacob he kinda angered me when Bella went to see him and he was very harsh and rude to her well ofc cause Sam told him he couldnt tell her he was a wolf now.But it just made me too sad see him doing this.But i think the part that freaked me out completely in the book i was feeling so intense reading it was while bella was running in the square when clock start to sound screaming Edward no!!I think i screamed as well couple of times Edward no:)

Jacob made me angry at that part too but he was forbidden to tell Bella the truth. So I understood his reasoning just as I understood Bella walking away from him. It's just I know how it feels to be used. I hate to say the word used but that's how I saw things at times. I felt incredible sympathy for Jacob as I did for Bella. I felt intense as well when Bella was running in the square. My roommate kept wondering why I was screaming at a book lol! But that scene HAS to be perfect! I want to be on the edge of my seat again. I want to slap the armchair because I am in suspense.

true..when i was reading that part where bella was running in the square, i can hardly breathe..i feel like i was really bella, running for my love's life/"existence"..yes, i agree with you, that scene has to be PERFECT!..and of course, the part where edward proposed to bella..that was so cute.,i read that scene for like more than 5 times already..

When i read in new Moon Edward leave's Bella i was almost crying.My best friend called me and she was cursing all crazy yelling why he left her and all.I really hope they show us bit more Edward than in the book.would love to see kinda while bella is depressed how he is as well same time showing how they both hurt apart and not just as flash back in the end as in the book.but thats just me.But well GO GO Team Edward!!:DDD

is the poster reaaaaaaaaaaal? :)
im waiting for the real one and i never know!!! haha

Totally agree with you i d like surely see Edward's emotions when Rosalie tells him for Bella's death.About jacob he kinda angered me when Bella went to see him and he was very harsh and rude to her well ofc cause Sam told him he couldnt tell her he was a wolf now.But it just made me too sad see him doing this.But i think the part that freaked me out completely in the book i was feeling so intense reading it was while bella was running in the square when clock start to sound screaming Edward no!!I think i screamed as well couple of times Edward no:)

When i read in new Moon Edward leave's Bella i was almost crying.My best friend called me and she was cursing all crazy yelling why he left her and all.I really hope they show us bit more Edward than in the book.would love to see kinda while bella is depressed how he is as well same time showing how they both hurt apart and not just as flash back in the end as in the book.but thats just me.But well GO GO Team Edward!!:DDD

I'm loving that poster, is it official?

I'm loving that poster, is it official?

Wow such a talent, you should be very proud, and you should forward that on to the New Moon people they may use it :)

Edward's name wasnt mention much in New Moon book. I hope he will have a lot of part in NEW MOON MOVIE. I can't wait to see the new Twilight movie!!

Edward's name wasnt mention much in New Moon. I hope he will have a lot of part in NEW MOON MOVIE. i cant wait

I want the movie to be as close to the book as they can get it...but I know they are going to have Rob in it more than the book shows Edward. He is going to make them money. I have to admit, (and I know I am not alone) Edward is the reason I keep reading the books over and over. Edward is the reason I saw the movie over and over. Edward is the reason I can't wait for the DVD to come out. I know he isn't real, and I am not in love with him, but I do LOVE his character. I had to take Stephanie's advice, she said you need to read NM more than once because the first time you are just speed reading to make sure Edward comes back...I totally did that.

they seemed to have gottan most right . as long as they can the part where Edward leaves her then ill be find.and the part where there in Italy then everything should be just fine

I agree with you guys. I read all night...I couldn't put the book down...I needed Edward to come back. I feel weird saying that, but I did. I think there are definitely ways to have Edward more involved in the movie without messing up the book's storyline. OME, I am going to have to go to this movie alone, I am going to totally cry and make an idiot of myself!

I think that Edward(rob) should only be in Bellas dreams and not have it be on what he is doing like tracking victoria we can hear about it but not see it new moon is all about Bella and Jacob and yes i amd a fan but i want it to be like the book not like a different movie!!

OME I love no.4 it is so true you have to put it in because it is like the best and i think that you should put the vote and how stongly do u apoz to G.T.A!!!!!!!!!!!

I want the movie to be as close to the book as they can get it...but I know they are going to have Rob in it more than the book shows Edward. He is going to make them money. I have to admit, (and I know I am not alone) Edward is the reason I keep reading the books over and over. Edward is the reason I saw the movie over and over. Edward is the reason I can't wait for the DVD to come out. I know he isn't real, and I am not in love with him, but I do LOVE his character. I had to take Stephanie's advice, she said you need to read NM more than once because the first time you are just speed reading to make sure Edward comes back...I totally did that.

I agree.... I want Edward in the movie a lil' more though, he just needs to be. I couldn't stand the part when he left her....I bawled like a baby and do every time I read it..... Then the drama when her and Alice go to Volturri to stop Edward....the drama needs to be there and then again when Bella meets up with Edward. <<<<Love that part...

NM was so hard for me to get through. If anyone has ever been dumped, even if not like that, but especially like that, then this book is going to hit home - in a real hard way. Like a wrecking ball. I guess for that reason, I am so thoroughly Team Edward, I just needed him to come back. It was physical, psychological, emotional. Edward WAS the need. Jacob was almost an irritant. I was so glad the phone rang, in Bella's kitchen when Jacob was going to kiss her! Even in his absense, without intending to, Edward was staking his claim. Bella belongs to Edward, she belongs to him. All I know is, if Bella had not jumped off that cliff - I was going to throw her off! :0) And yes! When Alice came back, she was just another life-line. Another connection to Edward. Like the means to an end. Then when Bella finally sees him - ahhhhh - it was heaven. Okay, so I'm just a teensy bit carried away here. But it's truly how I feel. And I am not a teeny bopper, as is evident from my lack of "text" language, I am a happily married mother of three supremely awesome kids - but I love Edward too! I'm really loven' these Twilight fans - what a great bunch of people!

You stated it so perfectly here....Everything was spot on!

they seemed to have gottan most right . as long as they can the part where Edward leaves her then ill be find.and the part where there in Italy then everything should be just fine

The director should definately keep NM as close to the book as possible. I did like the suggestions, all of them. I know that Edward was not physically present in much of the book, but honestly, the ONLY way I could get through that book, was because he would "speak" in Bella's (my) head. Those times allowed me to breathe. So that needs to be a part of the movie. We need to have those moments where we can gasp and breathe in that fresh air that is Edward's voice. So, I know he wasn't in this book much, but he's going to have to be in the movie a little more, just for that purpose. I want emotion in his face and voice when he's yelling at Bella, when he's pleading with her, when he's cautioning her, I want it ALL!

I definitely agree with you.... I feel the same way.... that's honestly the only reason I could get through the book without jumping right to the end....they have to have that in there too and I think they need to stick to the book as much as possible.

I agree with you guys. I read all night...I couldn't put the book down...I needed Edward to come back. I feel weird saying that, but I did. I think there are definitely ways to have Edward more involved in the movie without messing up the book's storyline. OME, I am going to have to go to this movie alone, I am going to totally cry and make an idiot of myself!

Yeah I can totoally relate to Bella's story. Everyone's fallen in love with a vampire then he left and u became best friends with a warewolf then he comes back and there's a big war and you have a little half vampire half human baby....Hasn't everyone?

yeah!! they got it right. just keep it close to the book!
there! problem solved.

I think that when people watch New Moon they should feel the loss, the emptiness, and the pain that Bella will go through when Edward leaves. The scene when Edward leaves should be very emotional (i know... just the thought of him leaving makes that lump in your throat swell up). I also think that before he leaves (and before Bella's b-day party) we need to see how happy Edward and Bella are together. New Moon should also have more kissing than Twilight because things aren't that new anymore. They've been together for a while now. They need to be building that part of Edward and Bella's relationship because it becomes more of an issue in Eclipse. And I think we all want to see those kissing moments from Eclipse in the movie. Edward and Bella's reunion in Voltera (like while their headed to see the Volturi and after they leave) should be in New Moon. And last but not least, I think that the moment when Edward promises to never leave Bella again should definately be in New Moon. And when Edward tells Bella that he will change her himself if she will marry him first.

NM was so hard for me to get through. If anyone has ever been dumped, even if not like that, but especially like that, then this book is going to hit home - in a real hard way. Like a wrecking ball. I guess for that reason, I am so thoroughly Team Edward, I just needed him to come back. It was physical, psychological, emotional. Edward WAS the need. Jacob was almost an irritant. I was so glad the phone rang, in Bella's kitchen when Jacob was going to kiss her! Even in his absense, without intending to, Edward was staking his claim. Bella belongs to Edward, she belongs to him. All I know is, if Bella had not jumped off that cliff - I was going to throw her off! :0) And yes! When Alice came back, she was just another life-line. Another connection to Edward. Like the means to an end. Then when Bella finally sees him - ahhhhh - it was heaven. Okay, so I'm just a teensy bit carried away here. But it's truly how I feel. And I am not a teeny bopper, as is evident from my lack of "text" language, I am a happily married mother of three supremely awesome kids - but I love Edward too! I'm really loven' these Twilight fans - what a great bunch of people!

wow that poster i fantastic!!! cuz bella says in the book she doesnt want to remember edward or think about his cuz it hurts but she doesnt want to forget him. thats my fav poster yet!!!

I think that Edward(rob) should only be in Bellas dreams and not have it be on what he is doing like tracking victoria we can hear about it but not see it new moon is all about Bella and Jacob and yes i amd a fan but i want it to be like the book not like a different movie!!

i cannnnot wait until the scene when she wakes up and edwards there & the proposall ; im afraidd to go to see the break up scene cause i know i will be hysterical crying lmao ; well this siteee is friggen amazing & im obssesed w/ ittt =)

ok so all 10 r pretty hed on EXEPT i think that rob really should not appear even in like flashbacks thruought the movie. if that happens then the viewrs wont get the feeling of what was really going on when edward left her. i mean i LOVE rob but it really needs to stay true to the book because if not then no1 will really get the full experience of what bella went through and thats really important for the rest of the series.

OME I love no.4 it is so true you have to put it in because it is like the best and i think that you should put the vote and how stongly do u apoz to G.T.A!!!!!!!!!!!

I like the poster ALOT

I definitely agree with you.... I feel the same way.... that's honestly the only reason I could get through the book without jumping right to the end....they have to have that in there too and I think they need to stick to the book as much as possible.

I agree.... I want Edward in the movie a lil' more though, he just needs to be. I couldn't stand the part when he left her....I bawled like a baby and do every time I read it..... Then the drama when her and Alice go to Volturri to stop Edward....the drama needs to be there and then again when Bella meets up with Edward. <<<<Love that part...

* I'm just hoping that New Moon is longer than Twilight ..
So it can have more details from the book & all that goodie.
I mean , King Kong was a 3 hour movie . I'm just saying .. Lol .

i think they need to show bella and edward a little more at the beginning of the movie...even if they have to add some stuff in there. while i loved the movie...i really didn't feel the LOVE like i did when i read the book...it all happened too fast and we need to see more of that BEFORE the birthday papercut scene.
am i crazy or do you agree?
this would also give edward some more screen time!!

k...i just finished reading the whole article...and it says kinda the same thing...i'm an idiot! :)

Yea I'm hoping for a true-to-the-book movie b/c NM is just so filled w/ emotions that they just HAVE to portray that on screen, they just HAVE to =]

I agree. What I am worried about too is people's reaction to Bella's depression, particularly people who have not read the books. It is my opinion that the relationship between Bella and Edward was not developed enough in the first movie, so when Edward leaves her, to some viewers her depression might not make much sense.
(I am not saying it doesn't make sense, just that people who are not familiar with the story will think that. Some people's reaction to the hospital scene, when Bella was having a panic attack, was to laugh. So...yeah.)
But I am keeping my fingers crossed, and I am trying to tell myself Chris Weitz can do amazing things with this movie, since nothing tells me he can't

RIght? I feel that same way... I truly hope they make the depression understandable, cause like you said, they didn't do a great job of portraying E's and B's relationship... in the book it was just... amazing!
But I totally get what you're saying 'cause I noticed too that ppl didn't quite understand (those that didn't/havent read the books) those moments... all we can do is cross our fingers and hope that Chris can do what we most desire w/ NM =]

The director should definately keep NM as close to the book as possible. I did like the suggestions, all of them. I know that Edward was not physically present in much of the book, but honestly, the ONLY way I could get through that book, was because he would "speak" in Bella's (my) head. Those times allowed me to breathe. So that needs to be a part of the movie. We need to have those moments where we can gasp and breathe in that fresh air that is Edward's voice. So, I know he wasn't in this book much, but he's going to have to be in the movie a little more, just for that purpose. I want emotion in his face and voice when he's yelling at Bella, when he's pleading with her, when he's cautioning her, I want it ALL!

Yeah I can totoally relate to Bella's story. Everyone's fallen in love with a vampire then he left and u became best friends with a warewolf then he comes back and there's a big war and you have a little half vampire half human baby....Hasn't everyone?

The acting HAS to be nailed just right in the more intense scenes and I agree that the Volturi must look eerie and also look like the "non veg" vampires that they are. I want to feel the same intense emotions while watching the movie that I felt while reading the book. Painful, raw, and real.

I agree that Edward can be shown in places throughout the movie, flashbacks, while Bella thinks she hears his voice, maybe show his despair while they are apart...that will all add up to an amazing movie!

yeah!! they got it right. just keep it close to the book!
there! problem solved.

I think that when people watch New Moon they should feel the loss, the emptiness, and the pain that Bella will go through when Edward leaves. The scene when Edward leaves should be very emotional (i know... just the thought of him leaving makes that lump in your throat swell up). I also think that before he leaves (and before Bella's b-day party) we need to see how happy Edward and Bella are together. New Moon should also have more kissing than Twilight because things aren't that new anymore. They've been together for a while now. They need to be building that part of Edward and Bella's relationship because it becomes more of an issue in Eclipse. And I think we all want to see those kissing moments from Eclipse in the movie. Edward and Bella's reunion in Voltera (like while their headed to see the Volturi and after they leave) should be in New Moon. And last but not least, I think that the moment when Edward promises to never leave Bella again should definately be in New Moon. And when Edward tells Bella that he will change her himself if she will marry him first.

i cannnnot wait until the scene when she wakes up and edwards there & the proposall ; im afraidd to go to see the break up scene cause i know i will be hysterical crying lmao ; well this siteee is friggen amazing & im obssesed w/ ittt =)

ok so all 10 r pretty hed on EXEPT i think that rob really should not appear even in like flashbacks thruought the movie. if that happens then the viewrs wont get the feeling of what was really going on when edward left her. i mean i LOVE rob but it really needs to stay true to the book because if not then no1 will really get the full experience of what bella went through and thats really important for the rest of the series.

..i think i want to see the effect that edward´s voice (inside bella´s head) has.. I need to see it!!,..
when i was reading the book.. my heart always stopped there..in that whisper.. specially the "be happy" one. cause idk.. he was almost telling her ..go on..do it.!. be jacob´s gf! i dont care as long as u are happy.. and that is for me..one of the most emotional parts of the book. i want to feel it on screen.

Thanks, I made it! :D

RIght? I feel that same way... I truly hope they make the depression understandable, cause like you said, they didn't do a great job of portraying E's and B's relationship... in the book it was just... amazing!
But I totally get what you're saying 'cause I noticed too that ppl didn't quite understand (those that didn't/havent read the books) those moments... all we can do is cross our fingers and hope that Chris can do what we most desire w/ NM =]

I like the poster ALOT

I agree. What I am worried about too is people's reaction to Bella's depression, particularly people who have not read the books. It is my opinion that the relationship between Bella and Edward was not developed enough in the first movie, so when Edward leaves her, to some viewers her depression might not make much sense.
(I am not saying it doesn't make sense, just that people who are not familiar with the story will think that. Some people's reaction to the hospital scene, when Bella was having a panic attack, was to laugh. So...yeah.)

But I am keeping my fingers crossed, and I am trying to tell myself Chris Weitz can do amazing things with this movie, since nothing tells me he can't

k...i just finished reading the whole article...and it says kinda the same thing...i'm an idiot! :)

* I'm just hoping that New Moon is longer than Twilight ..
So it can have more details from the book & all that goodie.

I mean , King Kong was a 3 hour movie . I'm just saying .. Lol .

i think they need to show bella and edward a little more at the beginning of the movie...even if they have to add some stuff in there. while i loved the movie...i really didn't feel the LOVE like i did when i read the book...it all happened too fast and we need to see more of that BEFORE the birthday papercut scene.
am i crazy or do you agree?

this would also give edward some more screen time!!

Yea I'm hoping for a true-to-the-book movie b/c NM is just so filled w/ emotions that they just HAVE to portray that on screen, they just HAVE to =]

Oh God, you're NOT the only one!!
I cry and cry and cry everytime I read it ('cause I go back and read them over) and ppl don't understand why, but WE just know, u know? lol!

The first time I read it, I had to call my sis in law and another friend to tell them how heartbroken I was... lol true story =]

I agree completely. There's just something about having a little bit of life experience that makes the emotional journey of the characters a bit more raw and unnerving!

BTW I love the fan made poster, its beautiful!

Thanks, I made it! :D

Wow such a talent, you should be very proud, and you should forward that on to the New Moon people they may use it :)

The acting HAS to be nailed just right in the more intense scenes and I agree that the Volturi must look eerie and also look like the "non veg" vampires that they are. I want to feel the same intense emotions while watching the movie that I felt while reading the book. Painful, raw, and real.


I agree that Edward can be shown in places throughout the movie, flashbacks, while Bella thinks she hears his voice, maybe show his despair while they are apart...that will all add up to an amazing movie!

i just hope the movie is really good scartch that i hope its GREAT i am very excited for it to come out

i dont agree with #6 . Edward should be in the book as much as he is intended to be. We alr eady know how much they are in love so follow the book!!! i am sick of people saying that there needs to be more Edward. Edward comes back dont worry!

I too would like them to stick with the book as far as Edward goes but I can't say that I would be opposed to some flash back scenes when she's dealing with his absence. There's an entire summer skipped over between Twilight and New Moon that they could flash back to.

sorry i got a little over excited
First of all bella better cry i want tears and
second i defnitly the scene when alice comes back and the whole italy stuff and the end when bella thinks shes dreaming.....
actually how about they just make it exactly how it is from cover to cover so yeah thats the only way it will be perfect!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

i agree. in twilight it didn't really look like alice and bella were friends so i think they need to work on that. and the PROPOSAL! omg. soooo cute. that's what makes the story the best one. DON'T SCREW IT UP. :)

Me to and I think that Stephenie grasped that, I'm sure as she would probably feel the same if it herself with her own children. I couldn't bear to be apart from my 2 two children and as much as I can appreciate that tweens/teens love these books I think the readers with children would understand it on a different level

Not sure i agree with number 1 : "Robert Pattinson". Don't get me wrong, i looove him but he can't be seen too much coz we reall have to feel how Bella was abondonned, feel his absence.

And I love number 4 : "the proposal". That HAS to be in the movie and they really have to get it right coz the whole "marry me" scene where she thinks he's joking at first and he's like "ouch".. I dunno, just loved it ! :) So i hooope kristen and robert will get it right coz it's intense as well.

yup spot-on and i would like to see more of the cullen history

Wow 100% agree, I'm looking fro real emotion in New Moon and I think we should see the desperation that Bella goes through and how Jacob helps her, and I agree that the volturri should be terrifying!

Exactly. When Edward leaves Bella it's just so raw. I had to put the book down for a second when I read that part, so I hope the movie gets all the emotion right on.

I also like that poster!

The first time that I read New Moon and when Edward left Bella I sobbed my heart out, I felt like the first time I got my heart broken, I cried and cried and cried and I had to put the book away, but it felt so raw that I had to skip to the end when Alice came back, read it from there and then when I finished I had to go back to the start, didnt help cos I still cry every time I read it LOL

Oh God, you're NOT the only one!!
I cry and cry and cry everytime I read it ('cause I go back and read them over) and ppl don't understand why, but WE just know, u know? lol!
The first time I read it, I had to call my sis in law and another friend to tell them how heartbroken I was... lol true story =]

I definitely appreciated New Moon AND Jacob Black so much more the second read. Yes Bella and Edward belong together but I just love the marvel that is Jacob Black. I love these books because they make you FEEL.

Ummm . . . it sucked the first time I read it. I thought I was dying inside!!

The second time I read Twilight, I carried New Moon around with me for a week before I could bring myself to open it. it still hurts . . . even though you know everything will be "OK" by the end of the saga (for everyone . . . Jacob included). I was telling "C" the other night that Stephenie opened up this series of books to more than teens when she wrote New Moon and the other books. There is soooo much more involved than a "teen love story" in New Moon and beyond!

Definitely, I think that we can relate more to the books is because we have experience off everything that has happened in them. I felf like I had my heart ripped out when I read new moon as I wasnt expecting him to leave so I felt every emotion possible, to sum it up I was a complete mess LMAO

I know. But I also found myself crying during Breaking Dawn. Particularly when Bella discusses preparing for Renesmee and Jacob to go if they have to. It tore my heart out. I can't imagine having to prepare myself to let my children go . . . even if it was for their safety. It made me so sad!

Me to and I think that Stephenie grasped that, I'm sure as she would probably feel the same if it herself with her own children. I couldn't bear to be apart from my 2 two children and as much as I can appreciate that tweens/teens love these books I think the readers with children would understand it on a different level

I agree completely. There's just something about having a little bit of life experience that makes the emotional journey of the characters a bit more raw and unnerving!

yeah!!!!

ahhh aahhha im first

..i think i want to see the effect that edward´s voice (inside bella´s head) has.. I need to see it!!,..
when i was reading the book.. my heart always stopped there..in that whisper.. specially the "be happy" one. cause idk.. he was almost telling her ..go on..do it.!. be jacob´s gf! i dont care as long as u are happy.. and that is for me..one of the most emotional parts of the book. i want to feel it on screen.

I know. But I also found myself crying during Breaking Dawn. Particularly when Bella discusses preparing for Renesmee and Jacob to go if they have to. It tore my heart out. I can't imagine having to prepare myself to let my children go . . . even if it was for their safety. It made me so sad!

I too would like them to stick with the book as far as Edward goes but I can't say that I would be opposed to some flash back scenes when she's dealing with his absence. There's an entire summer skipped over between Twilight and New Moon that they could flash back to.

Definitely, I think that we can relate more to the books is because we have experience off everything that has happened in them. I felf like I had my heart ripped out when I read new moon as I wasnt expecting him to leave so I felt every emotion possible, to sum it up I was a complete mess LMAO

I definitely appreciated New Moon AND Jacob Black so much more the second read. Yes Bella and Edward belong together but I just love the marvel that is Jacob Black. I love these books because they make you FEEL.

Ummm . . . it sucked the first time I read it. I thought I was dying inside!!


The second time I read Twilight, I carried New Moon around with me for a week before I could bring myself to open it. it still hurts . . . even though you know everything will be "OK" by the end of the saga (for everyone . . . Jacob included). I was telling "C" the other night that Stephenie opened up this series of books to more than teens when she wrote New Moon and the other books. There is soooo much more involved than a "teen love story" in New Moon and beyond!

BTW I love the fan made poster, its beautiful!

The first time that I read New Moon and when Edward left Bella I sobbed my heart out, I felt like the first time I got my heart broken, I cried and cried and cried and I had to put the book away, but it felt so raw that I had to skip to the end when Alice came back, read it from there and then when I finished I had to go back to the start, didnt help cos I still cry every time I read it LOL

i just hope the movie is really good scartch that i hope its GREAT i am very excited for it to come out

i dont agree with #6 . Edward should be in the book as much as he is intended to be. We alr eady know how much they are in love so follow the book!!! i am sick of people saying that there needs to be more Edward. Edward comes back dont worry!

sorry i got a little over excited
First of all bella better cry i want tears and

second i defnitly the scene when alice comes back and the whole italy stuff and the end when bella thinks shes dreaming.....

actually how about they just make it exactly how it is from cover to cover so yeah thats the only way it will be perfect!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

i agree. in twilight it didn't really look like alice and bella were friends so i think they need to work on that. and the PROPOSAL! omg. soooo cute. that's what makes the story the best one. DON'T SCREW IT UP. :)

Not sure i agree with number 1 : "Robert Pattinson". Don't get me wrong, i looove him but he can't be seen too much coz we reall have to feel how Bella was abondonned, feel his absence.


And I love number 4 : "the proposal". That HAS to be in the movie and they really have to get it right coz the whole "marry me" scene where she thinks he's joking at first and he's like "ouch".. I dunno, just loved it ! :) So i hooope kristen and robert will get it right coz it's intense as well.

yup spot-on and i would like to see more of the cullen history

Wow 100% agree, I'm looking fro real emotion in New Moon and I think we should see the desperation that Bella goes through and how Jacob helps her, and I agree that the volturri should be terrifying!

yeah!!!!

ahhh aahhha im first