I really think they should make BREAKING DAWN.They cant end eclipse that way, cause at the end of eclipse their suppose to be telling Charlie about the engagement.As far as the graphics goes I don't see what the problem would be.Cause in the book she never actually said anything about the sex, she just lead us up to it.We all know what actually happens but nobody says they have to show us.That would be more like the book that way.When it comes to the birth of Reneesme it would be pretty graphic ,but remember this is jacob book at this point they wouldn't have to show everything.And as far as Reneesme the way tech. is today they should have No problem with making her. If we remember THE LORD OF THE RINGS series look at all those graphics they way they made Gollum.After that movie series anything is possible.I think I would need to be a strong PG13 or a R for sure.But I think it would be very important to finish this to end the series and not leave us with a missing thirst.

Dear Summit,

Breaking Dawn must be made. Or I'll cry. Do you want me to cry? Really? I didn't think so. Make the damn movie. Or else.

The End.

i like your letters.

lol cute i would say that i would suicide my sellffffff and every thing will beon you lolol

Not even funny. Don't make me come over there and slap u girl!

you make a lot of letters... lol but i agree, breaking dawn was my FAVORITE of the series, and it HAS to be made into a movie

I really can't wait for New Moon and Eclipse to come out I am sooooo excited !! I really can't wait to hear for sure on Breaking Dawn though....They have to do that movie I agree with a few others it won't be the same if they don't , but, I have a feeling they will, there will be sooooo many fans REALLY outraged if not, and the complications as far as Renesmee well im sure they can figure out something They have so much tech. stuff on there side they can figure out somehow to make it work.

Yeh..It wont be the same if they just stop after Eclipse. The fanbase for twilight is so large now, that they know there will be plenty of money for BD and I agree with you that they can figure out something on the Renesmee-things ;) I really hope they will make it!

I agree with you E.C. Fan....plus with each movie, doesn't the budget go up!?? If the next 2 movies are a huge success, which they will be...then they're going to have a pretty big budget for Breaking Dawn....I agree though, it won't be the same if they stop after Eclipse. :)

I really hope they do Breaking Dawn.....they need to complete the series!!! And I don't think they will have a problem with Reneesme....there is the technology to create her!! Obviously, they are not going to be able to find a real baby/child to act the part! She'll just have to computerized!!!!

Let's all cross our fingers!!!!

Mine is already crossed! :)

I agree, ilr! They can do anything with today's technology; a great example is the aging Brad Pitt a la The Curious Case of Benjamin Button!

I truly believe Breaking Dawn will get made. I just know it will. Summit is probably waiting for New Moon to do extremely well, so Breaking Dawn can get the green light! It's up to us fans to make it happen and I know we won't let the series (or our Robbie lol) down. ;}. Even Taylor Lautner asked fans, in a recent interview, to see New Moon one more time in addition to the amount of times (times? lol) we saw Twilight. So, I think something is up. I will be crossing my fingers with you. ;}

Hey...if they can make the etrade baby talk..they can make Renesme talk.

I'm so excited to see New Moon, and I really hope they decide to make Breaking Dawn....it won't be the same if they don't! :0(

very true thats wat i was thinking it would be weird if they made the first three and stopped but summit was just thinking u no about BD like the difficulties of it like renesme who groes so fast and wat to rate like R or MA and like the birth and that but i think they will make it becoz it will be good money and the fans will cause an uproar if it isn't made so im hoping alot and i really think they will lol and i dont blame themfor keeping it quiet i think they need to be left alone if we want new moon to come out!!! im so exited tho that they are thinking of breaking dawn it had me worried, i mean i still am but i not as much :o) AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH im just so happy and exited i swear time is going fast tho but not fast enuff :op
Lizzie

you can hardly blame them for wanting to keep it secure and private, plus, he was paparazzi hmm i wonder what was in his hand, a camera maybe?! pfft get over yourself and let them do their work.

oh i hope they make all the books into movies!

i can't wait for new moon and breaking dawn.
i really want to know who's going to play renesmee.
go TWILIGHT or NEW MOON

Oh I'm happy BD is even being mentioned finally! I hope they keep asking, that is my favorite book and I would die if they didn't make it into a movie.

i hope they do make breaking dawn !! & renesmee is going to be hard to find but im looking forward to see who they get for the part!!!.. oh!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

YES YES! and I wouldn't mind if in the movie version there is a fight opposed to the book come on everyone loves those big battles in flicks. I want the Cullens to kick the Volturi's butt.

Even though Summit has yet to confirm this, I can't help but be ecstatic at this news! Oh wow, & I thought I was excited to see clips & sneak peeks of New Moon...just wait til they start filming Breaking Dawn, I'm gonna go crazy!

How can Breaking Dawn be released in Spring 2010, when Eclipse is only schedualed for June 2010? There's no way they'd release Breaking Dawn before Eclipse..

they will be filming when eclipse comes out

No...not released, they said they might start production in spring 2010

Filming in spring 2010. . . like New Moon has been filming.

Oh to see Garrett in the flesh, I have been Team Garret for a while and Kate! I love those two, she has got a cool power. the human err or vampire taser.

I love Garrett too! My sister was contemplating getting a taser a while back and I told her she needed a Kate . . . she looked at me like I was crazy (she hasn't read the books) but the girls in my office laughed. :) Garrett reminds me of like, Mel Gibson or Heath Ledger in the Patriot. Love, love, love him!

Lynda, it says that production will begin in spring 2010, not that the film will be released then.

summit hasnt comfirmed but rob has so...I trust him...

agreed!!!! TRUST IN ROB!

i really hope that BD becomes a movie.. i do understand the complications with reneesme but ill be highly outragged if they make the others and not BD..

In Rob We Trust! XD

They better make Breaking Dawn! or else ima be very upset T_T and there would've been no point on starting out with Twilight in the first place... for what so they wouldnt finish the twilight saga? pointless.

hee hee well this could be a good thing :D more surprises! i just hope they are good ones xD

I think they are waiting for New Moon to be released and than give it the green light. I guess to make sure which Im sure they will but to make sure they make more than it cost to make it. If i had the money, i would give them 100,000 and tell em to shut the hell up and make the damn movie

I agree. They'll wait to make sure NM is as big a hit as twilight before signing up for BD. That makes me a little nervous tbh, NM is imo the most difficult book of the saga to adapt (not technology wise but because it's more dark and slow-paced -except for the end- and the focuse of the storyline suddenly changes from vampires to wolves which be have the people who didn't read the books a little bewildered).

Anyway I do hope they'll green light BD soon! That's my favorite book, it's the apogee of the books and where all the storylines at last mix and come to the most awaited denouement which the 3 previous books set up and led to. What a waste it'd be if we robbed of the end of the saga! Seriously!

I know. Like i said in the other post. Riot!!!!!!!!!! if not made. You have to let bella become a vamp or whats the point of all the fuss. Thats all she fusses about in the first three

it's good they are keeping focus on one movie at a time, but I think it will now lets sit down and look at how they can make it not two but just one movie, I remenber reading it from a TwilightMom saying remove the dialque with action. Now the main plot point of the saga a
part from the love story is the Volturi's or Aro's jeolusy on what Carlisle has, so Reneseme is just the scapegoat for punishing them and getting his hands on Alice, Edward and Bella, the main reason he lets her live is to see how she turns out.

So the opening of Breaking Dawn can be either the Volturi condeming the Denali mom for creating an immortal child or we see the wolf Jacob in Canada.

The tension with the wolves.

The Volturi sending Irnia to spy on the Cullens.

Preparation for the wedding.

I HATE BREAKING DAWN!!!! DO NOT MAKE THIS BOOK INTO A MOVIE!!!!

Who asked YOU? Dont go see it!!!! we'll make sure that BD gets made.

HI FIVE ROB ROCKS, can't stand these haters, ugh, can you imagine we will get a proper kissing scene between Rob and Kristen. "You've been holding out on me". Bring a Bib, those are going to be hot. Especially when they go hunting, and he has to remove his shirt because her dress gets shredded and Edward don't want his bros to look at his wife's goodies.

aah you're killing me here!!!! Now I want to see that like right now!!!!
I can't even imagine how many times I'd go to the theater to watch these over and over...
And so many other great scenes to look forward to in that book.

i agree. i hope chris directs it. looks like his doing a GREAT job on NM

Isn't Chris's brother filming Eclipse??

its the rumor. but i think he is. you would think that they would state something by now if it wasnt. They havent denied it either

i don't care if anyone asked me chic!!! i can speak my mind!!! this book sucks it should never had been made!!! everything about it was awful and pointless!!!

well I "told" you what i thought. You dont like the books then stop coming on here just to piss everyone off.

hey she has the right to voice out her opinion, so dont hate on what she says.
i didnt like BD either, and i pray that Summit wont film it.
* Agreeing wit ForsakenMoon19*

Yes, i understand that she can voice what she thinks but thats all she ever voices is RUDE comments about BD and she replys rude. she was asked not the make certain comments that would make people mad.

the only reason you're getting mad is because your younger than i am and you take this whole thing too seriously!!! everyone's never gonna like what you like!!! you can never plz everyone, i should know cuz i own a business where i get crap from ppl who are never satisfied!! you don't know me so stop saying that all the comments i've made are rude!! that's just the way you're taking them!!!

Ok well first off you dont know how old I am so you seriously need to shut up. You need to grow up. and if people dont like your business than maybe you run a crappy business, ever think if that!!!!!!!

First of all you don't know what that hell kind of business i run!!! second of all what the hell do you know about it?! you don't know me so why don't you shut up and get off my back chic!! i'm done with this!! seriously girl all this crap you keep dishing is just amusing to me LOL!!!!

So you own your own business . . . SO DO I and I have for 8 years now. That doesn't make you any more mature than anyone else on this site. You are being rude. Truly . . . you are.

same goes for you "B"!!!! get a life!!!!

hey Confused!!! thanks for sticking up for me back there!!! glad to hear form another twilight fan that doesn't like the 4th book!!!!

DON'T GO WATCH IT!

Why do you hate BD so much? This website is for people who LOVE the saga and WANT it to move forward and do well. stop hating and move on.

Hey I know that person is a moron of the biggest kind for bashing Breaking Dawn but don't bash HP.

dont get me wrong, i like HP but they have taken sooooo long to finish the movies that im bored of em now. and anywho....twilight has some sexy, hot guys in it.

Hey You!! Don't judge someone you don't even know just because of a stupid book!!! by the way how old are you? i haven't been called a moron since the 5th grade and it wasn't in a joking matter!!! is that suppose to shock me cuz you're barking up the wrong tree girl!!! by the way, i'm not going to bash in the HP books or movies cuz i don't even read them or watch them to give a crap!!!! not my type of book gendre!!!

See, chill pill "forsakenMonn19". you really need to calm down. rude people dont get anywhere in life.

the only rude person on here is YOU!!!

OMG..shut up and leave me alone. i told you i was joking in the beginning...grow up

what are you going on about? you leave me alone and stop bringing this up!!! LOL!

BD is the only book i hate out of the saga, thank you!! and who made you this boss of this websit, any fan is allowed on here!!!! reguardless if i just hated one book out of four!!! oooooooooo big deal!!

IM NOT THE BOSS BUT ALL YOU DO IS DISS THE BD BOOK. YEA WE KNOW U HATE THE BOOK NOW ...GET OVER IT AND MOVE ON.

these polls are for chatting about certain topics and since this BD topic keeps coming up, i'm gonna speak my mind!!! i have to hear the rest of you go on about Team Edward-Team Jacob!!! that just drives me bananas!!!!

Yes but alot of that are the minors. We dont make you read the comments and so far most of your comments have been very rude. You have the right to say whats on your mind but I was just being funny when i asked you "who asked you". you got PO about it. seems like someone needs to take a chill pill. Everyone jokes etc on here and "most" dont reply back all pissy.

Im done with this subject

i'm actually right as rain and not PO!!! as you so delicately put it!!! this all started because you're taking everything i'm saying to offense!!! i didn't come here to offend any fans, if i did i'd be saying some pretty nasty sh*t by now!!! i'm on here to voice my opinions as like any other person that comes on here!! the reason this subject seems to be coming up is because ppl like you don't have a life!! again sorry if you're taking this all to offense!!!

Are you done bitching? because im done listening...

i can dish out as much as you can take if this continues!!! LOL!! but actually it's kinda funny to me!!! LOL!!!

Im Glad...

HE HE!!!!

Can I ask why you hate it? Just curious.

Please do not post comments that you KNOW will make the majority of posters on this site angry. Thank you.

you'll only get upset if your a teenage girl who takes these books way too seriously!!!

Why are you insulting me? I simply requested you mind what you say. Myself and my friends are not "teenage girls" and we love these books. This site is for people who LOVE these books. And while you are allowed your opinion, ARGUING and INSULTING OTHERS isn't allowed on this site.

ah ok how am i insulting others just because i said i didn't like BD?!!! and by the way i'm gonna defend myself from ppl lashing out at me over something stupid!!! if you're not teenage girls you sure don't act any older.............hmmmmmmmmmm

It's the way you are when you post that is insulting the other posters and just a bit ago you called me a "B." Really?! Not nice and not called for at all. By, by.

well i didn't appreciate being called a moron and told that i was being rude just because i had opinions that i'm being slashed for!!

well i didn't appreciate being called a moron and told that i was being rude just because i had opinions that i'm being slashed for!!

what! how in the world can you not like Breaking Dawn... you must not like the entire Saga than

i loved the first 3 books, book 4 however was the worst!!! i don't have to like the last book to be a fan!!!!

Sorry I didnt mean for it to come out that way... but I am curious what is it that you did not like about the book?

there was alot of things i couldn't get into. i wasn't a fan of her getting pregnant and becioming a vamp. nor did i like the direction Meyer took in subsituting Jacob's love for Bella to her daughter!! after everything that took place in the first three books i was just disappoint at how things turned out. sorry if i'm coming on like a preaching b**ch, i don't mean to be i just didn't like BD!!! it let me down in a lot of areas!!!

I guess we should understand... just because 95% of us wanted Bella to become a Vampire doesnt mean everyone did......

Exactly!! i probably would feel different if there weren't any obsticles involvled!!! other ppl!!! but i'm not a big fan of becoming something else in order to get the guy!

WHOSE TO SAY 95% wanted Bella to be a vamp? aren't there ppl out there going TEAM JACOB!!!!??

Just because someone is Team Jacob doesn't make them anti-Edward and Bella.

well i'm pretty team jacob didn't want to vampirize Bella!!!

Okay Okay who will you cast as

The Denali
Garrett
The Egyptians
Allistar
The IRish Coven
The Amazons
J Jenkins.

I really don't see how Breaking Dawn is going to become a film... I mean unless they are gonna bump the age limit for the film up... how is the whole honeymoon thing... with her being bruised... the whole birth... i mean that is seriously graphic!!!.. Renesmee... its more gruesome this book and i dnt see how they are gonna do that with the target audience...

gruesome? you are talking to someone who has seen Saw, Halloween flicks, and yeah the Hostel films, you don't know what gruesome is.

HAHA funny but very true

30daysofnight is one of my fav vampire movies! John Carpenter's Vampires! now those are gruesome and bloody BD is nothing like those I dont understaand why people say BD was gruesome? Maybe its a age thing lol

ahhh because it is gruesome!!!! that's one reason i hate the book, another would be the whole vamp bella transformation thing, how could i forget the whole reneseme-jacob thing!!! geez this book is the worst!!!

This is exactly what we are talking about. You have made your point in several posts above and continue to say things that you know are going to tick off others. We get it . . . you think BD sucked. Enough said.

plz don't come and harrass me for voicing my opinions, i'm not on here to start anything only to say what's on my mind. the reason i've overstated my points is because other ppl have asked me what i don't like BD!!!

Who does not want to see Vampire Bella? I do, especially seeing her practice her shield, can't wait to see how that looks. Besides we will get to see plenty of shirtless Rob.

shirtless Rob..OMG..."drowling" "breathe, breathe". gives me goosebumps just thinking that. "thanks"

I DON"T!!!!! she was more appealing as a human and relatable!!! i feel sorry for Rene and Charlie for having an idiot for a daughter!!! a chic who is sooooooo annoying and gives her whole life up for an unead creature!!! sorry the whole getting married and pregnant at 18 ( i didn't buy it!) HOW MANY TIMES HAVE WE BEEN TOLD TO USE A CONDOM DURING SEX LADIES!!!

Many people get married at 18 or 19. Just because it's not something you would do doesn't mean others don't. I have a handful of younger friends (mid-20's) that were married before they turned 21. It isn't uncommon. Deal with it. And why in the world would someone who was married use a condom? Good grief! Not to mention it is a STORY . . .

ya it is!! which why it is so unrealistic that this marrige between Edward and Bella wouldn't work out in the long run. just because ppl got married at 18 and 19 doens't mean they lived happily ever after!!! just ask my sister!!!!

Ummmm . . . . you are preaching to the choir. I was married at 19 and divorced 2 years later. AGAIN . . . . IT'S A BOOK.

Just jumping in here for a second.

Tweter, you sound a lot like myself!!! I was married at 19 and divorced two years later too. :x

I know it's just a book, but I still think Edward is real. Shhh. ;)

OMG! Love it!!!

good luck with that honey_bee......

Summit got the movie rights for BD, I suspect come time for production to start on Eclipse we'll hear more about Breaking Dawn. That is my speculation.

The issues with Renesmee is probably not gonna be as big as ppl may think. Like someone already said, there is technology to create a character like that now. The work on that kinda technology is constantly being developed. Look at Lord of the Rings trilogy. It took ages for it to be made into a movie trilogy cos well to recreate that world onto the silver screen it took the technology they had to create that world, so up until then it was literally seen as impossible to make. I seriously do not think BD is any more impossible than LOTR to recreate into a movie. I think it is a matter of planning and production schedule. Also unlike Harry Potter they do not have all the time in the world to make this, the actors DO get older, and even though some of that could be sorted with makeup and special effects there is extra cost involved to make sure an 20 something year old guy to make him look forever 17! So time wise they are kinda "running out of time". By the time BD could go into production Rob will turn 24. Even though the age gap isn't that huge but facial expression does change during that time. So this is why I am guessing or rather speculating that come time for production to start on Eclipse we will hear more about BD :-).

As for ppl who hates BD and begs for this movie to not be made, well sorry but if they do well on NM and Eclipse chances are very big BD will be made, I am pretty sure it will actually. That is ppl do not have to go see BD though lol. Personally I enjoyed BD and I DO want to see it made into a movie. I want the saga complete in movie version too.

Amen Marystat, Real Twilight fans want the whole saga turned into a movie. They made all the Harry Potters right and their fans go see them anyway. So to you bandwagon fans, get off already.

Question what should be the opening of Breaking Dawn? I was thinking instead of opening like the book, Bella in her new car, they should either open it with Jacob's voice over, maybe we see him in his wolf form, or it can open with the history of the immortal children? than it can switch with the preparation of the wedding, Renee was already in town, and Bella makes her escape to get gas in her car? Plus it be funny to see Jasper and Emmett give Edward the sex talk.

EXCUSE ME!! i am a twilight fan!! i don't have to like the crap that is Breaking Dawn to be a REAL fan!!!

Of course, I want them all to be made... I was just saying how are they gonna do it so that is like the book...
What was the film? PG? 12? So... all i'm saying is unless they bring the age up.. its not guna b like the book.. cos they cnt show the birth etc... thats pretty ..fine not gruesome but graphic lol...

The book was not graphic. It did not go into great detail. They can do it discretely enough to keep the movie pg-13. And just like others have said before, Stephenie is a mormon and they don't watch R movies . . . . I'm sure part of her deal with giving Summit the rights was keeping the movies pg-13.

I don't think the book was gruesome or graphic. I keep reading that quite often but I don't agree. I think it was pretty 'soft' for a vampire story actually lol or even for a love story for that matter.

It would be an outrage to fans everywhere if BD was not made into a movie! They can't film 3 out of the 4 books. That would be like filming every Harry Potter movie and leaving out the final one! The fans would be devastated! I'm sure with all the money they will earn from New Moon and Eclipse, they will be able to come up with ways to make the wedding, honeymoon, birth of Renesmee etc all work! Just look at what they can do in movies now! I trust they will make it work and it will be awesome!!! Can't wait for New Moon though! :D

they are definitely going to do it. i mean they would not just stop after the first three and not do the fourth. even rob was saying in an interview that they are doing Breaking Dawn. i think right now they are just trying to figure out how to get everything perfect before spreading the word that they are doing it. stephenie wants it to be broken into two movies so they don't miss anything. i would be down with that cuz that would mean more Rob!

What you guys think of Evan Rachel Wood for the role of Tanya?

http://www.celebrity-wallpapers.org/bulkupload/...

I can't wait for New Moon and eclipse! I really do hope they make Breaking down i wanna see Bella as a vampire and Renesme!!

OMG! I WILL HAVE A HEART ATTACK WHEN THAT MOVIE COMES OUT..I HEAR IF NEW MOON MAKE GOOD MONEY THEY DO BD...SO WE SHOULD ALL GO SEE NEW MOON...THEY SHOULD MAKE RENEESMME COMPUTERIZE OR GET A GOOD CHILD WILL UNDERSTAND IF A BABY CAN'T TO THAT PART..JUST MAK IT PLEASEE...

It up to the fans, I believe they will make Breaking Dawn, they are waiting to see how much money they make on New Moon. Everybody go see New Moon, the studio bought the rights to BD, so I believe it will be made if they make enough money, which I'm sure they will.

I'd happily go watch NM as much as possible to help BD being made but... alas how many times will I be able to see the break-up scene before my own heart breaks though?

They can definitely make this a PG-13, although personally I'd like to seen an R. They do not have to overdo the love scenes, or Bella having Renesemee. I do hope that they do one movie, and yes it will be long, but so was LOTR. I am certain they'll be able to do something for Renesmee. Some of the actors I'd like to see for these characters are Johnny Depp, even Hayden Christensen. Scott Speedman. I'll have to think of more. For the Egyptians, that Oded Fehr from the Mummy maybe.

I love Hayden Christensen!!! I would love to see him be a werewolf in a film though!!! I don't mean in the Twilight saga!!!

Hahaha..Thats pretty cool..I wouldnt want fans freakin out near the set either! But for Breakin Dawn..I think that maybe an R would be better, but think about all these teens that are under age..and are completley obsessed!!! Hahha,I doubt they will make it an R.Even though..In Breaking Dawn, they better not leave out details! That is the last book in the series, and When Bella gives birth to Nessie, thats like a must have in the movie!! But anyway..Im only frEaking out about seeing New Moon right now...Im so Excited ! :)

Breaking Dawn has to be made into a film...
it would be a complete and utter disaster if they made only the 3 books into films.
it HAS to be completed! x

As long as New Moon makes as much money as Twilight there will defiantly be a movie, who would stop a money making thing... I'm sure New Moon will be the movie of the year and I myself will go see it everyday in the movies till they stop playing it to help them make as much money as possible...

I think they should make them into 2 movies...and in the second one (if they run out of things to do, which i doubt they will but still) they could do a small section about renesmee in the future, living happily with Jacob!

2 movie is perfect... i can see two 2 hr movies, one ending with bella about to give birth they can cut out since some people think it will be ugly than cut back in with edward giving Bella the shot of venom into her heart.....bamn... movie 2 starting with Bella waking up...

Are you serious? Why the hell does everyone on here like that realtionship?!!!! it's sick!!!!

well if bella was supposed to end up with jacob he would have been able to imprint upon her, now doesn't that sound sick, making whoopie with a dog, i think thats illegal in some states in the US, don't know about other countries....

sorry was thinking something else and got sidetracked, didn't mean to comment on this .......

I will addmit that at first, i was kindof freaked out by whole thing. But slowly i became more used to it (mainly because i began reading many fanfics!) and the more i read the book the more it grows on me.

I just think it would be good to do it like that! And i also i like CindysGotOCD way of starting and ending the movie. And, like i said, if they run out of things to do they can do a teeny section about Renesmee in the future. It might also clear up any problems people have with Jacob about being a Pedo...because you will be able to see that physically they grow to the same age!

they seriously have to make breaking dawn or i will go crazy!! it will probably lead me to deppression or something!! there is plenty of beautiful babies around the world and they can just get different children when renesmee starts to grow up and when she's a baby and starts to talk they can use a computer! i will be a greater success than twilight and such a good movie. the ending of the book is brilliant and it doesnt leave you dissapointed and missing a huge adventure!! JUST MAKE THE DAMNED THING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
thank you!
pleez make it!

I'm on my hands and knees praying summit will make BD into a movie, don't care how they rate or how many movies it could be made into. The story has to be told so we can all rest easier at night, well atleast I will, no more nightmares about them ending with just Eclipse and never getting my resolution from the love triangle. Course we all know how it ends but still to see it on the big screen will just make our day or night.

how is getting pregnant at 18. enduring a gruesome birth and vampire transformation be so romantic?!!! sorry i don't see the romance in there!!!! not to mention dump her real family for a gang of undead, fangless vamps (who will have to continue going to school by the way). oh she won't ever have friends outside of the Cullens and Jacob's pack ever or grow up and mature like a decent person!!! personally if i was in the shoes of her parents i wouldn't know what to think of this spoild little brat who had everything handed to her including eternity!!! i really couldn't stand to live forever and watch everyone around me die!!! wasn't this supposed to be a doomed love story? that was the main reason i got attracted to these books!!! i was liking the whole first love between Bella and Edward but honestly i wasn't liking the direction Meyer took after New Moon!!! The whole rest of the series up until BD she's whinning like a child about being turned into a vampire!!! i could pull my hair out listening to that!!! I loved all the characters in the series except for Bella and Reneseme!! i can't stand them!!! i'm not a hater i just hate how things ended up, i can't stand Breaking Dawn!! that's just my opinion!!!!

IT'S A FREAKING BOOK. You are getting more upset about it than those who love the books. Try to control yourself.

ya it's a FREAKING BOOK!! Exactly what i was thinking!!! why didn't i say that before!!!

i really think Bella should have grown up a little during the events of Eclispe and decide to part ways with Edward and the Cullens!!! that's how i pictured it!!! Becasue really what kind of future would that be?!!! hunting on the blood of animals and never sleeping ( i'd go crazy!!) it was so unrealistic giving up evrything to live forever, that's just stupid!!!

You are awfully upset about this for someone who thinks only immature, teenage girls take it too seriously. And you really are on the wrong site to be saying this kind of stuff. While we are hear to voice our opinions, we are not here to insult or purposefully tick people off (which at this point is what I think you are doing). Be respectful of the site and why it was started to begin with.

actually i'm not upset!! stop judging based on "written" comments!!! i can say what i want as long as it has to do with the Twilight Saga and saying that i didn't like BD doens't make me hate the rest of the series!!! i love all 3 books, god give me a break!!

Thank you so much for your reply! I read this comment shortly after it was posted and couldn't even begin to reply to it because I was shocked! Your reply was very classy and I really appreciate the way you worded it. I'm not quite sure why someone who has those opinions would be apart of a community like this but they certainly aren't welcome.

No problem. :) I mean, we can all agree to disagree (or agree for that matter) but we don't have to get ugly about it! And I feel the same as you, why be here if you're just gonna stir up trouble!?! Glad to be of a bit of help!

Absolutely! I love reading everyone's opinion on here that's the whole point of the forums. There are plenty of things that I do NOT like but that doesn't mean i'm going to go join a site thats for fans. I mean seriously, Twilight fans can be SCARY! and people should know better than to mess with us lol.

Yes indeed....we Twi-pires shouldn't be messed with at all! (Particularly when we are PMS-ing). LMAO!

For your freakin information that was the ending Stephenie Meyer wanted. It's a love story between a girl and a vampire, It's what Bella wanted! So sorry if it didn't end with her picking your boy. But just because You hate it does not make it right for you to say that is shouldn't be made into a movie. Word of advice, stay at home with your Jacob Black fan fic thank you very much, and quit with the attitude, because you are making alot of enemies.

first of all... i never said anything about jacob black, where the hell did i mention him like that?!!! second i'm not as pathetic into thoes stupid teams of jacob and edward!!! i hate that crap!!!! and third sorry i never said i was a huge jacob fanitic, i know its a love story B!!! i'm a werewolf fan which has absolutly nothing to do with the twilight saga. your love story by the way, happens to be more about obsession though. and i wasn't just describing how i thought it should of ended i was thinking of the logical way to end the book because when it comes down to it why the hell would you give up everything important? mybe in my life stituation i would have done what she did, but because she had friends, loving parents and oportunitites to make something of herself either than being a monster, her choices were plain stupid. that's my anwser take it or leave it.

Ok so first of all, what does the Twilight/New Moon think they are? Not just because they are filming this huge hit movie means they own the place, or can do whatever they want. I'm really disappointed, and I really hope with all my heart that the cast does NOT have such behavior
Over and Out
Pablo Cohen

I believe it was about getting quality filming done in a short amount of time. They had a job to do which, without tight security, would be very difficult. I'm glad they kept things closed off from crazy fan-girls and the papps . . . .

Once again...I agree with you! I mean I love a little sneak peek but when November rolls around (big smiles) I wanna be in the theater excited not feeling like i'm going to watch all the clips of videos/pics that I saw over the past months on the net. AND, i'm a LONG way away from Vancouver so i'm a little jealous I don't get to see those things first hand :)

Exactly! I felt like I had seen Twilight before it even came out in the theaters due to all of the clips being leaked and pics being taken during filming. I truly respect their creative process and think the privacy will yield a better movie in the end!

Amen

LOL! I like seeing shots here and there just like every other fan girl but I don't want to see the whole dang movie chopped up into bits and pieces on you-tube! Glad you agree!!!

i really hope they make breaking dawn a movie ........everyone would see it if money is involved and thats summits concern........i just really hope they make it a movie they cant just stop at eclispe ....its unfair....( does a pouty face ) ..........:(

I agree completely my dear! *sighs*

ya *sighs* lol ...and adding a pouty face :(

But how could they make 3 and not the 4th? That would be pure insanity!!!!

ya its like they stop when its about to get really good to tell u the truth i thought breaking dawn was my fave and the best ...they were all great but i really loved breaking dawn ...and it would be pure insanity .....insanity i tell u ..:D

BD and New Moon are my 2 favs. Maybe because I couldn't stand the way Jacob and Bella were to each other in Eclipse. There would certainly be a bunch of unhappy Twi-pires if BD doesn't get made!

ya i loved new moon as well......and love the word twi-pires .....i usually like saying fanpires lol ....but they most deff should make breaking dawn a movie

Thanks....deedee and were talking the other day and I came up with Twi-pires! :)

lol hope u dont mind but i think i just found my new word of the day ........TWI-PIRES!!!!...lol if u dont mind....hahahahaha

Use it and abuse it! LOL. :)

Just remember you heard it here first! ;)

thank u lol hehehehhehahahahah ....and tell deedee its a great word to lol :D

of course i will remember i heard it here first ....all credit will go to u and deedee :D

LOL....and thanks for the props!

you r very welcome for the props .....lmao ......but it is a really neat and funtastic word hahahaha :D

*smiles and giggles to self* THANKS!

*giggles with u and gives u a half five * your welcome ......hahahahhahahah :D

Hey Tweter .. do I have your permission to email you?

Sure....

Hey, how do you get on the top commentors list?

I'm not sure. I think it's based on how long you've been posting on the site and how many posts you've made since getting on.

Oh...and what are the stars for and how to get one? i was just asking because i have more post than one or two on the list..so i was wondering...thanks

The stars are moderators. I'm not sure why you aren't on the list. How many posts do you have?

um over 240 i think

They site manager, disqus, keeps a running total of everyones and changes it each day. You'll should make it on the list tomorrow! :)

thanks

No problem. :)

Hey, I'm french and I think that many people must go see new moon and eclipse so that Summit must made breaking dawn that's our own option to do something, for harry potter(ok it's not the same!)they made all the movie.WE MUST DO OUR TWILIGHT FAN'S REVOLUTION!!!!!!

REALLii REALLii REALLii hope they make breaking dawn
ahh...im gonna be so sad if they dont
um..one question...how are they gonna make it in 2010 if they still need eclipse.....maybe the rumors are true about eclipse

Okay folks lets ignore the hater, I got a question to ask how would you like the movie to open, with wolf Jacob or the history of the immortal children, remenber movies may not open the same way as the books. And the stand off with the wolves most be tense, Oh I'm sure they can get a real baby for the birth. And like someone said they made Gollum they can make Reneseme.

Yeah, I like the idea of opening the story with Bella's voice explaining the immortal children, or sumthing. I'm actually excited (even though I don't really know for sure if they are doing it.)
I'm wondering how they will put it together...

I really hope they make BD. Even though some of it is not really...fit for a movie, I think they should! If they have to change afew things about BD to make it actually good (and not so depressing for all the younger people), then so be it. I love the Book too, though. If they just stop at Eclipse, I will get so mad. There would be no point in this story if there isn't a 'happily ever after'.
And people who don't like BD, you don't have to watch the movie. I liked BD alot, and the ending was perfect.
BD needs to be made.

I really really want to know where the location is. Why do they have to keep it so secretive? I know we're crazy fangirls, but I think we can control ourselves...when we have to or when we're forced to.

I had favorites in all the books.But for the ones that had me tearing up would be new moon when edward left and charlie found her and the words that came out her mouth were "HES GONE" and BD when Bella toward the end during the almost battle when she had told Reneesme that she loved her and always will and then told Jacob to run and then well page 722 I FLIPPIN CRIED LIKE A BABY!! I think that BD was a good book tho I also like the that fact that SM waited til they were married before they had sex..

Please... they need to make BD... that's the ending... or shall I say beginning of Edward's and Bella's life as a family!! I'm gonna throw a massive-21-yr-old-tantrum if they don't make it... I swear!!! It won't be the same if they just stop @ Eclipse... no, no, NO!! I'm keeping my fingers (and toes) crossed... =]

There was only one page of BD that I hated and that was page 755 where it says "The End". I read it and said WTF? Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo...

my two cents :o)

personally i liked BD the least, because of Renesmee and Jacob, its just weird. but thats just my opinion. BUT i would still want it made into a movie.. because its the 4th book. you can't not film the end of the story. and some people may just be watching the movies, not reading the books, ( i have done this with LOTR) you can't just miss the ending.

i am not a teenage girl. but i am a massive Twilight saga fan. I grew up watching Buffy and Angel, and i like pretty much anything with vamps. i am legend, 30 days of night, blood ties,moonlight,true blood, i went through a really traumatic experience 4 years ago. the books have really helped me. ironically i find it safe, familiar. its the world i retreat to when i can't cope. please don't judge every one who likes Twilight. in say 10 years time Twilight will still remind me of a good time in my life.

personally, BD was my least favourite of the books, (i dont hate it) because i found the Renesmee / Jacob thing a bit weird, but thats just my opinion BUT they can't not make the movie. there are 4 books in the saga, so they need to make 4 movies. what about the people who are just watching the movies, and havent read the books (like i did with Lord of the rings). you need to end the story.

i am not a teenage girl but i love Twilight. i grew up watching Buffy and Angel and i love anything with vamps,books, movies. anne rice, kelley armstrong books,i am legend, 30 days of night, blood ties, moonlight, true blood. to be honest, i was put off reading Twilight because i was told it was just another love story, and i read mostly vampire / sci fi/ horror books. 4 years ago something really bad happened to me and i have had trouble coping. i read Twilight and it helped alot. ironically it feels safe, familiar. it is the world i retreat to when i'm feeling down. its a story of hope. that against all odds, love wins and bella is happy. that everything was worth it. if you hated BD, did you not want Bella to be happy? to have her happy ending? if you've never felt like you would give everything up for your love, then you've never been in love.

to the person who said its not realistic to marry at 18 and stay together, some do, some dont. i know a couple who dated since they were 14, they are now in their 40s and have 2 children. anyways its a book. i refer you to my previous comment, that it gives people hope. whats wrong with that? if no one thought relationships would last, no one would ever get married or have children. all books and movies show an idealistic version of love. if they didnt no one would read/watch them.

sorry for the essay.. just thought i'd give my comments.

I love all the books. I love Twilight the movie. I so want to see New Moon. I also hope they make the rest into film. I think people that love twilight will really enjoy that. I know that I will enjoy watching them. Stephenie Meyers wrote awesome books. I enjoyed reading the. I will read them over and over agian. My favorite book it Twilight and Breaking Dawn. I love it when Bella and Edward was together. There were parts that I like in New Moon and Eclipse. I just could not put my two favorites down. They are all great in my eyes.

You have to think about BD as a movie....not as the book. The changing perspectives and the slower pace of it - a huge chunck of time is spent with Jacob watching Edward watch Bella in pain, with nothing that either can do - doesn't make for great movie. Also, there is not much action, just seuspense and tension. Whoever is adapting the book will have a lot of work cut out for them.

Personally, it was not my favorite book in the series, they finally get married, go on a honeymoon are extremely happy and then the misery begins. The happiness was too short lived, could have let a year go by with her as a human. After all 3 books of constant fear, could have let the characters be happy for a little while longer.

The wedding scenes will be beautiful though. When I first read it, I pictured the whole scene with the instrumental intro to Guns 'N Roses "November Rain". Amazing!