Get New Moon Tickets

Eclipse Movie

News from the Vancouver Set of the Eclipse Movie

Amazing New Moon Movie Posters

Grab the Eclipse Countdown Widget Timer with Official Release Date!

American Idol Justin Guarini Aims for New Moon Soundtrack

by Will on May 13, 2009 · Comments

in New Moon Soundtrack

Justin Guarini New Moon American Idol Justin Guarini, who was previously on American Idol, is yet another of the numerous musical acts hoping to get a slice of the New Moon soundtrack pie.

Although Guarini’s “New Moon” fate is still up in the air, he did say that the folks at the Chop Shop, the film’s music supervisors, have told him they’ve given the song a listen and will let him know if he makes the cut as soon as the decision is made. Guarini said that’s more than enough recognition for now. “I’m just happy they are considering it,” said the TV Guide Channel host, who’s currently working on his third full-length album. “It would be an honor to be on the soundtrack.”

Check out the song he’s proposing in the video below–do you think it fits with the movie at all?

Justin Guarini Still Hopes To Be On ‘New Moon’ Soundtrack

See also...

  • Briele
    i want another SUPERMASIVE BLACK HOLE type of music in newmoon!!! lol!
  • flightless_bird
    Supermassive black hole DEFINATELY should be in new moon !!!
    but also I LOVE this song : need by hana pestle

    ITS PERFECT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • alicefan
    All i know these mainstream...teenie bop singers should NOT be on the soundtracks. The music for Twilight and the score are fabulous. The new Moon music should be just as fabulous. No Jonas or Justin!
  • LadyLautner
    omfg, u should listen to Angel by Within Temptation, i think it fits perfectly
  • TwiLove
    I love that song too..... I created my own New Moon soundtrack on my ipod and that is one of the songs in it..... It is sooo perfect.... "Sparkly angel I believe you are my savior in my time of need..........No remorse cause I still remember, your smile when you tore me apart..You took my heart, deceived right from the start......." LOL...
  • LadyLautner
    yeah I KNOW, the first time i heard the song it reminded me of twilight instantly, lmao
  • bella vita
    Exactly! I agree with everything you said! The fact that they used lesser known artists on the Twilight soundtrack was part of what made it so great! The songs chosen for Twilight were chosen because they truly fit the tone of the story and the scenes they were used in, not because they just went with whoever the most famous people were that said they wanted to be on it. I don't want to see that change just because they have a bigger budget. I really hope that they keep that the same and don't go the boring cookie-cutter pop route. The Twilight soundtrack sold the way it did because the music on it was amazing not because so and so was on it. I just personally really loved the Twilight soundtrack and still listen to it all the time and don't want to see the music become more and more generic with each film. Some of my favorites from Twilight are obviously Muse's Supermassive Blackhole, Mutemath's Spotlight, Iron & wine's Flightless Bird, Eyes on Fire (I forget the artist name, but its the song playing when Edward runs away to Denali for a few days and Bella is looking around for him at school). Anyway you guys get the point! PLEASE DON'T RUIN NEW MOON WITH GENERIC BORING MAINSTREAM TWEEN POP MUSIC!
  • TiShCuLLen
    what's that rumor about kelly clarkson being in the soundtrack with 'Did you'??? I mean.. I like her music.. but that song is not good..
  • StephanieDJ
    that's one of the things I liked about the Twilight CD it wasn't all mainstream crap!
  • abby
    Agree 100%
  • Kim1524 (Fanfic Junkie)
    i really liked the fact that the music in twilight wasn't so mainstream, thats why i think this song by sia is perfect http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1wPo993nWGw
  • Roxie
    Kim, You have no idea how I agree with you. : ) I have 2 Sia cd's and they are nearly scratched to heck, because they get moved from car to home and back. I love Sia, especially this song.
  • Miami Coven Cherry Bomb
    The only Idols I want on any of the soundtracks are David Cook, Daughtry. and and

    ADAM LAMBERT.
  • SpydurMonkee
    David Cook is exactly who I was thinking of also!!!
    Listen to DECLARATION... if you haven't heard it already. It even has a twilight feel to it. Also LIE , is also perfect. THE WHOLE ALBUM IS AMAZING
  • Patience Isn't My Specialty
    Hi Briele,
    I agree with you! Have you ever heard ANGEL BY MASSIVE ATTACK? The beginning is slow but I think it has that New Moon mood...http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jZsHNkAJBDU
  • Briele
    Hello Polaca! Nope never heard of it but i looked at the link...It's pretty creepy one! ;-) i think it's cool. Well I'm pretty sure that they will be able to make a good soundtrack. Let's just not expect too much cause that's when we get disappointed if we are not satisfied by then. The volturi part should be easy for them as there are a lot of choices for it... Now the wolfpack thing should have some rock-on on it! lol! I'm sure i will like the outcome cause I'm not so hard to please as an audience. Comparisons would be thereafter but the fact remains that I appreciate the happiness they gave and will give to me! ;-)

    It will be perfect if all of us will like it by then :-)
  • aqua
    OMG THE SONG ANIMAL I HAVE BECOME by Three days grace Is perfect for jacob in new moon I love iT!!
  • i think stephenie chose that song for Midnight Sun lol.
  • R.Pattz is my homeboy;)
    this song is good u should check it out :
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x3U6BCUQqG8
  • kimpx30
    I am a huge Twilight fan, and I have been listening to some of the song suggestions that you guys have come up with and THEY ARE GREAT!!! I just listened to the group RED "Pieces," would work so well with the scene of Bella going to Italy to stop Edward.
  • R.Pattz is my homeboy;)
    thats wat i thought too :D
  • Briele
    love it!!!
  • Jake-is-my-h3ro
    such an amazing song...i can see it playing when bella is running to edward... while in italy.. very nice song
  • R.Pattz is my homeboy;)
    i know i so can't wait
  • Tia_jb10 (Team Pants Explode!)
    omg i kno rite i think of jacob and bella for this song cuz she goes to him to fell whole or more human or whatever or jacob cuz he has to deal with bein a warewolf and he likes bella so when he sees her hes all happy and stuff i listen to it All the time LOVE it so much=)))
  • R.Pattz is my homeboy;)
    I know i LOVE it too i listen to it every day
  • The Popper
    that was pretty decent...
  • nemesis_CarolinaCullenCoven!nH
    nice, i like it...well since everyone is giving their options, hehhe try listen "falling" by Lacuna Coil, pretty intense song and i think it totally fits when bella is jumping off the cliff :D
  • R.Pattz is my homeboy;)
    i listened to it it was pretty good :D
    also "Like a knife" by Secondhand Serenade
  • i like its a beautiful song.
    but if they dont put going under in the soundtrack im gonna cry! its perfect and even stephenie chose it for her playlist on her website.
    now, i know these 2 songs are mainstream but i feel it fits perfectly especially Happy Ending. i can picture their reactions in my head when i listen to these songs: Happy Ending, and Erase by Mika. i know their not gonna put it in but i love it. i think happy ending is a very sad song, the melodies. and erase as well. i also like Reason by Melanie C. it applies to Edward i believe.
  • TeamRotation (Meg1)
    Angel's a good song! Agree with that. I'd say this song might be good.. by Ween (sung by Gene) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9RWk-j5ko-M
  • csl09
    Great song for New Moon!
  • TeamJB
    LOL HALE YEAH!!! I love Supermassive Black Hole it still my twilight fav song!!!!
  • Tak
    Yep Totally agree!

    Besides Steph herself is now a big Muse fan herself so the chances are she probably likes Muse's songs the best. She sorta listened to their music the whole time she was writing the saga or something so she might have better idea which of their songs fit in which books best...something like that...
  • Lynn
    Can you seriously not see that this song fits perfect? Just listen to the words!! It's perfect for the movie!!!
  • Briele
    I wouldn't mind whateve song is in the soundtrack. For sure I will like it still. Like I said, I'm not so hard to please :-) I just thought that the supermassive black hole song was so perfect for that scene in the baseball field. They did very good at it and that every song in twilight was well picked.

    Now about this song, yes it's good. If they could fit this song in one of the dramatic scenes then of course that's alright because they know better than me :-) I'm sure i will like it still.

    I just don't think that the rhythm of this song can be levelled with supermassive black hole... Without the lyrics, supermassive black hole as a background music can make a scene very captivating. I don't know about this one :-)
  • cryebaby70
    The breakup scene needs something that would make you want to cry...what about Blackout by Muse - that's a really good song that would fit the scene - OR maybe a more morose (very sad) ending to her lullaby...it started with that...it seems only fitting that it would end with that...no? That would be killer and I would be bawling the entire time....
  • Frosta
    I just listened to it again,and have since changed my mind from thinking it would possibly fit to, there is no way. Because of the lyrics being so literal, the only place they would make sense would be right after he leaves her. At which point the music is too up beat for that. It's a very sad moment, and that's just too uppity for that time. Something like My Immortal would fit in better there. That's a moment that had better make me cry cause it sure did in the book and if the melody isn't right for that time it will ruin it, so no, this song will not work.
  • Briele
    yep...Though sometimes they change the arrangement but still, it's a little raw for the highly dramatic and action-packed newmoon!
  • unicorn glow(vampire_vixen)
    i agree frosta..the melody is not right; and the words are too literal..it's like the words comes from the book and not original..lol..i aint hating on justin; but i really want original songs on there and rock; not any teeny bopper or the obvious lyrical songs out here.. when edward leaves bella; dido song "here with me" can do; or something else; even evenescence song "my immortal" can do o in this moment.. i think evenescence song my immortal fits when bella is depressed and not wanting to get out of bed; or when charlie telling her mom to come get her and stuff like that..because the lyrics kinda match the mood
  • csl09
    They need to stay away from mainstream music all together for this movie just like they did for Twilight. There are definitely better songs out there than this one...
  • cryebaby70
    I don't think the American Idol lackey should have anything to do with it! He should just keep doing three shows a night in Vegas! I would be very put out if he sullied the soundtrack...most people would think it was a joke anyway!
  • The Popper
    im pretty sure he or whoever wrote this song, wrote it for this movie...i really thought the song was good, i did like it but not really 4 the these movies....its not the same feel..and i love muse....

    .....But in all fairness ......i kinda see this song rearranged to fit when bella's wondering/lost in the forest after she realizes what has happened ....

    when edward leaves bella ...she follows.....song starts @ instrumentals n middle of song(volume low) ...screen 2 bella's surprised/hurt face..@ the same time the song starts w/ the long strung out words of "you don't exist'....song continues through chorus.....she's wondering lost & confused for a minute/ back & forth flashes of diff scenes of them & her in forest alone....song steadily increases....he sings the end of chorus "i cant' live in a world where u don't exist" (on last words vol. sky rockets)...then there's instrumentals, volume lowers again...wideshot of bella in forest alone...back 2 her face....her eyes glazed over w/ almost tears....she screams "Edward!" into the forest, ....wideshot of no response from forest/ back to bella...in shock she starts to shake uncontrollably lifting her shaking hands to face, staring into the nothingness that is there.....then she falls on her knees staring into her hands as if edward might appear.....zoom in on her face....as tears stream down it and watch as her face settles into the realization that he's gone....she crumbles....cut 2 next sceen.....

    ...man..i should really be a director....lol...mayb I should have this patened..lol...just listen to the song and imagine it...I known I'm corny...but thanks 4 not being too mean....
  • Nat_Cullen
    Totally agree! This just was just... amazing, And it fits so well!!!
  • michelle
    Get the Mitch Hansen CD Endless Day. The song By You is perfect for the breakup scene and Bellas Lullaby is beautiful. I also really like Jacob Black. The chorus, your nothing but a dog and she's way to good for you. rocks!!!
  • cantabgirl
    I love Muse and have done for a long time and think that a lot of their songs fit so well eg: Sing for Absolution, Assassin. I also heard Hello by Evanessence the other day and it bought me to tears, thinking of Bella after Edward leaves, have a listen.
  • unicorn glow(vampire_vixen)
    omg cantabgirl; i love evenescence and that cd..that hello song makes me cry and it would work too i agree..also my immortal from them could also work to match bella depressed mood
  • cantabgirl
    I had originally thought of My Immortal, but thought the words to Hello just fitted Bellas mood better, because in fact she is so much in her own head that she really has no one to talk to but herself, Im so glad you agree....my hubby loves it too.
  • twilightedbyedward
    I think that one song, explained the entire theme of the relationship of edward and bella in new moon. He did try to kill himself when he thought she was dead.
  • vampyrgrl
    I agree........love that song and Muse!
  • lindsey w
    i dont think it would be a good idea to have a song that was on the first one to be on the next movie. This new movie is different from the first one so there should be a different soundtrack. And i like the song by justin its good.

    listen to frozen by within temptations

    just give it a listen and see what yall think about it
  • Warrenff5 TwiGuy
    This song fits extremely well, IMO.

    All Around Me - flyleaf
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_-sNIWi2fLs

    The video looks corny, so just listen, don't watch.
  • Meep
    How about "You are mine" by Mute Math
  • bella_clair
    i think the lyrics and music are good.. but i don't think his voice is powerful enough to carry it... maybe something a little less obvious?...
  • vanessa
    I agree with you about the lyrics and music and not him singing it, maybe a different arrangement of the song by a different band would work, at least he can still get cred for writing it right
  • lena
    i agree with you; different arrangement and different band could work, a little more edgy like linkin park, muse, staind genre, but then again why bother with him, just ask these 3 amazing bands and I bet they would come up with amazing songs for the soundtrack
  • Patience Isn't My Specialty
    ANGEL BY MASSIVE ATTACK would be great for this movie! Here is a video on You Tube: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jZsHNkAJBDU
  • ilovemasochist
    OMG
    EWW
    that was creepy sadistic scary and sick
    but I liked it : )
    It was like watching a mini horror movie
    A man on a visual trip to his grave
    *shivers*
    to dark for NM
  • jamey
    Lyrics ( I hope there right)

    Your Taste still burns my tongue
    Your scent still lingers in my lungs
    Your blood still sings that melody
    A song that is written just for me
    Right or Wrong
    Now that youre gone
    I cant live, I cant live
    If I cant touch you with my fingertips
    I cant live, I cant live
    In a world where, a world where
    You dont exist.
    Im possessed and I cant turn back now
    Im possessed, you own me inside out
    Im dead without the breath you breathe
    Your life will be the death of me
    Right or Wrong
    Now that your gone
  • zomglions
    I like the lyrics, just not the sound.
  • Jennifer
    I'm the same. Lyrics fit great, but the overall sound and feel of it just isn't right.
  • Nessi15
    I agree with you on the sound thing... it just doesn't mesh well
    I really like Blue foundation.. maybe Watch you sleep
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b7zRjc3ZJi0
    would work
    or even
    Daniel- by bat for lashes
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=00ZHah-c0hQ
    ...it would be soo much better if it said Edward instead of Daniel in the song it seems to catch the sorrow
  • keekster08
    LOVE blue foundation! they are really great.
  • Nessi15
    I have to admit I first heard them off of the Twilight soundtrack, but I did fall in love with their style of music. I hope the New Moon Soundtrack has some different and amazing artists too
  • MarcelaN
    That's kind of how I feel too. However, I know that a decent recording would make a world of difference - and a producer that knew how to get that decent recording.
  • Frosta
    I totally agree. The lyrics fit great, it just needs some work.
  • TwiAddict
    yeah; i feel that his voice can't sing this song right. i LOVE the lyrics though, just a different sound.
  • unicorn glow(vampire_vixen)
    love the lyrics; not the sound
  • Alessandra
    good lyric. the music is cute, but I'm not crazy for it...
  • MelissaIsATwilightLover
    Yeah, see, American Idol will kill Twilight. Dead. I like the lyrics, but this dude is obviously doing it for fame. Well Justin, your fifteen minutes are up.
  • Karen
    Doesn't fit the movie, waaaaay to romantic and waaaaaaaaay to main stream. Would mess up what they've created in twilight. Muse, Blue October- HATE ME ( I love that song, it made me cry), Paramore, Taking back Sunday, Linkin Park they're new moon materiel.
  • Lauren
    Totally agree. Too 'pop-y' for New Moon, doesn't fit with the sound theyve created for Twilight. Like the song, but not for NM.
  • othersescape
    YOU ARE SO RIGHT!
  • Kim1524 (Fanfic Junkie)
    This song just isn't right for newmoon, it's not the worst song i've ever heard but it's just so repetitive, yes we get it you can't live, geeze lmao!!
  • what's with these pop singers wanting to be feauture in New Moon??? Seriously, if they want to be feauture they shouldnt make their songs to freaking soft. Like mentioned before, the songs needs to be into the rock edgy! We dont want noo freaking fairytale songs, have they not seen the movie??? For God's sake its about VAMPIRE & WAREWOLVES & IMMORTALITY!
    BRING ON SOME LINKIN PARK, EVANESCENE, MUSE, PARAMORE!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Greg
    Just another hasbeen trying to get their hand in the pot. This guy is a joke. The song is eh ok maybe just use a sec of it in the movie if it even gets that far. But I dout it. They need to stick to the way they did twilights soundtrack. New moon needs to be better. I like "Need" by Hana Pestle. That fits more than this joke.
  • ItsRobert_Effing_Pattinson
    Ha! I agree with you - He needs to go back to the set of "From Justin to Kelly" and try to find his career, because that is where he lost it - it is small, he will have to look very hard for a long time....
    LOL
  • Charlotte
    Everyone should check out the band ONE LESS REASON you can youtube them....I love this band they have alot of songs that always remind me of twilight new moon and all the books. ill put some links if anyone wants to check them out I LOVE THEM

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a2q8AFykV-U&feat...
    ( THAT SONG IS CALLED "A DAY TO BE ALONE")

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uo_Ei-S81xY&feat...
    ( THATS CALLED "WORTHLESS")

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GH0HVAj0838&feat...
    (THAT ONE IS CALLED " FAVORITE COLOR")

    those are just some of their great songs that remind me of twilight books
  • Kassielovesthecullens
    I agree with you about that Hana Pestle song...she sounds pleading, torn, begging for him to stay....thats how i pictured Bella's sadness when the breakup happened. "NEED" is perfect.
  • Marianne
    I so agree with you "Need"by Hana Pestle fits New Moon perfectly. I thought so the first time I heard it. It makes you feel pain, longing, sadness.
  • RavennaFeldstrauch
    The song is great! They HAVE to put it on the soundtrack!
  • Mel
    This should not be put in any of the movies for Twilight. I don't care if they want it for the first dance at their wedding. Do not use him in any of the movies. He has not been a good singer since he was first on American Idol. I don't care that he made it to the runner up. There was a reason why he did not win and a reason why the contract he was given by Simon Cowel was cancelled. He SUCKS!!!!! This song does not fit the movie and I don't care how big of a fan he claims to be if he really knew NM then he would not have made that song sound like that. We definitely need more sounds like Muse, Paramore, Linkin Park, and etc. Oh, of course Rob Pattinson. His songs might be considered a love song but they are more dark and ominous. Paramore's songs (for people who know the books) tell the feelings of what's going on with the movie but not in direct words. Justin might as well have said Bella loves Edward, Edward loves Bella, They are in love and they miss each other. The song is too literal and has the absolute wrong sound and feel for this movie.
  • kerry
    Its' way to cheesy. Just read that Jonas Bros. wants to get on the soundtrack as well. That would be completely ridiculous! There's no comparison to "Twilight type" music versus "Jonas Bros/ Justin G." type music. It's not the right fit.
  • bella vita
    Seriously? The Jonas Bros? OH FOR THE LOVE OF GOD AND ALL THAT IS HOLY PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE DO NOT LET THEM OR ANY OF THOSE DISNEY KIDS ANYWHERE NEAR NEW MOON, ECLIPSE, OR BREAKING DAWN!!!! It will be the kiss of death! Surely Stephenie would totally disagree with using that kind of... I don't even know what to call it because that crap they sing sure isn't music. Steph seems to have great taste in music and the Jonas Bros and stuff like that don't seem to fit her style or the saga. AT ALL.
  • unicorn glow(vampire_vixen)
    agree kerry..the song is cheesy and too literal..o gosh....no way; no jonas bros here...please..i want something original like iron and wine and then ofcourse; the rock; and edgy sounds....please; let the jonas stay on disney where they belong..WTF..come on now..its pissing me off just thinking about it...ughhhh
  • Kimoppi
    We discussed this over in the Soundtrack section too. Someone mentioned it before.

    I listended to it, and I really wasn't a fan. It really SOUNDS like he wants to be in the movie (if that makes sense.) It just tries too hard. The lyrics are WAY too literal and musically it doesn't stand out from any other song. I think it's very generic. I could imagine it in a "Twilight the Musical" situation, but really nothing more than that.
  • ItsRobert_Effing_Pattinson
    hahaha!! OMG, Twilight the Musical??!?!? I totally just had a vision of guys dancing around while Edward sings the fact that he wanted to kill Bella so badly that first day. Wow, that would be a crap-tastic musical!! LOL. that's funny...
  • Ciggy_
    LMFAO!! Hey maybe they could do an Animatronics one too..
  • ItsRobert_Effing_Pattinson
    lol, yea cause that would be SOOO much better!! LMAO!!
  • Kassielovesthecullens
    funny thing is I would go see it...I like musicals...LOL
  • ItsRobert_Effing_Pattinson
    I am afraid that that is one cash cow I will NOT be buying into...unless, of course, it was actually Robert up on stage singing - in tights! now THAT I would go see!!
  • Kassielovesthecullens
    yeah...LOL Rob in tights....well?...he does seems to want to further his career and he can sing...maybe we will see him on broadway someday.....just not for Twilight the musical LOL
  • a
    HAHAHAH!!!
    I was eating and spit up my food laughing!!! HA!!
    hahahahahahahahahahahah!!! LMAO
  • edward_addicted
    LMAO!!!!!!
  • C
    Don't these people know that TWILIGHT FANS DO NOT LIKE THIS MUSIC!
    Why oh why would we want American Idol winner to be on the soundtrack?!
    None of this music fits.
    Twilight soundtrack was amazing. No way is Madonna or that Demi woman being on this track. More yet, the Jonas Brothers come on?! How worse can it get?
    I swear people are just out to ruin it for us all. >.>
    NO 2009 POP SENSATIONS.
    Who else is with me?! :D
  • Brooke
    I totally agree with you.
  • TheLionFellIn<3W/Ceci-ROBECI
    Woa... so many HATE comments... jeez people I know it's your opinion but damn!!!
    Personally, I LOVE the lyrics... they fit well... Justin has a nice voice but if they're really going w/ the Twilight-soundtrack-type of music then I don't know if they would include him, but I did like it... I LOVED the soundtrack for Twilight and I'm sure that I'll do the same w/ NM as long as the songs fit the mood and the emotions...

    Any who... since most of you are suggesting songs of your personal liking... I'll give ONE of mine (I have a zillion in mind)!
    I would love to have Almost Lovers by A Fine Frenzy!!! That girl has such an amazing voice and the song just fits perfectly... ooohh and Near to You by her as well for Bella and Jake... lol... ok I can go on and on... but yea, those are two of my favs =]
  • Guen
    Thats a great song! It fits perfect!
  • mschicklet
    NO NO NO NO NO!!! This song is terrible...all his songs are terrible. They do not belong on this soundtrack. MAKE HIM GO AWAY!!
  • iloverobpat
    Ew no, he sings bad.
  • Sage
    Yeah I was not even able to listen to the whole song. What about this song New Moon?
    Kelly Clarkson...Haunted.
    \http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9DxPzQoCVH4&feature=related
  • Kassielovesthecullens
    i liked it
  • Twilightchick
    I have listened to this song I think that it is fabulous. I think it fits really to the movie. LOVE IT!!!!
  • RobismyRomeo (RIMR_)
    ok, my opinion? I think it's a bit cheesy when the lyrics are that obvious. Paramore was able to write songs for the Twilight soundtrack, but anyone could have related to the lyrics- hence making the songs a hit.

    It sounds nice though, I'll give Justin props for that!
  • Rob_is_my_Kryptonite
    EXACTLY! Justin's lyrics are TOO OBVIOUS that it seems like he is taking lines from the book you know?! I LOVED Paramore's DECODE b/c she made me see Edward and Bella in a WHOLE different way but a way that was still true to the book...does that make sense?! She was completely ORIGINAL in her lyrics that I was able to enjoy it from another perspective. THAT is why I don't know if Justin's song would work. I hope I made sense?
  • RobismyRomeo (RIMR_)
    Yes, you make sense!

    Here's what I think, If I heard Justin's song in New Moon, I would think, "Ok, that makes sense, for obvious reasons".

    But, if I'm driving somewhere and heard that song on the radio, I would think, "WTF?" and change the station. I don't want to rock out to a song about blood and vamps on my way to work/school/etc! lol.
  • Rob_is_my_Kryptonite
    LOL
    I will rock out to VAMPS on my way to work!
    But blood? No!
  • Jake-is-my-h3ro
    you do
  • ilovemasochist
    Bingo you hit the nail on the head
    obvious lyrics, my son could have written it
    Kinda reminds me of Rob explaining the way Art sang in 'how to be'
    every word was so literal
    kinda embarrassing
  • It has to be better than Twilight soundtrack I want paramore to be in it again!
  • i love rob
    Absolutely.....we need more Paramore!!!!!
  • Jamie30
    I really wish that they would try and put Robert on the NM soundtrack. I know he doesn't really want to, but I would love to hear him singing again!! :)
  • i love rob
    Oh, definitely....that is a give in!!! We always want more Rob! Whether its acting or his music!!!

    I can never get enough of Rob!!!!!
  • They should do a song with Rob and Kristen together! And jackson!
  • Mrs. Robsessed
    where the hell r U???? Are u doing Rob deotx too??? You've missed a lot unless you have just been reading and not posting anything. I tired to wean myself but i can't!
  • Mrs. Robsessed
    holy shiz....where r u????? Have you been missing all the italy kissing coverage. I am dying over here. I've been through a box of tissue and have the hair is standing on the back of my neck. Did your husabnd ground u or something??? I hope your computer has crashed bcuz that would be the only acceptable excuse. I think Rob has crashed the world wide web 2day!
  • Stephanie
    Hell Ya!! More Paramore! Decode totally rocked!!
  • FL95 (JoJo)
    I like Paramore too, also liked Muse.... I think their remake of "Feelin Good" should be the very last song, as Bella and Edward are walking to the house to face Charlie, and she's talking about how she can face anything as long as he's there with her... yeah.
  • zomglions
    Ooooh. That would be cool! Love that song!
  • Rob_is_my_Kryptonite
    I agree...we need Paramore on the soundtrack again!
  • Tiffany Stevens
    Yes I agree. I hope there is more Paramore, Linkin Park, and Muse. I like Cold Play as well but on the next sound track since it will get more intense I hope they put Distrub - Down with the Sickness in it.
  • ♥Luvsthatcoldnhotguys♥
    definitely, i would love coldplay on there... especially their song Fix You... perfect for Jacob...(it was on Stephenie's playlist already lol) and i really love paramore and linkin park and muse... they make awesome music!

    and Need by Hana Pestle! She def needs to be on there... her lyrics are soooo New Moon mood and everything... perfect for when edward leaves and Bella's in the forest...she better be on the soundtrack and as well as paramore... lol
  • Jake-is-my-h3ro
    yeah i liked their songs
  • Tara_Kay
    I think i read or heard somewhere that they want be on all of the soundtracks if (the music producers of the soundtracks) let them. Keepin my fingers crossed!
  • nikitajuice - HisNeckIsMOINE
    Yeah, that's what I heard too, apparently Paramore is going to be the saga's houseband... would be a great choice.
    And I hope there's going to be more Linkin Park on the NM soundtrack, those guys rock.
  • Rob_is_my_Kryptonite
    I am crossing my fingers too!!!
  • mickey_lamb
    YA CUZ I LOVE DECODE! is carter burwel doing the music again??? i really really hope so because it was really good last time
  • Rob_is_my_Kryptonite
    I hope the New Moon Soundtrack will be just as good or even better than the Twilight soundtrack!
  • I like the 2nd song its catchy! but I dk if it would go with movie
  • RxJenluvsRob
    uhm, horrible song...... feels like a desperate attempt to me!
  • Jennifer
    NO no way no American Idol contestants! What are they thinking?? The Twilight soundtrack got it right. Don't Eff this one up, guys!
  • This COULD possibly work... I don't know. It's a stretch.
  • lion_lamb715
    ok ew no get some good people like paramore muse or Rob i mean cmon this guy is just desperate for fame
  • zomglions
    Agreed. We need more Muse on the soundtrack!
  • heyitsme0312
    LOVE LOVE LOVE the Muse idea lol
  • Swede
    it seems really desperate, that i can agree on, and the lyrics might fit a little too well? I don't know, it's like if the lyrics are to well fitted, they might make the movie disappear a little too much. And they might no be able to fit the whole song in to one scen? haha i don't know what i'm saying, but i think that would be kind of confusing...
  • Ash
    it can be good for quiet , little scene...
  • I ♥ TheCullenBoys ♥s Rob! ♥
    Um.... no! New Moon's soundtrack needs to be just like Twilights... even better..
  • P
    I think it does work, the lyrics go well with the film. I cant imagine on the advert, maybe the credits or something but i like it i think it should definately be on the soundtrack
  • Ashley
    Oh gosh yes it fits perfect. Maybe a part when Edward thinks of Bella like a flashback or something. If they even have something like that.
  • Rob_is_my_Kryptonite
    I LOVED the Twilight soundtrack b/c of all the great artists on it! ESPECIALLY the artists I had never heard of before until I bought the soundtrack...like Blue Foundation and Black Ghosts. I really hope they stick with this formula for the New Moon Soundtrack!
  • zomglions
    I agree. I like it better with some undiscovered songs; it makes the movie less mainstreamed (none of us want that). This one is too well-known, and has too much rock. I can't see it going with the feel of the movie, even though NM will be different.
  • I ♥ TheCullenBoys ♥s Rob! ♥
    Me Too... I love the Twilight soundtrack!
  • bella vita
    AMEN! That's what I'm sayin!
  • zomglions
    There is too much going on in the song, so it wouldn't fit as background music in the movie. Could work for the credits. It's not a bad song, but I think we can do better!
  • Marsha
    maybe for one of the scenes crying bella in bed scene or something.. for the soundtrack we need a song that blows us all away!
  • neev
    i don't like it..
    it does nothing for me.. there's nothing new really..
    hope the new soundtrack will be as amazing as twiligiht soundtrack is.
  • UrHoldIsPermanentNUnbreakable
    I thought I liket it till I realized it was just the prew itro , the actually Justin Guarini song is pretty lame and ordinary thers a lot of other songs that would have been better , I realy like pinks song "I dont beleve you" , when I heard it the first time I directly thougt of neew moon... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g6nQOVaqGgQ
  • TwiMomma
    i'm sorry justin, i think your song is eh, not worthy of this soundtrack, i agree bring back more paramore & more linkin park, they are more along the lines of the feel of the movies & books.....
  • Jake-is-my-h3ro
    you said it best TwiMomma!
  • Twi_Wife
    Yes! More Paramore!!!
  • lizel
    I think it will work with the new moon. it has lyrics that say "I can't live in a world you don't exist"...just like what Edward tell Bella.

    I like the song even if it will make it to the cut or not.
  • edward_addicted
    I like the song too but i don't like that guy singing it, I just didn't get that certain feeling that i think you should with him singing but of course thats just imo!!
  • Kassielovesthecullens
    Like the song too...but just not his voice singing it....maybe if they slowed it down a bit and used someone else singing it
  • bob
    hummm me thinks it is a obvious........possibly credits???
  • Jake-is-my-h3ro
    WHAT IN THE WORLD..........i read this somewhere before and was thinking.."OK"! maybe he could write an amazing song for new moon and it could be in the movie.....but once i saw the music video that he has for the song(WHICH SHOWS PICTURES OF BELLA AND EDWARD) I WAS LIKE OOOOOKKKK......BUT I HONESTLY DON'T LIKE IT....WHERE COULD IT FIT IN THE FILM...??? AND I THINK IT SOUNDS LIKE RUBBISH JUNK!
  • joanna86 aka Charlie's Angel
    It wasn't bad, but a bit boring, imo. And as everyone here I want NM soundtrack to be SPECIAL :)

    I liked the video, btw :)
  • RobismyRomeo (RIMR_)
    i agree!
  • imo= in my opinion. :0)
  • RobismyRomeo (RIMR_)
    haha thank you! i figured it out, and then tried to edit my comment before anyone saw. I felt so silly and out of the loop :-)
  • Breazee
    lol That's okay, I totally didn't catch the imo either.... I'm so out of the loop.
  • joanna86 aka Charlie's Angel
    sorry :D
    funny thing is I'm not even from any of the English speaking countries! ;)
  • rpattzgirl
    Nope, don't like it. There are way better songs out there for the soundtrack.
  • i love rob
    Doesnt do it for me......we need to have music with an edge!!!

    This was definitely not it!
  • rach101
    The lyrics are good but i'm not sure that the sound is right. It's a bit too obvious if that makes any sense. Like the songs on the Twilight Soundtrack were unusual but they worked perfect. This song is just trying too hard imo. Maybe it could work for the credits though?
  • suitejuju
    Sounds like he's trying to make a smart move.
    New Moon is destined to be a money maker and he could use the publicity.
  • Nat_Cullen
    I like this song, it's not that bad... but like someone said before, the lyrics are too obvious.. in my opinion...
    It think there could possibly be a better song... Something that makes us shiver... :-)
  • Opinionated
    Lyrically it could work but the sound is all wrong... It needs a more emo sound to work for Twilight.
  • bella_clair
    i gotta say.. i was listening to snow patrol's chasing cars the other day, and that live sounds so desperate.. "if i lay here, if i just lay here, would you lie with me and just forget the world".. but it wasn't just that, it was "all that i am, all that i ever was, is here in your perfect eyes, they're all i can see.. i don't know where, confused about how as well, just know that these things, will never change for us" and i just thought.. wow that'd be perfect in there somewhere.. maybe when he comes back and she can't believe it's not a dream..
  • Nat_Cullen
    Yeah, these lyrics would definetly fit... :-)

    But when I think of the Twilight Saga, I imagine more "darker" music... not on the whole soundtrack, but maybe a few songs... To demonstrate the pain Bella has... I think something from Evanescence would fit very well... for example...
  • bella_clair
    yeah.. they played near me the other night and the version they had on the radio sounded torn..i reckon with some pain in their voices they could pull it off ;)
  • UrHoldIsPermanentNUnbreakable
    by the way whats the first song you hear in the vid???? that one sound better then justins :P
  • Jake-is-my-h3ro
    lmao!! thats funny
  • Kimoppi
    It's the intro to "The Golden Floor" by Snow Patrol

    Here's a link to listen to it:
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=twR5_2IaZqw

    I really like this song. I think I'll add it to my personal New Moon playlist. It made me immediately think of the plane ride home from Italy. I can't tell you why, but it did.

    Oddly enough, the JG video that is posted was fan made... I wonder if he realized that the intro he put in was better than the song he made a video for? lol
  • TwiMomma
    hello.....it's justin from american idol & tv guide! REALLY, good lyrics or not he's trying too hard & aiming for the wrong crowd! he's not in tune w/ the other artists from the 1st soundtrack... it would be as if bella & edward were selling their musical souls to have him on it!
  • Give the song to a group like MUSE....and let them work their magic with it, I'm sure it would awsome, cause the lyrics rock, but I'm not feelin' Justin....sorry buddy.
  • I like the sound and the lyrics, but I don't think that it will stick to the movie.

    I would love that Ne-Yo makes a few songs for the film. I love his songs :)
  • Ciggy_
    Umm.. No.. American Idol people no.. There is a reason you dont hear much from him.. Stick with the edgy stuff. More Rob on the Soundtrack would be nice please.
  • orianne
    nope,not.i want paramore and muse and linkin park!!! this is boring, lyrics are great, but linkin p. should play it-then it would be something!
  • Rob_is_my_Kryptonite
    I don't know if anyone has heard of Flyleaf's "All Around Me"? BUT I cannot help but think of Bella when I hear this song...and I think it would be great to hear it on the New Moon Soundtrack. Just my opinion :)
  • Stephanie
    I have their CD and I agree that song would work.
  • Rob_is_my_Kryptonite
    It's a great song with A LOT of emotion!
  • a
    oh my god!! was reading these comments and thought of the same thing. Actually i am listening to that song right now. They even have an accoustic version that is great as well.
  • MelissaIsATwilightLover
    Yeah, but evveryone has heard of it. It's not new you know? I love that song, but I don't know about it in the soundtrack since we've heard it already.
  • bella_clair
    just found this one.. called if you find her (weirdly from an album called twilight.. ) and it sounds sad.. doesn't really fit the mood- too sad compared to twilight's usual angst.. but it's good :) by a band called future of forestry

    She won't falter easy
    She'll be careful, she'll be coy
    But still she paints her heart
    Among the musings of a boy

    If You find her
    Tell her that I love her
    If she hears You
    Ask her heart to come

    At the break of morning
    The day awaits her when she sleeps
    Deep inside her dreams is all
    The beauty that she keeps
  • letty
    i like the song,
    but i think it's too rock-y
    cause it's a sad song

    maybe music a bit more like Hana Pestle's Need?

    But why would they put in Edward's POV ?
    They didn't do it for Twilight, so why New Moon
  • MelissaIsATwilightLover
    Let Me SIgn was in his point of view.
  • i_like_em_sparkly (Sparkly)
    Um sorry, Justin Guarini's not quite who I had in mind for the new moon soundtrack. But I give him credit for trying. Also the lyrics are a little too obvious - they don't give you any room for your own interpretation.
  • mama B
    NO!!! NO!!! NO!!!! not sure this is emphatic enough...too sissy, not painful...maybe someone more like Eddie Vedder...Rob sounds a little like him with "let me sign" and "never think"...more soulful, painful, POWERFUL!!!!
  • RobismyRomeo (RIMR_)
    If you want the New Moon soundtrack to be cheesy, add songs like this. Or NSYNC's "I want you back". Or Taylor Swift "Love Story". haha. This one is too 'pop' for a vamp movie, even if it is a romance type movie.
  • shadow
    forget justin's song listen to the the golden floor by snow patrol which is the first 29 seconds of this vid his voice and the beat is crazy
  • patty
    well he might be godo but at the same time wow, we havne't heard about him in a while w have we. I think they should cosndier a wide variety of gernes as logn htey set the mmod. i would go with rock, metal,pop, upnk asl ong ast ifs the mood
  • Funny how I sent this to you 3 weeks ago Will. w/ a youtube video. But it gets posted now, and I'm not credited for it? Shocking.
  • twilightus
    Yeah me too. I sent this about 3 weeks ago too! hmmmmm
  • kcullen
    I think that it would only work if they show Edward finding out that Bella is "dead" and he goes postal and decides to go die too.......You know? It would work for that seen.......

    I think that it would suck for the credits.....the movie is sad enough I want a happy song at the end!!!!!! Since everything works out in the end it needs to match the mood!!!!
  • jcrunswithvamps
    Oh yeah! When he thinks she's dead! They could play the chorus. :D I like that idea.
  • MoreThanMyOwnLife
    I think the song can make a good exit the theater/credits song. But I do not think it belongs IN the movie. The lyrics are awesome though..makes you wonder where the inspiration came from lol...hmmmmm!
  • day
    I like it more than paramore...i think its great
  • Eh, its ok. I mean it's no Hana Pestle "Need" or A Fine Frenzy "Almost Lover" I would rather see songs like that make the soundtrack.
  • RobismyRomeo (RIMR_)
    just heard Evanescense "My Immortal" on the radio. Made me think of this blog! :^)
  • RobismyRomeo (RIMR_)
    wow, just looked up the lyrics. I like this song even more now- and I think it could pass as a song from the bella/edward perspective:

    http://www.metrolyrics.com/my-immortal-lyrics-e...
  • Kimoppi
    My Immortal was already in a movie.

    Another good song by Evanescence is "Missing." It's haunting and beautiful. If you check out the lyrics it is great from Bella's perspective. I hear it in my head whenever Bella holds herself together because she thinks he just left and doesn't think he suffers too. That's basically the gist of the song.
  • RobismyRomeo (RIMR_)
    Yeah, I wasn't saying put that song into this movie- I just liked it because I, myself, could compare it to New Moon :^). I liked their song "missing", too! Evanescence is a great band, and the kind of music they play goes well with the Twilight theme, I think.
  • IndiesR
    It's not bad...plus, he needs a paycheck. :)
  • Claire Danvers_Morganville
    I liked it, words fit the story well, it could fit in the background of a scene. Watching all those clips from Twilght has made me want to watch the film so guess I'll be getting my DVD out AGAIN tonight.
  • HELLZ TO NOZ!!

    What happened to the music being alternative rockish? Rather than whiny, poppy, "you stomped on my heart ohh ohhh" pop-n-lock dance time!

    Give it up Justin! Though I do like the lyrics.

    Give me some Muse, Sia, and more great music.

    My vote....Best I Ever Had by State of Shock. I cried peeps. Cried. I never cry for music.

    If they want to go pop try Love Games by Lady GaGa. Simple for the "I want to take a ride on your disco stick" lyric. If that doesn't fit Bella then I don't know what does.
  • ItsRobert_Effing_Pattinson
    hahaha!! "pop-n-lock dance time" holy crap...I am still laughing!!

    ....and who DOESNT wanna ride on his disco stick?? That could be the anthem for everybody on here, although the song does ignore the "Disco ball(s)", that deserves attention too!!! LMAO
  • lauraseclipse
    oh my what a crap song... that better not make the cut or even close to it!!!
  • lauraseclipse
    yeah i totally think like evanescence... actually a friend and i are making playlists for all the movies... obviously based upon the books... i have some really good stuff on it so far...
  • brebre
    i dont like the song at all!
  • HMM

    Not sure

    I like the song and it fits the story wel
    But i dont think it fits the feel ofthe book and definately not the feel of the movie
    Maybe it would be a good end credits song??
  • pinjablaah
    it's missing that something.. almost
  • ali
    hum its not that bad but i dont want it to be on the soundtrack .:P
  • AMBER BAIRD
    I LIKE THE SONG AND I THINK I COULD FIT BUT IM NOT SO SURE THEY SHOULD DO SONGS THAT COULD BE TOP SONGS WITH OUT THE HELP OF THE TWILIGHT SAGA. SO KEEP IT SIMPLE AND GIVE ME SOME NEW BANDS SORT OF LIKE BLUE FOUNDATION LOVE THE FACT THAT I HAD NEVER HURD OF THEM AND I LOVE THEM NOW SO I THINK IT SHOULD STAY THAT WAY. BUT THE SONG WAS GOOD IWOULD LISTEN TO IT . LOL
  • vampmom
    please oh please do not do this to the twilight saga!!!!!
    justin does not fit the bill in anyway, sorry but he's a has been that never truly was...new moon mania is to good for him!!!
  • Cassie
    Uhm he basically just took lines from the books and sang them.. We all know the books, Justin! Get a little deeper!! Like Rob's "Never Think"... It is incredible and deeper than just taking lines from what is already out there. I hope he ends up having a song in all the movies.
  • Kimoppi
    Never Think wasn't even written for the movie. It already existed.
  • sandi
    thats why i like it.. the same with Let Me Sign, or am i confusing the facts?
  • Kimoppi
    No... I misread your first post. I thought it meant that the song was written for the movie, but managed to have original lyrics as opposed to book quotes like this one. :-) Sorry.
  • pamcake
    no no no, the musi is okay, but his singing is not right for twilight. he sounds lightweight.
  • Janina
    Lyrics are ok, but not great.. But the melody and singing is really bad!
    It's not the quality for new moon! Evanescence is a good pick or Alter bridge- watch over you. Linkin park- with you is the best!!!!
    or something from snow patrol,,, Anything but this!
  • jcrunswithvamps
    Watch over you is a great song and broken wings is really good as well
  • NOPE! back to muse & eyes on fire kthnx!
  • KellieCullen
    This song fits New Moon so well (:
    The lyrics fits how Bella feels, I picture it playing in the background before she jumps

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YI3WuKKXY3I

    xx
  • MMM.. maybe it's not the best song ever, but it's good, but I do really prefer Adam L. <3
  • sandi
    it just seems like it was written for newmoon...

    thats not "right"!

    i don't like that idea. really. please don't use this song.
  • Jme
    How long are they filming in Vancouver? Will they still be there Memorial Day weekend??
  • Kassielovesthecullens
    the volturi people are all leaving/have already left yesterday....I don't know about the rest of them.
  • EddieGal
    Don't mean to get off topic too much but has anyone heard Erin McCarley's song, Pitter Pat? Yes it's gaining popularity (don't hate me fellow Twi-Hards) but it's actually really good - it makes me think of Bella when she's hearing Edward in her head and even more so when she misses hearing Edward in her head. Just something for you all to chew on. Can't wait for November! 191 days left, gang.
  • FL95 (JoJo)
    Anybody here Stephenie's new favorite bands (well, one of her favorites anyway) song "Hate Me" (Blue October)? Freaking heartbreaking!
  • Twi_Wife
    Well, it's better than I expected. But I think there's something better out there.
  • Roxie
    Same, better than expected. Have you heard Matthew Mayfield's " As Long As You're Not Leaving" ? - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YOgNwT8dNes -
    I can see people like him ( Matthew ) being on the soundtrack. Although Paramore and Muse were already in the spotlight, everything fit.
  • me
    All I have to say is.

    HELL NO!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • CarlyD
    Don't like this somg either... I am not an Americal Idol fan. That said I will mention that my daughter (Yes!! daughter..) has a David Cooke CD and there is a song on it titled DECLARATION... I don't know--I see Bella running into the Italian square every time I hear this song. A little rock-ish in sound- not as alternative, but a great song. Anyone agree? (Oh--go Paramore...definitely need more of them..)
  • kerbear585
    no way. don't like it!
  • trish13
    I agree that justin's style is not the right fit for New Moon. Maybe he can pull it off in other romantic stuff but the twilight saga is just so much more intense. It's not necessarily all rock and punk, there's just a certain *umph* factor to it. HOWEVER, the lyrics of "I can't live" bring a lot of justice to New Moon, so if he's willing to change it up a bit an not make it sound so teenage chick flicky, then maybe I would reconsider.
  • elaine
    Ladies, Twilight soundtrack was awesome, but we need something a little different. Adam Lambert's, If I can't have you," is awesome. He is not ur normal AI contestant. Just listen to it! I can't wait to see what they do w/ the New Moon soundtrack. Hopefully, some different artists. Just an opinion!
  • I personally think Tori Amos should be given a chance...Putting the Damage On and The Beauty of Speed come to mind. There is also Lacuna Coil- I Won't Tell You, The Pain, and Shallow Life. Then Rasputina- The New Zero and Transylvanian Concubine. Look them up. Just my opinion though
  • Kimoppi
    I think Rasputina would definitely be worth considering. Especially with their current line-up with Daniel deJesus. He and Melora have a wonderful vocal chemistry.
  • bella vita
    omg I remember that Rasputina song Transylvanian Concubine from Buffy the Vampire Slayer! It was featured in season 3, I forget exactly which episode, but it was the one with Drusilla's "birthday party" and the song plays when she is walking down the stairs dancing around. After watching that episode on DVD last summer I had that song stuck in my head for weeks until I finally did some searching online and found the name of the artist and the song! I never would have thought of it for the Twilight saga, but now that you mention it I think they could make that song work fairly easily in one of the films.
  • crj
    I totaly agree about that song, I have that soundtrack and the twilight soundtrack, every time I hear Bella's lullaby I think of Buffy and Angel's song, the beginnings sound VERY similar!
  • mocha_love
    I have a question, where does everyone keep getting this clip of the girl jumping off the cliff from? it's driving me nuts! where's that from? does anybody know?
  • Nat_Cullen
    Don't know if you mean the same one like me, but the scene where a woman is jumping off the cliff in a white dress is from a music video from "Theory of a deadman".
  • daniela
    Okay more paramore on the soundtrack. none of this guy on the soundtrack please. and everything will be bright as sunshine. (:
  • Gaby
    I didnt even hear passed the 1:40 mark...me no likes. Lyrics r to literal and so not original. Am not a hardcore fan of rock but even I jam to Twilight soundtrack. it fits with the movie perfectly. But not the case with this song..Try Again!
  • stehfuhknee_hale
    Yeah- NO.
  • twifan89
    i don't know about this, im not sure about justin guarini being a part of this saga's soundtrack in general....he's trying too hard. i like paramores attempts better
  • tara18
    i love the lyrics but i dont think his voice is right for it i really never did like him anyways but its a alright song better than i thought it would be
  • michno03
    Should definitely include Evanescene. My Immortal would be classic here.
  • crj
    would be a good break up scene song.
  • sarah
    i hope he won´t be on the soundtrack...that sounds so wrong in my ears...i cant find a connection to my imaginary of new moon. i really hope the soundtrack will be as perfect as the first one......never forget supermassive black hole and bellas lullaby was beautiful. :)
  • sarah
    and kelly clarkson isnt in line with new moon....definitely not.. that story with kelly clarkson,christina aguilera and the backstreet boys? no way.
  • tara18
    i hope they dont screw this movie up i just have a feeling its goin to be nothin like the book they need to put some good music on the soundtrack just like twilights i love every song on that cd
  • F_Fanpire
    I like the song and it goes well with the plot but I don't see how they could fit it into the film.
  • TwilightRox
    The lyrics are great, although a bit obvious maybe. =) But I agree with alot of what has been said, another form of arrangement and the song would be really good.
    Don't you guys think ROB would make it really great, he can take any song and make it his own with a very passionate feel to it, I think he would make this one sound GREAT!! =)
  • kathleeen
    YEAHH!!! its coming from Edwards point of view aswell! but the lyrics are a bit obvious...
  • LadyLautner
    yeah seriously, Angel by Within Temptation, i think personally, is the perfect song u should hear it if u haven't
  • Angie_P
    I think change is good. We cant have the same stuff as in the other movie. But we need ultimate depressive music.... The song sorta fits if we have a shot of ec pining over Bella... but thats it.... and I agree it's too mainstream. I think Kelly and this dude need to be far away from this movie.... at thispoint lets just have zac effrom make a song for it. UGH.
  • lena
    happy brithday rob!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1
  • Erica22
    I think it sounds ok, the lyrics match... but idk...
  • Avital
    I thought it was pretty beautiful!
  • combat
    No,No,No and once again NO! Too literal and that is bad.
    Do you realy wanna make out of this movie High New Moon Musical?
    Keep it out of the mainstream.

    But I agree this song is about pain. It hurts to hear it.
  • Immorta1
    Noooooooo, not Justin! Why not Adam Lambert?? Or better yet, outside American Idol, some Tool or A Perfect Circle.
  • Holly Jo
    Boy are you guys hard to please or what!

    I personally like the song and like his voice and will trust the powers that be on their decision whether or not to put it on the soundtrack. Just like I trusted when they changed directors, recast Sam, and were considering recasting Jacob.
    It will all work out!
  • Elodie
    Well, that's sounds pretty good to me...

    Some of you seam to think that it sounds quite too romantic...

    but I don't think it sounds more "romantic" than the Linkin'park song from Twilight...

    The lyrics seam to fit too, I like the voice which is one of a kind...

    (I actually don't really apreciate too much the linking park song...hey...I said not really, I didn't say that I do not like it at all ^^)

    Actually, the super massive black hole one is quite MAgic! And this is definetly my favorite one, and I think that after this, It is hard to find better... ^^
  • Elodie
    And please excuse my English, I am just French ^o^
  • Sus
    No, No, No!!! There's so much out there that's better than this CRAP!
    HAPPY 23rd BIRTHDAY, ROB ;-)
  • jaspers(dont F.. my avi) girl
    this song trys too hard!! it sounds cheesy. I'll just love if we can stick to some of the songs that SM listened as a soundtrack to this book, and def. some Muse is a "most-Be" on the movie, like she said,thay inspired this saga.
  • good grief I hope it's not included. So not right for new moon. Please, please please nothing commercial
  • Kathy
    if he gets on the soundtrack and not Kelly Clarkson thats a lot of crap.
  • ♥RobstenIn<32010::76♥
    not good enough..
  • gamybla
    please NO!!
  • anen
    I'm not dissing him or anything he has a great voice and all but It sounds to poppy & oh I don't know mainstream sounding for New Moon besides I think the lyrics are too simple for my taste I like more underground Indie music like Circa Survive or something like that idk
  • lilliian
    He does have a great voice, but it wouldnt fit in with New Moon....I really think the song Starlight by Muse should be on the soundtrack
  • yana
    i hope that they won't take this song into the soundtruck!
    maybe it's going to sound weird but, it's just that there is too much of the book inside the lyrics (all the quotes...) and it makes it sound not right for the movie...
    i just get the feeling that he tried so hard to make it right and it eventually ended up all wrong...
    and aside of that it doesn't fit into the atmosphere of the first soundtruck...
    but it's just my opinion...
    (i'm sorry about my english i hope that you can understand what i say/mean...)
  • me
    What the hell first the Jonas brothers and now him.. NO!!!!!!!

    They nees to stay with the kind of music they had on Twilight.

    More Paramore for sure
    Robert has to do a song and the song NEED by Hana Pestle
  • Tams
    yeah...justin guarini...no matter how hard he tries he is always gonna be categorized into the American Idol/Pop culture section. The song is good, dont get me wrong, but it isn't "Twilight" material. Definitely stick with the Muse, Jack's Mannequin, and Linkin' Park style of music...that is what makes Twilight, bc the music is different and dark and deep. Justin Guarini is not dark and deep. by any means....
  • JustMija
    OK I'm going to have to agree with thos who have said NO!
    There is something about this song that just doesn't fit seriously
    I have never liked his voice probably never will. I LOVED everything about the
    Twilight soundtrack. Paramore, Linkin Parkin, Muse.

    Give this song to Paramore, let them work out the kinks with the lyrics. old different feel of music. Hana song "NEED" is perfect for New Moon soundtrack!
  • RtP(*.*)ciel
    I haven't heard yet but it's probably like Kelly Clarkson's "leaked new moon song" it's too POP (i love POP) I think they should stick to same theme as Twilight. I'm so obsessed with Iron&Wine now, ooh why not have Rob do the whole soundtrack that will be awesome, no arguments there.

    *everyone just wants a piece of twilight publicity I think. Like did he just came out of a cave all of sudden "hey I m a Twilight Fan I have a song" Whoopiee ("~")
  • Kimoppi
    I didn't hear anything about a Kelly Clarkson "leaked New Moon song." Where's that? Kelly Clarkson is capable of a song that might fit the movie.

    I loved that Hayley from Paramore wrote a song for Twilight because she was a fan of the books before it had become the crazy phenom it has turned into. But NOW, it really does feel like everyone is just trying to milk the Twilight cash cow.
  • RtP("~")
    I saw it last week...umm i think it's here in the old entries...i like kellyC. just don't think the song goes with NewMoon.
  • ZTATwilighter
    Idont know if its just me, but i actually like that song a lot.
  • em
    dont get me wrong, its a nice song and all, but i dont think it has that new moon vibe. but thats just my opinion... anyone else agree with me???
  • LiL LeeLu
    totally agree... good song i like it, but i just dont see it flowing with new moon
  • Nat_Cullen
    Totally agree! NW Soundtrack has to be much darker and painful... It's not one of these other lovestories... It definetly has to be more emotional, soulful...
  • LadyLautner
    then u should listen to Angel by Within Temptation, the perfect song, lol, is has a dark, romanctic, emo, punk twist going on LISTEN TO IT, i <3 the song
  • Nat_Cullen
    Wow, great song!!! Thanks :-)
  • LadyLautner
    i wish they could put the song on the soundtrack, i think its absolutely beautiful
  • ROB'S MA KINDA MAN!
    i love the lyrics
  • Kim1524 (Fanfic Junkie)
    I think muse is pretty much a given, blackout by them i think would work really well, closer by kings of leon is also not bad, and i know a lot of people like need by hana pestle but i think this one is also really good its called breath me by sia http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1wPo993nWGw
  • Nat_Cullen
    Oh, "Closer" from the Kings of Leon indeed sounds really great!
  • Orla
    I don't think this is for New Moon.
    I thought the Twilight soundtrack was a good mix of more well known bands (Muse Paramore, Linkin Park etc.) and the ones I just discovered through it (esp. Mutemath.)
    As for suggestions I like "Like a Song" by Lenka. The lyrics and music are really simple but there's something about it that's just very haunting and relevant to New Moon , in my opinion.
  • joy
    so like I don't even care about the song I was totally stoked to see that they put clips of new moon on there yeh.
  • i got freakin goosebumbs by the song...... well its perfect for new moon :)
  • TwiMomma
    I think that for the most part the people are speaking out AGAINST THE MERE THOUGHT OF JUSTIN ON ANY OF THE SOUNDTRACKS! Let it go Justin, let it go!
  • Mandelyn
    I like the song the words fit the movie I also think they should put the song So long, Goodbye from 10 years in the movie the words are beautiful for when Edward leaves or maybe in Eclipse when Bella tells Jacob she chooses Edward!
  • ardnaxela
    NO. NO. NO.
    what's with all of the Bubble Gum Pop trying to invade on the franchise?
    New Moon isn't a Hannah Montana spin off.
    Disney Stars....BUTT OUT!
  • crj
    Jackson Rathbone was a Disney 411 reporter....
  • kii05
    I'm sorry but the Justin Guarini dosn't seem to be the right fite .... its very Pop like kind of music.. the sound track for twilight last year really rocked and i loved all the songs
  • Whoa!! Was this song so made for new moon or what?! I love the lyrics.. It fits.. But it is not super massive black whole! :)
  • MelissaIsATwilightLover
    I disagree....
  • LadyLautner
    idk if some of you will agree with me, so don't eat me alive, but i think Broken Man by Boys Like Girls, is perfect for new, it fits the way Jacob feels toward Bella and wishes she would get over Edward
  • Nataniasmom
    I haven't read any of the comments so I do not know everyones opinion.

    I hate American Idol.

    I was not going to listen to this at all, but decided to set aside judgment until I heard it.

    I think there were some lyrics that went well with the idea of Edward and Bella and their relationship. I think that the end of the song was WAY too repetitive. I get the point "you can't live" lol.
    All in all not a terrible song, but not right for the Twilight saga, just my two cents.
  • twifan89
    i have to admit that SOME good has come of that show, but justin guarini is not it. he's trying wayyyy to hard to be on the soundtrack. i thought paramore did an excellent job with their track.
    i mean people that have come out of american idol usually aren't who i like but carrie underwood, josh gracin, and daughtry are good in my opinion.
  • Nataniasmom
    My issue with American Idol is that JUST about anyone can sing with the right training, play an instrument that takes talent, even lessons can't teach an uncoordinated person to do that.

    I am not saying that some of the people on there are not good singers, but that is the ONLY thing that SOME of them can do.

    I also don't like that they do not sing their own music, I hate that even once they break away from American Idol they still have song writers, it makes the music less convincing and less personable.

    But as I said, not all of them are like that, I also do not like the style of most of the music, can't handle country or pop or folk or any of that.

    But again, that is just my opinion, to each their own :)
  • 30yearoldtwifan ♥Team Nessie♥
    I agree, Im also more of a rock girl or alternative rock but im a 90s girl so im definalty not into the pop..country stuff. I say a BIG no to this song on the new moon soundtrack.
  • tara18
    im goin to try to put a poll up but i dont know if it will work here let me try


    <div id="qp_main5574" style="border:1px solid black;margin:10px;padding:10px;padding-bottom:12px;background-color:rgb(141,44,114)"><div style="font-family:Arial;font-size:12px;font-weight:bold;background-color:rgb(90,18,63);width:100%;color:white"><div style="padding:10px">do you think this song is good for new moon </div></div><form id="qp_form5574" action="http://poll.learnmyself.com/results5574x52EA4cC9" method="post" target="_blank" style="padding:0px;margin-top:10px"><div style="width:100%"><div style="display:block;font-family:Arial;font-size:12px;color:white;padding-top:5px;padding-bottom:5px;clear:both;width:100%"><input style="float:left;width:25px;margin-left:-25px;margin-top:-1px;padding:0px;height:18px" name="qp_v5574" type="radio" value="1">Yes</div><div style="display:block;font-family:Arial;font-size:12px;color:white;padding-top:5px;padding-bottom:5px;clear:both;width:100%"><input style="float:left;width:25px;margin-left:-25px;margin-top:-1px;padding:0px;height:18px" name="qp_v5574" type="radio" value="2">No</div></div><div style="padding-top:10px;clear:both"><input name="qp_b5574" style="width:80px;margin-right:5px" type="submit" value="Vote"><input name="qp_b5574" style="width:80px;margin-right:5px" type="submit" value="Results"></div>ugg boots</form></div><script src="http://scripts.learnmyself.com/3001/scpolls.js" language="javascript"></script>
  • MelissaIsATwilightLover
    Ha, Ha, Ha! You really tried to do that. It's blocked. You're supposed to put a link.
  • tara18
    ya lol i just figured that out
  • LadyLautner
    OMFG AND ANGEL BY Within Temptation, i hope people are reading my comment so u can back me up with this, but Angel is THEE perfect song, i hope a whole bunch of people are reading what i'm saying and listen to the song, lmao
  • Breazee
    Ok, so I just looked it up an listened to it. Yes, a very good song for the movie. Memories & What have you done wouldn't be bad either. I think What have you done would be good in a few parts of the movie.

    The Howling would be good for a couple of the movies. In New Moon it would be pretty good in the part where he's about to step out of the tunnel.
  • Becca
    1) I feel like i'm in 1991 when I listened to that. Wow.
    2) If this makes the cut, it will be reason enough for me NOT to buy the NM soundtrack. I had to turn it off midway. Just....not original. "If I can't touch you with my finger tips..." as opposed to what? The back of your hand??
  • MelissaIsATwilightLover
    Ha, you just made me think of this awesome band, guess what it's called? 1997. Yeah, they are amazing. They should be on it!
  • I was thinking something like Evanescence
    Not necessarily Evanescence but like that deep sort of dark but still powerful sound.
    Also love "This is For Keeps" by The Spill Canvas.
    It fits really well and its a good song.
  • Tiffanyt
    yes i think it is perfect!!! it really feels as if "Edward" wrote the song about walking away from "Bella" and then finding out about her jumping off the cliff.
  • Mrs. Robsessed
    all i have to say is bring on more Pattz on the soundtrack......don't bring these pop sensations on that get a ton of radio play.
    On a side note, i wish they would use Wild Horses by the Sundays for when they are reunited..maybe when they are flying/driving back. it'ssuch a beautiful song and if u listen to the lyrics is perfect for Bedward!! I know it's on Itunes but it's probably on you tube too.
  • Team Alice
    Does anyone think that this song might be a little too blatantly obvious for New Moon? I think the lyrics are so "out-of-the-book" that it actually gives a sense of overkill. I'd much rather hear something with lyrics that are more deep and less obvious. And I agree with what everyone has been saying about Supermassive Black Hole. They aren't gonna top that song in the Twilight Saga. This poppy Idol song isn't gonna cut it.
  • twihard17
    i think that the lyrics fit in the movie welll but the tone of the song just is not right....its kinda like a sad song but in a pop/rocky way and that just doesnt do it for me
  • andreea
    Well...no, it sounds like a Mariah Carey song, and in the worst way possible. Can't liiive, can't live without you...I think we heard that before, loads of time. So...I was thinking of more of Muse. I think

    Hoodoo
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HmV1dbg4LpU

    Endlessly
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BBo_hePniW8

    And for the jumping scene I always thought Apocalypse Please was perfect, because it really catches the chaos in Bella's head.
    Apocalypse Please
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ofivZ0p-XLg

    I think we need more powerful songs rather than whiny ones. Aaaan i really love Closer by Kings of Leon
  • klynn
    This song sucks. And Justin Guarini sucks, too. Perhaps it should be a clue why he didn't amount to anything after American Idol!
  • Pita
    iron and Wine and i'm sorry but i don't think Justin Guarini should be in NEw MOon i don't think it fits the story. Remember New MOon is depressing and sad and thei is some excitement but not as much.
  • Kimoppi
    Don't be too hasty... If you noticed about the Twilight Soundtrack, not all the songs were about love. Hell, some of them had NOTHING to do with the story, but they contributed to the mood of the story musically.

    And New Moon isn't all depressing and sad. In the middle of it all Bella and Jacob fall in love. So there's lost love, new love, there's the joy of the Wolf Pack when they're running, and the majesty of the Volturi, and the excitement/urgency/fear/hope of Bella's run across the Piazza. I have my mental playlist while reading New Moon, and very little of it is actually sad and depressing because there's much more than that.
  • twilightaholic4life
    I didn't think I would but I actually enjoyed that!
  • jennifer
    I like it:) I like it, ALOT.
  • Elazar
    Some parts are very good an dthe tune gives me a Paramore type feel I also think he has some Kings Of Leon type of voice at some parts and some other parts are really good but Need by Hana Pestle is awesome oh and what about The Wind Blows by The All American Rejects and Imoghen Heap Come Here Boy and Chasing Cars maybe I unno how about some song by The Fray or better yet some song by Placebo gets top precidence this time.................. she only like mentioned it once in her books (I think) like wtf................................
  • jenn
    I love "Sleeping Sickness" by City and Colour, it's a beautiful song, very emotional. I think it would be perfect for Bella after Edward leaves.
  • mollie75m
    Justin's song sucks. Way too mainstream and GENERIC!!!! This has no place in any of the twilight movies. They beauty of the first soundtrack was that there were a lot of unknown artists.
  • hell yah
    I like it it is one of the type of song that can get suck in your head.
  • morgannnn
    Definitely not crazy about this song...
    Evanescence would be great for New Moon! Especially "My Immortal"

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=idd_92ajjwY
  • Dawn
    In the end it is up the the studio and the execs to decide who will be on the soundtrack.

    But if people want indie and non mainstream then why suggest Coldplay, All-American Rejects, Evanesence, Flyleaf, Disturbed, they are mainstream at least where I am from in the northeast. And Linkin Park was on the first soundtrack as well. They have been mainstream for years.

    Just my opinion, but let the studio decide what they think is best for the soundtrack they didn’t disappoint us the last time did they?
  • i guess its ok..... i kinda like it........

    ohh i really like this song for new moon.....
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=idd_92ajjwY
    wish it could be in new moon.
  • omg i love that song too its soo good lol my immortal is the best :D
  • yesssssss it is......... wish it could be in new moon....... but they havent said n e thing by now..... so i doubt it....... no matter what they choose i know its gonna be good cause i really liked all the soundtrack 4rm twilight...... my ultimate fav is BELLAS LULLIBY..... even though they didnt use the version Robbiekins wrote...AWW........ ohhh now that i said bellas lulliby i remembered...... my cuz is gonna use that song 4 the waltz at her party....... i like that idea.......
    jejejeje i always write MORE than is necessary..... im pretty chatty
  • i dont really like this song but thats my opion :D
  • khutch
    i really dislike this song. i agree with several of you in that justin guarini (as well as the jonas brothers) are just trying to get in on the franchise which = not cool in any way, shape or form.

    my boyfriend was having me listen to this knoxville, tn band the other day called "10 Years" and one of the songs, "Dying Youth" reminded me a bit of new moon during bella's edwardlessness. i'm not sure it's appropriate for the film, but i do think it's a good song. here's a link!

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vloNSv6KPAw
  • ashley
    i liked the song but i dont think that it fits the whole new moon vibe . . . like people said he just wants it for fame . . . and the jonas brothers trying to get on the new moon soundtrack is just a pure nightmare . . . i hope paramore can write a song for the new moon soundtrack and all 2 come!!!!!
  • i_love_vampovles
    i really think its okay but not that new moony
  • Mrs.EmmettCullen
    I think he should make a song for new moon! better than having the Jonas Brothers!
  • alison
    I actually like it but not sure if it will fit the movie. I have always liked him.
    I know My Immortal by Evanescence has been in other films but the lyrics are PERFECT for new moom ex.," you voice it chased away the sanity in me."
    I really hope that makes it somewhere. Even their song "Bring me to life".
    ANd I do hope another Linkin Park song maks it!!!
  • ohmy_feathers ♥ [since 03/09]
    I LOVE LOVE LOVE EVANESCENCE!!! It would be so awesome if they made the soundtrack! I love Amy Lee's tortured, beautiful, opera like voice, it is absolutely perfect! And it would work so well with a depressed Bella scene!
  • http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X8D08cDZEJs

    LOVE this song. Wish it was in one of the films.
  • Danielle
    PARAMORE AND MUSE NEEDS TO BE IN THE NEXT ALBUM

    Our time is running out by muse fits good when bella is searching for edward
  • TaylaaLautner
    its an awesome song .. :)

    buut they should put this song thow :

    Audio slave - i am the highway
  • CougarforRob
    The lyrics are perfect (IMO) for the movie. Just watching the scenes while listening just made me want more Rob.
  • RtP("~")
    ooowww...another thought....why don't they colaborate ROB and JACKSON R. or better yet since they are all musically talented why don't they just do a song together that will be so cool, imagine Kris and Rob singing together (giggles) and then after that they could do a concert together, watch it be sold out in 0 seconds.... LOL
  • Kimoppi
    What did Jackson call it?

    The Cullen Family Band
  • Treasure_7
    I totally love Super Massive Blackhole, and think that Muse is an awesome group. I really didn't ever listen to them before there was no distraction about who the group was and total focus was on Twilight. I really think that they need to do that with New Moon too. Only they know what sound will be perfect for New Moon. I am confident that they are going to pick something awesome.
  • I love it.
    :)
  • cutesweetiezzz
    I love it! I think the lyrics are perfect for New Moon. I think this song works for both Edward and Jacob, but slightly more Edward.
  • Valerie
    I think its perfect
  • MissLautner
    From this year american idol? i dont remember him. lol i forget like everyone except the winner tho.
  • ohmy_feathers ♥ [since 03/09]
    Wasn't he in the first season up against Kelly Clarkson?
  • bianca
    yea i thynk this is a good song 4 the part wen bella is trying 2 find edward in the woods *sniff sniff* so sad...but this song would go great with that scene
  • iloverobpattz
    no no no no no no no no no no no. this song is horrible. sorry.
    almost lover by fine frenzy is amazing or need by hana pestle either one would be perfect!
  • christy
    I think the ONLY mood/scene/whatever this would fit with in New Moon is possibly background music while showing Edward making his decision to go to the Volturi after he hears the false news about Bella. But since New Moon is SUPPOSED to be seen from Bella's point of view, I don't know that that kind of scene would be in the movie. Obviously this song would only fit to describe the feeling of being ready to commit suicide because the object of the person's affection is no longer in existence. For this reason alone, this song should NOT be used to show Bella's reaction, besides the fact that music outlining Bella's thoughts should be more depressive. That's her mind set. This music has kind of a motivating/driving-one-to-do-something feeling to it. It should only be used in a scene with just Edward, if at all.
  • YouAreMyLifeNow
    chatting tonight in the New Moon Chataholics room at http://www.chatzy.com/666105271665 around 8:00est
  • TeamJB
    Yea i dont think this will fit the movie...I love until tomorrow by Paramore it fits so perfect... and i know it will make me cry if they played it after the break up.
  • Tia_jb10 (Team Pants Explode!)
    i just looked at the lyrics and omg they are the perfect lyrics ever the even have like quotes from the book in there i can see why they would concider it and they should put it in there also "need" by Hana Pestle should be in there i love that song=)))
  • keekster08
    the lyrics were pretty good, but i just didn't like it. his voice....its just not a good fit for the type of atmosphere i envisioned. especially with all those amazing fan made trailers out there. this just doesn't live up to my expectations. he seems like a nice guy, just not right for this soundtrack.
  • keekster08
    it seems like he is just trying to get on this soundtrack to get another 15 minutes of fame. sorry, but he is definitely no daughtry.
  • Jessica
    I really like this song...it goes really well with the whole New Moon theme... I really also like Kelly Clarkson song "Did You". It really good as well...
  • ok i like the lyrics to the song but not the melody i think if he wants it in the scene were Edward tells bella that their leaving he would have to make it more calming because that scene will be an intense part in the movie so you would want to focous more on what Edward and Bella are saying thatn the song.

    OH AND CHECK OUT MY WEBSITE IT IS

    www.t-w-i-l-i-h-t.weebly.com and you can send my an email and blog on my blog section! please visit and email me on how i could improve it!!!
  • sarah.
    i don't want no stupid teenie pop crap on this soundtrack at all! muse was perfect and some of the artists were great. jonas and everybody else needs to back out from this situation, please and thank you! :)
  • Me
    The Spill Canvas has some good songs that would be perfect.

    If they add people like him and the Jonas Brothers on the soundtrack it will suck and I wont buy it.

    I really hope Rob wright's another song for New Moon!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • vampyrgrl
    This song sounds like he tried to write it for the movie, but it just doesn't sound right. I guess the lyrics are ok, but it I think he was trying too hard to make it fit the movie and to have a sound that doesn't fit his style.........sorry Justin, but I DON'T THINK SO!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • punker
    I think their should be LOADS of paramore!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!. like od paramore cause paramore ROCKS and none of this weird music. ^_^
  • ohmy_feathers ♥ [since 03/09]
    Hmm not so enthusiastic about this one... I don't really like his vocals for that type of music, it doesn't fit the rock sound... I like the lyrics and the song and although I think his voice is good I just don't think it meshes very well all together...
  • SoundTrack
    the soundtrack for twilight was AWESOME! New moon has something to top! please choose songs similar to the sound of the first... Nothing against Justin... the song is good and all but its not very new moon material... more iron and wine, paramore and muse would be awesome! something not so "teeney"... please!
  • ohmy_feathers ♥ [since 03/09]
    Evanescence- Good Enough.... That is a great Bella song! I wish I could be a music supervisor (the person that gets to pick music for movies)! Ugh how would I even start? I have a freakin Bachelor's of Music Marketing! :( bet no one can guess what job I have instead of my dream job...
  • Regina
    I think that song is amazing and totally fits the movie!!
  • Kimoppi
    I'm probably gonna get flogged for this:

    But I don't think there should be any Muse, Linkin Park, or Paramore on the New Moon soundtrack. I don't want to repeat 25% of the Twilight soundtrack. I want something completely new. New bands. New mood.

    No matter what, I think JG's song is pooptastic. Two thumbs WAY down!
  • iloveedwardcullen
    lyrics- YESSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    music- noo.

    the lyrics are so perfect and beautiful, but idt the pop-ish thing will work for the movie, another version of the song to fit the tone would be amazing!!
  • DELENA
    I THINK THIS SONG FITS PERFECTLY RIGHT IN BETWEEN THE TIME WHERE THEY FIND BELLA IN THE WOODS IT FITS EXACTLY HOW SHE FEELS IN THE BOOK AND HOPEFULLY HOW IT WILL BE ON THE BIG SCREEN.................I SAY YES................BUT THIS IS ONLY MY OPINION
  • amanda d
    I know a lot of fans want non mainstream artists but I think Incomplete by the Backstreet Boys is perfect for New Moon

    "I tried to go on like I never knew you
    I’m awake but my world is half asleep
    I pray for this heart to be unbroken
    But without you all I’m going to be is incomplete"

    and the piano score is so beautiful
  • Roxie
    I was introduced to Matthew Mayfield by a friken awesome FF. He not only fit her story so well, this song - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YOgNwT8dNes - but I can imagine it being at the end of when they are finally back and she thinks she is still dreaming.
  • icefire
    SM gave us a playlist for all her books the only thing that Summit has to do is stay along those lines like they did for twilight they don't have to be big names just great songs. My favorite c.d. right now is Secondhand Serenade A Twist In My Story I really think he would be able to right and sing a wonderful song for the movie also I am an Idol fan and think Adam L has the look and with the right song can sing the hale out of an emotional song for the breakup of even when the reunite.
  • Breazee
    You're right about the band, actually the song 'Like a Knife' would be great; also, 'why', 'Maybe', 'Suppose', 'Pretend' could work as well.

    BTW.... totally right about Adam L.. :)
  • n
    it's like this song has been taken from the book... he was not creative enough. It was too matchy and it should not be.
  • Breazee
    I haven't decided what I think. I keep going back & forth. I agree with others that it does seem way too literal. It's like it could of worked, but then it just went too far. Like cheap imatation. I mean it isn't hard to pick words out of the book and put them into lyrics. The sound, well ... it don't know...maybe. It might just work if we gave the song to a heavy band or melodic band and they changed it up.

    I wish we could make the sound track..... us fans know what we want & the way we feel. lol As I said on the Soundtrack page, I think 'The Dreaming' a band out of LA would be really good, they have some very fitting songs. There's been a few really good suggestions from us fans..... just wonder if anyone is paying attention... ya know.

    The Dreaming songs & lyrics

    http://new.music.yahoo.com/dreaming/albums/etch...

    http://lyricwiki.org/The_Dreaming
  • Team_Switz
    If Paramore is guna be on the soundtrack again, they should use their swim in silence demo. It goes perfect with Bella jumping off the cliff.
  • Breazee
    I agree
  • Mindy
    LOL I have decided that some of you fans should pick the songs for the sound track of new moon. I haven't heard of some of these people and I have been listening to them... and I have found some of the most amazing singers I have never heard.

    The Justin song is beautiful... maybe if it was wrote differently or sung slower with a different song... an eerie sound then yeah it would probably be perfect. So love the Song Need by Hana Pestle....
  • Breazee
    Thats what I was just saying about us doing soundtrack. I've also been going through here and listening to some of the ones listed. Pretty good bands & songs I've never heard of. There's alot of good choices. Btw, Need is good.... had it on my playlist for a few weeks. :)
  • Allytwi
    I personally love Almost Loever - A Fine Frenzy
    picture myself when Bella was struggle with her life after Edwrd left her
    esp the chorus : -

    I cannot go to the ocean
    I cannot try the streets at night
    I cannot wake up in the morning
    Without you on my mind

    it just make me chocked... seriously, i hope all of you can go and check it out at youtube..
  • FLIP
    If this song that doesnt make it into the New Moon sound track, then I think that someone needs to get their head examined. This song pretty much sums up Edward and Bella to a tee. It is a perfect fit!!!!
  • Kimoppi
    I can't fall asleep, so I'm gonna mention another song for people.

    I ALWAYS hear "Strange Boy" by Kerli in my head when I read about the wolves running. It's another one of those things I can't really explain. The intro makes me want to drive fast (since I can't run). I guess that helps explain it a bit.

    Anyhoo... she has some really great music. Check her out.
  • Anna
    I agree with Bellavita and the other smart people above, let me quote: PLEASE DON'T RUIN NEW MOON WITH GENERIC BORING MAINSTREAM TEEN POP MUSIC!

    I loved Twilight because it delivered great music from relatively unknown bands who got their chance to shine. I want more of that (and ofcourse, some new songs from Rob would be awesome). I mean, it's a good song but it's way to much alike so many others. It takes something extra to bring the feelings to the table in New moon, it contains alot of strong scenes and therefore it should contain strong music.
  • iloveedward
    its good :) thee film clip is alright but whats with the start?
    hp and the uninvited? lol
  • Shae-lyn
    I think there should defiantly be more songs by Robert Pattinson on it, but this song could work, maybe when he leaves her by the forest and she tries to follow him, no this should go when she jumps off the cliff, but I don't know, i just want more of Rob's songs!
  • susieast
    Oh yeah baby! I say YES YES YES!! I can already see it! They would be out of their minds to not add it! :)
  • MidnightSun
    I really like it! Thumbs up Justin!
  • 30yearoldtwifan ♥Team Nessie♥
  • beth
    i personally think this song is crap, his voice doesnt go with the music and it will taint the film!!!! But the pick for twilight was awesome an amazing soundtrack so i guess they no best.
  • linasavaye
    I think the song fits and it shouldn't matter who it's by. SO he was on AMerican Idol. Oh well. He may not have liked it but I'm sure if music was all you wanted to do you would take any chance you could get just to get yourself out there.
  • RobismyRomeo (RIMR_)
    hmm.. what about Katy Perry's "thinking of you". check out the lyrics, i don't know if it should be on the soundtrack or anything, but it definitely reminds me of new moon! Bella with Jacob, but missing Edward...
  • Angie
    the song sounds good, i mean it goes with the movie but its not the best...new moon needs to be perfect, almost as perfect as the incredible books
  • Mimi
    I do like the song, however I am not sure if it would fit in with the feel of Twilight. I could see it being in the movie, but I am sure many people think it wouldn't fit in
  • sandralynn
    THE SPILL CANVAS WOULD BE PERFECT!!
    they're sound and the mood of alot of their songs would be perfect.
    seriously people, give them a listen. they are my favorite band
    "this is for keeps" is about vampires, but idk if that song would fit this part of the story
  • crj
    I closed my eyes when i played the vid and just listened to the song, I picture this as the break up scene song if it's chosen. This artist isn't "teeny bobish" like I saw someone post, and heck if it wasn't mentioned that he was an Idol, I wouldn't of know who he was from Adam. If anyone is looking for some "unknown's" so to speak ROMAN HOLIDAY is up and coming www.myspace.com/romanholidaytheband. They are from Puyallup, WA and you'll be hearing of them soon!!
  • n/a
    i like the lyrics...
  • TARA
    RAY LAMONTAGNE'S SONG BURN WOULD BE PERFECT FOR NEW MOON AS WELL. IT FITS MORE TOWARDS THE END WHEN JACOB KISSES BELLA AND TELLS EDWARD ABOUT THE FUNERAL. HERE ARE THE LYRICS.
    Oh mama don't walk away
    I'm a goddamn sore loser
    I ain't too proud to say
    That I'm still thinking 'bout you
    And I'm so lonesome without you
    And I can't get you out of my mind

    Oh mama don't leave me alone
    With my soul shut down so tight
    Just like a stone cold tomb
    Ain't it clear when I'm near you
    I'm just dying to hear you
    Calling my name one more time

    Oh so don't pay no mind
    To my watering eyes
    Must be something in the air
    That I'm breathing
    Yes and try to ignore
    All this blood on the floor
    It's just this heart on my sleeve that's bleeding

    Oh mama don't walk away
    You leave me here bereaving
    From the words so hard and plain
    Saying the love that we had
    Was just selfish and sad
    Yes but to see you now with him
    Is just making me mad
    Oh so kiss him again
    Just to prove to me that you can
    I will stand here
    And burn in my skin
    Yes I will stand here
    And burn in my skin
  • Brooke
    Jacob doesn't kiss Bella until Eclipse.
  • Brooke
    At first, I had my doubts about the song. But then I continued to listen to the song and I started to get the chills; before I knew it, I reached up and touched something wet -- I was crying! I think it's definitely good for New Moon. I DO totally agree though; they shouldn't have crap like:
    Madonna, Jonas Brothers, Demi Lovato and
    all that crap on the soundtrack. It should be raw, emotional, songs and artists that
    aren't really known.

    I just hope that they don't get lame Disney groups and people on the
    soundtrack.



    (Oh and a plus is that Paramore is going to be on EVERY movie soundtrack; AMAZING!)
  • Brooke
    I think Meg & Dia are PERFECT for New Moon!

    And it definitely fits the twilight vibe-music.
    If that's what they want for New Moon, also.

    They have a very pure, raw, down-to-the-core
    sound.

    And it's all sincere and real; they write about books
    they read and on their newest album, Here Here and Here,
    they wrote about their lives. I absolutely adore them and
    their music.


    I suggest Inside my Head; and basically the whole album, haha.
    Well most of it anyway.

    check it out:

    http://www.myspace.com/megdia
  • jacob lover
    i think the words definetly match the movie, but the tune, the arrangement, and even the artist just don't feel like "New Moon" material to me. I think there should be more slow songs on the new moon soundtrack, beacause that's what new moon is; slow and sad. Bella thinks of the time period of new moon as her "dark days", the worst of her life. the soundtrack should reflect the mood of the movie, because music is a big part of the emotion behind the movie; it's what helps you feel the way the director wants you to feael in certain parts of the movie. so anyways, i think that the words are a perfect match, but that's only a little part of the song. For this particular movie, i don't think this song is the right one.
  • Miss Vicious
    I honestly really liked the song and I wouldn't be the slightest bit upset if it ended up on the soundtrack. Supermassive black hole was ok... Don't get me wrong I like Muse and have long before Stephanie Meyers was introducing to main stream teenie bopper america. I think ANYONE who makes a good song that can capture some of the emotion that I felt while reading these books, should get a chance.
  • Tamara
    the drum machine sounds like 15 step Radiohead i think Mazzy Stars music would be great for New Moon soundtrack look up Mazzy Star like 'Fade Into You'
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XucegAHZojc
  • Tamara
    Check out her related music like "Happy"
  • TheBlondeAmbition
    ive jus listened to RED and pieces its amazing... tho i love justins song 2.... i cant wait 2 c what appears in New Moon...
  • Elazar
    This song is amazing buzz off you complainers I know who this guy is know the one from Justin to kelly right? Well its eems he isn't bad and I liek it even if it is repetitive.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Ivonnnegreen
    Well, I liked it, I don't love it... but it's Ok. And I liked the video too, it's good
  • meline
    Come on guys!
    This song is just perfect for New Moon... I even can imagine Bella standing without the air in her lungs and the song playing..
  • team_switz92
    wow this song totally fits with the movie...its pretty much tells the whole story :)))
  • EdwardsLullaby
    I really dont want that song in New Moon its just...it's like, too much almost.
    I personally would love Hate Me by Blue October and Smother Me by The Used, I think those are much better choices and should definitely be considered for the soundtrack! :]
  • yadayada
    Chase to save edward in volterra, nice fit.
  • clair mone
    i like that idea of not having MAINSTREAM TEENY BOP on the sound track. i listened to that Mazzy Star and thats real cool. thanks.
  • Native~Bella
    WOW! HELL NO to this song, it sucks. I couldn't get past 1:07. He's trying WAY to hard on this song. I really hope their not actually thinking to add this to the sound track.
  • charlotte
    WOW!!!!


    i think that the song seriously should go on the new moon soundtrack or one of the other books movies


    i swear he would be the perfect guy :D
  • Can be, but "We are broken ( Paramore ) and Broken ( Amy Lee) it's better
  • Me
    I think the Beauty in the Beast by Gavin Rossdale would be a good song for the movie.

    Beauty in the Beast by Gavin Rossdale

    In the heart of the city,
    I’m awake now,
    the buzz open to the night.
    You’re the libertine.
    You’re philistine

    When I first saw you,
    I knew I was done.
    You are feel again,
    You. I arise
    feeling invincible, this moment’s mine.

    Strangers, landscapes,
    see the sky flip inside out,
    turning nightmares into dreams that bring you ‘round.
    There’s danger in the street,
    That’s the beauty in the beast.
    There’s danger in the street,
    That’s the beauty in the beast.

    In a blink of an eye,
    you seem to get me.
    You are my fox and I can’t see your eye
    I am the wheel,
    the knob of my heart,
    I know this road goes back to the star.

    you are feel again,
    you. I rise
    feeling invincible this moments mine.

    Strangers, landscapes,
    seeing the sky flip inside out,
    turning nightmares into dreams that bring you ‘round
    There’s danger in the street,
    That’s the beauty in the beast.
    There’s danger in the street,
    That’s the beauty in the beast.

    Your moon works when everyone’s asleep.
    sometimes what you want is just out of reach.

    Strangers, landscapes,
    seeing the sky flip inside out,
    turning nightmares into dreams that bring you ‘round
    There’s danger in the street,
    That’s the beauty in the beast.
    There’s danger in the street,
    That’s the beauty in the beast.

    strangers, landscapes,
    see the sky flip inside out
    how you make me turn around
    turning nightmares into dreams that bring you round
    theres danger in the street (x5)
    thats the beauty in the beast.
  • Me
    Beauty in the Beast by Gavin Rossdale

    In the heart of the city,
    I’m awake now,
    the buzz open to the night.
    You’re the libertine.
    You’re philistine

    When I first saw you,
    I knew I was done.
    You are feel again,
    You. I arise
    feeling invincible, this moment’s mine.

    Strangers, landscapes,
    see the sky flip inside out,
    turning nightmares into dreams that bring you ‘round.
    There’s danger in the street,
    That’s the beauty in the beast.
    There’s danger in the street,
    That’s the beauty in the beast.

    In a blink of an eye,
    you seem to get me.
    You are my fox and I can’t see your eye
    I am the wheel,
    the knob of my heart,
    I know this road goes back to the star.

    you are feel again,
    you. I rise
    feeling invincible this moments mine.

    Strangers, landscapes,
    seeing the sky flip inside out,
    turning nightmares into dreams that bring you ‘round
    There’s danger in the street,
    That’s the beauty in the beast.
    There’s danger in the street,
    That’s the beauty in the beast.

    Your moon works when everyone’s asleep.
    sometimes what you want is just out of reach.

    Strangers, landscapes,
    seeing the sky flip inside out,
    turning nightmares into dreams that bring you ‘round
    There’s danger in the street,
    That’s the beauty in the beast.
    There’s danger in the street,
    That’s the beauty in the beast.

    strangers, landscapes,
    see the sky flip inside out
    how you make me turn around
    turning nightmares into dreams that bring you round
    theres danger in the street (x5)
    thats the beauty in the beast
  • Me
    Beauty in the Beast by Gavin Rossdale

    In the heart of the city,
    I’m awake now,
    the buzz open to the night.
    You’re the libertine.
    You’re philistine

    When I first saw you,
    I knew I was done.
    You are feel again,
    You. I arise
    feeling invincible, this moment’s mine.

    Strangers, landscapes,
    see the sky flip inside out,
    turning nightmares into dreams that bring you ‘round.
    There’s danger in the street,
    That’s the beauty in the beast.
    There’s danger in the street,
    That’s the beauty in the beast.

    In a blink of an eye,
    you seem to get me.
    You are my fox and I can’t see your eye
    I am the wheel,
    the knob of my heart,
    I know this road goes back to the star.

    you are feel again,
    you. I rise
    feeling invincible this moments mine.

    Strangers, landscapes,
    seeing the sky flip inside out,
    turning nightmares into dreams that bring you ‘round
    There’s danger in the street,
    That’s the beauty in the beast.
    There’s danger in the street,
    That’s the beauty in the beast.

    Your moon works when everyone’s asleep.
    sometimes what you want is just out of reach.

    Strangers, landscapes,
    seeing the sky flip inside out,
    turning nightmares into dreams that bring you ‘round
    There’s danger in the street,
    That’s the beauty in the beast.
    There’s danger in the street,
    That’s the beauty in the beast.

    strangers, landscapes,
    see the sky flip inside out
    how you make me turn around
    turning nightmares into dreams that bring you round
    theres danger in the street (x5)
    thats the beauty in the beast
  • kelsey
    well, i hope thatthey put ths song in the soundtrack. it is sooooo like the movie. i love it!!!
  • justyouraveragegirl
    can you say HELL no!

    God, sure if you want this to be linked and in the same thought train as High School Musical or Glee.
  • amanda
    i enjoy the song the lyrics sound good for the movie but i think its too upbeat it should sound more sad and painful to help describe the way bella is feeling through most of the book
  • Did you listen the song "Bella" by Anek? We wrote it just for New Moon! It's on youtube, just search "anek bella" to find it. Then let us know what you think!
  • Jon
    I actually like this song. I think it would fit well with New Moon.
    But can anyone tell me what song is playing in the beginning of the video?
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: