*sigh* Much better! FIRST

My idea exactly...Bella needed to e in the middle...torn between Edward and Jacob!!

I dont like the layout of either personally bella shouldn't b holding on edward he's not there and she shouldn't b torn between jacob and edward bcuz that eclispe. This poster should b 4 eclispe bcuz it looks like Edward jus got back bella holding on 2 him cuz of the fear of him leaving again and Jacobs in the back looking mad cuz Edward came bac and bella went running bac 2 edward.

ssssoo true


mad az comment btw

way better!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

go kim!!!

well done you!!

And yes I think this is better...but think bella should be at the front

So much agree. Tell them that this should be how the poster looks. Maybe Edward should be looking away with his head down just a bit, considering that he isn't in the book as much and leaves her in the beginning. Show a little remorse.

Agree, Bella should be at the front. It's her struggle that is at the center of the NM after all

Agreed! Much better than the first!

hmmm yea i actually think its better!! lol good job anab :o)
Lizzie

no, the color is better, the moon should be a moon and not a sun and the original looked like it was an eclipse. but this revels the ending. both have stuff wrong.

Actually, I really liked the coloring of the first one a lot. In my opinion, she should have left that alone. It looks less realistic now.

I think so too. Because of the light I think it looks like a fan made poster (as it is....) Had she kept it how it was it would have been really great

Yeah gotta say i like this better :)

yeah I know at least it's BALANCED. The official one totally looks skewed n off balanced to me I dunno maybe because they are standing height wise or maybe it's just me starting to pick on the smallest details cuz It wasn't what I expected AT ALL

Now THIS is how the poster SHOULD look like!!! WTG Ana!

Your adaptation of the official poster does wonders, the positioning in the official one is completely wrong...Well done!

MUCH MUCH BETTER... Summit should have just paid one of the fans to make it.. they would probably do it for free just to get the credit... I always imagined bella would be between them.. what was summit thinking?!?!?

Def. a much better poster.. Summit should have had a fan do the poster.. they probably could have done a better job and for cheaper/free.... silly Summit.

Great work and this is more like it, lol.

Actually in thinking about the book .... The release is best. Jacob is constantly putting himself between Bella and Edward. And I have to say the coloring on the first makes it have more of a dark feel. Bella is in a very dark place for months.

The original is better off left alone. New Moon is about Edward not being there and Jacob filling the void. Instead of Jacob looking protective of Bella because of what Edward did to her, this one makes Jacob look like he's pissed at Bella, Bella looks like she's giving Jacob the cold shoulder, and Edward looks like he doesn't know why Bella is there. It's actually kinda funny

how is this better!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! i love it yes. but the officail better shows jacobs involvment in the story. if u look again, this version looks more like Eclipse with the way edward and bella r together and Jacob is upset about it!!!!! :)
anyway.....love it! :)

Although Edward is not physically present he is still a driving force throughout the book in how Bella conducts her life to cope with his absence and how its his disappearance that allows her friendship with Jacob to develop.

I feel that the original placements convey that better....Edward up front looking back at Bella, Jacob between them creating the triangle and being Bellas rock, with Bella leaning on him physically whilst looking around for the one she truly loves.

I think the above is more symbolic of Eclipse with Bella and Edward together as a couple and Jacob on the outside.

So true...

I couldn't agree with you more!

I agree with you. The original shows Jacob at a protective stance to shield Bella. I love the fists....

Yes....Jacobs in a fist always ready to fight for Bella against those who would hurt her physically and emotionally, Edwards looks like he is fighting hard not to stretch out for Bella reflecting his inner turmoil at doing the wrong thing for the right reason.

yes i like the original better as well...
and i also think this one represents mostly eclipse then new moon....
cuz i mean jacob was in the book a lot! not to b left behind...
hope you guys understood what i tried to say xD

I agree, I think the original conveys the story perfectly... Edward turned his back on Bella, Jacob was trying to take Edwards spot (see in the original how he's kinda standing in the middle, but it appears Bella is trying to push him to the side, as if to say friends stand beside you, etc) and protect Bella... Original is PERFECT!! Dont get me wrong, I'm on Team Edward, but really, New Moon explored the Jacob and Bella relationship more than Edward and Bella....

I don't know I think I like it the other way better.

i agree... jake protecting bella... thats the esence of the book...

Yeah I agree

i agree with you too... the other way is better... the story is mostly about jacob and bella and how he protects her and she is coming back to normal after the break up because of him...

like Irene said, its the essence of the book.

No honey the story is still about Edward and Bella, the motorcycle, the cliff diving, was so she could hear him and the reason she stayed in Forks, was because of Edward. Read it again. The essence of the story is that Bella and Edward can't live without each other.

Here, here Vapgirl! You are totally right, although Edward isn't around and Jacob is helplessly in love with Bella, she is completely oblivious to that fact, all she cares about, her main reason for everything she does, is feeling close to Edward again, therefore, he is extremely prominent throught the story even though he isn't physically there...

As for giving away the end of the story I think that if someone hasn't heard how the story ends, they've been living under a rock!

I love these books, I fully intend to pass them along to my kids as probably the most enjoyable series I have ever read, and I read a lot. I can't wait for the movie even though this book is my least favorite of all.

True, true...

i think edward is too prominent in both pictures..he isn't hardly in the story at all whether or not bella is pining for him..i feel bad that the storyline is MOSTLY about jacob and bella and yet in the Original of this pic and this remake..they're both like in the background..not cool :(
i wanna see the volturi pics!

Um the reason Bella did what she did in New Moon was Because of Edward.

I wouldn't say that he isn't in the books at all. Granted he doesn't have alot of page time but as you read the book you just know he is the very reason Bella is going crazy. He is very prominent through Bella's emotional turmoil.

I think I like the official poster better. Jacob is standing between Bella and her hallucinations of Edward throughout the book waiting for her to fall in love with him, but in the end Bella practically bolts to save Edward because she loves him so deeply. I think the first poster shows the emotions perfectly about how heartwrenching her choice is soon to be. I love Jacobs expression by the way, and Edward is wow simply Edward. I love it!
I am team Edward by the way. :D

I somewhat agree with you here, however, I think the original would have been better if Bella's head was leaning on Jake's shoulder. Then it would show her sadness a little more but still keeping determination also (if the same expression was still there of course)

I agree. Edward is a bit to prominent. He should be a shadow in the background.

i also agree, edward should be part of the backround...but this version is nevertheless better than the official one...

i think the characters' positions to each other are more approriate, in the official one jacob's pose is far too aggressive and also his position between the two is rather fitting for ecplice than new moon...

in this version bella clings to edward but he looks away, i especially like that (although he shouldn't be there in the first place :))

so thanks, i was rather disappointed with the official one so now i have one i can contently look at :)

Putting Bella beside Edward gives away the entire story.

You don't want to advertise the end of the movie; you want to give a hint of what the story is about.

I think it would have looked good if balla was in between edward and jacob but with her back turned to edward (like she doesn't know he's there) leaning against Jacob who is looking to edward with the same protective stance. And edward looking at bella.

I got the Bella back to back with edward idea from this poster:

http://www.newmoonmovie.org/2009/05/melissa-ros...

I think Jacob should have been placed in the front with Bella. Edward is in the story, but not the main focus. Placing him in the front gives too much away in my opition.

I think if Edward and Jacob were switch and Bella place with Jacob up front it would be better. This fan made poster is good, and I think better put together then the original, but there are problems with both posters overall.

Nope. I like the official poster better.
The coloring on this one isn't very good.
I like Bella better in Jacob's arms, becuase he's the one 'physically' there for her in NM.
Also, that's the whole feeling of New Moon to me when I read it: Bella's physically with Jacob who's trying to ger her over Edward, who still loves her, but she doesn't know it.

The whole time the anticipation of the reuniting of Edward and bella is the drviing force of NM. Thus the official picture better captures this emotion. Will Bella be with edward again?...That's why you have to read NM, therefore, this adapted picture is no good, it tells the end, but not the story inbetween.

No, that one is MUCH better!
It's perfect. Bella loves Edward so she is holding him.
And Jacob is mad and loves her too, but it the second choice, so he's in back

True, Bella loves Edward, however the way this poster has been configured is more reflective of ECLIPSE!! I mean in my opinion this highlights the choice Bella made in the end of the third book, holding on to Edward BECAUSE she loved him more, while Jacob is left outcast and heartbroken...*tear*

I STILL LOVE YOU MORE JAKE!!! (No offense to all the Team Edward affiliates)

This poster is more of a eclipse poster.. Bella holding Edward.. And Jacob looking back angry wanting bella.. Definatly more eclipse than new moon

Enjoying the comments. I love the poster remake. I know Edward wasn't real prominent in this book ,as was Jacob, but he was an undercurrent all the way through, He was Bella's reason to live and for a while,her reason to want to die,and he was always in the recesses of her mind and heart ,so I feel he should be prominent.( We all know we love to see our Edward prominent).. ha. Mercy! But it's like everything, everybody is entitled to their perception,and I respect that.It's just fun to be able to talk to other twi-lovers, and see different aspects. It's going to be a long summer and fall to have to wait for the movie, though.We'll have to keep each other pumped up.

i think the twilight posters were better... they should do a better job...summit

I like this one better too! :-) Bella needs to be gravitating towards Edward, not Jacob!

I like the other one because although Bella is grieving for Edward, she has Jacob as a safety net. That's why she was touching his arm. She also has that blank expression on her face, as if she was searching for someone. Jacob's position and stance in the other poster was genius to me, because it shows that he is protective toward her, and Edward's position was also nicely done because a person who has never read the book can see that they've separated somehow. He's also looking back somewhat hesitantly. Someone who has never read the saga can also decipher that there must be a love triangle going on.

LOL Agree!!!! WHOLEHEARTEDLY....

:-)

Excellent assessment!

I'll agree too. Yes, you're right and right on it. You have pointed out all of the books expressions.

This one feels more like the story to me too. All the time she is with Jacob she wants Edward. Jacob keeps her sane but the insanity is her loss of Edward. So, this one actually fits the story best. I think the Summit one was to drag in the Jacob Teams. PR for them.

I´m sorry to disagree but this poster reveals the final part of the book not all the book, in the studio they have managed to show Edward leaving with that sadness on his face, but always looking back because he can´t forget...Bella barely holding Jacob´s arms because that´s why Bella turns to Jacob to hold to something and not get mad at all, but at the same time you see that she is ready to leave in one second, and Jacob look at his hand hating the vampire and trying to get in the way...I´m not team jacob or team edward, i have read the book and this is the beginning and the middle of the book....there´ll be for sure more posters showing the end...the vulturis and everything but the first poster is showing exactly the majority part of the book.

I totally agree with you, jacobs the one like waiting for her to fall in love with him while she still holds on to edward and never loses any of the feeling she has for him even when hes gone, ya know? :-)

But Edward is such a small part of New Moon. He exists only in Bella's memories. Jacob is the only reason she's able to pull her self together and smile again. He becomes her sun, her light, her everything. And it's only when she's ready to let go of Edward and except that he's never coming back and she won't see him again that Alice shows up.

wtf? Jacob is not 'her everything',don't know what books you read. it's obvious who she can't live without,who her destiny is,and nothing what Team Jacob fans say will change that. the ending has been written. Everything's pretty much explained in BD,Jacob never was the one for her. it was that creepy little creature,Nessie.

He does become her sun and light. She calls him that through New Moon. She gets to the point that she has to be near him. That's why when he doesn't call her she talks about the whole he's left in side her, starts repeatedly calling his house, and eventually confronts him. I'm not trying to change the ending. But you can't negate his importance. There's also a chapter in Eclipse (after the Fire and Ice chapter when they kiss and she realizes that she has been in love with him all along (not as much as she loves Edward but still)) when she lays in bed with Jacob and they talk. It's when she tells him she's choosing Edward. When he says he can handle the clouds but not an eclipse. When Jacob says (and she agrees) that they would have ended up together had it not been for Edward. After that she spends an entire night crying and mourning Jacob with Edward holding her. She promises her self after that that she'll never make Edward see that again. She'll put it all behind her. So yah my point is: Jacob is a huge character and his importance can't and shouldn't be down played.

Very, very, very true!

I know that many Team Edward girls are young and feel like they have to choose sides and put down Jacob, otherwise they are not being loyal to Edward, but really girls Stephenie Meyer loves ALL three of her main characters. So if she created them and loves them, and we love the Saga, we need to be respectful of her and not put down her characters.

I am not a teen and I don't have to like Jacob's character, and I don't.

Exactly my point. You don't have to like ANY character, but you should be respectful of all of them, because they are what make the Saga great.

I just am tired of Team Edward people putting down Jacob and the wolves (and Team Jacob people) all of the time, when the those who love Jacob don't do that to Edward or Team Edward people.

I love Jacob Black the most, but I love Edward and Bella and all of the rest of the characters, too.

I don't like the Volturi. But I think they are awesome bad guys and would never put them down in a mean spirited way, because they are part of our beloved Saga.

You absolutely the right to who you like or don't.
I just wish some Team Edward girls wouldn't be mean spirited.

It took me a while to answer I had to take work home, so I’m taking a break to answer you. I appreciate your thoughts; you love Jacob that’s fine. You already know how I feel so we don’t have to go over that. What I wanted to respond to was the fact you said that Edward fan girls are so mean to Team Jacob fans. I’m sorry, but I don’t see that, every site I go on there is always Team Jacob fans blasting Edward, and some of it is really derogatory. Anyway, not only that the Team Jacob fans attack Robert Pattinson the actor portraying Edward. I don’t know what you have seen, but that is what I see. Even that Laniey Gossip lady is always attacking Robert; I asked what in the world does she have against him. What I heard from the DVD Stephenie Meyers said this was a love story between Bella and Edward and all they went through to be together. It is a beautiful love story and that is why so many people are so fascinated with it, people of all ages. Last, I love the saga, and I like all the fans right now I have an obsession with the books and movies. Have a good night; I have to get back to work.

I love all of the the Saga, the movies and the fans, too.

I just don't see that we have to be "choosing sides".
It is perfectly good and fine to love one character over the other. And normal.

What I don't like is the character bashing/fan bashing.

I have seen some Team Jacob fans say some things jokingly about Edward. But I don't think they mean it in a mean spirited way. However, I have heard some Team Edward fans say "I HATE Jacob!!", "I want Jacob to die!!". This, I think is disrespectful. I have never seen a Team Jacob fan say "I want Edward to die." or "I hate Edward."

I am not saying all Team Edward girls are mean spirited, but about 10% of them give the Saga a bad name, because they are so mean spirited about anyone saying anything the least bit not "Team Edward" and doing crazy things like asking RPatzz to bite their neck. I feel sorry for him because some of the fans are sooo crazy nuts. It is making his like difficult. I don't want him to get so overwhelmed that he doesn't want to de Breaking Dawn.

I also think Lainey Gossip is often says mean, disrespectful and unappropriate things to Robert Pattison and Kristen Stewart. But she is doing it to make money (which doesn't make it right). She is not a Twiight fan arguing over which character is "best". They are ALL wonderful in their own ways. I wish she would stop the Rob/Kristen Rob/Nikki stuff. It's just disrespectful and ridiculous.

Anyway, I didn't mean to upset you by anything I said. I don't consider fans like you the "crazy" ones. It is the ones who feel they have to defend Edward by saying things like "I hate Jacob" or "I want him to die." Even Stephenie Meyer says that hurts her feelings.

I love the Saga, too and am so excited that our beloved books are coming to life. I totally agree with you about it's fascination. We are completely on the same page for that.

One last thing, I am really Team Switzerland.
I TOTALLY get that Bella had to choose Edward. I would have been hurt and upset if she didn't. They are soulmates in a supernatural world and MUST be together.
So why do I defend Jacob? Because if I were a 16 year old again, he would be my ideal guy. Funny, caring, protective, loyal to the end, and Tall, Dark and Gorgeous! He would have been for ME! (but I guess I would have to be reborn again as Renessme!)

That's why I don't like it when people say he should "die" or that he is a "disgusting dog" or that he is a "pedowolf". He is a wonderful character.

I am glad that we can agree to disagree agreeably! That is what mature adults do. (but not what some teen fangirls do)

Have a good day,
ancha85

Bella didn't deserve Jacob anyway, sorry Bella lovers. She was selfish throughout the whole series. I don't dislike Bella, I just didn't like some of the things she did. She has called him her light, face it, she needed him like a drug. Even in Eclipse she sacrificed her relationship with Edward just to see Jacob.

Can we not put down ANY of SM's great characters, please.

Yes, Edward is for Bella, but she did love him, too, just less. And Nessie is not a "creepy little creature". Bella and Edward and Jacob and EVERYONE were willing to give their lives for her!

Everyone has the right to their opinion on who the love the most, but don't put down other peoples' choices, as it is somewhat insulting.

It's just an opinion. We're all stating them, it's fine. Everyone has personality flaws, right? If every person in the world were absolutely perfect, we'd live in a boring world. Same with characters.

haha me too i like jacob blocking Edward Team Jacob all the way baby !!!!!!!!!!

more like Edward blocking both Jacob and Bella. hmm the better man at the forefront of course,the rest is just a background lol

I think Bella should stay in the middle, but Edward and Jake should be switched. It's really Edward in the background of New Moon, not Jake...also, I like his protective stance over Bella.

OK having thought about this... this is how I would arrange the charachters given the chance...

I would have bella clinging to Jacob but staring into the distance towards edward
I would have Jacob topless with clenched fists similar to the poster but glaring towards edward
I would have edward not touching the other charachters and looking away out of the photo - sort of indifferent (even though we know better from later in the book)

Then with the rest of the wolf pack (in wolf forms) howling in the background in the forest.

That would be my ideal New moon poster.

I like this much better but think the official official one would work way better if Bella were reaching for Edward and not clinging to Jacob, she doesn't fall in love with Jacob in the book but Jacob does fall in love with her, however the way the poster is it is confusing people into thinking that Bella must be in love with both characters which she is not.

Hey, maybe that kinda poster were Bella is reaching for Edward would work on Eclipse, since Jacob becomes more aggressive in the third book. ;) I don't think Jacob were really that aggressive in the 2nd book that he would've really fight for Bellas love.

hmm..dont get me wrong....but i read somewhere...that stephanie meyers said bella does fall in Love with jacob in new moon...but she does'nt know it ..yet.......

this one is much better...

I like this one better than the official New Moon poster. The way Bella has her hand on Edward's arm seems more natural. It's like Bella's trying to hold on to Edward. When Bella's hand was Jacob's arm, it looked so awkward and forced. I actually liked the colour of the first poster. This colouring is too bright. But still, awesome job!

It worse than the 1st one ...

The Summit Poster is definitely Better. REMEMBER PEOPLE - the movie is about the BOOK New Moon, not Twilight! In Edwards absence she builds a friendship with Jacob - who in turn is protective of Bella. Although the entire time she's with Jacob she does want to be with Edward...... The best part of Edward's absence is when they reunite in the end.

On the Summit Poster, there doesn't seem to be any romantic chemistry btw Bella and Jacob which is very accurate. They aren't gazing in each others eyes, holding each other close. I think Summit's poster is more accurate a portrayal...and isn't that what fans asked for.....(fans of the books at least).

Although I do want to add that this Poster would be better for ECLIPSE. Bella has Edward back after those terrible months, but she also doesn't want abandon her friendship with Jacob. Bella truly is stuck in the Middle.

Agreed

Agreed

I still say that Summit needs to start looking at some of the amazing fan-made posters and then pay the creators of said posters to use them as the official posters instead.....make a contest of it even...think of how cool that would be for fans to not only have a say in what goes up, be BE A PART OF IT.

It would be better if Edward was looking away from Bella as she held onto his arm and she was slightly looking up at him with Jacob in anguish behind.

much better ;)

MUCHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH BETTER. I THINK THIS IS SOO MUCH BETTER. Team Edward alllll the wayyyy : )

I like this better too!....

Jacobs not in the way! lol....

Way better than the official one. She should be holding onto Edward not Jacob it completely undermines the story

I think I like that better. In the original poster Bella and Jacob look like a couple....and they are not! I think they could do better than this.

cool

ss

1?

??

why doesnt this work

Looks awesome! Good job

Yes Ma'am! That's what I'm talkin about! Team Edward baby! But, I have to say, I love the intensity of the official one.

yes, i like this one much better!

This on it much better the way it is supposed to be

I like :D

i cant wait to see Rob and Kristen act out their love on screen, the chemistry is going to be INSANE

I think that Summit has to learn a lot =)
it's much better!!!

nice ;d

It is better, but there's just something I don't like about the whole pic...sorry!

I like this one too GREAT JOB!

Im still distracted over Robs new pics...will come back later and comment on the poster more throroughly.......swoon AGAIN over pics LOL

Much better, but still the more I look at both posters the more I feel like this should be for Eclipse and not New Moon

I LOVE this one... so much better than the first!

Wow! this is amazing... you're very talented! i bet you'll do something great when you have the individuals photos of each one... it's gonna be even better than this one.

The official one is better because New Moon is about Bella and Jacob's relationship and Jacob should be in the middle. This one looks great but I just think the official poster resembles the plot of the movie better.

Thank you. You have just made my fury subside about 18% LOL

I agree. The official one was a better portrayal.

Agreed!

I like this one better. LOL

I dont think this is right. It works well for eclipse but not for new moon. Love the poster - just not for this installment of the saga.

agreed

This is one is great, but I still like the other one with the more intensity between Edward and Jacob. Hopefully there will be others out soon that actually show what new moon is about. But good job to this artist.

Yeah, that's actually kind of better... nice job!

its nice. i want another poster now! LOL.....im GREEDY

For example:
http://www.newmoonmovie.org/2009/02/new-moon-po...
http://www.newmoonmovie.org/2009/02/new-moon-po...
the post from CarloAdrian who one the contest is what I expect for NEW MOON.

Yeah this one is much better.... They left he space beside Jake for me... Move over Bella!!

LMAO!! :D

Yeah... what do you expect from me...???

Eddy shouldn't be in the pic as much as they have given the space... Not because I am Team Jacob but just because it is in the book that way. He should've had a prominent presence but not too in your face!

I 100000% agree! this whole "let's put Edward at the front even though he's absent from most of the book" thing pisses me off a little :)
I'm surprised that there's no Edward on other movie posters ;) imagine how many more people would go to see Star Trek if Edward appeared on the posters... :D

LMAO :)

Yeay for having Rob added to all movie posters from now on :) Hale yeah :)

kiddin lol

ahahahhah!!! I bet people would have gone to Milk film if Eddy had made an appearance to that too.

Roping in more of the character is good but try not to screw up the book people... I wonder how would they have felt if James was given more of a prominence in Twilight???

Ugh!

True! I agree, Jacob should in the front with Bella and Edward far in the back (in the back of Bella's mind). I still love the poster though. It kinda brings back emotions from the first time I read the books...I'm pissed that Jacob ends up with the baby! hahah He could have imprinted on ME! :P

LOL I wrote the same justification!!! :-)

Edward has much more role in this film than in the book... but that is ok. He has more role in the poster that too is ok...

What is not OK is the pissing match that is about to start by some Rob fans by saying that Jake is just a PR thing for Summit.... Seriously?? I mean seriously???

Ihowl2 yey havn't chatted in ages, i think it's right that edward is at the front, to me newmoon is more about realtionships than the actual characters but every process that is made by bella is because of the fact that edward has left her so for me he's the main presence in the book, i think it's unfair for people to say that about taylor, (although i do think he's an attention seeker, but hey he's young and wants fame nothing wrong with that) although i do think it's a little odd how he's winning in the mtv awards for breakthrough male, thats a little weird for me as i think to win an award it's kind of necessary to actually be in the film lol, i just hope this movie is representitive of the book then that way it's smiles all around!! :)

Hey Kim!!!! where are you girl???

hey you have the right to opinion... the way you described it was the way Ed fans see that. The way I describe it is the way Tay fans see that!!

:-)

I agree, even though i lean Team Jacob.

Rob should get it this year, and Taylor next year.

How do you find out who's winning?

Breathe, Howly, Breathe, b/c there's no point in fighting this argument.
I don't think Jake is a big enough name at this point to be a PR for Summit and unless I am wrong, New Moon is solidly Jake.. Did we miss the version in which they skipped from the breakup scene to Alice and Italy??????
Ok, you know what? I gotta stop., NOw
*Looks for Paul* I need a Yoga class to work this one off.

Oh, please, Patience! Don't even start me on the "imprinting was stupid because it was so dang cheap and easy after all the fighting Jake did for Bella, why didn't someone bust tail to fight for him.." soapbox. I could be here ALLLLLL DAY!!

I'm confused, you agree or disagree with me :P I would fight for him! He is one of a kind....and he ends up with that baby!? Come on! I still love the Twilight Saga....but that kinda pissed me off.

I feel you Patience. I was kinda pissed that he was so amazing and ended up with Reneesme. An epilogue of Jacob and Nessie could have made me feel better.

Well hopefully Reneesme will be a better catch for Jacob (when she grows up), than Bella ever was. I would have loved an epilogue of both of them too :)

Oh thank goodness. I thought I was the only one. I really wanted an epilogue that gave me a happy ending for Jacob. He more than anyone in the four books deserved a happy ending. If I ever get to meet SM that's what I'll ask her. For Jacob's happy ending.

I have been DYING for a Jacob/Reneesme book! He deserves happiness sooo much!

SM, I would love to read the rest of Midnight Sun, or a book about Leah, but please, please, PLEASE write a Jacob/Nessie book!

In the end Jacob loves vampires after all and not just any vampire but Edward's daughter. I must say I didn't like that I thought he should have ended up with Lea, but that is not the story. The wolf loves the blood sucker to use his words. I find that so funny.

I am agreeing, Patience, I am agreeing. I feel that after all the fighting/protecting/slogging Bella's butt out of depression in return for getting dumped on his butt the minute Mr. Sparkly shows his face again, that he did, he just got thrown a bone..

*Voila! And now, you have imprinted on this beautiful, amazing, kind, child. Take her and get out of the story, thank you very much, dog!*

ARRGGHHHH.

OK... must go find comforting wolf now. Temper is out of control .

Like you said, Edward should like be in the background. With his back toward us, and just looking back... I don't know why, but I really think that would be more right for New Moon in a way. But it may reveal too much for those who haven't read New Moon.

Nicely done, I'll give you that. But it doesn't ring true at all. Everyone is letting their "Team" color their perspective. This is about Jake and Bella's developing relationship; Edward is the underlying story in the book. He shouldn't be featured too prominently. He's always lurking in the background (in her mind that is); he should be shown full-on, but slightly set away from Bella and Jacob.

I don't see Bella's hand on Jacob's arm as showing the love between them yet. She's not facing him full-on, she's looking emotionless and away, but touching him. That doesn't scream love triangle yet. As we all recall, Bella and Jacob were quite touchy-feely in New Moon.

I think someone should re-create it to show Edward set slightly off to the side or in the back, maybe slightly muted, but shown full-on (for hardcore Rob fans). Bella and Jake should be together, with the same expressions, same touch, same her looking off to the side. That fits the tone of the book; Team whatever's just have to get over it. ;)~

Exactly! If Edward is that close to them in the poster she needs to be looking at him with longing in her eyes. Her looking away would work if Edward were in the background. And believe me ladies, I am totally Team Edward!!

I agree i think teams should be left at the door when it concerns the posters, although i have to disagree that edward shouldn't be feautured prominently, everything bella does is because edward has left her which for me makes edward the biggest presence even though he's never directly discussed or seen, i think you're right though about edward being set slightly to the side, i think edwards and jacobs expressions and stance is spot on but bellas is all wrong for me, if she's going to be touching jacobs arm like that i think she should be gazing somewhere in the direction where edward is and not straight ahead like that, that way it sets the tone for me as even though she can touch jacob she's longing for edward so yeah if they set edward slightly apart and have bella divert her stare i think it would be awesome, i wish i was a techie and could photoshop it, damn it LMAO!!!

Meg1 I understand where you are coming from. You have to look at the big picture and not who you like better. Even though this poster is fabulous, it does'nt fit with new moon as well as the "official" poster. however, bella doesn't realize she loves jacob until almost the end of eclipse. Right before the big fight with victoria and the newborns. So maybe thats where some of the difference in opinions come in.true bella and jake hold hands, and are very close in the book and she's even thinking about settling for the alternative. But her heart has always been and always been with edward.

I guess it doesn't bother me, because it doesn't look like Bella loves him in this poster, she's just touching his arm (like she's seeking support). It goes with the touchy-feely of the two of them, but her gaze should show her non-emotion and pain from Edward leaving.

I agree with what Kim said above.. that she could be looking in Edward's general direction with that look on her face. It would clue people in that she's getting close to Jacob but she's suffering because of Edward.

Well-spoken, Meg!

Good idea!

US, Howl, US......
And yes, let's just chuck Bella over our shoulders and hope she lands safely on a pile of soft leaves.

Wait... I am raking those scarce leaves... Dammit spring!!!

I put a cinderblock under those leaves :) Err...

stuff the leaves...

She is supposed to be in pain after all... and look a mess. If she did come crawling back at least the next poster could look realistic!

OK I didn't mean to be nasty. *sigh* Someone'd catch her anyway. And it'd probably just be another fantastic guy. Some girls get all the luck.

Yet again, I'm sorry, but the thought tickled my fancy!

Both are awesome!

I like them both...it was difficult seeing Bella away from Edward in the official one though. I like seeing them together:)!

Ow yes ...now i liked !! rsssss

i like this one better (:

omg haha what's next? Tiny Jake's silhouette lurking somewhere in the background? :D

GRRRRRR srsly... someone down below commented that Jake was PR thing for Summit... actually it is the other way round. Rob is the PR thing for Summit. This is Jake's book not Edward's!!!

*trying very hard not to stomp the feet or throw tantrum*

GRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR
This IS Jake's book, but they keep bringing up this insignificant.. *tries to remember name* Edward, I believe is what they call him.
Who was he again?

NOw I"m really smokin' mad, so let me go claw up a few pieces of furniture before I start a problem with someone that lands me in New Moon hell again.

LOL

Patience 4tw patience!!!

take the frustration out on the Pack... that is much more easier & good for your health too!!!

Oooh, so true...

*walks towards forest*

I'll be back when the anger has been um....worked.. off.

LOL

(There's gonna be a whole lot of new scars on those shoulders tomorrow. Just a forewarning)

Yes! Patience! hahah!

*rolls eyes*

*slightly retracts claws*

I'll try.

Amen! New Moon IS Jake's book.

I think, despite the "Teams", if you're being fair, yes, crucial moments happen because of Bella's love for Edward and his love for her, but overall, the book largely develops Jacob as a person, his relationship to Bella, the wolf pack as a whole, etc.

I think Jake/Bella relationship/friendship is needed to show contrast between Edward/Bella and Jake/Bella- book wouldn't be as interesting without it and I guess, depending on each reader's personal preference, they're going to gravitate towards one guy.

I personally actually like Edward very much, BUT I prefer Jake's casual, laughing, warm personality and um...other physical attributes, and his dogged (excuse the pun) loyalty to Bella despite the fact that she drops him in the blink of an eye, and keeps picking him back up when she needs her sunshine "fix"

I wonder if it would be the same way if more girls were drooling over Taylor than over Rob... :)

(and just to make sth clear: I LOVE Rob and GENERALLY think that the more Rob the better :D but this time I try really hard to remain objective :))

Thanks Jo!!! I will back you up when Charlie comes!!! :-)

It depends on the POV of the fan who made the poster... I mean it can also be taken as Jake is there for her (I am not believing that) but what I thought was that Jake has to be the force which is supporting her through the lean times when Eddy was gone. In the 1st poster it is is visible that she is leaning on Jake for the emotional support .... *screams* Get away from him Bella!!!... erm sorry! got a bit carried away!

Ooh, Jo, perhaps we should go one better and just have a small wolf charm dangling off her bracelet.
*Furious! Eyes glinty, claws out! *

LOL! or maybe the trees could symbolize Jacob...? ;)

Wow. The server is slow, your comment says 26 mins and hasn't reached me yet. Yes, I sense that we are understanding one another... perhaps we could even forget the trees, just put the Italy fountains up and we can use the sunlight as Jake's presence...
LOL

... or the colouring ;)

it took me ages to reply, NMM's slower than Bella's truck today!

much better! screw jacob!

*GASP*
*Shock*
*grin- Thank you, that's exactly what i'd like to do*
LOL

Ahahah we have much better word for it!!! But yeah your word also works!!!

:-)

I like this one better. It's lighter and the placement is better but now Edward looks mad at Bella. Oh well...

I like the other way better. Tells more about the story in the book.

This one is better :)
But I like the official one a lot, too.

Good job! But the real one is alot better...It's showing the real thing because Edward is turning back on her, Jacob is angry, possessive, protective...She holds on him because he keeps her alive, he's giving her some hapiness but she looks another way because her heart and mind , stills with Edward...
She's not suppose to hold Edward at all cause he's gone... But it's normal that he's there because, it's all about him, all the time. Everything she doe's it's because of him...
That's my 2cents..

I agree with venus 100%. you took the words right out of my mouth. nice!!!!!!!!! I love both posters, but this one is actually perfect for eclipse. The other one is good for new moon.

It's true it's hard to please US BECAUSE WE LOVE THE BOOKS SOOO MUCH !!!

I like this one,bella and edward yes.

I was disappointmed with the original poster. I think a lot of the fan made posters have been much better. I like this one better than the Summit version, but I'm also team Edward. :-)

The real one is really good but i prefer this one. It shows the longng Bella has for Edward, she does do dangerous things just to hear his voice. But thats just be and i dont like Jacobs character :) x

I agree, the re-imaging is better. I can see having the poster both ways due to story line, but Anna DID capture it MUCH better. One suggestion I'd make...perhaps if Edward was a bit more of an apparition since he's not really present when Jacob is, and having Bella embracing that.

When the vote was posted if people liked the official new poster, I just thought it was okay, I mean, the fan posters have been just phenomenal! I've got a fanmade poster as my wallpaper at work, I enjoy them so much.

i actually like this one better than the official one, it makes more sense since edward is who she REALLY wants to be with and jacob is kinda put on the back burner waiting for her to love him...good job whoever made this :-)...xoxo

haha, the vast majority thinks this is better than the original. I couldn't agree more.

*sigh* but yes, I am happy we at least have something official.

LOL they're making a BELLA sandwich

What I wouldn't give to be Bella in THAT situation ;-)

yeah I know...lucky girl.

:-( Some girls have all the luck...and mythical creatures fighting over her lol

perfect!!!

Great! Really really great! :)

I like the comment about the bella sandwich made me giggle :) x

I think this is better than the first one as well. (: With Jacob standing at the back it's more that he's ready to step in and save Bella as soon as Edward has gone. This makes more sense, I think.
At least we have something official. It makes it more realistic.
Summit would do a really good job if they actually asked Fans how they think the posters and trailers and things should look. (:

I agree!!!! I love this one.... with jacob standing in the back just waiting for edward to leave. although i htink jake should have been taller and bella should have been more bella than kristan. Sorry.
But im glad we gat something offical from summit. HAHA funny right after that one lady found the offical script in the trash! Maby they are trying to make up.Lol
Ok overall looking past the little things i really like the offical. Hopefully we get more than one poster though!

i like the look from Edward to Bella, the torment on his face which would mean he fact he is leaving or the fact he finds out the relationship between Bella and Jacbob or the fact he puts her life in danger.

The way Bella is holding on to Edward like she doesnt want to let him go which she doesnt and the look from Jacob like he knows he is always second best but like hes plotting of ways in which to maybe become Bellas number one.

The fact she is in the middle of both of them!!! which is what she is in the book.

I think this poster is sooo good much better than the original.

Nice poster... but the first one's way better... TEAM JACOB!

I know it's probably hard to do for the person who made this one (which I like by the way!) - but if Jacob was turned around, and holding onto Bella, I think it'd make more sense.... I do think this one makes more sense though, she may have Jacob as her safety net the whole time, but she still clings to whatever she can get of Edward through the book.... Kudos for re-working it! Good job!

God! It's like you read my thoughts... I did try sooooo hard to flip Jacob's picture, but it looked just too damn weird! (Plus, if I flipped him, I would've have to build his ENTIRE shirt, not just the bit I already did... and I really didn't wanna do that! =p)
Anyways, THANK YOU SO MUCH!

WOW!! I like the original but this one is SOOOOO much better!!

I really like this one
but now it looks kinda like Jacob is walking away instead of Edward
anyway good job!

I really like this one too, great job.

this one is better than the first one,but both are terrible.

Better than the first!!!!

i prefer the first poster as is has a better portryal of jacobs role in the novel which is too huge for him not to be placed in the centre.... don't get me wrong though... there is nothing better than a bit of edward!

I think this one is a little bit more like Eclipse then it is New Moon. Jacob's anger, Bella trying to make sure Edward never leaves again, Edward still disgusted with the wolves. It's eclipse so much. *sigh*

now THIS is what i'm talkin' about!!!! this is exactly how the official poster should've been. although summit can't change it now, i think they made the horribile mistake of cutting jacob's hair off for this poster because he only cuts it off later on in the book, and in that case bella should've looked wayy more depressed because her hallucinations of edward are stronger then. in the official poster it looks like bella's inlove with jacob, the way she's holding onto him...but i think she should've been either holding edward (like this fan made one) or looking at him, with a longing, hurt expression on her face. once again, i'm beginning to doubt whether they've made this movie true to the book :(

*continutation from my last post* this poster is defintely more eclipse...in this poster they should've focused more on bella's heart break and her depression, not her chosing between edward/jacob, because that's not new moon really, it's eclipse. this poster should've been, like other amazing fan made ones, bella lying in the forest complety falling to pieces, with edward looking back with a pained look on his face but with utter conviction, and jacob ready to come and save her.

If Jacob would turn around it would be perfect.

This is just NOT New Moon !!!

New Moon is about Jake & Bella ! And I'm not saying this cause I'm on Team Jacob. I'm saying this because I've read the books...

NM is about Bella struggling without Edward and trying everything to hold onto him and her memories of him even though it hurts her to even think about him. Jacob is jthe guy who helps her get out of depression but he doesn't make her whole again,she's still broken,and only whole when she can be with E again.

the other poster made it out as if B and J were a couple now,and showed E as the guy that lost. that's totally wrong.

more of an eclipse poster now
edward is looking angry at bella- not good

That's what i thought while looking at the poster for the first time. What does Bella do with her hand? Jacobs arm? Please!

Thank you, that's much better now ;)

I like this poster alot better... it does kind of show the end of the book. but i still like it better. :)

i would have to say, even tho i am team edward, that i like the first poster better. it shows what that true meaning of the book is. in new moon she doesnt have edward but for the first part of the book. so she caters to jacob but yet is looking past him because she still longs for what she cant have. jacob is just filling the void she has right now. also notice how jacob has his fist clinched because hes mad/jealous of edward cuz he know if he were to come back then he would lose bella in a heart beat. but yet still insists on trying to block edward from belle or vice versa.

dont get me wrong this poster is good as well but i agree it is me for eclipse then for new moon. cuz in eclipse bella has edward again but jacob still trys to get bella even tho he knows it wouldnt work. thats why hes in the back ground.

I think seeing as this is new moon, the line up should be:
Bella
Jacob
Edward

cause ed left, and jacob's "protecting" her. plus then we'd get to see more of jacob :)
anways, these posters are major letdown for team jacob, why the heck is edward in the front??? this is jacob's only chance to shine!
sheesh.

Both posters were good, I like the official the best. Its all in how you take in their body language & to me that says it's a New Moon poster.

this is Bella and Edward love story, they were made for each other,E was her destiny,Jacob is just that irritating third wheel Meyer threw into the mix to spice things up a little and for her to swoon over yet another guy eww. He was always on the losing side,dunno why Summit are trying to make it out as if he has a chance. delusional and overdramatic much?

This is beautifully done, but it seems more like Eclipse because Bella isn't with Edward in New Moon (emotionally yes, but they're not actually together). The original fits the mood of NM much better and shows the turmoil and pain felt between all the characters, as well as the true circumstances of this story. I love both Edward and Jacob, so it's not that I'm biased against either of them or anything, I just like the truer portrayal of the original poster.

Yeah, i love edward and jacob both. But your right the first one does fit new moon better.

I completely agree. This was a well done poster, but I am glad they didn't do it like this. It doesn't portray New Moon at all. It is more for Eclipse. I love both Edward and Jacob too and I am getting pretty aggrevated when it comes to all of these people who constantly want it Edward, Edward, Edward... That is not the way Stephenie Meyer wrote it, and Jacob deserves more tips then that...

The original was perfect. This one was beautifully done, but yes, it is also more an Eclipse poster. Bella being inbetween Jacob and Edward would show her turmoil between the two. Edward and Jacob looking at each other would have been perfect but what would be really good would be for Bella to be holding on to Edward while she reaches out to Jacob. That would be a beautiful sign that she won't let Edward go, but she is determined to have Jacob in her life too...

Great job...

Not that i don't like this poster, because it's really good, but i don't think that edward must be in the front, the book is mostly about jacob and bella, so i like the first official poster a bit more than this one.

i actually thought the official poster was a fan made.. lols!

I think I like this way best. I thought Bella should have been in the middle, not Jacob.

very nicely done, I don't really mind Rob being to prominent, I think they actually did
that because everybody wants more Rob, and they did say that it's a bit different from the book. I think it will be much better than Twilight...can't wait!

Sorry, but this movie is about Jacob and Bella and He should be prominent. Edward should be in the background.

I agree that Bella needs to be in the middle, it helps with the visual of tug-of-war between the boy and the man!!!!

The issue I still have with the posters (both so far) Edward should be in the back!!!!!

Bella should be holding Jacob still, she clings to him in the movie......not Edward!!!!!

I think that the light is wrong on both as well.....the movie is supposed to dark and gloomy!!!! They are both to bright....the whole new moon concept is the fact that it is dark (No moon!!!) There should be no light ball at all!!!!!!

You're absolutely right. Edward should be shadowy in the back. Jacob has
saved Bella and she is clinging to him to him in the book. I don't have a
problem with the lighting because Bella says that Jacob is her Sun and she
can see sunshine thru the gloom. I just hope that they give Taylor/Jacob
the time he deserves in the movie and that they don't cave in to the demands
for more Edward where he doesn't belong.

yes! i think it would be good with bella in front (seeing as the book is about her....) holding her arms around herself, holding herself together. then jacob trying to hug her. then in the back should be edward, facing the other way, slightly looking back. seeing as he is the one who left her, and it's almost like jacob is "protecting" her. i wish i could make posters, lol. i have such an awesome idea for how it should look....

i love that version

i like the official more, cause there it's more about jacob and bella, and in this one you see edward more than jacob and that isn't like the book, so i think that edward must be much more in the background en bella en jacob in the front. But you made it look like it's also an official movie poster so you did a pretty good job!

I ike the official more, because there it's more about jacob and bella, like in the book. In this one you see to much of edward, it isn't like the book... but you did a great job with the light and stuff and made it look like an official movie poster, if you told me that this was the official i would almost believe it xD

now THAT is how it should've been in the first place!!!!

Excellent job - this version is so much better!!!

i like this one better too! i understand jacob fans prefer the official..but that seems not right. she loves edward. i totally agree with cutesweetiezzz! "it´s like trying to hold on to edward. [...]" i really hope there will be published better official posters..the first one is very disappointing.

sorry for the double comment xD the server was busy so I had to write my comment again, and now there both posted... xD sorry, won't happen again :P

The first one was better because Edward leaves and Bella is brought to life again by Jacob. Edward becomes a secondary character like in 70% of the book.

hey greapt oste.r the roignal is cool too as well!

personally i like the concept of bella being in the middle yes their are many things wrong with this poster as far as attention to detail go but i visually like this one better. She is stuck between both in new moon. Yes you could argue that its more about jacob and bella.

The first one follows the book more, Jacob is protective of Bella no matter how she feels about Edward, hence the original stance. Edward doesn't like that feeling, hence his. Bella may love Edward but she knows the strain her love for both has put on them. So the original poster was great and this one looks good, but doesn't follow the concept. It's too "Bella and Edward" which is cool and all, but not the entirety of all the books. There are other players and plots and emotions in them.

I like both personally. I totally understand everyone views about Bella being in the middle; Edward should be in the background; Jacob should be between them; etc. They are both nice posters and lets the audience us their imaginations. I just think that the characters on the original should've been bigger like in the fan remake. I think that is what is making the remake so visually appealing to me. They are both well done.

sorry i like the original one better.
it was made that way for a reason cuz of the storyline.
good job doing a remake but i like the original.

both posters speak volumes of the movie, but even though 100 percent Team Edward, the offical posters tells the story. Bella is not even looking at Jacob, she is looking past him to get to Edward. This poster would resemble more Eclipse, although like someone pointed out, she is holding on to Edward like suggest that stunts she performance to Jake being there to catch her.

oh its very nice. dont lke bella touching jacob. i mean. urgg...

I really like this poster. It seems to make more sense to me in comparison to the official poster. I still like the offiicial poster, but this remake is a little bit better in my opinion. Is that the only official poster that Summit is making? I hope there will be more...

Put all this into a poster, and you will have a winner!

Bella grieving
Edward grieving
The Cullens moving away
Bella nightmares
Jacob in his garage
Cliff diving
Motorcycle wreck
Quileute boys
Victoria

This one is better, BUT - It should be Edward with his back turned to Bella ( he left her after all) Her hand should be on Jacob ( she leans on him the whole book) .
Bella DEFINITELY should be in the middle though!!!

Great work! If I could to something as talanted as this (wich I cannot) I would have done the same thing - you rock AnaB! I dont like that Bella is holding Jacobs arm, because she doesn't care about him in that way (yet. for eclipse, this would have worked perfectly). Sure she's all about Jacob to forget (and to rembember) Edward and Jacob's all about Bella for the love he feels but.. I dunno. Guess I'm such a devoted Team Edward-member that this one feels like the better option. The best. Haha.

Aaawww! Thank you so much! =D

This one reminds me more of Elclpise, anyone else agree?
Its still very good though, shes very talented :)

Yup. That's why I didn't like it basically it Reveals the ending. The whole suspense of the Movie that is New Moon is taken out gggrrrrrr

I like the original better. Even though Bella is holding on to Jacob to me it looks like she is trying to get past him to get to Edward.

It's kind of like Jacob is telling her "No, don't go to him" but she is saying "Sorry, it is him. It has always been him."

this one is very well done! i like it better than the first one!

hahaaa
i was just guna comment and say, why is edward so pale?! lol
kinda forgot he was a vamp hahaa
silly meee

Wow great job on the poster, you cant even tell there were changes made but I still like the original from Summit better because it shows how in New Moon Jacob is between Bella and Edward.

A part of me feels there could have been so MUCH more added to the New Moon Poster. I am glad it has the main components :Edward, Bella & Jacob. BUT I kind of wish there was more besides them just standing there. Especially since there were a LOT of great Fan Posters.

I also manipulated a copy of the poster to change up the coloring. My thoughts on the characters positioning is that the original is perfect (no offense). It shows the dynamic that Bella is in, because she knows that Jake would be good to her, and he is the only one standing in between her and going after Edward. Kudos to New Moon for making K-Stew look so attractive in this poster. Much better this time around, and much more realistic. Edward could beef up some though, he looks like he has been using Heroin or something...too skinny!

I believe the original poster is truer to the theme of New Moon. The fan made poster is very indicative of the ending. I do like the idea of brightening up the poster, but the symbol of the sun is very wrong for this part of the saga. This was a very dark time for Bella. I do think it's creator is very talented but I think she has the theme wrong. This would be great for Eclispe.

Yep, I prefer the character placement in this one. :)

HATE IT! I think the Original is truer to the theme of the book New Moon. This is one makes Jacob look like a Villain/evil & Bella is scared of him--Which is Not right =(

yes, the characters placement was all wrong and the colors...
ugh.

It's forks, it's green. Why all the brown??

This one is MUCH better-sorry Jacob fans!

PERFECT!

i like the official one better. like someone else said, this could easily be eclipse's poster.

WOW.it's wonderfull

This poster is so much better than the real one. The real poster makes it look like Bella is cheating on Edward. Also, is it just me or do the characters look different?

okay lets make this the eclipse poster haha jk jk i like this one a lot she's holding on to Edward - but I think Jacob is a little off -- like he would have that stance in Eclipse or BD - in New Moon he is still protective of Bella and closer to her - not with his back to her

nice! but i'am actually pleased with the official one. It tells the story perfectly in my opinion, in the original you get the feeling that jake is protecting bella from edward which is more prominent to give the feeling that he's like impossible to reach( for bella) and edward looks like if he's angry or maybe jealous by the fact that bella is with jacob. Bella has no expression she's a ''zombie''. I think there's something like pain in her eyes.

This is how it should have been. It actually makes sense.

O Dear Lord how did you have time and will to this? Great work I must say. Al though I think that the placement of the characters in the original poster suits more the story of the New Moon.. Ok at the end she is still back with Edward how ever she is still thorn between Jacob and Edward. I would actually prefer her in the centre of poster and the two hotties around here at opposite sides.

I agree!

I like the official one, it tells the story more in a way. I don't like this one though, cause edward isnt there for most of the book, jacob is! I think the official one makes more sense. Jacob is protecting bella from edward.

The first one was better. Sorry. She shouldn't be touching Edward....unless this is supposed to represent the ending of the story (which would be stupid. Again, sorry). People need to get over the fact that New Moon is mostly about Jacob and Bella's relationship. You're going to have to deal with those two touching lol

I agree obviously Obsessed Team Edwardess is written all over his poster and is not being true to the movie New Moon. Seriously people are getting way ahead of themselves basically telling the ending what's the point in that In a Movie Poster!!!!! MOVIE POSTER SUPPOSE TO CREATE SUSPENSE NOT TELL YOU THE ENDING!!!!!

This is way better than the first one. I thought the first one was really awkward! This one would be good for Eclipse too, if the color scheme was different...because that's the one where Edward and Jacob are really fighting over Bella.. Haha Edward looks like he's thinking, "Oh really, Jacob? You think you can take MY girl? Biatch, please" and Jacob looks like he's thinking, "I'll take you DOWN, Edward" :P

This one was way better !

way better character locations =)

Still think that this poster is great, but it really works better for eclipse. The original is better for new moon, but even that isnt great. This story is more about Jacob and Bellas story - edward features and is a pivotal part but not the only thing that the story revolves around.

i still think that edward shouldn't be so prominent in the posters cause its all about how he is like a dream to bella in the stage she was in new moon...still i like this one better

I like this one better! :-)

I like the first one better. This has a more eclispe feel than the first one does.

I like the coloring in the first one better, but I like this one better just because I don't like Bella clinging to Jacob like that. I agree with you that this has more of an Eclipse feel to it than a New Moon feel though. I still like this version too though.

I liked the official one....this one is more of eclipse...sort of..like....jacob is angry & hurting ....Bella is lost in tought..(about jacob hurting).....edward is looking back down toward bella wondering if she's thinking about jacob again...lol....o well thats what it looks like...

i dont like it....the official is better!!!!

Haha, good editing wise, but that looks more like an Eclipse poster--Bella in the middle, but leaning towards Edward.
And its all blurry like they got caught in a dust storm, haha...
the official one was WAYYY better, no offense!

definetly Bella should be next to Edward. these books are all about their relationship. just cuz Edward isn't physically there in the book this is about him and Bella. jacob is kinda irritating as he wants to take Edward's place in Bella's life... he should just stay in the background and keep quiet! xD whatever... if this is the official poster we cannot change it. i still think Bella should be next to him but at least Edward is in the front!

I like it, but i like the first better. The first shows that she leaned on jacob when edward wasn't there.... this one is more for eclipse.

While this poster is good, I still like the original better.

New Moon is when Jacob started to become between Edward and Bella. The original makes more sense to me.

much better than original the lighting is better and Edward doesn't look so evil but I think I liked Bella better on Jacob's arm

I love her poster too but i think it better represents eclipse

I like this poster. But I rather the first official one for New Moon. I think Bella should be between them in Eclipse. This movies about him leaving (him being in the front) and Jacob being there for her physically. I really like the official one for New Moon, but def big props for this remake.

The original is one better, she shouldn't be holding edward because he is not there in majority of NM. The reason they did this was because in NM she is loving Jacob, she completely believed Edward did NOT love her nor want her. So she questions whether she would live a lie to make the person who loves her happy. And in the book she said she would tell Jacob that she will always love Edward even though she would live a married life with jacob. Her not holding Edward also shows that he is not there, its just an illusion. As in the book!. People who want Bella holding Edward are not understanding the concept of his absence. yes i agree that the book is about how she can't live without him. But she never knew he WAS going to come back, so she was trying to move on. But obviously ppl know that edward was going to come back, and thats why ppl keep thinking she couldn't live without him. But she was if Edward did not come back.

i like the coloring in the real one better but i like where bella is in the remake...good job!

I definately like this one wayyy more. Bella should be between Edward and Jacob not off on the side like the original...jeez. Also I like the fact that she is holding on the Edward. It's symbolic of her unwillingness to let go of him. Where as in the original it looks like she could give to craps about Edward and all her focus is on Jacob...which is completely wrong. urg. I guess the original is okay...but I really love this one alot more!

I really like this one better... it would be even cooler if you could some how make Edward look like some kind of dream... like he is fading or something hazy like...

omg thats so much better.. Bella still holding onto him even though he rejected her which is shown by the positioning and expression of his face. Also her grasp on Edward and 'friendly' attitude to Jacob is shown by his displeasure of being 'second-best'

HAHA you can tell i just had an english exam today x

i actually like this one better!!!!!
good job!!!!

great job :D

oook i like much better..:)

i like it but ehh like ther first one better.
this would be better for eclipse.

I agree.
I just think Bella's eyes should have been looking tword Edward in the original.
Just my opinion.
:)

Totally agree. Not just your opinion. :)

Ooooh me likey!! Lol... I love this so much better just b/c she's standing and touching my "Edward" but I think that the official one is also good due to the love triangle thing... Love it either way... as long as Rob is there... it's all good =]
Kudos to you woman!!

How do you make a fan mad one? and if it comes out good who do you email it to????????

MUCH BETTER! The whole point is that she wants to be with Edward... not Jacob!

wow this one is way better.... love both of them

so so much better

this one isn't very good actually, sorry. as people have said bella shouldn't be holding edward because he's not really there, it's more eclipse because they are a couple but she's still between edward and jacob. and the coloring is off. i guess it's supposed to look misty but it looks more like she just erased out parts of the picture instead. so, from both a graphic design standpoint and a new moon standpoint, the original one is much better.

I think a lot of you are getting the official poster wrong...Sorry, I like the original better. I don't like the fact that she is touching Edward in this one...He leaves in the beginning! Hello!!!??? Did anybody read New Moon or did you just skip to the end when Edward comes back???? Why would she be physically touching him? The reason Jacob is between them is because it symbolizes the space between Edward and Bella...AND...Jacob fills that space while he is gone. Bella is touching Jacob because she "leans" on him for "support". Everything about the original poster is perfect...The expressions, especially Jacob's, the positions...Everything! Who ever came up with the concept knew what they were doing! This fan make over poster screams Eclipse to me.

I think this would of been better as an Eclipse Poster because she is stuck in the middle of both of them fighting over her. But in the end she ends up with Edward. The first one was better it showed that he left her and she turned to Jacob for help to get over Edward.

i think this one represents Eclipse more

just an opinion tho =)

much better.. but i still prefer the original color

I think this is WAAAAY better then the original. The placement of the characters makes a lot more sense to the story.

Well done.

this one is soooooooo much more accurate and way better <3 i love it. if only Summit knew how to make posters. *sigh*

I like this one so much better!!

i like this one way better cause it shows that Bella likes Edward way more than Jacob.

i LIKE THIS ONE SO MUCH MORE THAN THE ORIGINAL!!!!

I EXPEECTED MORE THAN WHAT THE OFFICIAL POSTER GAVE!!!!

AMAIZING!!!
=)

THIS SUCKS

is not True to the New Moon Plot instead it reveals the Ending WHY WOULD YOU HAVE THAT IN A POSTER???? Posters suppose to create suspense Not tell you the conclusion hugh SO wrong for this Movie better for Eclipse.

I LIKE THE ORIGINAL ONE MAKES MORE SENSE

I didn't like the first one at all, but I don't really think this one does it either! In the original poster, bella doesn't look distraught to me at all. The lighting and idea was ok, Bella should still lean on Jacob, but I think Edward should be in the background, with Bella looking slightly back like she's deciding whether to go forward or to hold on to the past.

Character placement is MUCH better, this is the way it should be, except of course Edward's expression, because he's looking at Bella not Jacob. But it's not like that can be helped. I like this one much better.

i think, it will better if like the first, the official. but i think bella must be hold edward's hand. like stop him, but jacob still like protective

LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOVE IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

first one is so much better. soo much better.
your moderate photoshop skills are good. definitely portrays more of eclipse.
edward left her, so how could she be holding on to him. and why would jake be pissed?
def. not new moon. so much more of eclipse.

i think jacob is in the middle in the real one because he is guarding bella from edward. just a thought.

that picture looks stupid now!!!
first edward looks like "eww get away bella"
then jacob looks like" ok bella im leaving now, bye"
that's how it looks like now!
THERE WAS A REASON WHY PPL PUT THEM THE WAY THEY'RE SUPPOSE TO BE IN THE REAL POSTER! IDIOTS!!!
so um...yeah i like the regular on better! so sad, TOO BAD!!!

Well, okay then... I just wanted to say you do have the right to not like it!

I just really don't appreciate being called an idiot because I wanted to make something different... I do know how a thing or two about poster making, but I'm not a professional yet. I'm a fan who had an idea and thought it would be a good thing to share it...

So I'm sorry my take on it upsets you! Please, don't be disrespect me and my work... this is what I love doing and I wanna keep doing it... you may not like what I do, but please don't disrespect me by calling me an idiot!

Sincerely,
AnaB

Yes OMG this is way better I really hate that Jacob is in between Bella and Edward I swear man I feel that Jacob messes up my book AHHHHH!!!!

This is sooo much better!!!
Summit should use this because i love that Bella's in the middle
cos its her struggle u know. she's pretty much torn between the two ..almost
Cept jakes more like a friend.
I like Edwards face cos he looks sad to leave
yet he has no other choice just like in the book

I like how Jacobs in the back cos he's close to the forest
and he has that mean expression like when he had to
join the cult.

Oh yeah n i like that where bella's hand is on Edwards . It looks
like he's slipping away.. fading into her memories

And jacob looks like hes the crutch, holding her up!

PERFECT!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I actually like the original one better! It is more fitting for the storyline of the book. Jacob is trying to come in between Edward & Bella. The original poster shows that better!

I agree with jax!

I think thi is much more an eclipse poster than a new moon .. The official nm poster is great and this would be perfect for eclipse...:)

I don´t think that this is better.... Official poster´s not perfect but there is everything what could be there.. There are great positions of Jake Bella and Edward.. Jake protects Bella before Edward and Edward looks at him absolutelly misanthropically and that´s apposite.. But I think that bella could touch edward by her left hand, not Jake ... it could be better... but this seems like edward hate, or doesn´t want, Bella and bella fawns on him ... that´s not good .. and jake seems there like a jealous ignoramus ... i don´d like it ,´cos it doesn´t apposite the situation ..

Bella is torn between Edward and Jacob, so this is what should be the offical movie poter for New Moon, i agree 10000000000000000000000000000000000% with everyone who thinks the same way,

This poster is nice. But the original shows more of the situation at hand. The "protective" stance of Jacob. Edward being there but his back towards Bella and Jacob with an eye over his shoulder. Sort of like he's missing out on the events that are taking place while he's away. I know a lot of fans would always want to see Bella with Edward forever and ever. But hey, we're only in New Moon. The Twilight movie saga will continue.

Lol! [Gets rid of Jacob.. ] Thats mean but looks sooooooooooooooooo much better 8]

I like this one much better. It kinda shows how Bella is touching his arm but he's turned away and the look on his face shows he's kind of scared. And jacob is turning away from her because in the book they do drift apart.