Noooooooo!!! Why?? Why? Why? Why? Why? Why?
Why did you shoot this scene??? is horrible ..

Let's be realistic on the religious point of view... A sin is a sin whether he is kissing a man or the pictures of him in a bar drinking beer... If your going to condeme him for one then throw the Bible at him for all of it. Being able to place yourself in the role IS acting... It doesn't make him gay, it makes him an excelent actor... ( unless he does announce he's gay... Then I'll cry) Keep in mind this was pre- twilight, has stated in the GQ interview that in was scraping bottom with roles and took it thinking nothing else would transpire.

Its ewww...
Edward is a tall man and MACHO!

ang now he will be a gay ?!
INFERNESS hah ! wahahahha....

he's moves in that scenes are not good ....
he's like a GAY , SUPER !

... that's only part of his job - to kiss a guy and beyond that is nothing more. I don't think Robert is gay, gosh!!!!

looks like Robert is a good kisser, don't you think?

Totally WEIRD!!!!!!

Sexy sexy sexy!

damn some of yall are seriously some intolerant homophobes haha..
im straight but it looked like some pretty good man on man action to me

oh my my hearth cant stop beating why the hell did he kiss a guy then say the guy was a better kisser than kirsten stewart i love rob pattison but what the hell was that eeww no im not accepting gay people it makes me sick

this is the most digusting thing iv ever see
wtf was he thinking.
dugusting.

zOMG! that gave me goosebumps! he is so friggin' hawt!

It's a beautiful scene! I liked a lot!

Some people need to calm down. Rob was acting...he's an ACTOR. I think movies are art, and art is meant to disturb. It gets people talking or thinking about issues, and this is a current issue in the U.S.

poor rob.........

omg i thought the scene was gonna be more explicit and the kiss more like a make-out session!!! what was the buzz all about people???? this is a wonderful production, and this two men are excellent actors!!!! and that was what its all about.... ACTING!! they are not gay in real life.... and you guys make it seem like it was going to be a porn scene or something... it was just a very sweet and innocent kisss between LORCA and DALI... period!!!!

hahahah
CUUUTE

well thats something nobody saw comin & thats not some thing u see everyday

it's quite desturbing & weird

even as I am screaming no no no at my monitor as I watched this-- I still find myself imagining me at the receiving end of that kiss... Doesnt matter who he is kissing-- I still wish it was me...

O Swoon!!

i wish i was kissing edward instead!!!!

WTF

WTF?

okay asm uch I lvoe Rob, I am chrhsitain and I do not want to see two guysm aking out! hosmexuilty is sin. yes many mvoes that I lvoe have or like ahve soem sinful elelemtns like saiyng God's anme in vain (altohugh soemtiems it is onyl sued once), but at the same yeah. but at hts ame tiem it's no bdf, because there arp eelanty other movies to see Rob in guys!

When someone knowingly clicks a link to watch a video clearly marked "man-on-man" but then goes on about how disgusted/offended they are or how immoral it is - it kind of makes you wonder why they couldnt help themselves but to watch it?

People this is practice for Isle Esme, Hello! We also get our own Moonlight swim, so we get to see Rob in two versions, ha see everyone is happy one for the same sex couples and one for the straight folks, So Kristen heads up honey cause YOU ARE NEXT!

its a film based on a influential artist, and a chance to showcase the talent of 2 actors, not an outlet for people to discuss religious and moral beliefs.respect the film for what it is, an if you have that big of an opinion about the clip, the simply, Don't Watch IT! its not rocket science. out of sight.. out of mind!

awww... I think it's romantic and sweet. ^^

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=43sbtkQM6zc

I hope that this won't offend anyone, but I just had to put it here, since it fits very well into this discussion, debate or whatever this is. I kind of understand reactions some people have had to that clip, because I thought very similarly when I was younger. Maybe this goes to the category, you live you learn. Beautiful clip. I hope they show this movie in my country soon (sorry about the english, that America comment was funny though, from here Finland :) )

Aww the movie seems good! I love the atmosphere and there's nothing yucky about this scene as some of you see it... Well I guess the readers of this blog are spread world wide but it's weird how homo phobic some still are. There's nothing wrong with this scene nor the fact that there are two men kissing at all. The only thing that bothers me is jealousy for that Javier guy! I love the way they're circling in the water, cute!

a light bulb has just appeared in my head, why don't we mature Twilight fans offer an iniviation to Paul Morrison the director of Little Ashes to be the director for Breaking Dawn? And who wouldn't mind seeing Javier as Eleazar. Admit it, I'm a genius.

Well my dear Robert you definitely put a spin on that!!! Practive makes perfect!!! Luv ya!!

Whew. I am so happy I missed this CRAP last night!
Hilary, Indies, DeeDee,VampVixen, 30, my hat is off to you ladies for your well said statements! *applauds*

Generally speaking, if you have a problem with the fact that Robert plays a gay man in Little Ashes, NO ONE is forcing you to watch the film! It's that simple. I certainly wouldn't let it affect me to the point where I would miss out on an incredible performance, but to each their own. Everyone has their own limits, everyone has their own opinion, but it doesn't make it right to come onto a public forum and spew hate against homosexuals!

Amen Gina Amen! besides we need more love stories, and I love anything to do with Spain, seen I'm Cuban American, Cubans are Spanish desddants, soo.

You know what people? This is just a movie and they are actors! It's what they do! I'm a Christian and I'm not exactly for this either, but its just a movie! Rob is a great actor! He's straight and can do this movie with no qualms about it and does it well. We can't help that Salvador Dali was gay. It was very much part of his life and Rob plays the part well. He deserves an Oscar for his performance and he might just get one. I'm all for it! Go Rob! We love you!!!!

wow now I know how guys feel when they see two pretty girls kissing. Hehehe yes I'm a perv so sue me.

It's hot :)
Love this dreamy atmosphere...

umm its a kiss and called ACTING i still love rob and think he is straight not becuase he gets a role im going to descriminate no i am not love u rob

Everyone, Robert said that after his past times in movies he wanted to try something new. That is why he went with this movie. Not because he is gay or anything. Both men in this movie are straight NOT gay. I had to clear that up because now people are starting to thing he's gay...i am a HUGE fan. I would know if he's gay. Also it was just a peck. It wasn't like making out. So its nothing to be sickened by.

Rob looks so HOT in the water : D yumyum

i just want to say that i thought the music was beautiful and it was very artistically filmed. i think it was a sweet and romantic scene which im sure it is ment to be.

the website for the film is

http://www.littleashes-themovie.com/synopsis.php

and i think some of u need to grow up. if a certain someone above wanted us all to be the same why'd he make us so diffrent. in the times we live in people are being murdered etc... for just protecting their families, get a life.

dunno blout bsome of u but i was vthinking gthe same as ilovemashocists KEEP SWIMMING lol rob did great he said all the crew were laughing bless him he must have found it hard to concentrate.

Also do u like cruel intentions? buffy the vampire slayer? yes then dont be a hyporite theres gay kisses in gthat also most of the soaps on tv.

sorry people maked me mad

TEAM EDWARD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I agree! My argument with the God crutch in this is, according to various religions God loves his/her/their children right? Well if God is all love, for all of his/her/their children, how could said God hate someone for being different. *shrugs* I don't get it lol.

While I may disagree with the anti-comments (minus the complete nutcases)...it is their opinion. They are entitled to it just as use pro-commenters are entitled to. If someone feels this display of affection is wrong so be it. Part of accepting others is accepting a difference in opinion. Perhaps if we want anti-comments (or whatever) to accept our feelings, then maybe we should try the same. Just because someone is indifferent to this video, or anything like it, does not instantly make them a homophobic. How can we shout at others, who think differently (minus the psychos), about how they NEED to accept our views if we are unwilling to try and understand their opinion.

The whole problem with this world is one side believes they are the ultimate truth. That the opposers are a bunch of idiotic, brain dead sexist/racist/phobic, ignorant people. Let me tell you something before I am flamed. I have dealt with racism my entire life from relatives, supposive friends, and lovers of ALL COLORS. It is not pretty but I accept their views. I will not allow a difference in opinion of my skin tone to bother me. I personally have way too much pride (Native pride woot woot!). If I can do that, so can others. Let's just all get along even if we disagree without name calling.

That being said....I thought it was romantic, and beautiful. Love who you love.

i dont really thingg its good,
im a little desspointed

:(


itss JUST my way to think
andd
i dont really se the "LOVE " in that kiss,
and i dontt know how rob can accepted
i think it dont really seems like i think he was

xd

im so exited about this movie...waiting to watch it soon. Im so glad that im living in this times...where everybody is able to express them self as they wish...is so wonderful when you can share so differents ideas, feelings, point of views, cultures...and you can be open mine about it. I would really like to have the oportunity to play a rol like that that might be a great experience...to walk in somebody else shoes traying to understand a complex personality like the great artist of Salvador Dali...Im glad to watch robert playing this rol...i just adore him and i can see that he did a great job in here

Lol. That was disturbing... :D

i didn't think it was THAT big of a deal. i think the relationship was portraded beautifully... i really want to see this movie. i think movies like this and How To Be will really present him as a great actor and less like an icon... if he can help it lol

I wonder how i can get in the middle of that action yummy

First off, adults who cannot see Rob as Edward anymore, you're close minded.
He is NOT edward Cullen, or Cedric, or whatever. He is just Rob. He loves his craft and he likes testing his limits within it. When you doubt his sexuality or say "Eww Edward wouldn't do that!" you're indirectly disrespecting Rob and dehuminizing him.
Until he states what it is, if it ever comes to that, throw around all the bible talk you want.

Personally, the scene was beautiful because of the lighting and effects. It seemed as more anxious type of kiss than anything to me at least LOL

I repeat,

ROB is NOT EDWARD CULLEN. HE IS AN ACTOR.

I liked it. About 3 things ran through my mind though
first----------------can I join you two :P
second-----------oooooooooooooooo naughty
third....................just keep swimming, just keep swimming, just keep swimming

Your comments is why I think this role is perfect for Rob. It's not about is it okay to be gay or straight, but is it okay to show the person, who holds you affection, the truth about who you are and they still accept it. This scene also shows how people view two men kissing. Fascinating. Really. Rob is fearless when it comes to the roles he portrays, and LOOK AT THE WORK. Leave your opinions behind and just absorb. Then give your opinion. He is absolutely unique. Do you think Zac Efron would do something like this?? Courageous. Bravo!

Its a beautiful thing. I watched it twice. I am not gay, nor does "two guys doing it" turn me on. But, I can APPRECIATE it. If you dont like ACTORS playing the role of gay men, or two guys kissing, then dont click on a link that says " TWO GUYS KISSING " then if u comment and say its gross whose the bigger idiot in all this? U guessed it...U!

It sure ain't no Edward and Bella... but it's still hot : ) Way to go R Patz. Don't listen to the Haters... It's great to see an actor have some balls and take risks. I look forward to seeing the whole film.

i wish that was me.....lucky guy (javier). I liek the kissing scene in Twilight but I hated it when he stopped himself....it was just getting good!

Wow that was tastefully done and very artistic--I was moved by that little clip. Go Robert!!! Thank goodness I decided not to read the comments above lol!

NOOOO though that kiss was breath taking It was not better than the bedroom kiss in Twilight Please Ive seen that part over and over again lol. Rob practiclly atacks her and his face OMGGGG you can even hear him!!! his aggressiveness OMGGGG especally his face in the gazebo in that last kiss... his kissing expresion is perfectoooooooooo.

ok stop! my poor heart can't take your words lol!

Yeah shiiiiiii guess what movie I guna watch now lol. *me drool*

Yeah how can anyone say the Twilight kiss was lame? Hello it's up for Best Kiss, I forget how many times I rewind that scene. but not just the kiss when he throws back on the bed. Sweet heaven can't wait for New Moon, holy mother.

Wow! that scene is hot! For all you haters "Judge not less ye be judged!"

I cant wait to see it this friday, im so excited, i hope it does wonderful at the box office. im heterosexual but that kiss made me catch my breath, thats what wonderful actors can do to you. nicely done. lov u Rob. brunie oxox

All you need is love folks, seriously one of the things that the Twilight Saga taught us is that love has got no boundaries. You think a teen age girl in a love affair with a vampire is normal? Okay what you mean that the Twilight kiss was not good, okay smarty pants, I guess you are new to this, Yes the kiss in Twilight has got to start slow, if you would realize, there are three more movies coming up, New Moon, Eclipse and Breaking Dawn.

This is how you can look at the kisses in the Twilight Saga.

Twilight: Mild
New Moon: Warm
Eclipse: Hotter
Breaking Dawn: Some one call the fire department or Al Gore is going to be peeved.

You know what's disgusting? Bella kissing Jacob, now that will be pukable, Kissing a dog, bah. J/k just trying to lighten the mood, those who are offended don't watch it simple as that.

Now peace, folks. We need more lovin.

Hey, WOW!
This is just a part in a movie for Rob, the way he makes a living not a personal statement. Judge not less ye be judged, for all you who can't see past yourselves.

good kissing scene and im sorry to say but it is way better than twilight although i still love the movie but this kiss is better. im glad rob decided to this movie it shows he is a talented and versatile actor and that just makes me like him even more as an actor.

Wow, there is a lot of drama just for a beautiful portrayal of an artist. If it bothers a person that much, do not see the movie. No one is being forced to watch it. I personally think this just shows how diverse an actor Rob truly is, he has an amazing gift.

I thought out was a beautiful scene. Very well performed. Very classy actually. If that scene had been performed by a man & a woman people would be swooning. I think Robert shows an incredible maturity in his acting being such a young age & I think he's amazing for being able to embrace such a role. I think it speaks volumes of what he is capable of as an actor. I think everyone has the right to their own opinions but I think people should think about this for what it is... An actor doing his job & doing it well, & stop dissecting it & putting a label of right or wrong on it. It doesn't matter either way. All that matters is that the actors did their job, & from what I have read their portrayals were done perfectly in honour of the real life characters they were playing. I can't wait to see the movie!

Gross! Just jealous of Javier!

Damn i forgot to say :) A lot of comments say relax it's only acting so it's ok.

I couldn't give a crap if it's acting or not, Rob would be every bit and beautiful if this was 'for real'.

We don't know Rob, and maybe it seems unlikely, but if he turned out to be gay, it would not make him one bit less special than he is now.

:)

Once again I totally agree, and to me it is gossip yet again. Hearts will be broken starting with mine but regardless who he likes as long as he finds someone he truely loves he has my blessing :)................. please week fly, only five days left !!!!

I was a little shocked at the vitriol on some of the comments :)

I just wanted to say really, that a lot of young people who are struggling with their own sexuality will read the comments here, and they need to know that it not just ok because it's acting :) But it's ok to be who you really are in real life as well :)

Yeah i think people should want him to be happy if he was, not that he is :)

Am putting my soap box away now LMAO

Oh my god :) i missed all the drama here :)

I'm gonna say my piece though....Rob is incredibly beautiful here :) And thats an amazing kiss :) And that's all that really needs to be said :)

can't wait to see this - love Dali, love Rob :) Win win for me :)

I am really looking forward seeing this movie. I enjoy watching Rob do different roles. This clip was so much more romantic than I imagined...I liked the setting.

It's a fantastic movie and i'm glad that he did this. Just proves that he isn't going to price in on being good looking but will do what ever movies interest him.
Good on him.

p.s i'm jealous of javier as well :P

do u now when the movie comes out??????

depends where u live but its out in the uk in a week

I never gat why the director changed though

Wow....This story has caused alot of....emotions out there.....Talk about "rocking the boat"....
What a tremendous actor Rob is! What a challenge it must have been to play such a tormented artist....Salvador Dali was an incredible mastermind of art.....
As far as the whole "God debate".....Pipe down all ye believers!!!.....Simmer it down a notch or two....Take a deep breath and relax yo! It's all good....Worry about your own households.....
I can't wait to see this movie.........For one: To see into the life and mind of Salvador Dali is going to something else.....Secondly: To see Mr. Robert Pattinson portray Dali is going to be priceless!!!!!!!!!!!!! That's my shpeal....

Totally right there with you :) You said it all for me :)

Nicnix xx

Oh my sweet, sweet Edward!!! Jeez... is it really sad for me to be jealous of Javier? Damn it... 'cause I really AM!! This is so sweet in a strange way... I still love MY sweetie pie... I can't wait to watch the movie =]

I'm jealous of him too. *hangs head in shame* LOL

Hey Indie, maybe we can fantasie of Us being the center of that Oreo cookie, kinky
I know.

LMAO! Why are you taunting me?! You know I cant go there! Arghhhhh!!! LOL

LOL... I knew you would be too!! But there's no need to hang our heads in shame.... it's okay... it's okay LOL

LMAO!

LOL is it even worse to be jealous of both of them?? I am :)

It's not like Javier fell out of the ugly tree :) That man's a bit of a babe too :)

Oh yeah, thats for sure, Javier is smoking hot too...I wouldnt say no to him either. LOL

Yeah I wouldn't throw Him out of bed either. I have a weakness with men with spanish accent. Oh lawd.

oh so do i :) or just men who are drop dead gorgeous :) and they both are :)

i just saw your oreo cookie comment :) Now that's my brand of cookie :) LMAO

Ewwwwww...........................

And I thought Brokeback Mountain caused drama. Calm down girls! I would rather watch this tasteful representation of human emotion, then a marathon of I love New York. No one yells about straight whores having sex with 20 men, but a kiss between two men and the Bible gets brought out, the earth splits open, and the apocolipse is coming.

Open up your eyes, there here-there actors-and you better get used to it!

I agree!! Well said!! LOL

er....guyz are real!!! hahhh...rob looks likE a gay really... hehehehe,.... amazing dUdE...

This makes me laugh haha you rock.

hahaha yeah i agree but it was hard to stomach because it is Rob and hes just so gorgeous...just difficult to see with a er man:/
yet again he picked the role and knew what it entailed so yeah...that was all Rob you guys.lol.
and i agree with twifan89 i love new york is effing halarious!
hahaha

the fact that he chose this role, makes him a REAL actor and a Real man. thats what i admire most about him, he's not afraid to challenge himself and take risky roles.
which one was him, the one on the right?

yeah i think so...yeah at least he is comfortable enough with his sexuallity to handle and be mature about the role.
ah sweet rob:)
lol.

Yeah I agree Hilary. I happen to think that was a very beautiful, sensual and innocent scene from Little Ashes. I don't think boy on boy is bad. And in Little Ashes it's about love and it's sweet and innocent in nature.

yea but i somehow dont think it was that innocent in real life, if it happened at all.

haha, but peopel do react to the wohle girl rpnmocis gurisl. I am chritian and as much I lvoe rob, I r am not a supprot of hosemxualtiy though I am not aohmohpic. it isasin but I'm not gonna join osme god hates hosmexual groups. God doesn't ahte anybody.

I couldn't agree with you more.

but i have to admit that i watch i love new york cuz its EFFING HILARIOUS bahaha if you watched the second season you would get how comedic it is. i really don't have a comment about the actual topic lol

LIKE OMG ... a guy kissing a guy .. OMG!! PPL .... come on .. lets be simple about thissssss


Cause that doesn't happen EVERY DAY!! GROW UP!!! I would never condemn someone for their sexuality.

LMCullen

LMAO!!!! I love your comments!!!

xo

LOL, "Let's be simple about this"!!! Guys, guys...

That's exactly what i thought! Haha. "I'm just a sweaty guy!" Hahaha.

bhahahaha Good One!!! lmao...cheeseburgers haha

LOL, cheeseburgers! Oh I need to go watch that again!

kimberlina: ok this is super random but i was just looking at the twicon post from like 2 weeks ago and i came across your post that you said you live in dallas...i live in plano! are you going to twicon? do u know if there are any tickets left? ahhhhh i just learned about this way too late!!!

Do itttt hahaha. i can do without kristen and catherine commenting because nothing came close to how funny rob was!

I'm confused. I'm a little new to this site... what are you talking about with the cheeseburgers thing??? and the actors commenting?? so confused *no hating, i'm a twilight freak, just new to the site...*

no worries =) welcome! we're all pretty friendly, we only get a bit upset if people bash the news or make ill comments.

the cheesburger thing is actually something Rob Pattinson said during the commentary on the DVD of Twilight. if you go to special features on the DVD and do directors commentary..it's Rob, Kristen Stewart, and the Director Catherine Hardwicke commenting on different parts of the movie. Cheeseburgers was something really funny he said when commenting about a line he said during the movie! haha if you haven't watched it yet, you should because it is hilarious!

I love Robert Pattinson even more now....

me too :)

well if that was possible :) lol

really beautiful scene. Rob is a phenomenal actor.

Its the same moon from twilight

This kiss was better than Twilights one.
It had much more meaning.

yea the kissing in twilight was pretty lame..i hope NM and eclipse are better..Rob even said that his co-star in little ashes was a better kisser than kristen stewart...lol

I was so moved by this kiss and it made me melt when I saw the intensity and the passion between the two characters - then of course, I made the mistake of coming onto here just to see the dumb "Adam and Steve" comments. That is getting so old seriously! I am so tired of people putting others down because they don't believe in the gay community. Whatever if you think it's wrong. You don't speak for all of us when you say it's not right. And throwing God and Jesus into this little fight isn't helping either. God loves everyone. Regardless of who they love and who they kiss.

Wow..its crazy how a lil movie clip can stur up so much controversy and religious arguments..wow people..its time to grow up...there are plenty of other actors who have potrayed gay/lesbian characters..frankly, i think its courageous to portray someone like that..i give props to Rob and Kristen and nikki in the upcoming k-11 films...i hope that movie is sexy..lmao!!

The whole time I watched that I kept hearing Bella in the ballet studio screaming NO EDWARD DONT! lol

For the record I was just being funny there, I personally am straight but have NO ISSUE at all with anyone elses "affiliations" if it isn't in my bed, it aint my bizznes!

I am really not shocked byt how many people disapprove of Rboert kissing another man, I feel for thos of you that dn't want to see this clip or the movie "DON'T GO SEE IT OR CLICK PLAY" Personally I don't mind it , he id doinga job that is how I look at this. He is telling a story about about someone and if you feel that you can't handle or spprove of don't click play...I personally am glad he did this movie, itshows how good of actor he is, he is up to any type of role that he is offered.

For people who are closed minded, don't like same sex couples You have that right but don't come on here bashing an actor for taking a role in movie. Most of you people who dislike same sex couples are close minded. They don't understand that people are born that way. Just for the record I have family memebers who are gay, lesbians. I still love them for who they are. I give much props to Robert for taking this role and letting the world know he can do more mature adult films then PG-13 movies.

I was SO scared. It wasn't that bad though. kinda romantic in a weird way :)

If there was a video entitled "Rob Kicks a Puppy" I would not watch it because 1) I think that's wrong and it goes against my animal-friendly lifestyle and 2) it would make me cry.

I would not watch it.

If you see something labeled as "man on man action" and you believe that same-sex relations are wrong, then WHY on Earth do you hit "play?" Is it because deep down inside of your Rob lusting self there is a teensie weensie part of you that wanted to see some hot Rob/Javier action?

i totally agree with you!

and
rob is absolutely awesome!

Oh my gosh THANK YOU! Someone who has some sense!!!

P.S. I'm animal-friendly as well >_<

My last comment,

I'm so glad Rob did this movie, even if it was before Twilight, now he wont be stuck in the Tween type of films only, hes a very talented person and deserves respect even if fans don't agree with his decisions.

ok im done. Play nice kids :-)

Exactly! Hopefully he will not be typecasted since he has done other films with very different characters. Like I said in my other post, Rob is a versatile actor:)

Was that comment directed at me InSearchOfEldorado ? No you are right, I'm sure everyone in the world shares YOUR views. Yes, I'm sure all the anti poster are coming from one person.

I replied to you so yeah, it is directed to you obviously.

No, I don't think that everyone in the world shares my views. And No I'm not saying that ALL anti posters are coming from one person.

I'm just mentioning few: 'cullen fam', ' what r u', 'ec', ' hale fan', 'Emmmmett'....And for gods sake see it for yourself
http://disqus.com/people/5c82f5b6221b8d13040d79...

Thanks for the info insearchOfEldorado. I didnt know we could see that. Thank God im only 1 person lol

but why do you change your username all the time ? first twi fan,then what r u,ec,cullen fam,hale fan,now this. what's the point in this?

I thought about that statement RED REI after I posted it.. I should correct myself haha...
99% of us are SUPPOSED TO BE ADULTS! LOL

Just because you watch something, doesn't say anything about whether you like it or not. Haven't you sat through annoying commercials!? Give me a break.

Can I just ask you one question...why are you changing your username with every post "Twi fan"?

Are you trying to make it look like a lot of people are sharing your views?

You do realise we can see that you are the same poster over and over again.

hahaha good one

I personally worked in a gay bar and I am straight as they come.. I have gay friends and they all know I dont agree with their lifestyle, but that doesnt mean they dont love me or I love them any less. Its their choice, and whatever anyone believes, they can face whatever to whomever their creator is...
SEE HOW THAT WORKS.. TO EACH THEIR OWN!
BUT PERSONALLY! I could have gone myyyyy entire life without seeing Rob kissing another man.. that just ruined the whole kissable thing for me.. give a month til I forget then he will be kissable for me again ROFL!
I love him as an actor and I think hes amazing with the way he handles himself. He chose this role as a challenge, and whether or not anyone agrees with it. He did an amazing job portraying it...
but again, wow, I sooo need something to scratch that out of my brain.. Gonna go read my books and watch Twilight over and over til I remember him kissing bella lol

and if you dont like what I say, then thats your opinion, but seriously, arguing about it on a fan site is really childish, and thats pretty damn sad considering 99% of us are adults here

Actually 35% off visitors to this site are kids, and some off those kids could be struggling at the minute with their sexuality, then they come on here and read comments that say its ewww, gross and wrong and immoral. That alone is going to make them feel worthless and even more comfused.

So this is for any kid out there reading this who are struggling with there sexuality and don't understand or are confused.....There is nothing wrong with you, what is happening to you is normal and just another way off life. Its not gross, its not wrong and it's certainly NOT immoral. It's who you are, so love yourself for being you and shut out all the narrow minded fools on here. Your family and friends will still love you for being who you are, and that is all thats important!

99% of adults,I somehow doubt it after reading comments under this video.

Unfortunately a high percent of adults here behave like childs.

Your right, they are a bunch off narrow minded biggots, makes me ill to my stomach they way they act.

And welcome Chris I don't think I've seen you here before!

SO true Chris. You hit the nail on the head with that.

hehe that's true.

Christ,if someone is offended by it,DO NOT WATCH IT, it's freaking as simple as that. And save your moronic comments to yourself. Rob is not the first and not the last actor to play in such a movie,what's the big deal really?

Why did we watch?? Ever heard of curiosity?

The whole point is that it self explanitory from the title alone, your where forewarned what would happen in the clip, if you knew you didn't like it why watch it?!?!

yeah curiosity,the first step to hell

LMAO! I really find that funny. LOL

oh and ever heard the saying that "curiosity killed the cat"?

hahaha thats a really good one.. funny but true all the same

Regretful about watching/reading these comments. Wish I wouldn't have even found this page. Going back to the books. *shudder*

Here's the difference, there's a way to say something on a blog, and a way not to say something, being rude and disrespectful gets people mad and fights start. Obviously people are entitled to there own opinion I'm a big fan of that one, but why if people are offended by this movie would they even bother to watch the clip is beyond me.

wow. that was so gay. i still love robert though :)

Anyone?

No offense. But I just find the scene repulsing. I know Rob is a great actor and very brave for acting this type of role. But it just gross and i dont know honestly why you guys like this scene.yuck!

if you are repulsed by that kind of stuff, why would you watch it in the first place?

i would watch anything with robert pattinson in it honestly
but two guys kissing not my thing thats all i saying
don't get mad or upset about it, it is just my opinion

and who deleted my comment?

Ok so can someone please tell me y my comment got deleted?? Now im pissed because it was not offensive or rude.. and deff not near as bad as some others on here

Man, the scene is romantic. No discussion.

Thank you, haha.

The music is really sweet, don't ya think? I love the music! as for the kissing thing, I'm afraid to say what I'm thinking because i might just start another argument here...so the music was GREAT! =) does anyone else agree?

Last time I checked, this site was started and is being run by an American. Obviously if you aren't one then the comment above wouldn't apply to you. Duh

it was just a peck, gosh! no need to freak!

Has any one ever heard "If you have nothing nice to say dont say anything at all" ?

Please no more bible talk. This is a website for newmoon and the actors not bible class. Sorry I know I'm being rude but enough already.

All of you people who are supposed to be so open-minded are really rude for being mean to the person who said they didn't like the clip, or the fact that it was being shown. HHHHHHHHHHEEEEEEEEEEELLLLLLLLLLLLOOOOOOOOOOO, this is America, we are all entitled to our opinion. Just because you are in love with the clip, doesn't mean everyone should be.
So keep your PISSY comments to yourself!!!!!!!!!!

There's a difference between freedom off speech and being darn right rude in that freedom. And no it's not America, there is people from all over the world on this site, me being from Northern Ireland knows that. You can be entitled to your opinion without being rude or offensive!

This is not America....this is internet.

lol

LOL, SO true!!!

I couldn't watch, but I second the *choking, puking* comment earlier. And I'll add *barfing, gagging* to it as well.
Robert seems like a wonderful, talented guy. No offense to him, I just think we should have left Dali's life where it was. Out of sight, out of mind. Don't know if I can get back to a pure picture of Edward now after reading some of these comments.
And don't bother responding with hateful comments, I won't be reading from here anymore. *shuddering repeatedly*

Ok in the bibble you read stories about MEN and WOMEN....NOT MEN and Men.....that is very rong...team taylor iz da best cus he's not in gay movies

*facepalm"

For people who enjoy movies for the story, Little Ashes is a good one.

I've done a lot of reading since being laid off... and the story of that period of Dali's life is absolutely heart wrenching. I really hope the entire cast can pull off such a film.

As for the kiss itself... it was beautiful and memorable, which is what moments like that are supposed to be.

And for everyone "disgusted" by such things... why did you watch it, then?

Ok,well i dont care about guys being with guys.No biggie love is love.It's just really weird seeing Robert kissing a dude!Ever since Broke Back Mtn there has been more and more movies with guys.And it's just odd.That's not Rob.It's just weird.=| Im gonna see the movie.Will i like it.More likely not.But i do support Rob.I just dont like that roll!

OMG! get over it, its just acting. so what if they kiss hes getting payed for it thats his job, i personaly dont like it but if hes ok doing it then there shouldnt be a problem. as a true fan of rob i will support him with whatever he decides to do.

P.S i found this video and sent them the link ..and they didnt put thanks karen:( how sad!!

Who wouldn't wanna kiss Rob? :)
I think this scene was well done. Actually kind of cute.
Rob is a good actor and I think he will do good in this movie.
Has anyone seen the trailer for this movie? it looks good.

its just a movie! hes ACTING because hes an ACTOR....Its not Rob...hes playing a role....thats it.....

yes it's not Rob.it's Dali. two totally different persons.

exactly

to all those people making religious comments about this scene and movie you are being slightly hypocriticall because what do u think GOD would have to say about u being in love with a vampire it hardly follows the bible now does it. So leave the subject alone, at the end of the day it is only ACTING people .

Personally, I'm in love with the actor (person) who plays the role of a vampire.

It's pretty sad when in THIS country and THIS day and age, people are so bigot minded and just plain pathetic. a.) it's a role. b.) even if it weren't just a role, homophobia just plain sucks and people who are so closed minded that they are policing someone else's love life are just pathetic.

The man can act his ass off, he's smart and diverse enough to take a variety of roles that can showcase his range instead of staying in the pigeon hole of Twilight (which, by the way, as a film SUCKED. And yes, I'm a fan of the saga and Pattinson). Get over it. He's an actor. I suppose if he plays Hitler in a movie that makes him a Nazi.

So many great actors have done that in the past. Di Caprio,Heath Ledger,Sean Penn,James Franco(recently),Damon,Hanks,Gyllenhaal and many more all played in such movies. I applaud him for taking on that role. Not everyone would have the balls to do it. You certainly wouldn't see that ladyboy Efron do something like that.

LOL @ that ladyboy efron....LMaO, my sentiments exactly..i said the same thing earlier..this role will set rob apart from all thes lame ass actors and actresses in hollywood..as i said earlier, remeber haliry swank in BOYS DONT CRY, no one knew her. the film was a strong true life movie. i love haliry swank so much. she nail that role to a tee..and what happen? she got two oscars under her belt ....so rob is going the right way and i love it. all the edward cullen fans can back off..lol i do like edward, but i m more of a rob fan and true fans support their actors and can distinguish between movies and reality

Jules60 if its true (I haven't heard about it) but if its true, I would defiantly watch it. Sounds interesting to me. Though im not a Nikki Reed fan, I would still watch it.

Can't wait to see all the movies Rob is in. This one especially!! Love edgy roles!

I think it was well done, good on Rob for not being scared to make a film like that. I think its a good way of showing a gay kiss without beeing nasty like most people think in there mind.

As for all the God talk i just wanted to say, if God wanted us to all be the same why are we all so different? As long as you live your life with love and happyness and your not hurting anyone then thats amazing and i'm sure God just wants us all to be happy.

I pray to God all the time for the right thing to do and he knows my heart and i'm a good person. So if i wanna kiss another girl or boy then it doesn't matter love is love.

Just don't be a sl*t about it.

i dont see what the big fuss is about and this comment is to the person who said it wasnt romantic, but morally wrong...infact, my previous comment was also a response to that..sean penn. heath ledger amongst others did gay movies and they didnt get no heat...they got praises. all of a sudden, poor rob did a movie he felt passionate bout before the twilight frenzy and now cuz he's famous or larger than life, so people are making all these comments bout his sexuality or a fuss bout the movie....hes so freaking goood in that movie and he might just get an oscar nod..so people dont hate...rob is not any kind of buff guy so he might get in a lot of shyt about the ppossibility of being bisexual or gay.... he used to be a model duh..and plus he's not really metrosexual, unlike zac efron and the rest..love his scruffy look.....he's not buff, but they got a lot of buff guys that are on the DL.....so people need to back off about gay rumors and other stufff...im going to be so happy and laughing come oscar time when hopefully he's nominated..i will be smiling at the haters

Listen people he is just acting! This is base on a real life person, and this is what happened. This man was a bisexual, and this is a movie about his life. Why are people fighting about God. What is the fight about? Rob acting in this type of movie, or Dail’s life? Well, he is a good actor and this was a challenging role, maybe you don’t like him acting in this type of role, but that’s what actors do they play a role.

Everyone please remember that these are actors playing a PART!

This is not Rob P. and it is not Edward, it is Salvador Dali. Who led a difficult and tragic life. He had lots of issues and problems and acted quite crazy at times.

For Rob to attempt to play him, knowing how difficult it was going to be, and to put such passion into learning about the man and doing his best to portray him true to life is quite amazing.

I, as a teacher, do want to see this movie.

Yes, if there are some graphic homosexual scenes, I will probably feel uncomfortable during that part. But, that is Dali, a very strange and complicated man, but a very gifted artist.

However, if this clip is a good example of the rest of the movie, it was tastefully done.

Please remember that this is Salvador Dali and Federico Garcia Lorca (who was great writer and poet, by the way), not Rob Pattison or Javier Barden

aww....... i think thats sweet......... dont know why..... jejeje
wow...... jux shows how wonderfull he is............ even men want him

time i sign off on this..this was very romantic due to the lightening etc...rob is versatile and i cannot wait to see this..now moving along..this is not a religious site to discuss imorality or not..i personally odnt have nothing against homosexuals because i have a lot of them as my friends..and p.s, rob is playing a character, so i dont see the need for people to discuss imorality with this..i think the sence was more romantic than the kissing scene in twilight....only God can judge us alll...God love all of his children and also, not everyone that goes to church is holy and we shouldnt forget that the bible was written by man on what they wanted civilization to obey and follow..even though they say its Gods word, but the bible is one of the most books that people see some error with in the writting and messsage as opposed to others..so lets all just keep this topic as the movie sence and how romantic it is and forget about in the beginning there was adam and eve, not adam and steve stuff...persoanlly. religious topics give me headaches..ugh..LOL

whats wrong with a movie like this? did I miss something?

Yes apparently you missed the 1950's along with the rest of us ;)

i reallly wonder y rob would want 2b in a movie like that. he's a good actor and w/ his rep. he could play almost any part

wow it looks like something created out of a dream sequence, very tastefully done. Is it wrong I totally said 'awe!!!' ?

So cute & romantic :) ♥

I thought he did a great job! The water is phosphorescent that's one reason it looks so cool. Very romantic...looks like a fantastic movie with possible Oscar mentions all the way around.

ok...im cool with gay people but i really don't want to actually see the action....and with robert, well lets say now when i watch twilight kissing scenes i'll be a little creeped out.

agreed

well then be prepared to be 'creeped out' even more after NR and Kristen film their movie K-11.

Like I said before..they'll see Kristen as a gay Joan Jett as well, before K-11 comes out.

omg k-11 and the runaways are gonna be awesome movies!!! Lets get it on!!

they certainly will be. I'm happy for all of them,those are very big career moves on their parts,huge steps towards not being typecast and being seen only as Edward,Bella,Rosalie....get out of that teen idol trap guys, you're too good for it..

i know i agree...the best way to establish a resume is to play a gay character..lol..just kidding..but it does help with publicity..

you gotta admit that was pretty gross

And you just proved that you are a one year old, mommie and daddy shouldn't let you on the computer until you reach a certain age.

I was like a deer in head lights....couldnt look away..but not really sure if i wanted to watch...not so bad...really romantic...I will def see it when it comes out on dvd

That was certainly .. different. Not bad .. just .. gave me goosebumps ya know *Laughs* Gosh. I'm kinda Jealous. I mean .. kisses from Rob Pat. Woo !

Art is Art it doesn't discriminate and neither should people nor judge it. I give Rob a lot of credit for doing this movie ! So far what I have seen its not a porn flick, its a movie about a persons life.

Rob looks sexy as hell no matter who he kisses girl or guy! I cant wait to see this hole movie!

Thanks for posting this newmoon.org

i think they both look gorgeous here :) and i'm seeing that movie for sure :)

;)

Omg I was hyperventalating the whole time... then when it got to this kiss scene I was like oh, that wasn't that bad... lol. :)

The scene is very romantic, but weird because I see "Edward Cullen" kiss a guy lol

Don't get mad at me Rob's addicts, but I always thought that Rob is gay.

Wow you do actually realise that he is acting? That this is a movie?
And now your "suspicions" are confirmed because you seen him ACTING.

This is what always happens when ever someone plays a bi or gay person. I bet now when Kristen and Nikki get it on in their next project people will think they are really lesbians.

yup. you are right. when kristen and nikki does K-11, people will say they are gay...ugh...he's acting..acting is art, entertainment and it doesnt and shouldn't discriminate people...rob is only getting this crap because he isn't buff like other guys...most buff guys are the ones on the DL any way. rob has a beautiful look and he's clearly not really metrosexual like zac efron..LOL. i do however love rob scruffy look..he a beautiful man who both sexes fantasize about, so people get a grip. sean penn acting gay in MILK recieved praises and an oscar, not heat about his sexuality...this is so sad how low people think..oh i guess because rob dont have a girlfriend now..people forget to know that this was a pre-twilight movie and we probably won't be talking a lot bout it or see it if rob wasn't famous from twilight...and all those people who say, "ewww..i love rob as edward and seeing him kiss a man gross me out and watching twilight will be creepy now," sorry, but you are not in love with rob or a true fan, you love edward and last time i check, true fans ride or die with ther actors...p.s rob is not a factional character...hope he gets an oscar nod..i can feel it..ok i got it off my chest

Well, they will get to see Kristen in a gay role before K-11. Joan Jett is gay, and Kristen and Dakota Fanning will be gay lovers in the Joan's Biopic.

Rob is not the first to portary such a role and get criticized, Heath Ledger did also, as well as many others, and i'm sure Rob wont be the last.

No.
I thought about the idea of Rob gay or bi whatever, before I see him in Twilight so ..
Maybe I'm wrong, but I'd be not surprised if one day Rob says "I love men".

Ok, if you followed his career so thoroughly before Twilight so you have a "feeling" about him.
I just wonder what would you think if Tay played a gay person and if that story was around for a while before the release of NM for example......

I would be very sad LOL
No seriously. I told you what I thought. I love Rob, he's a very good actor. If he's gay, bi, hetero, whatever, I'll always like him.
The same for Tay, but I'll be I little upset because I'm in love with him lol

You just don't like Rob, you don't think he will, but you don't know what kind of roles Taylor will play.

Sorry, I am a bit pissed because I've read a lot of stupid things on the net in relation to this clip.
People can be really dumb, and especially Twilight fans which I am sad to say.
So sorry if I was a little jumpy :D

No worries ;)
I understand ! :D

thats why i LOVE EDWARD, edward and rob are not the same at all, they dont even look alike. i know edward would never do that.

OMG. I didn't know how to feel before they started kissing. I was a bit nervous...lol But it was a beautiful scene, very romantic. Maybe I'll see this movie after all...

oh dear, so many girls (me included :D) would like to go swimming w/ mr.pattz and give him a kiss so sweet like the one javier gave him....well, rob is very professional and mature, that's another 10 pts for my baby!!!!

Hum all I gotta say is im going on Friday to support Robert and anything that he does. N also I am Spanish so i would love to see some history behind it. Woot woot cant wait till Friday =)

i agree with indiesr and qwerty get out of ur ass for a minute and stop being so homophobic there still people who really gives a shit

No matter what anyone says this is my opinion and everyone is intitled to have one so no comments that say anything rebutting my comment please:

That was romantic and very sweet. I'm happy that in an uncomfertable situation Rob and Javier can pull-something very different for them-off so well. I'm very happy with that scene and can't wait to see the rest of the movie!!!

This just shows how versatile of an actor Rob is. Even though he portrays Edward Cullen in the Twilight Saga:) , its refreshing to see him in other rolls. BTW, loved him in How To Be. Great little film. awwww Rob<3<3<3

wow! one word dude.... WEEEEEEIIIIRD!!!!!!!!!!!! i wonder how he felt... *shivers*....

I agree. It would be so weird if u were straight to kiss another guy. How strange would the conversation be between Rob n the other guy before and after this this scene?? Like what do you talk about when u've just kissed another guy!? lol.

also, the quality on this video wasnt very good. hopefully someone can post a better one soon.

ROFL. that was priceless.

I STIIL LOVE HIM! but i don't liked.... it was awfal jaja

If I weren't so disturbed by the fact they are both actually kissing, I think the scene would have been awesome. I loved the lighting, or lack thereof. I think that made it more bearable, and I guess "sweet," though I'm still kind of.. eh. It's just so strange to see Rob play such a vulnerable character like Dali. I know Rob isn't the manliest of men, but he seems too fragile here. Which I'm sure was the desired effect. So good on him.

Who was twirling around in the water like a maniac? Lol! I do that, it's fun.

um...what is this movie about...

its a biopic of Salvador Dali, the artist.

thats romantic, and artistic and beautiful. If your in love with someone I dont know what is wrong with it.

um...that's it? i thought this was sultry...

ewwww do i see penis in that action?????? HOW COULD U ROB????affffffghhhhhhhikjklhmahhllluuuuu......!!!!!! [chocking and puking]

This just proves what I think about some of Twilight fans....
and I just knew that this will happen, people just don't understand when someone is acting. They can't separate actors as persons from their roles.
Most of them are either homophobes, or are delusional and they see Edward kissing a man or they're just dumb.
If you don't have anything smart to say than don't say anything at all.

I'm just sick of it, I've read moronic things on the net in last couple of days about this...it's just terrible

yea i am a twilight fan, but not crazy to not understand acting and reality..some of the moronic things being said are truely frustrating..gosh so what if rob was gay? big deal. he would have loyal fans like some of us, but he's not. in the movie, it isn't edward cullen kissing another. it's rob character Dali kissing another man. edward stays in twilight..i personally dont dive a dayum if rob did a hideous role, more grafic than this, i would be happy because it would seperate him from the rest like the ones like zac efron still singing HSM...people need to stop complaining...i will so be smilling like i said during oscar when he gets nominated hopefully...i can feel the oscar buzz already...like when hilary swank did BOOYS DONT CRY, one of my favorite movies and actresses of all time..it was small, independent and i felt oscar buzz and now look, she got two..inorder to get acknoweldge in hollywood, you gotta go the way rob is trying to go or else you will be loss in the dumb crowd like linsday lohan...and the rest..need i say more

Agreed! Boys Don't Cry was a beautiful film. Heartbreaking, but beautiful! Hilary's academy award was well deserved!

Oh come on grow up seriously, the film is about dali, you knew what you would see just by the title, if you don't like it don't watch it!

They're wearing boxer shorts. >_<

wow, it was a very beautiful scene!! it's so romantic and sweet. The drops of sea water are so hypnotic...

omg that's so hot, I wanna watch that movie now.

I think its hot, just my opinion. Things like this is what is going to get his name known and show how briliant he is, all great actors have been there, portraying a gay man, Tom Hanks , Matt Damion..... Its a character, thats what we have to look at its not Rob himself a chatacter, it was romatic and sweet, and like I said I think it was hot.

discusting...i like him better when he's kissing kristen :) lol

hahaha..if u thought this was bad...wait til u see the nude love scene..lol

You could say you didn't like it instead off disgusting, this is what acting is all about, Rob did this role fantastically and I take my hat off to him for going out off his comfort zone.

YAY!!! I cant wait to see this movie! He done so much research for this role, just to get into character more, so he could give his truest interpretation of Dali & I think hes going to be amazing! I admire him so much it takes a lot of courage for a young actor like Rob to do his first sex scene ever with a guy! Ive read a lot of smack talk about him doing a gay role, but good actors take challenges, and thats what this was for him and lets face it, we all love Rob so much we would watch him no matter what hes doing or who hes doing it with lol

Totally agree.

Aww that was romantic :) Good for Rob for doing something like that :) Many actors would never touch something like that so go Rob!

Even through the layers of ultimate jealousy I can tell that this is one romantic well made scene :)
I admire both Rob and Javier for the courage to take up the challenge of those roles :)

layers of jealousy...I have those too... :-)

That's for sure, I admire them both. They are not the first actors to portray such roles on film, and I'm sure they wont be the last. Kudos to them.

well said IndiesR - 100% agree...and bizarrely it was kinda cute to watch

Hmmm...not sure what to say about him kissing another man. Although they way the scene was done very well. It had a romantic feel to it. He does have some balls to do that. =)

I am not into watching guys make out....but damn...even Rob can make this scene still sexy....he can do no wrong....I dont get it.

I'll just pretend that was me in the water instead

That's what I do too....but I have to admit, I do that regardless if he's kissing a girl or boy. LOL

wow...idk what to say about this one. It was actually kinda cute(or maybe i was just fasinanted by Rob himself) but the fact that he's kissing a man is a lil bit disturbing.

That was so romantic. A little awkward...But romantic!
Go Rob! You've got some balls to go and do that for a movie!

word!

i thought it was very romantic and emotional. even though I haven't seen the movie, I can tell the romantic development between the two of them just in this scene.

I can't wait to see this movie; a lot of young actors wouldn't take a chance on a movie like this. Good for you Robert for pushing the envelop... ;) You're hot, no matter who you are kissing!

Wow, I need to see this movie.

i know me too.

omg. that was pretty cute. i found it funny that he said in a past interview that that guy who he kissed is a better kisser than kristen stewart. i wish i was that guy

Can I join in? :)

awwwww Rob is gping to be AMAZING at this movie!! Can't wait to see it. I knew the guy could pull it off.

I think its romantic! That's my little spunk, he melts the hearts of men as well as women. Cant wait to see this movie. :)

It was a beautiful scene. Didn't anyone read the recent survey that found women get as turned on by man-on-man sex as man-on-woman? Rob's just proved it true!

Hey Indie what you think of my idea of Paul Morrison being the Breaking Dawn director and Javier being cast as Eleazar?

It really doesnt matter what I think, what does Summit think? LOL

P.S. I wouldnt object to Javier in any role in the Twilight saga. :)

Oh you bet ya!! He melts my little Edward-loving heart *sighs*

aw...it shows that he really IS pashionate about his work! I am sure he didnt WANT to do it (unless he has something to tell us XD) but he is always saying how he enjoys taking on different roles in films, so it must have just been a good oppitunity for his acting career.

I think this scene was really well done! I loved the drops of se water at the beginning!

The reaction to kiss him must be completely involuntary, i mean who would or could resist him!!

Gah that was hot Kim wasn't it? UH! Sweet dreams!

I'm glad i'm not the only one who thinks thats hot :) lol

LOL, Oh no you're not. I can't stop watching it...I just need to jump in that pool!!

Yes it was kim lol, my spanish rob dream tonight is going to be awesome LMAO

Personally, I couldnt resist Rob in anything. :)

ya i agree :D

I think that is one of the most beautifully done scenes I've seen in a while..I was watching that wather and how it drops from their fingers, I was almost mesmerized by it.

It really is romantic, they've said it was tastefully done. They were right.

Ah! Romantic indeed. Every time I watch this scene, I picture skinny dipping in Isle Esme. *blushes*

Agree, i think it's one of the most beautiful movie scenes i've seen for a while :)

I have nothing against gays. It's just with Rob it seems really wrong. I watched it for like the fifth time just before and I really was trying to see how you guys think it's romantic but I really couldn't. Sorry :/

That's definetly not romantic that's disgusting and morally wrong! What's happening to the world where people think men should be having relations

Well eating humans is disgusting and wrong, but I'm assuming that since you visit this site, you're a fan of movies where humans (dead former humans, whatever you want to call them) eat other humans.

haha, EXACTLY!

Are you kidding me?? You are joking, right? If you are not, then there is something wrong with you! So sad, that there are still people like you out there in the world! I don't get how you can't understand that love is love, no matter what! You don't decide who you fall in love with!

Damn troll!

What???? are you serious, catch yourself on you narrow minded fool!!!! do you go to the same brain washing school as Miss California!!!!!!!

HA HA as soon as I read the comment I was thinking "Miss California, is that you?"

I know right, it's been like all over the internet about Miss California and when I was reading the comments I was seriously thinking it was her, or they went to the same school or something LOL

everyone is entitled to their opinion however this is a bit much - this site is for talking about the NMmovie and other movies it's star make - its not a soap box for controversy. please think before submitting thanks

Wtf? Why does it matter? Its their LIFE stay out of it! Really.

Mind your own business, and your OWN damn life! Thanks! :)

Then why don't you mind your own business and stay out of my life?

you came in all of our lives when you started this so why don't you go where you came from and take your bigoted views with you!! SHUT THE HALE UP AND BUGGER OFF!!!!!

I'm not trying to get in your business, its just wrong to judge people because of their Sexual Orientation.

Have a little bit of respect for their life choices.

girl you stole TSH picture!! LMAO watch out!! hhaha

WHO STOLE MY AVTAR!!!!!!!! LMAO

does anyone have this photo yet?? i'm not gonna step on toes, and i have tons of him... so, let me know and i can change it!! thanks :O)

I've not come across it but I don't pay attention to Rob... I pay attention to the pack ...and carlisle!!

and the doc? come on tsh you cant have em all....LMAO

all of them!! I want them ALL!!! LMAO

NOT ME NOT ME hahahha LMAO =)

LMAO!! But thank you very much for noticing and getting TJ3 to change her's else I would get angry *hulk voice* 'and you won't like me when I'm angry!' lol

LMFAO i just pictured the hulk saying that! hahaha soo funny!

LMAO! We have this unspoken rule that no one can steal another's avtar! It's wonderful! Don't take my Awesome Oscar Rob!

LOL we need to make the rule official when people sign up!!

We do, no need to have people getting catty on here over a picture!!

hahha AWESOME OSCAR ROB!!! i would NEVER steal him, but i love loVE LOVE that picture of him! so sillly!

I know I told Kimberlina yesterday that everytime I see her avtar it crack me up! lmao

Thank you for being kind and not stealing him! There are other really good pics of him being goofy!

haha i'm loving that pic btw...guess i haven't seen the photos of him wearing fangs!

I think this is the wrong thread but who cares! Yes, I am going to TwiCon with a couple other girls from here, there should still be some tickets left! But they are pricey!

its from the VMAN shoot...there is one of all the twiguys wearing them

Haha,
Idk how this works so i'm a little slow on pictures, but i think I THINK i changed it. :)

Then answer me this...why aren't u having any respect of my life choice

Is judging others your life choice? I bet God loves it.

You do have a point.

jeez, it just bothered me the way you wrote that. Saying its 'disgusting' was a little bit harsh!

But it is your LIFE CHOICE to put that, its just that this is a Fan site, and i'm not sure why you would feel it was necessary to put something so rude like that on here. At least use better and nicer words.

Thats all I'm complaining about.

This is based on a real persons life, and they are just telling his story. You may disagree with it, but if that person is happy who are we to judge them?

Well if that makes this person happy because they're homosexual then why can't I be perfectly happy judging others? See how your philosophy disagrees with itself? So apparently it's ok for me to judge others since your tolerant of someone elses lifestyle

How about... go judge it on a religious site? This isn't exactly the place for it.

um because judging people hurts them! that's not a hard one to figure out...if everyone would just mind their OWN business and keep up with their OWN lives, this would probably be a happier place...but instead we have the few ppl with nothing else to do but sit around and judge others...i just had to jump in on this one.

Congratualtions!!! U just hurt my feelings by judging the way I judge others LOL

buzz off...nobody wants you starting stuff on here.

hey=) i wouldn't bother with this person. they won't give up and giving them this debate is what they want. so have fun commenting wit IndiesR =) and people who are enjoyable to talk to. if i just ignore these people i find that they tend to go away.

true true they are just here to start stuff...thank you deedee for banning them!

Nahh I'm here to stay

Eh just so you know your ip address is blocked so any comments you try to post or by using a different username will automatically be deleted. SO DON'T WASTE YOUR TIME!

LOL, GONE!

No your not cos I just banned you!

Too late

I dont think it my place to judge anyone. That's between them and the creator. I accept people for who they are and treat them the same, with respect, just as i want them to accept me for who I am and treat me with mutual respect. Everyone is different, we are all not the same, but we are all human beings and should be treated as such, regardless of our relationship preference. There is only ONE judge!

wow, I hope today is not a slow news day. I come here to escape for a bit in between school and work. Is anyone else bummed about how heavy this discussion has gotten?
I have read through this discussion thread and from what I can decipher from other users responses my comment to directed towards "qwerty"
To me it seems like people are trying to make personal preference into a public war of words. So some artist happened to be gay, so someone made a movie about his life who cares. Are you going to bash every gay person until they listen and act according to the way you see fit? To me that seems a bit more "sinful" to continuously berate people for their sexual preference than it is to live a good life as a gay.

And that one judge will judge me AND my smoking habits!! hehehe

hahahaha. You're right! But I'll still let you know that smoking is hazardous to your health, but, also, I still love you, just as you are. LOL

yeah yeah I know .. I'm the devil .. :P I'll quit, eventually. Just not ready yet. Its very hard!!

I'm glad you still love me! Even us devilish smokers have ppl who love us!! mwah hahaha

You're not the devil...are you? hahhaha LMAO!

IndiesR i SOOOO agree with you! Don't listen to "qwerty".

Well said Indies. He's just playing someone who was gay and every relationship is beautiful!

Yes, every "loving" relationship is beautiful. Some of us opinions on that will defer, naturally, we are all not the same, and we dont think or see thinks the same. But being in a loving relationship with someone, regardless of who that someone is, is beautiful and special...not everyone gets the chance to experience this in life.

Totally agree with IndiesR! Who are we to judge?!?!

Just because everyone is different doesn't make what they're doing right and the fact that a man and another man should relate like that is wrong. And would u please tell me who this ONE judge is? I would really like to know and don't say God because HE wouldn't tolerate a homosexual action like this or any other perversion of one His creations or ideas

I'm sorry your now banned by being a narrow minded biggot!!!

ok I'm not going to state my beliefs, although i do have some strong ones about this subject. Im not going to "judge" judge is a relative word, it means different things.

What i dont understand is.... Ive been reading these comments, some of them have been obviously removed. But the all of the comments that have remained all share the same attitude about this issue. Why may i ask? All have "JUDGED" on this issue. some of you dissaprove, and others are approving... You all are in essence JUDGING what you deem is right within your own moral standards.

What really worries me is that this site has deleted certain viewpoints, and has kept others. You have chosen the JUDGEments that is parallel to your own. Instead of allowing a free thinking atmosphere... its now a website affliliated with certain opinions.

yes, who are WE to judge OTHERs opinions?

You are right, maybe JUDGE was not the right choice of word, we all do it in some form or the other, the correct word would have been, in this discussion, CONDEMN. In my opinion, that's what "qwerty" was doing based on her comments, hence our religious arguement or discussion (depends on how you look at it). Unfortunately, her comments were removed so you cannot read them.

Yes sure, this website is not designed to discuss religious beliefs and morals.. but all of you just shared your beliefs!!!! to quote:

“I think its romantic!”

“Yes, God does tolerate this! He tolerates everything we do, because his love for us is unconditional, and he's long suffering.”

“He's just playing someone who was gay and every relationship is beautiful!”

“being in a loving relationship with someone, regardless of who that someone is, is beautiful and special”

“Gay is in... deal with it”

“God loves everyone. Regardless of who they love and who they kiss.”

that is an interesting point

BEAUTIFUL is just a strong of word as DISGUSTING

once again, i remind you, my opinion on homosexuality is anonymous and irrelevant to the point im trying to make

that's not what she did. she respects her opinion but she disagrees with the way she stated it. and THEN she gave her own. don't mix it up!

but you see, your still basing your judgement on your own belief. you believe that a person cant help themselves being gay. To you, your belief is more right-minded, justified, loving etc..... If you truly think its wrong to judge someone, Dont judge someone who thinks homosexuality is wrong.

Look the point that was trying to get put across is that while this person is trying to put an opinion across it was also extremely offensive. I believe don't believe inGod so it wasn't an opinion that I was trying to get across that God excepts everyone, I'm not going to preach about it because I would be one hell off a hypocrite if I did. Everybody is entitle to what they believe in.

But what was darn right offensive is when some one comes on her and starts bashing someone about being gay. Its rude to the point, this was about Robert playing an extremely pivotal role about one off the most famous artists off our time. He had show the essence off Dali, his life and if leaving the point out off Dali being gay, well then that wouldn't be about him then cos he is what he is.

I believe that being gay is not a choice, for someone to come onto a site and bash someone for that then its just plain rude and hurtful. So that is why everyone jumped on the defensive. There is nothing wrong with it, its part off live, and as soon as the narrow mindedness off this world grows up, the better world it will be to live in.

and AMEN to that!

such a fool that person was, iritates me no end, I couldn't sleep last night for being so wound up about it.

don't worry. your reaction was appropriate. unfortunetaly, we live in a world that still needs to grow up!

yea........ lol

oh dear here we again

I don't think that a clip from a movie, where an actor portrays one of the most intriguing artists of 20th century should start a debate about morals or does god exist and are we his creations or not.
This is not a place for that kind of discussions.

While I do not want to start a religious argument on NMM.org, I am referring to God. Yes he made it clear that "Adam & Eve", not "Adam & Steve", but at the same time, he created each of us. He loves us regardless of our choices and we each have to answer to him for OUR OWN choices and actions. While you might not be in a same sex relationship, I'm sure you are NOT perfect in whatever you do.

P.S. Yes, God does tolerate this! He tolerates everything we do, because his love for us is unconditional, and he's long suffering.

That's it for my religious take on this...sorry if I offend anyone who does not believe in God.

well thank a chrisitna tiwlighter well ther emany butI do agree. hosmexualtiy is a sin but God does love us and we do have to answer up him though I don't god tihk wold toelrate us killing people as in murder.

If you do read the bible (even though its written by men) you will find that God loves even the murder too....just saying.

oh my god! a sin? people can be so narrow-minded! i'm not a religious person, but i do remember that God made us the way we are and love everybody. Christians or protestants (whatever) want to be Jesus-like. that's the point apparently. Jesus never said ONCE that homosexuality was a sin AND do i have to remind people tha the bible and all the "sacred" texts were written by men? i'm not sure i want to believe in what other people think i should live my life.

whoa, whoa, whoa there. You just took this topic into a whole theological discussion. I can gladly explain to how wrong you are about what jesus said and the bible somewhere else, because the people here have made it clear that this site is not for theological discussion.

Although i garauntee you that your theological opinion will not get you kicked off, because for some reason, this is the popular BELIEF between many of you.

It would be nice to hear exactly how this person stated their opinion if only her opinion was left on for me to read it. how exactly did she state it: hmmm, i think it was something along the lines of... "I think homosexuality is wrong"

you think homosexuality is good. Some of you think its beautiful, enchanting, romantic...

BUT some one happens to say its disgusting. you kick them off, call them a "narrow minded" , "biggot"
YOU YOURSELF ARE NARROW MINDED FOR NOT ACCEPTING THE FACT THAT SOME PEOPLE IN THIS WORLD BELIEVE DIFFERENTLY ABOUT HOMOSEXUALITY THAN YOU!!!!

ok this is getting kind of old, but let me explain one more time..

You are guilty of committing the same thing you accused a "christian twilighter" of doing.

Hey you have every right to say, "yes, it is my belief that christian people view of sexual immorality is stupid, narrow minded, ignorant, rude, offensive, hateful,."

Its a free country, say it if you wish.

Here is another hypothetical senario... a christian person said,

"I believe abortion is wrong, people who have had one are stupid, narrow minded, ignorant, rude, offensive, hateful, and that they are wrong to do what they do."

Umm hypothetically, i believe you both have just judged one another. how can you say, let me take that speck out of your eye, when you have a log in your own

whatever! go to Oprah!

case closed

hey, why did tht user get banned? i was reading and got confused...lol

Since I already replied to the same question. Please see my response comment above to Nadeeo9. You could also see Deedee also made a response to this question.

hey im confused why did tht user get banned? im lost?

While every user has the right to state their own opinion on whatever is posted here on NNM.org, it is also expected that every user is respectful as well as tactful. This user had make her opinion on the matter quit clear, however, the user also resorted to taunting others as well as being rude. Moderators do have the responsibility of deciding how to handle such a user, in this case the user was banned. I'm not sure if the band is permanent, but that's the choice of the moderator.

Because the user was being offensive and rude. Thats why the comments have been removed.

You know my views off god but you haven't offended me in the slightest. Everyone is entitled to their own believes and I respect that 100%, if you want to share your opinion on your believes indies you are 100% entitled too.

Thanks, but I'm well aware that NMM.org is not an outlet for me vent my believes on religion, I kind of lost it, just a tat, I just had to say something. :)

I know but you shouldn't have to explain yourself to narrow minded fools, your openly entitled to voice your believes because they are not insulting to anyone in any way.

Thanks. :)

Yes I agree with u that God loves unconditionally no matter what we do and He has plan for our lives and a way to live our lives according to what He ordained and that doesn't invovle being homosexual. And if God did tolerate homosexuality then in the Beginning He wouldve made Adam and Steve as u put it. That's not the way He intended us to be and even tho he loves us I doubt that He would tolerate the way mankind perverted His creation.

Qwerty how would you know that's not how God intended us to be? Are you God? I don't think so.

Again, NMM.org is not a place for our little religious argument...I stated my opinon already and I'll leave it at that. But if you wish to continue, maybe you should find a religious site to discuss your take on this or take your concerns to church.

i really did not expect such a debate to happen on here, i thought everyone or most will like it. guess i was wrong.

Btw even tho He loves us no matter what when it comes down to judgement day and if we don't live our lives according to Him, He won't tolerate it.

P.S. This may be a religious fight for you but its a discussion on Faith for me

idk about anyone else, but i think people have rights to choose how to live their lives, so who are we to judge them?

I'm not fighting. I'm just making it clear that this is not the place to argue or discuss our religious believes.

omg!! qwerty is just a hater!! lol..thank god they got banned from the site!!

I totally agree! :)

Well judgement day is coming for u then because he wouldn't condone your bahaviour, i'm pretty sure ignorance and narrow mindedness is something he doesn't preach.

LOL, so true edcullenlovin!! who are we to judge who should and should not be loved by God?

Alright then i'm sure!!!! if u have certain beleifs then thats your decision but you shouldn't express them on this site, go to church and express your woes or somewhere that is acceptable for that kind of debate as here obviously isn't one of them.

i think it is romantic too!

which one is rob?

Lol I know xD I had to watch it twice anyway he's the one with less muscle mass (under the water) when they stop he's always at the right

Hawt Lol I was giggling the whole time sometimes throughout the whole clip I couldn't tell who was who they look the same xD

WOWOWOW!!!!
i love it!
i cannot wait for little ashes!

ahh no comment..........

Wow...it was kinda romantic...but a little creepy at the same time..i admire Rob for taking on such different roles..he seems to be extending his branches..good job!!

I think it was romantic..and I think Rob will be awesome in this role, cant wait to see the whole movie.

Yeah I found it really touching, It wasn't the type off "yeah I'm going to jump your bones" type off kiss, but a really sweet romantic type one.

yea me too..its sweet and they look happy

Exactly! :)

awwwww how cute u can be romantic deedee not just dirty hahaha. yes it was a wonderful kiss :o)
Lizzie

omg!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I cannot wait to see this movie! It looks like Robert Pattinson is going to be genius in this!

hahhhh
aw robert.

ew!

there's nothing 'ew' about it.

lol ikr i was like thats just wrong i could hardly watch it its just not rite for rob to kiss a guy but the movie did look gud

um not sure what to say to that

FIRST!!! sorry its exciting to be first :) um rob looks hot in the water...but i would be lying if i said i wasn't jealous of that javier guy!

Yes, it is exciting to be first! Congrats! :)

thanx :)

LMAO, i bet you a lot of girls are jealous of him =)
and one of these days i'm going to be first ;-)

SO jealous!

you will be first one day! i hardly got on here at all yesterday and then i logged on just now and this popped up right away haha :)