Comments on: Harry Potter is Eclipsed by The Twilight Saga http://www.newmoonmovie.org/2009/08/harry-potter-is-eclipsed-by-the-twilight-saga/ Complete News & Info on the New Moon Movie, Coming November 20, 2009 Fri, 19 Mar 2010 08:52:59 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.9.2 hourly 1 By: Aoife http://www.newmoonmovie.org/2009/08/harry-potter-is-eclipsed-by-the-twilight-saga/comment-page-4/#comment-2428871 Aoife Thu, 13 Aug 2009 17:12:09 +0000 http://www.newmoonmovie.org/?p=9174#comment-2428871 Harry Potter is eclipsed by the Twilight Saga?<br><br>Ok, let me just say to all you Twilighters - yeah, right. That will never happen. Harry Potter is HARRY POTTER. JK Rowling did 5 years of plotting before starting the first book. She developed hundreds of incredible characters, and invented a whole new world that awoke the imaginations of millions of people. Oh yeah, and she can write. <br><br>Meyer just sat down one day and wrote to wherever her hormones and over-fuelled sex-drive led her, not bothering to think about logic, plotting or character development in the process. And most of her descriptions go like this, "His voice was like melting honey." Firstly, honey doesn't melt, it's already a liquid. Secondly, even if it did melt, it doesn't make a noise. Thirdly, even if it did make a noise, somebody's voice couldn't sound like that, because voices make words! MEYER CAN'T WRITE. Harry Potter is eclipsed by the Twilight Saga?

Ok, let me just say to all you Twilighters – yeah, right. That will never happen. Harry Potter is HARRY POTTER. JK Rowling did 5 years of plotting before starting the first book. She developed hundreds of incredible characters, and invented a whole new world that awoke the imaginations of millions of people. Oh yeah, and she can write.

Meyer just sat down one day and wrote to wherever her hormones and over-fuelled sex-drive led her, not bothering to think about logic, plotting or character development in the process. And most of her descriptions go like this, “His voice was like melting honey.” Firstly, honey doesn't melt, it's already a liquid. Secondly, even if it did melt, it doesn't make a noise. Thirdly, even if it did make a noise, somebody's voice couldn't sound like that, because voices make words! MEYER CAN'T WRITE.

]]> By: Aoife http://www.newmoonmovie.org/2009/08/harry-potter-is-eclipsed-by-the-twilight-saga/comment-page-4/#comment-574521 Aoife Thu, 13 Aug 2009 13:12:09 +0000 http://www.newmoonmovie.org/?p=9174#comment-574521 Harry Potter is eclipsed by the Twilight Saga?<br><br>Ok, let me just say to all you Twilighters - yeah, right. That will never happen. Harry Potter is HARRY POTTER. JK Rowling did 5 years of plotting before starting the first book. She developed hundreds of incredible characters, and invented a whole new world that awoke the imaginations of millions of people. Oh yeah, and she can write. <br><br>Meyer just sat down one day and wrote to wherever her hormones and over-fuelled sex-drive led her, not bothering to think about logic, plotting or character development in the process. And most of her descriptions go like this, "His voice was like melting honey." Firstly, honey doesn't melt, it's already a liquid. Secondly, even if it did melt, it doesn't make a noise. Thirdly, even if it did make a noise, somebody's voice couldn't sound like that, because voices make words! MEYER CAN'T WRITE. Harry Potter is eclipsed by the Twilight Saga?

Ok, let me just say to all you Twilighters – yeah, right. That will never happen. Harry Potter is HARRY POTTER. JK Rowling did 5 years of plotting before starting the first book. She developed hundreds of incredible characters, and invented a whole new world that awoke the imaginations of millions of people. Oh yeah, and she can write.

Meyer just sat down one day and wrote to wherever her hormones and over-fuelled sex-drive led her, not bothering to think about logic, plotting or character development in the process. And most of her descriptions go like this, “His voice was like melting honey.” Firstly, honey doesn't melt, it's already a liquid. Secondly, even if it did melt, it doesn't make a noise. Thirdly, even if it did make a noise, somebody's voice couldn't sound like that, because voices make words! MEYER CAN'T WRITE.

]]> By: Aoife http://www.newmoonmovie.org/2009/08/harry-potter-is-eclipsed-by-the-twilight-saga/comment-page-4/#comment-348851 Aoife Thu, 13 Aug 2009 12:12:09 +0000 http://www.newmoonmovie.org/?p=9174#comment-348851 Harry Potter is eclipsed by the Twilight Saga?<br><br>Ok, let me just say to all you Twilighters - yeah, right. That will never happen. Harry Potter is HARRY POTTER. JK Rowling did 5 years of plotting before starting the first book. She developed hundreds of incredible characters, and invented a whole new world that awoke the imaginations of millions of people. Oh yeah, and she can write. <br><br>Meyer just sat down one day and wrote to wherever her hormones and over-fuelled sex-drive led her, not bothering to think about logic, plotting or character development in the process. And most of her descriptions go like this, "His voice was like melting honey." Firstly, honey doesn't melt, it's already a liquid. Secondly, even if it did melt, it doesn't make a noise. Thirdly, even if it did make a noise, somebody's voice couldn't sound like that, because voices make words! MEYER CAN'T WRITE. Harry Potter is eclipsed by the Twilight Saga?

Ok, let me just say to all you Twilighters – yeah, right. That will never happen. Harry Potter is HARRY POTTER. JK Rowling did 5 years of plotting before starting the first book. She developed hundreds of incredible characters, and invented a whole new world that awoke the imaginations of millions of people. Oh yeah, and she can write.

Meyer just sat down one day and wrote to wherever her hormones and over-fuelled sex-drive led her, not bothering to think about logic, plotting or character development in the process. And most of her descriptions go like this, “His voice was like melting honey.” Firstly, honey doesn't melt, it's already a liquid. Secondly, even if it did melt, it doesn't make a noise. Thirdly, even if it did make a noise, somebody's voice couldn't sound like that, because voices make words! MEYER CAN'T WRITE.

]]> By: mentalfunhouse http://www.newmoonmovie.org/2009/08/harry-potter-is-eclipsed-by-the-twilight-saga/comment-page-4/#comment-345458 mentalfunhouse Tue, 11 Aug 2009 18:13:50 +0000 http://www.newmoonmovie.org/?p=9174#comment-345458 Anyone else want to slap that smug look right off of Meyers face?<br><br>Twlight is never going to be able to beat Harry Potter. It's just not possible. Anyone else want to slap that smug look right off of Meyers face?

Twlight is never going to be able to beat Harry Potter. It's just not possible.

]]> By: lixami http://www.newmoonmovie.org/2009/08/harry-potter-is-eclipsed-by-the-twilight-saga/comment-page-4/#comment-339488 lixami Sun, 09 Aug 2009 20:29:29 +0000 http://www.newmoonmovie.org/?p=9174#comment-339488 Oh, please. Harry Potter, just a phase? I beg to differ. <br>The utter rubbish that is the Twilight "saga" will never match Harry Potter. JK Rowling's series has characters with actual depth, she did research, she planned each book longer than it took Meyer to slap her dream on paper in the rush to milk the cash cow. <br>I'm sorry for those that truly believe Twilight to be a good book. Truly, I do. Oh, please. Harry Potter, just a phase? I beg to differ.
The utter rubbish that is the Twilight “saga” will never match Harry Potter. JK Rowling's series has characters with actual depth, she did research, she planned each book longer than it took Meyer to slap her dream on paper in the rush to milk the cash cow.
I'm sorry for those that truly believe Twilight to be a good book. Truly, I do.

]]> By: rachaelwsz http://www.newmoonmovie.org/2009/08/harry-potter-is-eclipsed-by-the-twilight-saga/comment-page-4/#comment-333555 rachaelwsz Thu, 06 Aug 2009 07:30:08 +0000 http://www.newmoonmovie.org/?p=9174#comment-333555 Yeah I did. Hated the song. Lol. :) So Disney-like...<br><br>Gah. That kiss! Felt so wrong... urgh... haha<br><br>I was just watching out for Taylor. lol Yeah I did. Hated the song. Lol. :) So Disney-like…

Gah. That kiss! Felt so wrong… urgh… haha

I was just watching out for Taylor. lol

]]> By: ferni http://www.newmoonmovie.org/2009/08/harry-potter-is-eclipsed-by-the-twilight-saga/comment-page-4/#comment-331698 ferni Wed, 05 Aug 2009 18:27:46 +0000 http://www.newmoonmovie.org/?p=9174#comment-331698 LMAO!<br><br>sorry Nutty..i've just never been interesed in those!<br><br>OHH and Eddie is AAAAAHHH-SOOOOMEEEEEE!<br><br>SO THERE!<br><br>LOL LMAO!

sorry Nutty..i've just never been interesed in those!

OHH and Eddie is AAAAAHHH-SOOOOMEEEEEE!

SO THERE!

LOL

]]> By: HaleyElena http://www.newmoonmovie.org/2009/08/harry-potter-is-eclipsed-by-the-twilight-saga/comment-page-4/#comment-331549 HaleyElena Wed, 05 Aug 2009 17:40:49 +0000 http://www.newmoonmovie.org/?p=9174#comment-331549 JKR has 7 books, not four. I dont think its fair to compare Breaking Dawn to the Goblet of Fire. Yes the Goblet is the fourth book, but the Harry's story is in the middle there. Maybe it would be more fair to compare Breaking Dawn to The Deathly Hallows JKR has 7 books, not four. I dont think its fair to compare Breaking Dawn to the Goblet of Fire. Yes the Goblet is the fourth book, but the Harry's story is in the middle there. Maybe it would be more fair to compare Breaking Dawn to The Deathly Hallows

]]> By: HaleyElena http://www.newmoonmovie.org/2009/08/harry-potter-is-eclipsed-by-the-twilight-saga/comment-page-4/#comment-331548 HaleyElena Wed, 05 Aug 2009 17:39:48 +0000 http://www.newmoonmovie.org/?p=9174#comment-331548 JKR has 7 books, not four. I dont think its fair to compare Breaking Dawn to the Goblet of Fire. Yes the Goblet is the fourth book, but the Harry's story is in the middle there. Maybe it would be more fair to compare Breaking Dawn to The Deathly Hallows JKR has 7 books, not four. I dont think its fair to compare Breaking Dawn to the Goblet of Fire. Yes the Goblet is the fourth book, but the Harry's story is in the middle there. Maybe it would be more fair to compare Breaking Dawn to The Deathly Hallows

]]> By: Mr_Darcy http://www.newmoonmovie.org/2009/08/harry-potter-is-eclipsed-by-the-twilight-saga/comment-page-4/#comment-331518 Mr_Darcy Wed, 05 Aug 2009 17:37:13 +0000 http://www.newmoonmovie.org/?p=9174#comment-331518 That's a little project I have been working on in what scraps of spare time I have. It's basically the backstory of why Mr. Darcy is a wolf (Jane Austen's Mr. Darcy, it picks up some time after Pride and Prejudice ends) and what he does about it. I suppose you could call it a fanfic, but Bella and Edward and Jacob are nowhere to be found (as it's mid 19th century) That's a little project I have been working on in what scraps of spare time I have. It's basically the backstory of why Mr. Darcy is a wolf (Jane Austen's Mr. Darcy, it picks up some time after Pride and Prejudice ends) and what he does about it. I suppose you could call it a fanfic, but Bella and Edward and Jacob are nowhere to be found (as it's mid 19th century)

]]>