Comments on: Let’s Re-Read New Moon Together! Chapter 11

By: Tiffys17

Tiffys17 — Mon, 09 Nov 2009 09:41:32 +0000

Aww i couldnt have described this chap better than u!!!
i love those quotes too...
I even cried when Jacob break up with her, she even lie to him about changin her feelings about him, i felt her pain, poor Bella first Edward and then Jake, it was awful, but i dont even what to imagine what Jacob felt, cuz just like Edward he doesnt felt what he said, i mean he just said those things to protect her, but at the end he just hurt her so much...
I liked Jake so much more this time i read the book chapters before, but this time he was just so MEAN!!!
and again i dont think he wanted to treat her that way. And is so funny that she was just blaming Sam for everything that happened and Jake telling her that it wasnt his fault,
Anyways I felt so bad for bells

But it was a really intense chapter, IDK i kinda liked the intensity..

By: Tiffys17

Tiffys17 — Mon, 09 Nov 2009 03:41:32 +0000

By: TeamMindReader

TeamMindReader — Sun, 08 Nov 2009 12:51:29 +0000

The first time I read the book I felt that way too like about him leaving her with something, but he thought it was the best way for her to get over him without reminders of pain.

It's just so sad because as motherly Esme is, she had to run away too. I think it makes it even sader because she has to compare the Cullens with the pack ( mostly I mean Jacob) Both the Cullens who were her new family, the family she would literally die for and Jacob who was family in a way both left her alone and broken.

By: TeamMindReader

TeamMindReader — Sun, 08 Nov 2009 12:44:40 +0000

I know! I wish she would get the book done. I've read midnight sun 10 times already. Edward had to take her choices away from her because he knew she wouldn't let him leave if they tried talking about it without him being decided. I feel like he took all her things away to try and make it as easy as possible as it could be for her to get over him and his family. That's why I defend him when people are all like I'm so mad at Edward for leaving and he's an a$$. He would never ever hurt Bella and the only reason he hurt her by leaving was because he thought by him and his family being in her live any longer it would hurt her even more in the long run when she wanted a baby and grow old together and Edward couldn't give her that. I mean they clearly didn't know that vampires and humans could have babies lol.

I agree with everything your saying. I love Edward and how he isn't cocky about things and how he thinks he's a monster ( not that he is) but it makes him seem more down to earth. I love how he doesn't see himself the ways other do because I think that makes him more likeable.

Exactly! I mean I've gone through my share of breakups and friends screwing me over, but to have the only two people you've ever actually related to on the same level basically tell you they don't want you and your not good for them over and over again. I'm suprised she didn't jump off the cliff sooner than she did.

By: Snowyhedwig - 12 days!!

Snowyhedwig - 12 days!! — Sun, 08 Nov 2009 01:42:40 +0000

Yeah, that made me cry, too. To know that she's willing to cheat, given that she's already hurting? That sucks…

By: Snowyhedwig - 12 days!!

Snowyhedwig - 12 days!! — Sun, 08 Nov 2009 01:33:33 +0000

Seriously? You are too kind… LOL, that would be, like, the 10-hour version of each book… bring your blankie, wear your comfortable PJs, and be prepared to be there for a while…

By: Snowyhedwig - 12 days!!

Snowyhedwig - 12 days!! — Sun, 08 Nov 2009 01:22:57 +0000

ah, OK, THAT I could do. Yes, you are! You are MY stoopid lamb, darlin'!

By: Twilight_is_my_escape

Twilight_is_my_escape — Sat, 07 Nov 2009 22:00:50 +0000

I LOVED midnight sun, and I'm not mad at Edward for leaving, in general. It is so his nature that it was inevitable that he would try to leave her to save her. This is also why it doesn't bother me when Bella forgives him so easily at the end. But I guess my own emotions over this pain Bella feela in the middle of the book comes to a limit and I start to think that he could have at least left her with something to cherish and remember him with.

Bella thinking of Esme and Carlilse, just tears me up at the end of this chapter. She's been broken up with twice, and now she has to compare the wolves to the Cullens, and its just too much.

By: OhEdward (The Original)

OhEdward (The Original) — Sat, 07 Nov 2009 18:39:36 +0000

She needs you! She needs an expert to advise her and consult her to stay on task. I like to look at it like she is working for YOU. See, I'm not no stoopid lamb. LOL

By: nomesters

nomesters — Sat, 07 Nov 2009 17:04:42 +0000

I did read Midnight Sun. It was amazing, and I wish SM would finish it.
I completely understand Edward. One thing I wrote about in my rant (somewhere on this page, I think) is that Bella considered Edward to be perfect. She thought he embodied perfection. Well, I sort of see the fact that Edward broke up with her in the way he did as one example that shows his imperfections. In my opinion, I felt like Edward was sort of taking choices away from Bella, the choice to remember him and his family. I mean, he not only lied to her about how he felt about her, but he also took his whole family away from Forks, so Bella was without the Cullens. Then, he took everything that he had given her, so she had nothing of his. He said he “It would be as if I never existed”. I know he had no idea what Bella would go through, and the fact that she went through what she did proves that it didn't matter what he took away, they would always be a part of each other's lives. Edward had good intentions, I really love his character, and I know he was doing what he thought was best for Bella. I just think that Bella considered him to be perfect, and I don't think he was – his imperfections are more reason to love him, in my opinion.

That part was so hard to read, too. When Jacob is a total jerk to her and she has to go through pain like that again. Not pain like Edward leaving, but still, horrible. How hard would that be, to open up to someone and to have one person in the world you thought was always going to be there after your love left you, and then to have them act like that? I can't even imagine.