Get New Moon Movie

Eclipse Movie

Breaking Dawn Release Date

Breaking Dawn Movie

Eclipse Trailer

  

MTV Interview: Team Edward or Team Jacob? The Debate Continues!

by LMCullen on November 13, 2009 · View Comments

in Kristen Stewart,Robert Pattinson,Taylor Lautner


MTV.com has a new interview with New Moon stars Kristen Stewart, Taylor Lautner, and Robert Pattinson asking them the burning question: Are you Team Edward or Team Jacob -

Ms. Bella Swan herself, Kristen Stewart, views the choice between the vampire and the werewolf as one that pits your head against your heart. “For whatever reason, Bella is instinctually in need — I mean, can’t live without Edward,” she explained in an interview provided by studio Summit Entertainment. “So if I had something like that, that definitely would be what I went for because I wouldn’t have a choice.”

Yet Stewart said that while Edward has captured Bella’s heart, the “Twilight” teen knows Jacob would ultimately cause her less pain. “Objectively, from the outside, she should be with Jacob,” Stewart said. “She’s best friends with him, he’s warm, it’s easy, there’s no problems there. But you can’t always take the easy way. ”

Taylor Lautner said, depends on what type of person you are. “Team Jacob. If you believe in that friendship and you guys are friends at first and you develop this deep friendship, then all of a sudden fall in love later on, then you should be Team Jacob,” he said, stumping for his character. “Come to the dark side! But if you believe in love at first sight and seeing that mysterious man in the corner, then all right, join Team Edward.”

What does Robert Pattinson think? To the man behind Edward Cullen, it’s not about going with your heart or you head, and it’s not about choosing friendship over mystery. For RPattz, the important distinction between the two characters — and the key to deciding whose team you should be on — comes down to whether you want to go through life riddled with anxiety or be able to live in the moment.

“In really simple terms, Edward is much more of a worrier — not a warrior but a worrier — and Jacob isn’t,” Pattinson said. “And that’s the biggest difference between them.”

Check out the rest of the article here!

[Thanks, Kelsey!]

Related Posts with Thumbnails

{ 1 trackback }

Tweets that mention MTV Interview: Team Edward or Team Jacob? The Debate Continues! — New Moon Movie -- Topsy.com
11.13.09 at 8:08 pm

{ 280 comments… read them below or add one }

1 *BLOOD&KIBBLES* 11.13.09 at 7:20 am

ed

2 TeamEdward Jakes just a boy 11.13.09 at 7:20 am

1st

3 Team>Show_me_the_damn_ring 11.13.09 at 7:21 am

congrats:)

4 Alice Whitlock 111 11.13.09 at 7:24 am

Still top 5! Hell, yeah, it's been a long time since I was this close to 1st.

5 IndiesR 11.13.09 at 7:24 am

Just Stop it! Does it really matter? We all know how it goes, this is a ridiculos ploy to get everyone riled up…..anyway, I'm definately TEAM VAMP (EDWARD)! hahahaha

6 Alice Whitlock 111 11.13.09 at 7:25 am

Haha, who knew that Friday the 13th could be so awesome? ^^

7 robsessed_21 11.13.09 at 7:25 am

top 5! and team edward ladies!

8 TeamEdward Jakes just a boy 11.13.09 at 7:27 am

I am Team Edward b/c Bella & Edward are suppose to be together
However, I had a hot dream of Jacob and it almost turned me!

9 VickylovesRob(robert_4ever) 11.13.09 at 7:27 am

TEAM EDWARD al the way and i agree what Rob said.

10 30yearoldtwifan ☠Team SLADE ☠ 11.13.09 at 7:27 am

Yay I like the mysterious.. passionate… suck my neck type of guy. Edward all the way :)

11 Team Twilight Space Cadets 11.13.09 at 7:32 am

I am totally Team Edward because as already stated.. Bella and Edward are supposed to be together.. they fit together. And when you find the person that you want, crave to spend your life with.. then what does it matter?

12 yurwoundingmyeggo_No spoilers 11.13.09 at 7:34 am

The answers were interesting, but my goodness, Robear's answer was so thoughtful :)

13 Karixoxo {Team Club Sandwich} 11.13.09 at 7:35 am

I totally agree with Kristen; 'You can't always pick the easy way'.
But I hate how Taylor is totally dissing Edward in the end. He's basically saying 'You could have cookies and sunshine or you could have a punch in the face'. Which is NOT how it is.

I've always been Team Edward, and nothing has ever swayed me, even a little bit.

14 Team Twilight Space Cadets 11.13.09 at 7:37 am

with all this Team Edward or Team Jacob for New Moon.. what are they going to use for Eclipse? There's the real love triangle.. but they won't have anything left for it

15 Forever-NoMatter (FNM) 11.13.09 at 7:41 am

i can't see the movie already!
arrggghhh!
D:

16 Alice Whitlock 111 11.13.09 at 7:48 am

Team Jasper forever <3. Twilight is all about Team Edward, New Moon is Team Jacob, Eclipse is Team Jasper. What about Breaking Dawn? Team Nahuel! Ahh, love him.

17 IloveyouEdward 11.13.09 at 7:50 am

Team edward BECAUSE HE ROCKS!

18 !!! TEAM RPATTZ !!! 11.13.09 at 7:54 am

ahhhhhh what a lovely question :/

Team Edward! Forever, and ever and ever and ever and ever…..

19 cclore ~ Team CW for BD 11.13.09 at 8:00 am

Gotta follow the heart and go with Team Edward!

20 NTJB-TeamS**DrivenPeople T-6 11.13.09 at 8:02 am

Your first first!! Awesome! Congrats!

21 NTJB-TeamS**DrivenPeople T-6 11.13.09 at 8:04 am

OMG, I was about to respond to this interview when I saw my countdown and realized that we only have 6 days until the release!!!!

LADIES! 6 days until Surround Sound Moan and 20 ft. abs!! SIX DAYS!!!!!

AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!

22 TeamEdward Jakes just a boy 11.13.09 at 8:05 am

Thank you!

23 IloveyouEdward 11.13.09 at 8:07 am

7 for me WATEVER snif snif

24 I♥TayDaniel(TeamUpNotherNotch) 11.13.09 at 8:07 am

Lmao “20 foot abs”?!
Well that's a great way to look at….& HE MOANS!!!!!!

25 NTJB-TeamS**DrivenPeople T-6 11.13.09 at 8:07 am

Welcome. :)

26 !!! TEAM RPATTZ !!! 11.13.09 at 8:08 am

YES! i really don't like Taylor's answer ehh whatever..

Robert's answer was soo cool btw..

27 NTJB-TeamS**DrivenPeople T-6 11.13.09 at 8:08 am

When EC moans, a unicorn is born.

28 NTJB-TeamS**DrivenPeople T-6 11.13.09 at 8:08 am

7? You're not going to the midnight showing?

29 I♥TayDaniel(TeamUpNotherNotch) 11.13.09 at 8:09 am

*cough* Team Jacob real men don't sparkle..*cough*

30 mAriE_(MarblePoleLover)CC-VG 11.13.09 at 8:09 am

well we all have our pick and say to this, but i am definitely TEAM EDWARD.

'nuff said. ^_^

31 IloveyouEdward 11.13.09 at 8:09 am

nooooo im not :'(

32 IloveyouEdward 11.13.09 at 8:10 am

*cough* Team Edward real men dont turn into dogs.. *cough*

LMAO ;p
im playng :D

33 IloveyouEdward 11.13.09 at 8:10 am

llmaaaaaaao

34 NTJB-TeamS**DrivenPeople T-6 11.13.09 at 8:11 am

WHAT?? Why not? Aww man.

35 yurwoundingmyeggo_No spoilers 11.13.09 at 8:11 am

For Eclipse u say…..Team Jasper…lol ;)

36 NTJB-TeamS**DrivenPeople T-6 11.13.09 at 8:12 am

That's right. EC's not a real man. He's a realsuperman.

And supermen sparkle LOL.

37 mAriE_(MarblePoleLover)CC-VG 11.13.09 at 8:12 am

WOW. awesome! well said! ^_^

i'd like to add one more thing too!

-Hes willing to die for and w/o u. ^_^

i'd think of something and get back to u.. *wink*

38 IloveyouEdward 11.13.09 at 8:13 am

my mom says its too late LMAO
:'( oh well imma watch it on the 20th tho forsure ill be so jelous but at the same time i shouldnt be cuz its just a movie and alot of other countries get to see the movie b-4 us so yea

39 mrsMcullen 11.13.09 at 8:13 am

congraaats :D happy friday 13th for u too

40 VampTramp 11.13.09 at 8:14 am

TEAM TWILIGHT!!!
TEAM TWILIGHT!!!
TEAM TWILIGHT!!!
TEAM TWILIGHT!!!
TEAM TWILIGHT!!!
TEAM TWILIGHT!!!

Isn't that all that really matters?

41 mrsMcullen 11.13.09 at 8:14 am

and for many other reasons :)

42 I♥TayDaniel(TeamUpNotherNotch) 11.13.09 at 8:14 am

Oh there are ways…and there are ways

43 NTJB-TeamS**DrivenPeople T-6 11.13.09 at 8:15 am

That is true. It is just a movie. And Australians get to see it in four</4> days. It's all good, though. I just hope they don't spill anything. Grr.

44 CF911 Flippy 'N Mullet Mofo 11.13.09 at 8:16 am

As far as Team Edward vs. Team Jacob … meh.

I am Team Flippy and Team Mullet Mofo.

That is all. :)

45 CF911 Flippy 'N Mullet Mofo 11.13.09 at 8:16 am

Oh, geez. haha. You guys are too funny.

46 TSO☠MiamiCoven'sAro☠ 11.13.09 at 8:17 am

LMAO!! That would make a great shirt.
BTW… Do you think the unicorn is born through his armpit?!

47 IloveyouEdward 11.13.09 at 8:17 am

:O they r so lucky -_-
and good luck on the first night!
its going to be hard understanding anything ppl r gunna go crazzzzzzzy

48 CF911 Flippy 'N Mullet Mofo 11.13.09 at 8:17 am

Finally got my warrants taken out. It only took me two freaking days. You see what this place does to me. LOL

49 IloveyouEdward 11.13.09 at 8:18 am

Yes that tooooooooo :D
and thanks

50 CF911 Flippy 'N Mullet Mofo 11.13.09 at 8:18 am

Bahahahahahahha.

RFLMAO.

OMG… Priceless Comment.

51 TSO☠MiamiCoven'sAro☠ 11.13.09 at 8:18 am

I am SWTZERLAND!!!
Actually TeamSwitzOlturi (TSO baby)

52 DDB_DazzledByRob 11.13.09 at 8:18 am

Team Edward, mutts howl..real men growl…:P

53 mAriE_(MarblePoleLover)CC-VG 11.13.09 at 8:20 am

tee hee.. sure thing! i'd love to help my co-team edward. *wink* ^_^

54 IloveyouEdward 11.13.09 at 8:20 am

P.S jacobs not a man yet :O
poor kid was wat 15-16 throughout the saga XD

55 yurwoundingmyeggo_No spoilers 11.13.09 at 8:21 am

Yeah…*Hi5*

56 edwardcullen_luvr 11.13.09 at 8:21 am

Surround Sound moan!! *thud*

57 xxTeamYouCanGoToHellxx 11.13.09 at 8:22 am

Exactly, we know the story and how it ends, no point in teams. (unless it's about who you prefer) The whole who's better for Bella and who she should choose is pointless, the ending has been written.

58 mAriE_(MarblePoleLover)CC-VG 11.13.09 at 8:22 am

damn! awesome answer again! *claps hands*

ooh! i have another one!

team edward bcoz real men have marble pole. *wink*

just saying… hahahahaha ^_^

59 sagrario 11.13.09 at 8:23 am

I´m Team Edward for myself and Team Jacob for my daughter so…i think it´s clear we have them both at home…and my husband is team “yes, darling”…haha

60 IloveyouEdward 11.13.09 at 8:24 am

“Let the best man win .. pup”

LMAO i love that line <3

61 Team_Paris - Dont crop out Tay 11.13.09 at 8:25 am

Team Jacob because i cant have a man telling me what to do, even it is because he loves me.
oh btw im also Team Rob

62 TSO☠MiamiCoven'sAro☠ 11.13.09 at 8:25 am

Thank you, thank you very much!
LOL

63 yurwoundingmyeggo_No spoilers 11.13.09 at 8:25 am

LOL…@ your husband team “yes, darling”

64 mAriE_(MarblePoleLover)CC-VG 11.13.09 at 8:26 am

oh god i wish thats true!

it'll be much easier for us..

not so much fun though.. tee hee.. ^_^

65 IloveyouEdward 11.13.09 at 8:27 am

lmao haha LOVE IT!

66 Team_Paris - Dont crop out Tay 11.13.09 at 8:28 am

vampires dont growl they hiss
a la twilight
LOL

67 NTJB-TeamS**DrivenPeople T-6 11.13.09 at 8:28 am

And TSO wins again!

Actually, I think the unicorns are born and frolic merrily through the forbidden forest, i.e., his bouffant.

68 Wolfi ♥(TEAM LEAH)♥ ♥ ♥ 11.13.09 at 8:28 am

TEam FLIPPY and MULLET MOFO RULEEEEEEEEE!!!!….lol

69 Wolfi ♥(TEAM LEAH)♥ ♥ ♥ 11.13.09 at 8:28 am

TEam FLIPPY and MULLET MOFO RULEEEEEEEEE!!!!….lol

70 mAriE_(MarblePoleLover)CC-VG 11.13.09 at 8:28 am

oh god u're like my fave person right now… soo awesome! ^_^

71 TSO☠MiamiCoven'sAro☠ 11.13.09 at 8:29 am

LMAO!!! You win! Haha!

72 Team_Paris - Dont crop out Tay 11.13.09 at 8:30 am

i think we all know how it ends i mean come on at least everyone here has read the saga more then 3 times lol
this whole team thing is for who we prefer
not who we want bella to be with

73 Spectra 11.13.09 at 8:32 am

Yeah, that's what it is for me. It's which guy “I” prefer, that is all.

74 mAriE_(MarblePoleLover)CC-VG 11.13.09 at 8:32 am

*blushes* why thank u! im glad i could flaunt my marblepole man here. hehehe. ^_^

75 Wolfi ♥(TEAM LEAH)♥ ♥ ♥ 11.13.09 at 8:33 am

TEAM LEAH!!

TEAM LEAH

TEAM LEAH!

TEAM LEAH!!!!

YOU KNOW YOU ALL WANT TO JOIN IN MY CHANT! FOR THE BEST LEGENDARY MYSTICAL CREATURE TO EXIST IN THE WORLD OF TWILIGHT!

76 NTJB-TeamS**DrivenPeople T-6 11.13.09 at 8:33 am

I know but I wouldn't be able to concentrate on anything at work if I waited until Friday night to watch the film LOL. And I'd have to avoid NM LOL. I can't avoid NM for more than at least 5 hours of the day LOL.

77 NTJB-TeamS**DrivenPeople T-6 11.13.09 at 8:34 am

You? I'm supposed to be applying for grants that are due next month and binding books that'll take all friggin day to do. ANd yet again, I'm here. God, when will this end. I miss being productive LOL.

Well, not really but still LOL.

78 NTJB-TeamS**DrivenPeople T-6 11.13.09 at 8:34 am

I KNOW!

<dies>

79 Wolfi ♥(TEAM LEAH)♥ ♥ ♥ 11.13.09 at 8:35 am

let me try this aswell

hmm

when JB growls, a dragon is born…

it doesnt have the same sentiments!!…lool

80 laj_teambreakmyheadboard 11.13.09 at 8:35 am

TEAM EDWARD ALL THE WAY!!!!! going to the beach this weekend gonna have alot to catch up on miss u guys have great weekend

81 NTJB-TeamS**DrivenPeople T-6 11.13.09 at 8:35 am

<bows>

Woo!! It's good to know I win at somethin. Popper whipped me in our vampire war earlier this week LOL.

82 IloveyouEdward 11.13.09 at 8:35 am

awww thank you blushes :$ (L)

83 yurwoundingmyeggo_No spoilers 11.13.09 at 8:36 am

wow, the two of u are literally twins….lol

84 xxTeamYouCanGoToHellxx 11.13.09 at 8:36 am

Sneaky sneaky Rob trying to cop a feel and take a peek? lmao (his hand was unusually high during the photocall that day)

http://i669.photobucket.com/albums/vv56/mikala1...

http://www.imagebam.com/image/b79aa955877219

http://www.imagebam.com/image/964c6955877230

85 TSO☠MiamiCoven'sAro☠ 11.13.09 at 8:36 am

You beat me in the poop fest too. Can't forget that one! LMAO!

86 laj_teambreakmyheadboard 11.13.09 at 8:36 am

that line sooooooo better be in eclipse

87 NTJB-TeamS**DrivenPeople T-6 11.13.09 at 8:37 am

LMFAO! No, it certainly doesn't LOL. You know why, though? Cause JB doesn't growl, CGI wolf growls.

But Robward moans, moans, moans, like a good sex god that he is.

Grr, 6 days cannot roll by fast enough!!

88 NTJB-TeamS**DrivenPeople T-6 11.13.09 at 8:37 am

LMFAO! No, it certainly doesn't LOL. You know why, though? Cause JB doesn't growl, CGI wolf growls.

But Robward moans, moans, moans, like a good sex god that he is.

Grr, 6 days cannot roll by fast enough!!

89 Team_Paris - Dont crop out Tay 11.13.09 at 8:37 am

TEAM LEAH!!

TEAM LEAH

TEAM LEAH!
because shell kick your a**

90 DDB_DazzledByRob 11.13.09 at 8:37 am

Nahw they moan!! lol..Btw I see we have the same avi..H2B suggested it to me, told me it was still available, do you want me to change it? I don't know who had it first so.. :)

91 yurwoundingmyeggo_No spoilers 11.13.09 at 8:37 am

Yah,…..TEAM LEAH!

92 IloveyouEdward 11.13.09 at 8:38 am

ah im going to avoid going on the internet firday all day ! i dont want any spoilers, but i cant belive this 6/7 more days! i waited all year for this movie :O :|

93 mAriE_(MarblePoleLover)CC-VG 11.13.09 at 8:39 am

awesome! way to promote ur team!

hmm.. since we're doing this, i'd like to promote mine..

TEAM MARBLEPOLE!!!

oh damn.. thats right. it's still team edward huh? hmm… oh well.. *shrugs*

TEAM MARBLEPOLE!!! ^_^

94 mAriE_(MarblePoleLover)CC-VG 11.13.09 at 8:40 am

u deserve it! *claps hands again* keep it up! woohoo! ^_^

95 Spectra 11.13.09 at 8:40 am

lol he never said anything close to a punch in the face. What he said was accurate about Jacob, and that's why I love Jacob. What he said about Edward is true too, but not in much detail. Edward IS the love at first site, and is the big handsome man of mystery. It is completely accurate, but I like how Kristen goes into more detail, Edward is who Bella cannot live without, her love is deeper.

96 katytrail 11.13.09 at 8:41 am

Dogs are MAN's best friend and Diamonds are a GIRLS best friend… Team Edward baby!

97 CF911 Flippy 'N Mullet Mofo 11.13.09 at 8:42 am

I've practically thrown in the towel on being productive until the Monday following the weekend to end all weekends.

I've done what I set out to do, so screw the rest. haha.

98 katytrail 11.13.09 at 8:42 am

Funny how he doesn't mention how guys like Jacob force themselves on you even knowing you're in love with someone else. I guess he thinks women should want to be with selfish pigs. Oops, I mean selfish dogs.

99 Chel*STILL NOSPOILERS* 11.13.09 at 8:43 am

Can i join team marble pole??? you know how much i love that marble pole *snickers*

100 Spectra 11.13.09 at 8:45 am

:( I can't watch the video because I'm in Canada. Sucks.

101 mAriE_(MarblePoleLover)CC-VG 11.13.09 at 8:46 am

*giggles*
of course! everyone is welcome on my team!

come one, come all! *grins*

though i get to have the marble pole ok? MINE! muahahaha ^_^

102 TeamRotation (Meg1) 11.13.09 at 8:46 am

I can see the appeal of both. Edward is lovely, but I guess in terms of MY preference, it would probably be Jacob. Though a mix of the two wouldn't hurt. ;)

I don't know that I particularly believe in love at first sight or soul mates.. there can be a strong feeling in the beginning, but who's to say it will last forever? Soul mates = I think there is more than one out there for people. Maybe I'm a little cynical. haha.

I like the idea of being best friends with the person I'm in love with, though. :)

103 CF911 Flippy 'N Mullet Mofo 11.13.09 at 8:47 am

Of course.

And as of late, I have joined a new team:

Team Panty Peekage.

LOL

104 Spectra 11.13.09 at 8:49 am

He forces the kiss because he's trying to get her to realize she loves him. He's hoping that the kiss will click something for her, like it does in Eclipse. He does it because he wants to save her, to keep her human by her choosing to be with him. He is desperate.

105 CF911 Flippy 'N Mullet Mofo 11.13.09 at 8:50 am

I wonder if Rob does that kind of stuff just to see if anyone would notice? He seems like the type that would get a kick out of trying to mess with Stewy and the photogs. LOL

106 Chel*STILL NOSPOILERS* 11.13.09 at 8:51 am

yeayyyyy!!!!! ah marie you can keep it but can we borrow it??? *looks pleadingly*

107 NTJB-TeamS**DrivenPeople T-6 11.13.09 at 8:54 am

LMFAO. HAZMAT suits. Never leave home without it hahahaha.

108 mAriE_(MarblePoleLover)CC-VG 11.13.09 at 8:54 am

hmmm…. maybe once of twice a week. but thats it. im putting my foot down. ^_^

109 NTJB-TeamS**DrivenPeople T-6 11.13.09 at 8:57 am

i wish I could do that. Can't. Too many things going on at work.

110 Wolfi ♥(TEAM LEAH)♥ ♥ ♥ 11.13.09 at 8:59 am

arghhh British Sucks!!…

lol i cnt watch any of the mtv videos!

111 Spectra 11.13.09 at 9:00 am

I liked his answer too. I would choose Jacob – Live in the moment! :)

112 Chel*STILL NOSPOILERS* 11.13.09 at 9:00 am

aww *looks at ground kicking dirt around* ok then that'll do…….for now!!! LOL

113 Gypsy0531 11.13.09 at 9:04 am

that isa good one Lol. :)

114 EdwardForSure 11.13.09 at 9:06 am

I just can't read the Twilight saga, and NOT fall in love with Edward.. After all it's from Bella's pow and with all that dazzling going on it's clear who Bella falls for.. But if I look at it objectively I'm sure Jacob would be the “right” choice. Well, however, we all know how it ends :)

115 I♥TayDaniel(TeamUpNotherNotch) 11.13.09 at 9:08 am

sure,sure but edward can't make you sweat the way jacob can!!!
:)

116 I♥TayDaniel(TeamUpNotherNotch) 11.13.09 at 9:17 am

no no no *shakes head*
it's all about that team jacob because sparkling doesn't keep u warm at night haha

117 Prislovesteamrobsten 11.13.09 at 9:18 am

There are way too many reasons why I am team Edward. i think my number 1 is because he cannot live without his true love:) Thats a pretty deep love.

118 Prislovesteamrobsten 11.13.09 at 9:20 am

So true about the diamonds things, but that is just a plus for edward, i love him for so many other reasons;)

119 I♥TayDaniel(TeamUpNotherNotch) 11.13.09 at 9:21 am

*chuckles*
i like my men w/ a pulse..just sayin

120 NTJB-TeamS**DrivenPeople T-6 11.13.09 at 9:22 am

Hahaha. Not according to Bella, sweetie ;)

121 I♥TayDaniel(TeamUpNotherNotch) 11.13.09 at 9:24 am

lol say that again & i'll give u a papercut…in front of jasper..& edward won't be there to save you
lmao *laughs hysterically*

122 I♥TayDaniel(TeamUpNotherNotch) 11.13.09 at 9:27 am

i like ur name!
that's right *yells*
DON'T CROP OUT TAY!!!!

123 Gypsy0531 11.13.09 at 9:30 am

of course he is going to say something stupid like that. the majority prefer edward and not his character. so he has to make edward look like the wrong choice. If i had to choose between a guy like jacob and someone with edward's qualities in real life, i would go with the edward type. The guy who behaves like jacob in real life manipulation/assault is the one you should not be with. The guy who has edwards qualities maturity,patience, selfless, experience…. is the right one. In real life jacob is the wrong choice. someone who has edward's qualities is the right choice.

124 I♥TayDaniel(TeamUpNotherNotch) 11.13.09 at 9:32 am

Team Bella because let's be honest she gets all the fun!

125 Spectra 11.13.09 at 9:35 am

You may see Jacob as assaulting Bella, but what about Edward's controlling behaviour? If you say it is because Edward loves her and is trying to protect her, well so is Jacob. He's trying to protect her from the vampires, trying to get her to choose to stay human. He fears she will be gone forever if she becomes one of them.

They both have faults, but they do them because they love her.

126 robsten_fan 11.13.09 at 9:38 am

why do they come up with this crap?
no offense guys,but really.
as long as you enjoy the book its all that really matters. No need to get in a fight here. But the again fight away the comments ae hilarious!

127 I♥TayDaniel(TeamUpNotherNotch) 11.13.09 at 9:39 am

pfft “according to bella” ? really?
don't forget this is the same girl who almost killed herself by jumping off a cliff..she has a couple of loose screws…

128 Gypsy0531 11.13.09 at 9:41 am

notice that i am not talking about edward and jacob i am talking about someone in real life who behaves like jacob and someone with edwards qualities. as far as edward he came to realize the error of his ways did nt he apologize to bella for having alice hold her hostage. and never gain did he stop her from spending time with jacob. but again i was not talking about jacob and edward.

129 DDB_DazzledByRob 11.13.09 at 9:44 am

But when you're on an island where it's really hot..a guy who doesn't have a pulse can come in handy…lol

130 I♥TayDaniel(TeamUpNotherNotch) 11.13.09 at 9:48 am

hmm touche'
but when you're in a tent & it's freezing below 0, a scorching “HOT” guy can come in handy in so many different ways *wink wink*
lmao.

131 NTJB-TeamS**DrivenPeople T-6 11.13.09 at 9:52 am

Dude, she got two hot guys chasing her. Apparently she's doing something right LMAO.

132 DDB_DazzledByRob 11.13.09 at 9:54 am

Yeah you got a point..hmmm…let's call it even:)

133 LoveForTwilight<3 11.13.09 at 9:58 am

LMAO i am loving all your comments :)
i've always thought as lovely as Edward would be, he is in no way practical!! always cold, and fighting against killing you!

134 mAriE_(MarblePoleLover)CC-VG 11.13.09 at 9:58 am

*rolls eyes*
what do u mean for now? thats final missy! HA! ^_^

135 Spectra 11.13.09 at 9:58 am

I know you are talking about real life qualities of Jacob and Edward. And in real life you say Jacob would be abusive, but therefore that would make Edward controlling. I don't necessarily think that, mind you. I don't feel what Jacob did was abusive, nor do I think Edward was a controlling man, in the real sense of both those words. They both acted the way they did in order to save her, as they loved her. Both men are forgiveable. It's not like Jacob kissed her to fulfil his own lusty desires, nor did Edward do the things he did because he felt the need to control his women like possessions.

And yeah, the sea… rofl… dear lord.

136 riza ♥ vamps(teamEDWARD_4ever) 11.13.09 at 10:13 am

TEAM EDWARD babe, all the way! xD

DROP DEAD GORGEOUS VAMPIRE or a FURRY DOG? ^^v

on reading of newmoon i was like “”stuck with that part when i was reading the book. its really hard when edward just disappeared and er, a dog came.. its never easy to accept a new concept easily..especially when Edwards is long established in your mind/heart..XD” but when ive read the eclipse i realized that i also adore the present of jacob black as a BESTFRIEND of bella. :]

137 TeamKristen(L)RumpyPumpy 11.13.09 at 10:15 am

As if their is a debate?

Team Edward. Diamonds are a girls best friend. LOL

138 I♥TayDaniel(TeamUpNotherNotch) 11.13.09 at 10:25 am

aww thanks *blushes*
i have to take up for my alpha.
edward is a piece of work & if i was bella i would be like “look i don't have time for your mess”
lol.

139 Chel*STILL NOSPOILERS* 11.13.09 at 10:26 am

LMAO it's until i get greedy and need to visit the marble pole more and more often hee hee!!!!!

140 I♥TayDaniel(TeamUpNotherNotch) 11.13.09 at 10:29 am

ok *shakes hand*

141 mAriE_(MarblePoleLover)CC-VG 11.13.09 at 10:37 am

no, no. no, no. u wont be able to do that. even if u got greedy enough, i wont be able to take advantage of the limit i gave u. HA! hehehe ^_^

142 LoveForTwilight<3 11.13.09 at 10:41 am

LOL the first time i read New Moon and Edward was all like i'm leaving i was like SAY WHAT!?! after all that hassle of falling in love lol.

143 Kimberlina Dirty Pirate Hooker 11.13.09 at 10:42 am

*waves TEAM VAMP flag in left hand*

*waives Team Roberlina flag in right hand*

144 Chel*STILL NOSPOILERS* 11.13.09 at 10:42 am

AWW *looks at marie pleadingly* PLEASEEEEEEE????!!!!

145 Kimberlina Dirty Pirate Hooker 11.13.09 at 10:43 am

The one that catches me everytime…he's mature! Seriously that becomes a huge factor in Eclipse when he's willing to let Bella go and walk away and Jacob won't.

146 Gypsy0531 11.13.09 at 10:44 am

ok. In real life someone like Edward is the right choice for me. me. Jacob is the wrong choice for me. I would rather have the guy who even though he tries to stop me from seeing my friend because i may be in danger,later on apologizes and see the error of his ways. on the other hand the other guy assaults me (and to bella it was assault because she even said it) and manipulates because he feels that so and so is wrong for me. well here is what i say who is he to tell me what is right and what is wrong for me. if i keep telling him that the other one is the one i want to be with then respect my decicion after all it is my life. and if it's a mistake so be it. there are other ways that you can try to reason with someone without resorting to those tactics.

147 I♥TayDaniel(TeamUpNotherNotch) 11.13.09 at 10:45 am

i know she almost died trying to be with him lol james was gonna rip her to shreds then edward just decides “oh it's too dangerous i have to go”…B*tch u knew it was dangerous when u first fell for her so that's BS!!!

148 mAriE_(MarblePoleLover)CC-VG 11.13.09 at 10:50 am

*snaps fingers*
na-uh! no can do dear. thats final! ^_^

149 LoveForTwilight<3 11.13.09 at 10:50 am

but Edward…frozen as 17 yet… really really old.

150 Chel*STILL NOSPOILERS* 11.13.09 at 10:52 am

*huffs* ok fine….. i'll just have his bouffant and other parts of his anatomy instead *sticks tongue out* LMAO

151 Spectra 11.13.09 at 10:59 am

That's the whole thing. Choosing whose characteristics you like more. Though Jacob doesn't do what he does because he didn't like a person she was dating. He feared for her life and was desperate to keep her out of that world. Just like Edward wanted to keep her safe. They both used different tactics, and both were wrong, but both did it for the right reasons. So I like them both, but when it comes to the GOOD qualities, or basically who there character is, how they talk, etc, I like Jacob. Nothing wrong with either choice. I just hate when people put Jacob on the same level as a s**ual harasser, when it's not about s**, just as much as I hate when people say Edward is an emotional controlling abuser. Neither are true in my mind.

152 LoveForTwilight<3 11.13.09 at 11:03 am

haha steady on :)
Tbh Edward managed to not kill her on so many occasions, and nothing real bad happened with Jasper….so maybe man up a bit?? lol
so many people will hate me saying that :/

153 TeamEdward...NEWMOONIN6DAYS <3 11.13.09 at 11:06 am

this is not even a competition…i mean, its Edward Cullen <3

154 LoveForTwilight<3 11.13.09 at 11:08 am

Totally agree with that :D TEAM TWILIGHT!!!

155 mAriE_(MarblePoleLover)CC-VG 11.13.09 at 11:09 am

thats fine with me! just dont touch the marble pole. that's mine to keep.. tee hee… ^_^

156 Gypsy0531 11.13.09 at 11:29 am

exactly you go with the one who gives meaning to your life. and for bella life without edward is meaningless. without edward physically she is alive, but emotionally and mentally she is dead. life has no meaning. and that is the reason why she stayed with edward because she knew that life with jacob as nice as he is will be no life at all. what does she care about living in the moment. really it would not even be that. she might as well be dead. so what if there are worries who said life is perfect if you have the right one with you you can overcome anything. bella knows in her heart who she can NOT live without (edward) and who she can live without (Jacob)

157 IndiesR 11.13.09 at 11:33 am

hahahaha….wave those flags high and proud. :)

158 I♥TayDaniel(TeamUpNotherNotch) 11.13.09 at 11:44 am

i don't hate u!
you are right he did need to “man up” i got tired of his whining it was depressing.

159 Gypsy0531 11.13.09 at 11:54 am

please believe me when i say that i don't consider jacob abusive. never never did i think that jacob was acting out of lust. i know why he did what he did but it does not make it right. what matters is how you feel about it when it is done to you for whatever reason. and bella was upset she was not ok with it. she did not even go back to spend time with him after the incident. even with the manipulation he starts to kiss her she still does not want to he manipulates more until she gives in. then she feels like pure crap afterwards becuase in her eyes she betrayed edward. she has to be feel guilty, self loathing over something that she did not want to do in the first place. again i am not with those who say that jacob is a s**ual harasser. I myself have said that any girl would be lucky to have a guy like jacob minus the behavior. :)

160 LoveForTwilight<3 11.13.09 at 11:55 am

lol thank gawd!

161 Chaskes_Lover (EASYYY) 11.13.09 at 12:01 pm

Ummmmm derf! Team Jacob! Let's face it. If a man sparkled I'm real life, I'd think he's batting for the other team and have unicorn stickers all over his notebook lol Jake is masculine. He works on cars and gets all covered in grease =P he's all warm and the whole shaking thing he does before he gets mad….I find that hot lol if I were Bella, I wuda picked the tall dark and handsome one =)

162 Spectra 11.13.09 at 12:02 pm

Ok, I definitely believe you. I thought before you were saying that's what he was, and I get edgy like that lol. So I'm glad it's not like that! :)

I totally see what you are saying too. He definitely should have apologized for that! That's why I'm torn between the two. Both have great qualities and personalities, yet both are so different. I'm way too excited to see all this on the big screen!!!

163 BB-TeamLet'sGetDownToBusiness 11.13.09 at 12:47 pm

There is no other logical answer other than Jacob :)

164 Chel*STILL NOSPOILERS* 11.13.09 at 1:13 pm

ok i'll have EVERYTHING else ooh i could always borrow tattwards titanium rod *smirks*

165 Chel*STILL NOSPOILERS* 11.13.09 at 1:13 pm

ok i'll have EVERYTHING else ooh i could always borrow tattwards titanium rod *smirks*

166 mAriE_(MarblePoleLover)CC-VG 11.13.09 at 1:23 pm

hehehe. good luck to u then! it wont be as good as the marble pole but i think it'll do… *wink* ^_^

167 Chel*STILL NOSPOILERS* 11.13.09 at 1:26 pm

nothing is as good as that marble pole but i think it'll help ALOT hee hee hee

168 mAriE_(MarblePoleLover)CC-VG 11.13.09 at 1:28 pm

hmmmm…. enjoy ur rusty pole then! muahahahaha *smirks* ^_^

169 RobPattz_Wifey 11.13.09 at 1:30 pm

To help you go on…

HE'S SUPER INTELLIGENT
He Dresses like a model
He wants know to about you
He listens
He holds you…even when you cry over other guys
He's inspirational
He could be your best friend (if you allowed him to be)
He's Family oriented
He's a provider

TOO! GREAT ANALYSIS. And I'm at work so I so hence me ceasing to go on

170 IloveyouEdward 11.13.09 at 1:32 pm

awwwwwww
He holds you…even when you cry over other guys

i LOVE THAT ONE how cute
and its sooooooo true
edward rocks man!

171 Chel*STILL NOSPOILERS* 11.13.09 at 1:37 pm

its not rusty it's made from titanium and its polished very often & very thoroughly

172 mAriE_(MarblePoleLover)CC-VG 11.13.09 at 1:40 pm

hmmm… and u would know right? *wink* hehehe ^_^

173 Chel*STILL NOSPOILERS* 11.13.09 at 1:46 pm

LMAO what can i say i do like to polish *snickers*

174 Gypsy0531 11.13.09 at 2:08 pm

ok. sorry that it came across that way. and you re right they each have great qualities. I'll try to be more open minded when it comes to jacob after all he did a lot for Bella/Edward and the Cullens in breaking dawn. and that outweights what he did in eclipse. I'm excited too. :)

175 Spectra 11.13.09 at 2:12 pm

I love when things end peacefully with understanding from both sides, unlike some people….. I think you know who I mean. ;)

176 red_sea 11.13.09 at 3:16 pm

How does Jacob not let her go?

He lets her go to the Volturi to save Edward.
Edward won't let her go to the werewolves who saved her life.

If Edward were sincere about letting her go, he'd have stayed away from in the first place.

Edward only said what he said in the tent-scene because he was manipulatively cribbing fromWuthering Heights when he found out it was Bella's favorite.

177 red_sea 11.13.09 at 3:17 pm

Mature men don't cofuse lust with love.
or pursue teenagers
or stalk, sabotage, and kidnap

178 breezin_hc_twifan 11.13.09 at 3:19 pm

seriously!!…love that line

179 red_sea 11.13.09 at 3:22 pm

Bella prefers 108 year old perverts who sneak into her bedroom to watch her sleep and slip her supernatural roofies.

180 red_sea 11.13.09 at 3:26 pm

Taylor put the nicest possiblt spin on Edward.

You should hear what Rob says:

He compares Edward to a creepy ax murderer. A manic-depressive, a 108 year old virgin with issues, and said that if he had a girlfriend like Edward, he'd tell her to shut up.

He also says that Bella shoud be with Jacob, because Jacob's much more interesting.

181 breezin_hc_twifan 11.13.09 at 3:27 pm

ok….totally team edward because he's perfect in every way!!……but….

when I'm not totally enveloped in *Twilight World* and living in the real world…I kinda see how he doesn't really exist and Jacob does….sooo, it's kinda hard to decide…..

Definitely Team ROB…without a doubt!!!

182 red_sea 11.13.09 at 3:30 pm

He was deperate because Edward manipulatively dropped the bomb about their engagement right before Jacob was about to fight a deadly battle for Bella while Edward sat behind to babysit.

183 red_sea 11.13.09 at 3:33 pm

As Edward says, she's his heroin. As Kristen realized, she's addicted.

So they can't live without their drug. How romantic.

184 Sarabara16 11.13.09 at 3:54 pm

OMG can't wait for the movie!
I've been playing this cool Twilight match-up game on Wonderwall!
It's so much fun.
Keeping me pacified until movie is out :)

http://wonderwall.msn.com/movies/week-in-photos...

185 twilighter87 11.13.09 at 4:01 pm

TEAM EDWARD!!!!!!

when my baby is born ill buy him/her a tiny team edward shirt. how cute will that be?!

186 Gypsy0531 11.13.09 at 4:14 pm

yes i know. and by the way i was right i knew it would not be long before “some people” would let me have it. lol

187 Gypsy0531 11.13.09 at 4:19 pm

well hi there. i was waiting to read what you had to say. you have such an interesting way of thinking. :)

188 I♥TayDaniel(TeamUpNotherNotch) 11.13.09 at 4:23 pm

lmao that is funny!
where have u been all my life?

189 Gypsy0531 11.13.09 at 4:24 pm

As Edward says, she's his heroin. As Kristen realized, she's addicted. So they can't live without their drug

hey whatever floats their boat.

190 Spectra 11.13.09 at 5:12 pm

ROFL! Oh my, you made me spit my coffee out!

191 Spectra 11.13.09 at 5:14 pm

lol you should read all his posts, they'll give you a giggle.

192 irresistible_lost_cause 11.13.09 at 6:13 pm

i have to say that throughout all of breaking dawn,
Bella was comitting statutory rape against Edward
cuz hes only 17 & Bella was 18!!
where is Charlie “the stash” Swan when you need him?

193 Gypsy0531 11.13.09 at 6:21 pm

yes but what happens when it's hot outside. would you not rather have the sparkling man who can keep you cool at night.
Jacob and his 108 degrees won t cut it

vampires can come in handy too:
you have a portable airconditioner when you want to take a romantic stroll on the beach on a hot muggy night.

you can use him as an icepack like bella did when she hurt her hand punching jacob. lol :)

194 red_sea 11.13.09 at 6:21 pm

You might want to Google Dan Bergstein blogging Twilight. Lotsa lols

195 Gypsy0531 11.13.09 at 6:24 pm

lol. never thought of that.

196 red_sea 11.13.09 at 6:25 pm

The only guys who read Twilight are closeted gay guys.

And they're Team Edward

197 I♥TayDaniel(TeamUpNotherNotch) 11.13.09 at 6:32 pm

lmao he is hilarious!

198 I♥TayDaniel(TeamUpNotherNotch) 11.13.09 at 6:33 pm

lol when it's hot outside? hmm…he'll just give me a fever! we can always use ice & take cold showers *smirks* together.
ha!
beat that. :P

199 Gypsy0531 11.13.09 at 6:43 pm

he'll just give me a fever. lol
yes but that would be equivalent to being outside in the cold and jacob's 108-109. you ll still get a fever. and unless you re planning to be in the cold shower all day you better have plenty of ice. 108 degrees will melt them pretty fast.
and hey you can always wrap yourself in a quilt. not very romantic but when you re in love who cares. :) lol. you can always get a space heater. :)

200 IloveyouEdward 11.13.09 at 7:00 pm

but edward did let her go..
its just in the begining he didnt want her too go..

but same with jacob he didnt wanna let her go save edward.
but she ended up going

201 I♥TayDaniel(TeamUpNotherNotch) 11.13.09 at 7:04 pm

i see ur point
but if i'm cold a quilt won't keep me warm. that means i'd be bundled up in 100s of layers of clothes..mmm no thanks.

202 Gypsy0531 11.13.09 at 7:04 pm

who sucks the blood outta live animals…with his mouth.

yes but he does it without making a mess of himself :)
bella does'nt complain in Breaking dawn she happens to find it very exotic. Lol :)

203 Gypsy0531 11.13.09 at 7:26 pm

bella was'nt bundled in 100s of layers of clothes. and she was fine. and edward kept her nights nice and cool in isle esme.:)

204 I♥TayDaniel(TeamUpNotherNotch) 11.13.09 at 7:35 pm

*growls*
u are making this hard.
*feels defeat* bella is an idiot!
haha

205 Chaskes_Lover (EASYYY) 11.13.09 at 7:35 pm

But that is completely grooossssss lol when Jake did the whole wolfy carnivore thing, it freaked me out and then he went back to regular food. He was an innocent deer away from being on the bad side lol Bella is out of her everlovin mind for thinking that's even the tiniest bit exotic. If I were Bella, every time I'd kiss Edward, I would think of what unsuspecting animal touched his lips before me *shudders* lol but hey, if ur into that kinda thing, its cool =P

206 Gypsy0531 11.13.09 at 7:45 pm

then do your best to have a hot dream of edward and turn back. lol :)

207 Gypsy0531 11.13.09 at 7:50 pm

lol.

208 red_sea 11.13.09 at 7:57 pm

Jacob asked her to stay.

Edward sabotaged her car, then took her prisoner.

Not the same thing at all.

209 Gypsy0531 11.13.09 at 8:19 pm

i dont think you re being cynical. you re being realistic. In the real world love at first sight (If there is such a thing) is not necessary for a relationship to work. i feel like you too i don t know that i believe in love at first sight. In the real world of course best friends with the person you re in love with is ideal. :)

210 confused1414 11.13.09 at 8:27 pm

i never understood why there is a team.
isn't it kinda obvious that a particular sparkly vampire wins?

211 Gypsy0531 11.13.09 at 8:37 pm

Jacob was about to fight a deadly battle for Bella while Edward sat behind to babysit.

Yes and I suppose that while Bella was being attacked by Victoria, Edward was sitting on his a** playing checkers. Hero Jacob had to run back to the camp site kill Victoria and riley single-handed, thereby saving Bella and becoming the hero of the day.

And the “hero of the day” medal goes to Jacob Black. For his single- handed killing of Victoria and Riley. Let’s everyone give Jacob a standing ovation for his acts of bravery and heroic deeds.

212 TeamRotation (Meg1) 11.13.09 at 8:42 pm

Thanks. For saying I'm not cynical and agreeing. hehe. Cause I certainly feel that way sometimes! Glad to know I'm not alone. :)

213 Gypsy0531 11.13.09 at 8:52 pm

you re welcome and i'm almost sure that many feel like you do.:)

214 Gypsy0531 11.13.09 at 9:11 pm

lol.

215 paulalee 11.13.09 at 9:45 pm

I am Team Edward all the way from Twilight to Breaking Dawn!!!

216 red_sea 11.13.09 at 9:46 pm

It's a good thing Victoria unexpectedly showed up then or Edward would have been a glittery wimp for the entire series.

Somehow he's able to behave like a psycho-boyfriend to keep bella from doing perfectly reasonable things like visiting her best friend or sleeping without a stalker, but when she asks him to stay out of a fight, he's so very accomodating.

The entire supernatural communtiy is expected to fight to save Bella's whiny behind, while her boyfriend sits it out.

217 Gypsy0531 11.13.09 at 9:47 pm

Jacob was about to fight a deadly battle for Bella while Edward sat behind to babysit.

Yes and I suppose that when bella is about to be attacked by Victoria, Edward is sitting on his a** playing checkers. Hero Jacob then has to run back to the camp site kill Victoria and Riley single-handed, thereby saving Bella and becoming the hero of the day.

And the “hero of the day” medal goes to Jacob Black. For his single- handed killing of Victoria and Riley. Let’s everyone give Jacob a standing ovation for his acts of bravery and heroic deeds.

218 Gypsy0531 11.13.09 at 10:01 pm

but when she asks him to stay out of a fight, he's so very accomodating.

of course. he wanted to stay behind and play checkers while everyone else was fighting for bella.:)

219 red_sea 11.13.09 at 10:07 pm

After that reunion scene in New Moon, it's gotta be Team Alice.

220 cutesweetiezzz 11.13.09 at 10:50 pm

Before I was Team Edward, but now, I don't know anymore. Why can't we be on both teams? They're both amazing guys. Edward is awesome in his own unique ways and Jacob is awesome in his own unique ways. I guess I'm Team Switzerland for now.

221 Riss<3Twilight-TeamBELLA 11.14.09 at 1:34 am

I live in Florida… GIVE ME THE COOL VAMPIRE!!
lol

Plus, I'm pail.. I don't need tan Jacob making me feel inferior..
I'll take the vampire again, I won't feel as bad;) lol

222 Riss<3Twilight-TeamBELLA 11.14.09 at 1:36 am

HEYYYY! *points to own name*
Not cool man, not cool!
Take it out on Rosalie or something. lol

223 Riss<3Twilight-TeamBELLA 11.14.09 at 1:38 am

“who sucks the blood outta live animals…with his mouth”

.. but that could come in handy;)
LMAO

*looks around for mods*

224 Riss<3Twilight-TeamBELLA 11.14.09 at 1:41 am

I completely agree.

I think people could love many different people, but it only last when you find a person who is as willing as you to make it work.

My favorite line from a movie I forget(lol):
“Sometimes love just isn't enough”

225 Riss<3Twilight-TeamBELLA 11.14.09 at 1:43 am

I beg of you.. don't feed the flame.
*whimpers*
puhpuhpuhpleasssseeee:(

226 Riss<3Twilight-TeamBELLA 11.14.09 at 1:45 am

LMAO!! You know, the three of us(you, me and spectra) should really start a team or something.

Are we the only ones who see this? Or are we the only ones who waste the time? Either way.. I can't stop laughing, I'm cryinggg right now. lol

227 Riss<3Twilight-TeamBELLA 11.14.09 at 1:48 am

See this discussion *points below to you and Spectra*
is how it's supposed to be done. Clearly listening to one another and maturely responding.

lol I love how you pulled an Alice there btw ;)

228 Chaskes_Lover (EASYYY) 11.14.09 at 1:48 am

Lmao!!!! Gotta love the mods =P

229 Riss<3Twilight-TeamBELLA 11.14.09 at 1:49 am

See this discussion *points below to you and Gypsy*
is how it's supposed to be done. Clearly listening to one another and maturely responding :)

230 Riss<3Twilight-TeamBELLA 11.14.09 at 1:55 am

Think I'll get away with it? lol

231 Chaskes_Lover (EASYYY) 11.14.09 at 1:56 am

There's no telling. Sometimes ppl get away with it. Other times ppl think they got away with it and BAM! You've been modded lol

232 Karixoxo {Team Club Sandwich} 11.14.09 at 2:27 am

You're forgetting one thing. Bella knows she wants Edward and his life and his family. She doesn't want Jacob like that. Even after Jacob's mouth rape in Eclipse she stil picks Edward. Jacob knows Bella wants Edward, just as well as Bella knows.

233 Karixoxo {Team Club Sandwich} 11.14.09 at 2:34 am

Wait. You think all Edward feels for Bella is lust?

234 TheHoneyBear_YouCantHandleThis 11.14.09 at 4:03 am

This article and interview is so deep and intense, topic-wise that I stopped watching it halfway…

And I know there are some thought-provoking comments down there…

235 red_sea 11.14.09 at 5:17 am

He feels an overwhelming lust for the scent of her blood which turns to love how? After weeks in Alaska away from her? After sneaking into her bedroom to sniff her? After seeing her make dinner for her father?

He calls what he's feeling love because he's a repressed freak who can't acknowledge what he's really feeling.

It's pretty much the same for Bella, except there's also greed on her side. All through the series she's desperate to attain the perfect beauty and eternal youth of vampirism.

236 Karixoxo {Team Club Sandwich} 11.14.09 at 7:15 am

Are you kidding? Have you not read the books or something?

Yes, he feels a 'lust' for her blood, but (even though this sounds cliche, its true) when he gets to know her he starts to fall in love with her. Not because of Alaska or her culinary prowess. And of course not the 'sniffing her' thing. That's going against what you said. You said the smell of her blood invoked lust, not love.

I'm not even going to go near the second bit of 'reasoning'. After almost a century of not feeling love – atleast not romantically – he'd know. If you can't figure that out from the Saga, read Midnight Sun.

And again, haven't you read the books? Greed? You are twisting the story completely. She has never wanted “perfect beauty and eternal youth”. That's just what she gets when she completely commits to Edward. Because they love each other. End of story. Literally.

I maybe Team Edward but altleast I'm rational when talking about it.

237 Karixoxo {Team Club Sandwich} 11.14.09 at 7:19 am

Are you kidding? Have you not read the books or something?

Yes, he feels a 'lust' for her blood, but (even though this sounds cliche, its true) when he gets to know her he starts to fall in love with her. Not because of Alaska or her culinary prowess. And of course not the 'sniffing her' thing. That's going against what you said. You said the smell of her blood invoked lust, not love.

I'm not even going to go near the second bit of 'reasoning'. After almost a century of not feeling love – atleast not romantically – he'd know. If you can't figure that out from the Saga, read Midnight Sun.

And again, haven't you read the books? Greed? You are twisting the story completely. She has never wanted “perfect beauty and eternal youth”. That's just what she gets when she completely commits to Edward. Because they love each other. End of story. Literally.

I maybe Team Edward but altleast I'm rational when talking about it.

238 Spectra 11.14.09 at 7:41 am

rofl!! What can I say? It comes naturally with maturity… ;)

239 Spectra 11.14.09 at 7:45 am

I'm not forgetting that at all, because we were not talking about Bella, we were talking about the characteristics and qualities of the two men in her life. Trust me, I'm well aware of Bella's wants, and for that I think she should be with whom she loves more, which is Edward. I'm Team Jacob because I love him, not that I want him to be with Bella. :)

240 red_sea 11.14.09 at 8:18 am

When does he get to know her? He barely speaks to her, then runs off to Alaska so he won't kill her, then comes back because he can't stay away from a girl he doesn't know. While he was thousands of miles away he decides that instead of wanting her blood he wanted her love.

I said the smell of her blood invokes lust and Edward's so self-deluded he convinces himself that lust is love, just like the rest of Team Edward.

She NEVER wanted perfect beauty and eternal youth? She obsesses over Edward's beauty, the only time she mentions other aspects of him is when she's being defensive, she compares vampirism to winning the lottery on their first official date, she has nightmares of aging, she compares herself and Edward to her old motorbike and his new one in Eclipse, and can't wait til she's as perfect as him.

“Because they love each other. End of story. Literally.”

That's pretty much Meyer's method. She tells you they love each other, doesn't bother to show it, and her little apostles can't come up with anything better than “She said so!”

Team Edward and rationality or at least reading comprehension are mutually exclusive.

241 Riss<3Twilight-TeamBELLA 11.14.09 at 11:06 am

Yea… Spectra wants Jacob all to herself;) lol

242 I♥TayDaniel(TeamUpNotherNotch) 11.14.09 at 11:26 am

lol u know red_sea's funny too haha those were some good jokes.

243 Riss<3Twilight-TeamBELLA 11.14.09 at 11:46 am

Oh they're funny.. but they're not joking.
lol

244 Gypsy0531 11.14.09 at 12:31 pm

We should. lol…i think others gave up. they shake their heads and say “no comment”.

245 Gypsy0531 11.14.09 at 12:34 pm

Clearly listening to one another and maturely responding

Hopefully it rubs off on “others” :)
we can only hope.lol

246 I♥TayDaniel(TeamUpNotherNotch) 11.14.09 at 12:46 pm

haha
wait they are serious?
lmao
that makes it even funnier.

247 FefiLovesTaycob-12/04ComeFast! 11.14.09 at 4:59 pm

BD is going to be Team Renesmee of course =) <3

248 FefiLovesTaycob-12/04ComeFast! 11.14.09 at 5:15 pm

“-Hes an amazing kisser”

Oh I love that quality *drools*

I'm Team Edward cause I love him, he's perfect for all the reasons u said and more!

Go Team Edward!

But I want to go to the dark side too! He's just sooo tempting! LOL

249 Spectra 11.14.09 at 5:51 pm

As much as I enjoy editing your posts, please stop insulting the fans here. It's one thing to state your opinion of the books, it's another to sling around insults.

250 Riss<3Twilight-TeamBELLA 11.14.09 at 5:53 pm

Yes, very serious. It has gotten pretty bad.. so bad that it does become comical. lol

251 IloveyouEdward 11.14.09 at 6:04 pm

lmao rlly your team edward?
you name doesnt seem like your team edward..

252 FefiLovesTaycob-12/04ComeFast! 11.14.09 at 6:48 pm

Oh no really I'm Team Edward! But as i said, Edward, not Robert.

Ok I'm gonna make a little explaining here:
ppl usually confuses Edward with Robert, Rob only plays Edward's caracter, he's not Edward. Now said that, in real life, I like Taylor a lot more than Rob. That's where my name comes from, though maybe i should change it to “FefiLovesTayward” LOL

Side note: this really doesn't make any sence given that this is a fantasy world written by a woman who was utterly obsessed with vampires

Side note 2: I love Twilight and everything related to it ^-^

253 red_sea 11.14.09 at 7:07 pm

How is “at least I'm rational about it” not an insult?

She insulted my rationality, I responded in kind.

254 Spectra 11.14.09 at 7:50 pm

You didn't respond “no I'm the one being rational”. You felt the need to comment on the reading comprehension of not only her, but all of Team Edward, and then you went on to insult everyone else who disagrees with you with your “apostles” comment.

We can all speak our minds without throwing insulting words about the author and the fans. That is unnecessary in getting your point across. I'm asking you to please be nice. Thank you.

255 LMCullen 11.14.09 at 8:06 pm

Maybe you should just leave. Seeing as how you are a “gray” face, and haven't even bothered to set up an actual account w/ a profile pic.

We are a family here. And we do not always agree on everything each one of us may say, we always RESPECT that other persons opinion.

You've been warned very nicely by Spectra. And still you continue to be belligerent (if you don't know the meaning, google it).

I do not have the patience that Spectra has.

256 red_sea 11.14.09 at 8:20 pm

If you all RESPECT the other person's opinion, how does that apply to the “at least I'm being rational” comment?

Maybe you should try Googling: Hypocrisy.

257 Spectra 11.14.09 at 8:37 pm

“I do not have the patience that Spectra has.”

And for this I am glad. :)

258 Karixoxo {Team Club Sandwich} 11.14.09 at 9:02 pm

First, I want to say something on that sarcastic comment you made about Stephenie Meyer. If she says they love each other then it's true. Well you're right. That's how a story works. The author tells the story, and she tells the story that Edward and Bella love each other.

When Bella and Jacob kissed and Bella thought “Yes, I am in love with both of them”, I didn't want to believe it. So I didn't. You're doing the same. You don't want to believe that Edward and Bella love each other – ignoring the whole storyline, not to mention the author herself – so you don't.

I don't agree with what you said about Bella wanting vampirism for selfish reasons either, but I can tell you will keep that opinion no matter what I say.

259 IloveyouEdward 11.15.09 at 3:23 pm

ah i see lmao
yea it should be tayward :O
LOL! anyways yea i like rob too
and yea he definetly is not edward.
Edward's serious and polite and yea..
Robs a dork <333
hehe Taylors awsome too

But yea im team Robward woooooot. :)

260 Riss<3Twilight-TeamBELLA 11.16.09 at 3:06 am

I could just about kiss you right now LMC.

Thank you.

261 Riss<3Twilight-TeamBELLA 11.16.09 at 3:10 am

It's true, no matter what you say red sea will never admit to being wrong. Even at points where she clearly misconstrued the text and quoted it wrong, she wouldn't admit it. It's a hopeless cause I've abandoned.

262 Chel*STILL NOSPOILERS-3* 11.16.09 at 7:09 am

*waves* Hey Marie how was your weekend??

This is the best day EVER!!! 3 days to New Moon and one of the girls in work surprised me this morning with the NEW MOON calendar BEST DAY EVER *does Jackson happy dance*

263 mAriE_(MarblePoleLover)CC-VG 11.16.09 at 7:15 am

hey chel!!

WOW. really?? thats sooo awesome of her! im happy for u! *does happy dance* ^_^

it's getting really close now huh? we can just feel it. now that u have ur calendar and all… *wink* hehehe

well i just saw the tc spot for NM and it was just goosebumps galore for me. woohoo!! 3 more days chel!!! ^_^

264 Chel*STILL NOSPOILERS-3* 11.16.09 at 8:04 am

yup i have it open on January already lookng at lovely lovely Edward and his golden eyes mmmmm!!!!

I know 3 more days is it wierd that i feel sick with excitement???? it's gonna be so great!!!!!

265 mAriE_(MarblePoleLover)CC-VG 11.16.09 at 8:10 am

awesome! what a way to greet u with that calendar! cant wait for january then huh? *wink* hehehe. ^_^

oh no dear. i feel for u on that one. i am being more giddy by the hour, knowing that each hour that would pass, will get us closer to NM. seeing that tv spot made my heart jumped. im not sure if i can behave in the cinema now. good luck to me! hehehehe ^_^

266 Chel*STILL NOSPOILERS-3* 11.16.09 at 8:34 am

oh i won't be able to contain myself i'm gonna end up being the screaming fangirl i would normally smack *facepalm* i'm screwed for thursday!!

My friend rang me on friday to tell me she'd seen the Tv trailer and he bought a ticket to come with me on thursday, i finally recruited her!!! yeayyyyy

267 mAriE_(MarblePoleLover)CC-VG 11.16.09 at 8:45 am

hahaha. look at u huh? recruiting people to watch NM! thats soo awesome! im happy for u! and tell ur friend welcome to the club. tee hee.. ^_^

well the first time that i'll watch the movie, i'll be alone. after that, tons of movie dates with my HS friends, college friends, family, then other HS friends again. never ending! gotta love it! hehehe ^_^

268 Chel*STILL NOSPOILERS-3* 11.16.09 at 8:50 am

I know i'm gonna be in the cinema that much they may aswell just give me my own private seating area LMAO,
She had to give in eventually she's read the books and loved them she's just not as manic as me well she'll get there in the end!!! *winks*
I'm so fricking excited 3 days, 2 bloody sleeps………….*dies*

269 mAriE_(MarblePoleLover)CC-VG 11.16.09 at 8:59 am

hahaha. totally agree with u on that one! i'll be like “some privacy please! leave me and NM alone!” hehehehe ^_^

my friends too! they're just not as crazt as i am like right now. well look at me, im here right? before i was just “oh i love the books! i love edward” but after finding this site, oh god! it practically changed my life. literally. hehehe. no regrets though. at least i got to talk to u guys who can really understand what it feels like to go gaga over the series. i can finally say that i am not alone. tee hee.. ^_^

270 Chel*STILL NOSPOILERS-3* 11.16.09 at 9:08 am

well if your crazy then so am i!!! i spend more time on here than i do actually working thats not good at all!!! *starts singing you are not alone, we are here with you,though we're far apart……..*

271 mAriE_(MarblePoleLover)CC-VG 11.16.09 at 9:17 am

good luck to ur work then huh? tee hee… ^_^

ooohh… i love it! thanks for that! i feel so much love from the girls here, including u, that i dont feel alone. AT ALL. well not anymore. tee hee… ^_^

272 Chel*STILL NOSPOILERS-3* 11.16.09 at 10:18 am

*blushes* You're welcome *grins*
I know that feeling dunno what i'd do without you girls on here I think i'd have been locked up in the looney bin by now LOL

273 mAriE_(MarblePoleLover)CC-VG 11.16.09 at 11:08 am

awwww….
*runs to hug chel, rocks her back and forth*
u are never alone ok? never! dont say that again! *smirks*

but it's true though. i'd be a goner if i wont be able to go and scream how i love the saga, the site and everything. totally be crazy w/o it! *shivers at the thought* ^_^

274 Chel*STILL NOSPOILERS-3* 11.16.09 at 1:26 pm

*hugs Marie back* thanks i feel so much better now *grins*

275 mAriE_(MarblePoleLover)CC-VG 11.16.09 at 1:34 pm

sure thing chel! anytime! *wink* ^_^

276 Chel*STILL NOSPOILERS-3* 11.16.09 at 1:55 pm

*high fives Marie* ok so…… what have i missed so far today, what do i need to catch up on??

277 Karixoxo {Team Club Sandwich} 11.17.09 at 5:31 am

Yeah, me too.
You can't make people see what they don't want to.

278 Karixoxo {Team Club Sandwich} 11.17.09 at 11:31 am

Yeah, me too.
You can't make people see what they don't want to.

279 relle 03.27.10 at 12:00 pm

but he then himself go with bella to jacob place and alll that

280 musicADHD 03.28.10 at 3:12 am

sweating's gross anyway lmao

Leave a Comment

You can use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: