Comments on: Robert Pattinson Q & A with TIME

By: train_wreck

train_wreck — Mon, 23 Nov 2009 23:09:59 +0000

When did Edward moan? I've seen the New Moon twice, and I don't remember there being a scene where Edward moans.

By: swoonovredwrd

swoonovredwrd — Mon, 23 Nov 2009 22:50:10 +0000

I definitely think people got the wrong impression of Edward from New Moon movie if they hadn't read the book....Taylor even played Jacob stronger and more independent than he was in the books. In the books I felt Jacob was just needy and would do whatever Bella wanted. My friends who haven't read the books felt that Edward was mean, more worried about himself, in the movie... we will see how it portrays in eclipse! Team Edward all the way! please click on the following link I need hits for a class project. Thanks! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K067aBAV6sE

By: jacobfan101

jacobfan101 — Mon, 23 Nov 2009 19:49:03 +0000

i agree im a big jacb fan and it just wasnt all there lol

By: pinktwilightlover

pinktwilightlover — Mon, 23 Nov 2009 19:36:58 +0000

Yes, I agree. You're right, he is amazing, and has done so many interesting roles. I just hope Remeber Me comes to Norway.. Neither of his other films have, that's just tragic

By: Spectra

Spectra — Mon, 23 Nov 2009 18:39:15 +0000

Well in Eclipse I don't see Jacob “forcing” himself on Bella as if he wants her her in a lustful way. The reason he kisses her forcefully is because he is desperate to save her. He wants her to realize she has another option. He's scared for her. He doesn't want her to get hurt or become a vampire. His kiss is him trying to save her life, for her to choose him, trying to get her to see that she does love him and can be happy with him as a human. And she does see this at the end of Eclipse, however she also comes to the realization that she loved Edward so much more.

The things that bugged me in Eclipse was Edward making sure her car wouldn't work or doing other manipulative things so she couldn't do what she wanted to do. Don't get me wrong, I like Edward, and I know WHY he did these things. He wanted to protect her from Victoria, but I wanted to slap him and say, “She WILL be safe with Jacob!” All she wanted to do was visit her friend and he wouldn't let her. That's what really bugged me, and that's when I started not liking him so much.

Both Edward and Jacob did bad things in my eyes, Jacob with the kiss, Edward with the controlling, BUT BOTH did them because they loved her and wanted to keep her safe. Jacob didn't kiss her like that so he could get off on it, and Edward didn't do those things to show who is boss. So I understand why both did the things they did, but for some reason what Edward did really invoked anger in me while I was actually reading the book.

So I understand Team Edward, totally, I mean when I read Twilight and Midnight Sun I LOVED him. And when he broke up with Bella in New Moon I had tears in my eyes. And even reading the rest of New Moon I liked Jacob, but really wanted Edward back. It wasn't until Eclipse that my mind changed. Then I just re-read New Moon and I really enjoyed the whole Jacob part SO much more…

So I don't hate on the Team Edward at all, because the way I see it is this… We all have different tastes in men right? My husband is not even close to my best friend's husband in character, and that's alright. And it's not that I necessarily want Bella to be with Jacob. I'm Team Jacob, as in he's my favorite character and I want him to be happy. That's why I'd LOVE to see SM do another book, showing 18 years have passed and now Reneesme is older and we see if and how her relationship with Jacob works out.

By: SC~3rd_Wife(TeamSM)

SC~3rd_Wife(TeamSM) — Mon, 23 Nov 2009 17:49:27 +0000

*Joins Team Tyler*

By: SC~3rd_Wife(TeamSM)

SC~3rd_Wife(TeamSM) — Mon, 23 Nov 2009 17:48:55 +0000

Am I the only one who reads these interviews and 'hears' Rob's British accent? *swoon*

By: SC~3rd_Wife(TeamSM)

SC~3rd_Wife(TeamSM) — Mon, 23 Nov 2009 17:47:50 +0000

I'm Team Edward forever, but I can understand Jacob lovers, b/c I do like his character. That said… You have my curiosity. Will you please explain how Edward annoys you in Eclipse?

For me it was more the opposite. I understand him in NM trying to make Bella fall in love with him now that Edward is gone. He is trying to heal her and even shows his patience. Once Edward comes back you would think he gets the hint, but in Eclipse he just forces himself on Bella.

By: SC~3rd_Wife(TeamSM)

SC~3rd_Wife(TeamSM) — Mon, 23 Nov 2009 17:37:01 +0000

I haven't seen Little Ashes yet, but plan to. I just watched How To Be, and I have to say – it was really hard to stay awake!! No, I'm not a 'tweenie' (I'm 29), but it was very hard for me to enjoy. I put no blame on Rob. I understand the character and think he fully embodied that – it was just extremely boring dialogue and I don't know what else to say, but it was missing something. As I was watching the trailers I was a little worried b/c they all looked very boring, especially 'It's so much like real life it's not even like your watching a movie' – no, it's not – movies are entertaining.

So, I blame to writers/director. Of course I can't wait for Remember Me!

By: SC~3rd_Wife(TeamSM)

SC~3rd_Wife(TeamSM) — Mon, 23 Nov 2009 17:28:04 +0000

Because of the trailer to Remember Me it is easy to tell that Rob will definitely NOT be typecast. He has an amazing talent and range. I thought I would just be canting 'Can't wait til June' but now it's 'Can't wait til March!'